
Every week, Andrew Harvey live tweets live from St. John’s city council chambers. Follow him on Monday afternoons at http://twitter.com/thescopeNL
Andrew Harvey here to bring you the call of all the municipal madness from the bunker on New Gower.
I am again joined in the gallery by striking Metrobus workers, who have been at council each week since they went on strike.
It’s budget day!
I just had to argue with someone from the city clerk’s office to get a copy of the budget.
She wouldn’t give me a copy of the budget until she asked the city’s communication officer who said, “yeah, he’s the Twitter guy”
That’s right, I’m the Twitter guy, and I am just as legitimate as any other media-type who sits on the floor of council chambers.
The mill rate is set to be increased by 0.5 mills. This will be discussed and voted on today.
This increase of 0.5 mills would be an increase in property tax of $100/yr for a $200k home.
The residential water tax will increase by $10 to $580/yr per home.
Council has started to assemble. As Frank Galgay entered, the Metrobus workers said, “you didn’t forget about us did you Frank?”
I am not sure what exactly the Metrobus workers are hoping to accomplish. Council has made it clear that try are not getting involved.
“His worship, the Mayor”… O’Keefe has arrived, and the meeting has begun.
Paul Mackey from the city is making a presentation regarding changes to garbage collection over the holidays.
All of council is in attendance for this budget meeting.
Changes to the garbage collection schedule start on Dec. 18th. For next week everyone is a day early.
Please check your calendar, or call 3-1-1 if you have questions.
Paul Mackey says that Christmas wrapping paper is not recyclable, and should be treated as garbage. Unless you wrap in old newspaper, that is
A business on 84 Gower Street is being converted to a residential property. Is this the old furniture store? Someone run down for me.
RT @NostalgicNerd Google Street View says yes, the one with the funky statue outside it.
The nomenclature committee is naming 6 new streets, and renaming one old one.
Duff is presenting the budget as the chair of the finance committee.
45% of the increase in city expenditures will go to wages and benefits.
Addressing concerns over the increases to city budgets, Duff says these are related to increasing service levels, and new regional services.
Duff says that our budgets carry the cost of some of these regional services are cost-shared with other municipalities.
She says these cost-shared services are deceptive, and make the increase in our budget look worse than it is, as we recoup some of this $.
Commercial tax rates and business occupancy tax will also increase by 0.5 mill.
Hanlon: “I know that no one here likes to see an increase in tax, but I will support the budget.”
Hanlon is also happy to see the relief for seniors, with the seniors tax discount increasing to 25% (from 20%).
Galgay: “This city is expanding in leaps and bounds”
RT dougjonesphoto the city is expanding in an irresponsible manner and spiraling out of control.
@dougjonesphoto Agreed, we are paying a fortune for servicing large areas of unsustainable urban sprawl.
Galgay also says that in-migration to the NE Avalon places much more demands on city infrastructure.
Galgay: “I don’t like increasing taxes either, but we have to be responsible.”
Breen says he will not support the budget. He does not agree with all of the city’s grants and subsidies.
Another place Breen disagrees with on a “philosophical level” are some programs which the city funds. He did not give an example of which.
Breen: “We need to start looking at three year budgets, which will bring some stability”
Breen says in the new year he will bring a motion forward to expand the mandate of the audit committee, which he chairs.
Breen says he does not think they did enough to ensure the budget was as efficient as it could have been.
O’Leary says that it is important to ensure we continue to fund cultural, recreational and community groups through grants.
O’Leary says that although it is not in this budget, she does not agree with increasing salaries for councillors.
Tilley says he cannot support the budget on a matter of principle. He is doing this to stand up for his constituents.
Tilley says that because of our zero-based budget, it leaves no room for reducing budgets for individual programs.
Tilley: “The Fortis project, we threw it out the window.” Not quite Bruce, council never voted on it.
Tilley wants a full review of city services. He cites that the city pays $100k for the Aquarena, and collects no tax from the university.
As Tom Hann stood, Metrobus workers all coughed in unison.
Hann: “We have done a lot on the cycling plan, which I question as a priority right now.”
