
Adam Clarke on the Bridesmaids war.
“Women be different than men.” So sayeth stand-up comedian and noted gender role advocate, Sinbad. There’s a curious relationship between women and comedy or, rather, the perception of women being outside of the realm of funny. Jerry Lewis once infamously remarked that women weren’t funny and, to this day, there are those who still hold on to this belief to varying degrees. No one seems to have a problem with women as comic actors. The careers of Jane Curtin, Catherine O’Hara and Julia Louis-Dreyfus are a mere handful of women who’ve earned critical and popular success in comic roles on television. The idea of women not being funny applies more to stand-up comedy and film vehicles; the former mostly applying to the backhanded compliments aimed at Sarah Silverman when she broke out in the late 90′s and the latter most recently lobbed at last week’s Bridesdmaids.
It’s not just that comedians like Silverman or Maria Bamford are funny. They’re funny, you know, for women. That is even more offensive than Jerry Lewis’ misogyny because it presents the compliment as if it were a pleasant surprise. BREAKING NEWS: WOMEN POSSIBLY AS FUNNY AS MEN. FILM AT 11.
The company line in the marketing of Bridesdmaids has been that this is “a funny film with women that guys will actually want to see.” Salon writer Mary Elizabeth Williams described the film as “the first black president of female-driven comedies” (DEAR MARY ELIZABETH: THAT DOESN’T MAKE ANY SENSE.) Interviews about the movie have even gone so far as to say that women find bodily fluids and stuff like that to be just as funny as men do.
Yes, that’s right. Audiences everywhere have been clamoring for one thing and one thing only: more low-hanging fruit at the rotting multiplex.
Roseanne Barr’s recent piece in New York Magazine about life in show business proved timely amid all of the talk about Bridesmaids. Her stories of battles with tired old TV hack writers was depressing, but unsurprising. It seems like nothing has changed since the Roseanne finale in May of 1997. She summarizes that today’s TV viewers, “now prefer their comedy dumb and sexist.”
I. Don’t. Get. It. Is this a thing that we’re still doing? I mean, the idea that a “raunchy” comedy with women is something new is ridiculous, since that was the whole point of the misbegotten Sex & The City franchise. Secondly, the idea that men respond largely to comedies with “body fluids” bewilders me. I’ve never laughed at a Farrelly Brothers movie. I think The Hangover generally wasted the talents of everyone involved, as anyone who has ever seen Ed Helms or Zach Galifianakis’ comedy can attest. There’s no need to usher in Bridesmaids as a new era where women can finally be seen as funny because our benchmark for comedy celebrates lowest common denominator material rather than wit or cleverness. We should just have better standards.



May 22nd, 2011 at 10:03 pm
you might be interested in the Canadian doc Wisecracks, which is about women and stand-up
http://movies.nytimes.com/movie/review?res=9E0CE2D7143CF937A35755C0A964958260
May 23rd, 2011 at 1:30 am
Great article but you seem to be under the impression that a world exists where everyone will praise higher intellectual comedy. Sadly there will always be a place for such BS, because the world is full of douche-bags.
May 24th, 2011 at 10:09 am
I don’t think he’s implying that, so much as the fact that the comedy that the public is going for is increasingly dumb. Two and a Half Men is the biggest comedy on TV. The Hangover is the highest-grossing R-rated film of all time, and was generally critically acclaimed. Both of these examples play to the Spike-TV crowd, and it seems like the best way to guarantee making money these days.
Anyway, I was pleasantly surprised with this article. I’m sick to death of hearing so much about this movie meaning so much for women. It shouldn’t, and it doesn’t. Most reviews I’ve heard and articles I’ve read about this act like this is the beginning of the end of some long-standing battle. But look back at the comedy women have been making 10, 20, 30, 40 years ago (even Roseanne, mentioned above, is a good example). This movie doesn’t show progress on top of all that, it shows how much public taste has moved backwards in the last 10 or 15 years.
I’d never expect the majority of people to like intellectual comedy, but even still, I would expect that people would realize that something that stopped being funny in the 1960′s (for very good reasons) shouldn’t have any reason to start being funny again.
But then again, this is a world where Dane Cook is considered a comedian.
May 25th, 2011 at 12:53 pm
I’m a little perplexed by this article. Not sure what the point is…thought I was getting a review, but I guess not…?
I’m a huge fan of comedy. I’ve worked in comedy. I like it all. Quirky, gross, intellectual, cheap, fresh, you name it, I like it. We honeymooned at Just For Laughs. I like comedy.
So, this movie. I went in thinking – oh, it’s The Hangover for women…it isn’t. In fact, I almost ruined the movie for myself thinking about it that way.
Did I almost shoot Fresca out of my nose with laughther? A couple of times, sure, but it wasn’t overly outrageous in that way.
Did I nod my head in a santimonious, knowing way and say to myself “that was funny” without cracking a smile? At times, yes, but it wasn’t that kind of movie either. Thanks be.
Was I moved by the relationships written and portrayed? Yep.
Could the film have been edited differently? Yep. A few hilarious characters should likely have been sacrificed for the better of the narrative. But what are you going to do?
So, what kind of movie was it? It was a well-written, well peformed, nuanced movie with enough poopy-bum-bum humour to make me giggle and take my mind off my troubles. Was it the best movie in the world? No. Was it good? You betcha. My husband sat next to me, laughed along with me, and we both recognized the characters as women might actually exist in the world rather than just boobs on legs to be mocked by the other male characters like in other Appatow-produced movies (that we also love).
Go see it. If you are looking for a recent reference point…think Adam Sandler and Seth Rogan in Funny People more so than The Hangover. Just my several cents.
May 25th, 2011 at 4:39 pm
Thank you Jen for the review.
I get the distinct impression that Adam didn’t go and see the movie.
May 25th, 2011 at 6:05 pm
I took this to be more an article about the press surrounding this movie than a review of the movie itself. I understand why too. I’ve heard, seen, and read at least 7 or 8 reviews of this movie by now, and very, very few actually focused on the movie. All I keep hearing is how women are actually funny now (as if they’ve never been before).
I’ve been wondering if we’d be hearing this at all if Apatow hadn’t released any of his previous movies.
May 25th, 2011 at 9:25 pm
JB is correct. I get the distinct impression that commenter “a” doesn’t know how to read.