
Michael Myers frightens Jamie Lee Curtis the same way Activia terrifies Adam Clarke
I feel like a ‘Nam veteran after watching all these Halloween sequels. I’ve seen things you wouldn’t believe, man. Evil Irish mask-makers, Stonehenge, psychic connections, incest, legit Druid cult conspiracies, fake Druid cult conspiracies…
Oh, and Michael Myers. We forgot about him, didn’t we? In the hopes of bringing the series back to its roots, Jamie Lee Curtis was lured back for Halloween H2O & Halloween: Resurrection. Both films make a conscious effort to go back to basics after the increasingly convoluted mythology of the past few sequels. In Halloween H2O and Halloween: Resurrection, we have Myers returning to some aspect of the first film: his dogged pursuit of Laurie in H2O and finally coming home in Resurrection. These films would mark the end of the series before it was rebooted by Rob Zombie in 2007.
Halloween H2O
1998. Twenty years after Halloween, we learn that Michael Myers simply disappeared after the events of the first film… or the second film… or the sixth film. With H2O, there’s an attempt to clear up the confusing mythology from the last couple of films that only muddies the water even more.
So here’s what we know: in H2O, Laurie Strode (Curtis) faked her death sometime after her run-in with Myers, which was implied by the character’s offscreen disappearance in Halloween 4. She knows she’s Myers’ sister, so Halloween II is still part of the story. However, neither Myers nor Loomis died in the explosion at the end of Halloween II. There seems to have been no explosion, given that Loomis died some time in the 90s, which seems to correspond with the end of Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (theatrical). Myers also has no burn marks in this film and it’s said that he never struck again after 1978.
So everything in Halloween happened. Parts of II happened. Loomis was alive until recently (as per the 88-95 sequels), but there are no Druids or genetic experiments as per the events of Halloween II, III and the various versions of Halloween: The Curse Of Michael Myers. Jamie Lloyd probably wasn’t born, but if she was, Laurie Strode ain’t talking about it.
You’d need Superboy to punch a hole through the universe to make sense of any of that. Thankfully, the film doesn’t try. We now know that Laurie is the headmistress of a California prep school, where she’s been working for years under a new name. For some reason, Myers comes out of hibernation, finds out where she lives and stalks her yet again. But is it Laurie he’s after? She was attacked when she was 17, which just so happens to be the age of her son, John (Josh Hartnett). Laurie will now have to face the family secret she’s been running from for twenty years and kill her homicidal brother.
Lauded as the sequel with Laurie Strode kicking ass, H2O feels even more like “Halloween in name only” than Halloween III: Season Of The Witch. The opening scene just seems to confirm this notion as we pan across a series of news clippings related to Myers and Laurie. Instead of of coughing up a few extra pennies to license the use of Donald Pleasence’s real voice, the H2O team hired a cheap soundalike to re-record Dr. Loomis’ “devil’s eyes” speech from the first film. Why pay homage to the actor who gave Halloween and its sequels their power when you can save a couple of bucks to throw towards the film’s wrap party. H2O tries to pay homage to the original, but does so only by doing the bare minimum.
The look of H2O seriously undermines its success, as the film could easily be mistaken for a big-budget episode of Dawson’s Creek. Say what you will about Halloween 5, but at least that had an autumnal feel and tried to create a frightening atmosphere. Director Steve Miner, best known for directing two Friday the 13th sequels, is competent at best. He never generates any tension save for a brief sequence with Michael Myers flipping tables in a classroom.
Worst of all, Michael Myers is all wrong. It’s bad enough that the film is overlit like a soap opera, but this Myers is constantly being pummeled or knocked over. Sorry, but seeing the once-terrifying “The Shape” get knocked out by Josh Hartnett is heartbreaking. To make matters worse, the various masks used for Myers throughout the film all look really chintzy. The effect of these oversights is that the guy playing Myers never convinces. He’s a PC-brand Michael Myers. He’s not The Shape, he’s No Name Brand Presents Budget Shape-like Murderer.
It shouldn’t be hard to replicate the original mask used in the first two films. Previous sequels sported acceptable variants on the Myers mask, but H2O‘s mask reveals the actor’s eyes in every shot. The earlier films opted to keep the actor’s features hidden whenever he was wearing the mask, emphasizing Michael’s lack of humanity. If you always see his eyes, the actor just looks like a guy at a costume party. Comparing H2O‘s mask to the original or the ones used in any the previous sequels, you can’t help but notice how wrong it looks.
Halloween:

Halloween 5:

Halloween H2O:

See? That’s not The Shape. That’s just… some guy.
H2O updates the characters from the original and Laurie fares much better than Michael. Laurie would definitely become an overprotective mom and she’d definitely be working in education. It makes sense that she’d have nightmares, drink too much and quietly mourn her dead friends from the original (I wish more lip service had been paid to them). Some moments, like the idea that she was married to a meth addict(?), ring incredibly false. Still, we’re here to watch Laurie finally kill off Michael and move on with her life. While there’s a certain thrill in seeing Curtis battle her iconic opponent, it takes about an hour before that happens.
While the scenes with Laurie are quite good (especially those with her son), the main problem from Halloween: The Curse Of Michael Myers resurfaces here. No, there aren’t any references to Thorn or gene-splicing in H2O, but it does suffer from too many characters running around. Since we know Myers won’t get Laurie’s son (that would defeat the purpose of the film), we need potential victims. The script introduces us to some nondescript teens and a security guard who moonlights as a romance novelist. To pour salt on this particular wound, the filmmakers have cast LL Cool J as that security guard. Woo.
H2O doesn’t have much reason to exist save the novelty of seeing Jamie Lee Curtis again. This is one aspect where the film doesn’t disappoint and the climax works more often than not. Some viewers might also get a kick out of seeing Joseph Gordon-Levitt (Brick), Janet Leigh (who previously appeared alongside Curtis in The Fog), Michelle Williams (Take This Waltz) and Nancy Stephens (er… Halloween) pop up even if the script gives them nothing to do. Though it was praised upon release, H2O‘s just a generic post-Scream slasher that grinds to a halt whenever Curtis isn’t onscreen.
Oh, and to leave you with a bad taste in your mouth, a Creed song plays over the film’s end credits. Goodnight, America!
Halloween: Resurrection
Rather than having such a padded first and second act, H2O would’ve benefited from an extended coda where we see Laurie piece her life back together. While such endings can often be clunky (see James Cameron’s original ending for Terminator 2), the star of H2O was Laurie, not Michael. The last moments should’ve been given to her instead of a severed head. Such a coda would prevent the inevitable sequel after H2O‘s success.
Enter Halloween: Resurrection, which brings Rick Rosenthal back to the series because it seemed like a good idea at the time.
Rosenthal directed Halloween II, which was partially re-shot by John Carpenter since Rosenthal’s cut was “as scary as an episode of Quincy” (as per Carpenter’s description). Resurrection offered Rosenthal a second chance to prove himself. Turns out John Carpenter was right. Halloween II was a little drab, but it was a decent slasher. Halloween: Resurrection has a bad script and, impressively, even worse direction.
Resurrection (originally given the more suitable title, Halloween: Homecoming) has Myers improbably surviving the climax of Halloween H2O. He finds Laurie Strode in an insane asylum (don’t ask) and finally succeeds in killing her. The result is a bewildering scene where Laurie kisses Myers before dying, recreating a behind-the-scenes candid shot from the original Halloween. So here we have something that would theoretically please fans who get the reference, but makes no sense whatsoever in any other context.
With that business out of the way, Myers heads back to his childhood home in Haddonfield. Lucky for him, the Myers house is now the site of a reality show populated by hot, young stereotypes. When Myers shows up and begins eliminating contestants in his own way, there’s only one man who can stop him. With Dr Loomis and Laurie Strode dead, it’s up to Busta Rhymes to defeat evil while rolling off catchphrases like “Trick ‘r’ Treat, motherfucka!”
Halloween: Resurrection is a failure on every conceivable level. It’s ugly, poorly-shot, cheaply-produced, nonsensically-written and the acting is atrocious. With John Carpenter’s help, Rick Rosenthal created Halloween II, which was a sometimes chilling film. Without Carpenter, the end result is Halloween: Resurrection.
In revisiting the Halloween series, one thing seems obvious: they focused on the wrong aspect in trying to build the series. Rather than bringing back Michael Myers or having Tom Atkins fight haunted masks, the key to the series’ success was right in front of everyone’s face: Loomis.
Nevermind that Donald Pleasence had the chops to lend gravitas to even the most hokey scripts. Loomis as a character had a lot of potential and Pleasence made him an icon of the genre. The smart thing to do would’ve been if Halloween II had picked up where the first one left off, but Myers doesn’t return. He simply vanishes. While searching for his former patient, Loomis ends up facing different threats, overtly supernatural or not, in his unending search for others who, like Myers, have come to embody evil. Say what you will about that idea, I’d take Dr Loomis fighting vampire women over Busta Rhymes, long-lost siblings or genetic engineering shenanigans any day of the week.
Next week: There’s no way in Hell I’m watching Rob Zombie’s remake. I’ll review something without a William Shatner mask, I promise.



Adam Clarke | Tue, Nov 20, 2012 | 560
On Screen