The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Write a message for the Rant Farm
12
Like

Blaming the victim

Posted on Thursday at 9 am - 17 Comments.

I am appalled at the number of instances of drugs being slipped into drinks at George Street bars. What is even more appalling, though, is the number of people who place the blame on the men and women who are being drugged.

I read the article on CBC.ca about Sara Tilley and her horrifying experience at Distortion last weekend and some of the comments on the article were atrocious.

Some were scolding her for going to the media when there was no proof that she was drugged since there was no blood test (because she wasn’t in any shape to have one at the time). Some suggested she probably came down with the stomach flu that’s been doing around and wasn’t actually drugged. One person even insinuated that she drank so much and perhaps made a fool of herself so she claimed that she was drugged to avoid any embarrassment.

Date rape drugs are a serious problem that has been around for too long and is getting worse as each week passes.

If society doesn’t take it seriously, and people continue to believe that the problem lies with the victims, how can we expect it to get better? To come up with a solution, we have to come together as a community and look out for one another. Blaming the victim surely isn’t going to help anything.

Rant by

«

»

 

17 Responses

  1. avatar
    iNvoLved Says:

    Agreed! I thought she had a great response to a terrible experience – being this forthcoming can only benefit the larger community. The cynical second-guessing of her situation/motives is so deeply frustrating, and emphasizes the reasons drugging & sexual assault are so under-reported.

  2. avatar
    NG Says:

    Agreed. I also noticed the focus both by the media and public seems to be on the people who get drugged and not the people doing the actual drugging. I’ve heard and read countless remarks about watching one’s drink (which is a important message people I agree with) but no one seems to be talking about trying to catch the people who are slipping these drugs to people.

  3. avatar
    LobF Says:

    I agree that it’s a scary thing… but…
    How does she know she was drugged?
    She simply doesn’t.

  4. avatar
    blerg Says:

    Ugh.

    You know if you’re drunk…humans have the ability to know if they’ve been drugged.

  5. avatar
    iNvoLved Says:

    Is it certain? No. Is it likely? Yes – very. The coverage I saw acknowledged this. But this kind of comment misses the point – these druggings happen here, and discussing her experience has a) raised awareness, b) prompted responses from local businesses, and c) will hopefully translate to pressure on people who use these drugs – positive outcomes for the community. Meanwhile, a vocal minority (god, I HOPE minority), wastes time questioning the motives for discussing this.

  6. avatar
    bringitup Says:

    “One person even insinuated that she drank so much and perhaps made a fool of herself so she claimed that she was drugged to avoid any embarrassment. ”

    Yea but this actually happens. Blame the people who do this kind of thing, not the ones asking questions.

  7. avatar
    OUTLAW Says:

    Also, she confidently suggested on live TV that it was a male who drugged her. This is another thing she simply doesn’t know for sure.

    I can see where she’s coming from, and do respect her show of concern for others, but I wouldn’t want to try to convict someone based on the proof she has.

  8. avatar
    LobF Says:

    No, we don’t.
    That’s why we have blood tests.

  9. avatar
    Pre-defeated Says:

    …Seriously? Most studies suggest only ~2-4% of sexual assault allegations are false; the real number is probably smaller, given that many of the studies conflate ‘false’ accusations with those that cannot be prosecuted (‘unfounded’). An estimated 46% of assaults are reported at all – so the real problem is the rate of under-reporting (54%), not frivolous over-reporting (~1%). I don’t know the numbers for date-rape drug cases, but it’s reasonable to expect a similarly tiny false report rate (and similar under-reporting rate).

    Please stop perpetuating the myth that women lie about assault & related crimes for personal reasons. It’s really not a thing, and contributes to the under-reporting rate.

  10. avatar
    The Hawk Says:

    Obviously LobF has never been drugged. It’s unmistakeable. You remember everything up to the first sips of a new drink and then all of a sudden you wake up and it’s hours later, the sun is up, you’re on the floor. You might be naked. You might feel as if you’ve been violated. And you really have no freaking idea. Like—none. Nothing can spark a memory. So you try to find your clothes and your shoes (which might look like they’ve been hurriedly peeled off you; maybe your jeans are still around your ankles) and rush home to find some dignity in solitude, only your head feels like an egg being cracked on the side of a sizzling skillet and you can’t stop vomiting up yellow stomach bile and your whole body hurts like popcorn bursting out of it’s kernel and your skin is itchy and, oh yeah, you might have just been raped, but you don’t know because that part of your life was just taken from you—entirely stolen, completely gone—in a few sips. Trust me, it’s unmistakeable. And a blood test is the last thing a hurting victim of the most violating kind of crime needs or wants. She wants her mommy and a good three-month long cry.

    For women who don’t have their friends on hand the way Sara Tilley did, getting blood tests and going public is just a way of perpetuating the pain. Because Sara was safe with her friends, because she was not raped, she was in a strong enough place to go public. I commend her and thank her for doing so.

  11. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    If those 2-4% of men are wrongfully convicted and sent to prison for sexual assault it is far too many. Radical feminists see them as collateral damage, but there really are some crazy women out there who lie about this sort of thing. The courts need to be impartial, they cant be afraid to question the alleged victims of sexual assault, even if that offends feminists who think that questioning a complainant equates to victim blaming.

    Sexual assault is obviously a horrible thing and I am sure the process of pressing charges and dealing with cops and courts is not very nice either, but we simply cannot send innocent men to jail and ruin their lives because the courts are too afraid to question the women. That would just not be right.

  12. avatar
    Pre-defeated Says:

    It’s a big jump from ‘false reporting is extremely rare’ to ‘let’s abandon due process’, Gordon. I challenge you to find anyone stating on record that a few innocent people in prison is inconsequential collateral damage; you’re sketching a cartoon of a ‘radical feminist’ that just does not exist outside of Rush Limbaugh’s imagination.

    Coming back to this specific case: no one is being accused, and no charges will arise (pretty much always the case with date-rape drug incidents), so concerns about protecting innocent men are completely irrelevant. Yet we still question her motives for speaking out, which says a good deal about attitudes towards victims of sexual assault.

  13. avatar
    LobF Says:

    I’m surprised it ever made the news.
    Girl gets sick on George street while out partying, suspects she was slipped something, refuses to get a blood test… goes to media with a story about blacking out, saying she thinks she was drugged. No evidence was ever produced.

    How did this ever get any traction?

  14. avatar
    Gambit Says:

    Agreed, Hawk.

  15. avatar
    Thought... Says:

    Are people questioning her motives or her proof?

    It seems to me that people are accepting of the fact that it’s a serious problem, but are questioning if the “date rape drug” is actually what happened here. I feel for her, but she has absolutely ZERO proof that it was indeed the “date rape drug”.

  16. avatar
    BOB Says:

    sure she never had one of those george street hot dogs before she went in the club?

  17. avatar
    Erin Says:

    well said, Hawk


RANT FARM: Got an opinion? Then we want to hear from you. Submit your unsigned accusation or confession here. One submission will be printed in the paper each fortnight. Submissions may be edited for length, grammar, spelling, legal, or potty-mouth reasons. The Scope's Terms of Use are here.