Adam Clarke is not friendly, nor can he be found in your neighbourhood. Nonetheless, he did watch all three Spider-Man movies this week.
I love Spider-Man. The character, the comics, the ’90′s and ’60′s cartoons (flawed though they were), the theme tune and the myriad variations on the costume. Spider-Man alone was the reason I read Marvel over DC. Crap like that matters when you’re a kid (see also the Sega vs Nintendo feuds that lead to the bloody “Blast Processing” war of ’93).
A new Spider-Man film is hitting the cinema that promises to reboot the franchise. Yeah, ’cause if there’s one superhero who needs to have his origin story retold, it’s Spider-Man. It hasn’t been re-counted in the comics numerous times, nor has it appeared in a few cartoon adaptations of Spider-Man, nor did the original movie devote a solid chunk of its running time to it.
Regardless, it’s still to early to judge the upcoming Amazing Spider-Man. Andrew Garfield seems miscast as a young Peter Parker since he looks like the kind of guy who would beat up Peter Parker in high school. Nonetheless, I have fond memories of the first film, which is one of the few comic book movies that recaptures the fun of a superhero comic. In prep for the upcoming flick, I gave all three of Sam Raimi’s Spidey films another glance. Sure enough, Spider-Man 3 is still pretty terrible…
Spider-Man was great because the character was likeable, interesting and had the greatest rogues gallery a kid like me could hope for. When the first film was rolling into theatres, I couldn’t believe how happy I was, not just to see Spidey, but that Sam Raimi would be helming it. I knew he wouldn’t let me down.
The first Spider-Man is one of the only superhero film I consider better than the original king of tights ‘n’ fights pictures, Superman: The Motion Picture. I loved the casting (and I don’t know whose cameo I loved more: Bruce Campbell’s or Macho Man Randy Savage’s), the score by Danny Elfman is one of his finest and the film got something that none of the 80′s/90′s Batman films ever considered. Namely, giving your title hero more screentime than the villain. I adored it from a comic geek’s perspective because the look, tone and performances were perfect to the comic. I adored it from a film geek’s perspective because of all the references to Sam Raimi’s other pictures and because someone finally made good on the promise Richard Donner showed when he first got Christopher Reeve to don a cape and have comic book films that weren’t immediately forgettable.
I saw the first film three times in the theatres and picked it up cheap at a pawn shop when it hit DVD. The second film followed suit and I was less of a fan. The film was a bit too episodic and we got far too little time with Doc Octopus, who dies a fairly contrived death. Still, it was a fine follow-up and it was exciting and fresh in a way that I never found any of Bryan Singer’s X-Men films to be. When the third film was gearing up, the promise of it being the last one for the crew and the presence of Venom and the symbiote was enough to send me over the moon. I was a bit cautious, as the presence of the black costume, Venom, Sandman, the revelation that Sandman is Uncle Ben’s true killer, Harry Osbourne following in his father’s footsteps, Gwen Stacy in a prominent role and the continued presence of the Daily Bugle staff along with appearances by Rosemary Harris, Bruce Campbell and Stan Lee on top of the continuing love story between Peter and Mary Jane just seemed like too much. Still, it was my childhood dream come true; a Spider-Man movie…where he’s in the black costume… with Venom! It was essentially everything I wanted from a movie when I was 8 years old.
Well, there’s nothing worse than getting what you thought you wanted. Spider-Man 3 starts off pretty well, but there’s too much ground to cover and, frankly, the end result is a messy, jumbled film with serious third act problems.
When we last left Peter Parker/Spider-Man (Tobey Maguire) and Mary Jane Watson (Kirsten Dunst), they were together and happy. However, despite Peter’s enthusiasm and the public’s growing appreciation of Spidey, things are far from perfect. MJ’s acting career has hit the skids, having been unceremoniously dumped from a production after opening night and Peter, high on New York’s near-unanimous love for their friendly, neighborhood Spider-Man, doesn’t even notice (Eg. The bit of soap opera scripting where he babbles about how awesome Spider-Man is even though MJ looks like she just got hit by a Greyhound). Worse still, Mary Jane Watson now believes herself to be in competition when, in a photo op, Spiderman kisses Gwen Stacey (Bryce Dallas Howard) while hanging from his web ’cause it would make a great picture… even though Peter knows MJ is only ten feet away(!) In all this, Peter’s trying to pop the question to Mary Jane without realizing that he’s driving her away.
Sounds like pap, doesn’t it? Rest assured, gentle reader, it’s worse than Passions.
In the meantime, Harry Osbourne (James Franco) makes an attempt on Peter’s life, only to get a bad blow to the head that makes him forget the past five years and act like Barney The Dinosaur on a hug rampage. Inevitably, Harry’s memory is triggered and he then proceeds to do the most devious thing he can think of to revenge his father’s demise…
He gets MJ to break up with Peter and laughs. Seriously.
Meanwhile, Flint Marko (Thomas Hayden Church) is a thug who took to crime in the hopes of stealing enough cash to pay for medical treatments for his frail daughter. Marko is chased by the cops into a top secret scientific experiment and falls into a “particle accelerator” that is surrounded by nothing but sand. The experiment goes ahead even after Marko’s presence is detected ’cause the cops failed to think of alerting said scientists that they were hot on a wanted man’s trail. Later, the sand particles that remain slowly form back into Marko, in one of the film’s few breathtaking moments.
