
The safe word is “Imzadi”, says Adam Clarke.
I love Star Trek. Star Trek (and its first six movies), Star Trek: The Next Generation and Star Trek: Deep Space Nine raised me more than any human being ever did. You see, my parents abandoned me in Sears’ electronic section where I spent all of my childhood and teen years. There, TV took over and the various Star Treks raised me on tales of weird alien cultures that are all-too-human and omnipotent aliens that exist only to ham it up in front of starship captains.
Incidentally, I’d like all you readers to keep vigilant in my quest to find my birth parents. The police have issued this computer-rendered sketch of what my parents might look like based on my dim recollection of them…

Papa! Mama! Come back to me!
Hey, speaking of dim…

Star Trek: Insurrection (1998)
There’s trouble afoot when the evil plastic surgery enthusiasts, the Son’A, try to quietly relocate a small population of immortal space-Luddites in order to harvest some planetary rays that could result in eternal life for all!
Wait, that doesn’t sound too ba–anyway, the Enterprise crew discovers that Starfleet is working with Son’A, lead by the evil Ru’Afo (F. Murray Abraham). Time for an insurrection! Oh, and the planet causes people to regress physically and mentally (maybe) causing them to get zits, flirt or appreciate proper boob firmness.
Going through the TNG movies in reverse order makes Insurrection seem a lot better than it actually is. It is superior to Nemesis in every respect save one: the villain. Sure, Shinzon’s bald head and shoulder pads basically made him look like Skinhead Murphy Brown, but Tom Hardy was trying to rise above the material and he had Ron Perlman to play off of. F. Murray Abraham plays the lamest villain in the history of Star Trek and that includes those few weeks of TNG when the Ferengi were supposed to be scary. He whines, screams and purses his lips in every single scene, as if his sole bit of direction was “can you act like a 10 year old girl ordering a chocolate chiller at the mall? Do that.”
Insurrection threatens to get worse before it eventually does. The minute Worf and Picard are shown in a remarkably cheap-looking and unexciting chase scene with Data, the entire movie has already jumped the Gorn. From there, we have Worf reduced to broad comic relief (a role he is handed again in Nemesis), Troi revolted by the thought of kissing a bearded Riker (forgetting she’d already done that because no one remembers poor Thomas Riker), Picard mambo-ing, Geordi going on about sunsets (I wonder if he saw a butterfly in the sky) and Beverly Crusher trying not to blend in to the background.
That almost makes it sound as bad as Nemesis, but the movie is redeemed partially by the TNG regulars. In the cast’s final film, they’re all too tired to care about anything. In Insurrection, the Enterprise crew is finally having some fun and, for the first ten or fifteen minutes, we just get to hang out with these much-loved characters. First Contact starts with a war just after the opening credits and Generations is overshadowed by the presence of William Shatner, Insurrection gives us a chance to watch these characters interact and kibbitz with each other during a diplomatic mission they’d rather not be a part of. It’s kind of fun until the plot of the movie kicks in and the humour goes from tongue-barely-in-cheek to Joe-Piscopo-In-The-Holodeck goofy.
Insurrection is a film that awkwardly shifts in tone from a more comedic take to the stock Starfleet conspiracy plot to the action movie cliches of the film’s second half. Precious little of it works but Fade Out (an unpublished book on the writing of Insurrection, which has since leaked on the internet) inadvertently shows how these awkward tonal shifts were the result of making a movie by committee. Patrick Stewart wants a lighter storyline? Bring on the laughs. Brent Spiner thinks he’s underused and should be killed off? Put in more Data. The producer expects a villain to rival Khan and the Borg? Get F. Murray Abraham on the phone, etc.
Was there ever a good Next Gen movie?
Next week: The Trek movie marathon continues with First Contact.



Adam Clarke | Tue, Dec 13, 2011 | 986
On Screen