
Illustration by Ricky King
The most common date rape/aquaintance rape drug is alcohol. Even ‘nice’ people do this. People you would never suspect. In this country consent can’t be given by someone who is drunk. The second ‘rape’ happens when so called friends don’t believe you and brush you off because they can’t get their head around the fact that Mr. Wonderful would do such a thing. Happens more than most of us realize.
Rant by HGrace






February 8th, 2013 at 10:11 pm
This really goes too far. If drunk sex is not consensual than most of us are criminals. I’m not sure if this law even exists, but thankfully the courts see past this BS and sexual assault cases are routinely thrown out of court when the “victim” was too drunk during the alleged assault to give credible testimony.
There is a real double standard present in the OP’s opinion. If I get drunk and get behind the wheel of my car I am held responsible. Yet a woman who chooses to get drunk and then has sex with someone she may not have otherwise chosen is somehow a “victim”? Nonsense. You are responsible for your own actions. If you choose to have sex with someone while drunk you don’t get to wake up the next morning with a hangover and say “That was a mistake, I wouldn’t normally have done that, therefore it is rape”. We all do dumb things when we drink too much, but we are still responsible for those decisions. You do not get to play the rape card when you get drunk and do something you regret. It doesn’t work in any other situation and it shouldn’t work here. So don’t spout this nonsense unless you are talking about a situation where someone is held down and forced to drink alcohol.
February 9th, 2013 at 11:34 am
Hi Gordon.
FYI, the law does exist and does specify that it is a sexual assault if the complainant (the person being assaulted) cannot consent to the activity. It’s Criminal Code 273.1 (b). The link is here.
(http://laws-lois.justice.gc…
The definition of inability to consent isn’t written into that section, but the interpretation of the law has been that intoxication makes a person unable – as does being asleep, unconscious, etc. You can read a bit more on this here (http://www.mun.ca/sexualhar…. If you’re still not convinced, do some googling on how Canadian courts have interpreted this – it’s quite consistent.
Their own intoxication is also generally not a defence for someone accused of committing an assault. A specific provision was written into the law in 1995 to prevent it from being used this way. A good summary is here:
(http://www.thecanadianencyc…
Having gotten consent previous to the encounter is also not a defence recognized in law. This was confirmed at the supreme court fairly recently. (http://www.cbc.ca/news/cana…
Under the law there isn’t a difference between intoxication from alcohol and intoxication from something else (roofies, for example). That wouldn’t make any sense – there are lots of things that impair your judgment. Just because alcohol is used more often and is more acceptable socially doesn’t make it not a drug. The fact is, sex without consent is sexual assault – and a partner can’t give consent if they are intoxicated. How they got there doesn’t matter. It doesn’t matter if they chose to get drunk, whether someone doubled their drinks without telling them, or dropped pills in them.
You mention that these cases are “routinely thrown out of court” if someone was too drunk to give credible testimony – as far as I know there are no statistics to justify this claim. There are definitely cases of that defence being used. The most recent one I know of was in Calgary in 2011; in that case the perpetrator was convicted – the “she was too drunk then to testify now” defence didn’t work.
Sorry to turn this into a lecture, and sorry to be harsh, but that’s the reality. There are a lot of sexual encounters that end up on the wrong side of the law. Want to stay safe and onside of the law? Get consent.
If, as you put it, someone wakes up the next morning with a hangover and realizes that something has happened to them that they didn’t want to have happen, that’s not “playing the rape card” – that’s rape, and they are fully within their rights and within the law to file charges. Just because it happens a lot doesn’t mean it’s right.
Please also try and think about this from the victim’s perspective. Sexual assaults often go unreported, and part of the reason is attitudes like this. People who have been assaulted while under the influence feel like nobody will believe them or that their personal morals/responsibility will be questioned, so they stay silent, and rapists get away with it.
The idea that women – and this story is almost always about women – decide after the fact to falsely accuse someone of rape is a myth. Let me repeat that. It. Is. A. Myth. The rate of false reporting for sexual assault is no higher than for any other crime, and is in absolute terms quite low (most estimates I’ve seen have it at around 2%). People can’t just report on a lark – it’s a pretty involved process that (unfortunately) is often quite difficult.
To the OP – if you or someone you know has been a victim, there are supports out there for you. I’d encourage you to get in contact with the NL Sexual Assault Crisis and Prevention Centre. They have a 24 hour crisis line (1-800-726-2743). The volunteers staffing the line are there to listen and to connect you with resources.
Sorry for the long post, but there a ton of misconceptions about this issue and the laws involved floating out there, and people get hurt because of them. Rather than go after victims for being “irresponsible”, maybe we can start a more productive conversation about we can all go out, have fun, have a drink, and do it safely.
Thanks,
Josh Smee
February 9th, 2013 at 11:39 am
My post in response to Gordon Gekko’s at the bottom – forgot to put it in as a reply. Sorry.
February 9th, 2013 at 3:56 pm
Thank you Josh. This happened to me long ago and far away. The betrayal by the friend was equal to that of the rapist. It nearly killed me. Actually, I nearly killed me. Still haunts me.
February 12th, 2013 at 10:16 pm
I agree with most of what Josh said, but “intoxication” is not specified. If the linked wiki is to be believed, simply being intoxicated is not enough to negate consent (“Poor decision making, memory loss, or loss of inhibition or self-control due to alcohol does not negate consent” and “An intoxicated complainant may still have the ability to consent”).
So what is “intoxication”? And at what point is a party unable to consent?
There’s also the weird situation that if both parties are drunk they are simultaneously sexually assaulting each other, which barely seems to make sense.
http://en.wikibooks.org/wik…