Meanwhile again (you get used to that with Spider-Man 3), a meteorite has fallen to earth and spurted sentient black goop that latches on to Peter’s bike while in the woods at around the four minute mark in the movie. It crawls into and occasionally stirs in the apartment, but goes unnoticed until the aforementioned subplots are well underway. Collapsing on his bed shortly after Capt. Stacey (James Cromwell) informs him of his uncle’s true killer, the black goop latches on to a sleeping Peter in costume and he wakes to find himself hanging off a skyscraper in a black version of his costume. Parker notes that it “feels good”, has no idea where it came from and has almost no scientific curiosity about it. He wears ’cause he thinks it’s neat and somehow manages to get a scrap of it in its liquid form to his science teacher, Curt Connors (Dylan Baker), who warns him not to come in contact with the stuff until they figure out what it is. Peter ignores this and gradually becomes self-centered and arrogant, strutting in the streets, showing off, starting fights and, inexplicably, altering his hair and clothing so that he looks like the head of the My Chemical Romance fan club.
Anyway, the black costume is eventually repelled when Parker finally realizes he hates what he has become. Then, it moves to Eddie Brock (Topher Grace) and soon Venom and Sandman team up to stop a common enemy.
All right, going into spoiler territory, I’m more than a little disappointed that Venom got about ten minutes of screentime. He looks great, but gets killed off in about one second, never to be seen again. Eddie Brock and the symbiote are vaporized by a goblin bomb and nobody blinks an eye. The whole thing is ridiculously anti-climactic. And how the hell did he know about Marko’s daughter anyway? Even Peter didn’t know Marko’s motives.
Speaking of goblin bombs, when Peter and Harry have their final fight, the former lobs a goblin bomb in Harry’s direction and it explodes in Osbourne’s face. How come the bomb that reduces you to a skeleton only gives Harry mild facial irritation. He only shows up to die heroically anyway and why on earth does no one notice or comment on it until Peter shows up at Osbourne’s manor. Raimi may have wanted us to be surprised by his survival, but it comes off as a real narrative cheat.
Speaking of narrative cheats, how come Bentley the butler is all Harry needs to become one of the good guys. He loathes Parker because he thinks he’s killed Norman Osbourne and plots his former best friend’s death at every turn, but a few kind words from the Osbourne family butler sets him right. The hell?! Bentley claims to have inspected Norman’s wounds and found them to be the same blade from Osbourne’s glider. Osbourne’s top secret glider that no one save top brass in the army and his company knew he created. Hell, no one save Peter knew he was the Goblin anyway, but Bentley saying he loves Harry and that his father killed himself on the glider is enough to make Harry risk his life to save Mary Jane and trade quips with Peter like nothing happened??!!
If that doesn’t have you groaning, maybe the doozy of an ending will. Peter lets Marko get away because he forgives him for killing Uncle Ben, but, um, what about all those people he stole from? What about all the crimes he’s committed? And, to top it all off, the relationship between Peter and MJ is almost completely destroyed by then end of the movie and the film just abruptly ends with the two of them dancing mournfully in a jazz bar. The hell?!
All in all the film had all the cards and proceeds to screw up nearly all of them. Some have problems with Maguire and Dunst and their performances are almost exactly what you’d expect after the previous two, but they worked well in all three films. Franco also gives a nice performance and JK Simmons and the rest of the actors playing the Daily Bugle staff do their usual jobs. Bruce Campbell, as always, is the highlight of the movie and it really makes you wish Raimi will use his clout to do a comedy with his former star in the near-future.
As for the new cast, the choices were great but the execution was lousy. The best of the bunch was Topher Grace who gives Brock/Venom a vulnerability and backstory without losing the character’s sinister edge. After that, James Cromwell is always nice to see even though it’s nothing more than a glorified cameo. Howard’s Gwen Stacey is a plot device and she fails to make that character interesting. Finally, the biggest disappointment was Church, not because he was bad, but because they failed to do anything with him. He’s got about five lines in the whole movie and, frankly, that’s a role that’s beneath an actor of his caliber. It’s a waste of talent (and money) to get an actor like Church to do something that anyone in the World Wrestling Federation could do with ease. I’m happy the guy got a bigger paycheck than Sideways or George Of The Jungle offered him, but it would’ve been nice to see him interact with anybody, which is largely left to his Sandman form where cool looking sand effects are ruined by a goofy Stay Puft Marshmellow Man roar.
The whole thing’s a bit of a bust, really. It would’ve been better to cut something else entirely, like removing Flint to focus on Harry, the black costume and Venom or removing Gwen and Venom to give Marko more depth or at least some damn dialogue. There certainly needed to be fewer scenes of Peter strutting and the whole final act is just a redo of the first two with some neat special effects. The film doesn’t work as a whole, but it’s okay.
As much as I love the character, I’m cautious about this new film. Once bitten by a radioactive, you get magnificent powers. Once bitten by a comic book film franchise, twice shy.

Still from the new Amazing Spider-Man



Adam Clarke | Mon, Aug 1, 2011 | 1098
On Screen