Hann says that we have not done enough to bring the sides together on development.
Hann says she is shocked to see that the city gave money to a cellist to go to Toronto to renew their creative juices.
Hann: “We cannot continue to turn these things [proposals] down.”
Hann: “A complete review is long overdue of how we spend taxpayers dollars.”
Hickman says that at the beginning of the process he did not expect to have to increase taxes.
Hickman also agrees that we need a full operational review of the city to find efficiencies.
Hickman has a plea for the provincial government, that the city needs enhanced support from the province.
Hickman says that we should try and work out an arrangement for payment in lieu of services for what we do for provincial buildings.
Hickman “begrudgingly accepts” the budget.
This is Colbert’s 21st budget! He says he will support it.
Hickman says that the main thing we need to keep in our mind is our debt-equity ratio.
Colbert says that our city staff, councillors, and citizens have worked for the last 20 years to keep the city in excellent financial shape.
Colbert: “This city can stand above all others in the province, possibly across Canada” in relation to our debt-equity ratio.
Colbert says that because of the good financial state we are in, when federal funding becomes available, we are able to avail of it.
Collins: “The same three guys who aren’t voting for it this year didn’t vote for it last year.”
Collins: “That’s only BS as far as I’m concerned,” talking about the dissenters complaints, and inability to point to where to save $6.8 million.
O’Keefe: “We have been voted the #6 city in Canada… That vibrancy comes with a cost.” In reference to our ranking on the most livable cities in Canada list by the Conference Board of Canada.
Going back to what Collins said, he said the dissenters never came up with any solutions where to find the $6.8 million gap.
Collins says they only criticized grants of tens of thousands, not the millions they needed to make up.
O’Keefe is proud that they will keep service levels that people reasonably expect, and currently have. “That adds up to a reasonable budget”
O’Keefe: “You can’t talk about restraint then go and spend a quarter million on an operational review. I won’t support that.”
O’Keefe also says that we need to look at how municipalities are funded, provincially, and federally.
O’Keefe: “So ends the sermon” to his own rant on the budget.
O’Keefe says this is “not a budget of restraint,” but a reasonable one.
Duff: “We have a philosophical debate here about what kind of city we want.” In reference to going back to core values of the city only providing infrastructure and essential services.
Budget passed! With Tilley, Breen, and Hann voting against.
Duff wants to thank Ron Penney for the stability he has brought to the city, and the fine staff he leaves the city with.
O’Leary is asking where this council isn’t encouraging both parties in getting back to the table to negotiate an end to the Metrobus strike.
O’Leary comments got huge applause from the crowd.
Hann: “Despite what the busdrivers might think, there is a lot going on behind the scenes.”
Hann says they will continue to offer suggestions, and they want to see an end to this strike.
Colbert says that Ron Penney has not done a good job, but an outstanding job.
Collins: “[Ron Penney] can finally throw away his nerve pills.”
O’Keefe: “The man exudes [fiscal prudence]” in reference to Ron Penney.
O’Keefe would like to see both sides make “a valiant effort” to resolve the Metrobus strike before Christmas.
Ron Penney: “It has been a tremendous honour to be the city manager of St. John’s.”
That’s all folks, that was the last meeting of 2010. It has been a pleasure tweeting you, see ya in 2011. Andrew Harvey out.



December 14th, 2010 at 7:29 pm
Looks like we have 3 councilors down there who are looking out for the interests of their constituents. Hats off to them. The rest of them should hang their heads.
In a time when one of them or another are in the media talking about deficits, you’d think they’d have the sense to demonstrate some fiscal responsibility. But no, here they are wasting money on things like a cellist to “recharge their juices” in Toronto.
Why is O’Keefe so afraid of an operational review? Afraid he might lose one of his cruise ship related trips?
We should have elected Ellsworth when we had a chance. At least he knows how to make money.
December 14th, 2010 at 8:51 pm
We need term limits for city councilors. The only purpose of council should be to run the city smoothly, instead we get stuck with the likes of Dennis O’Keefe, who’s biggest concern is his own cruise ship vacations every year, and Shannie Duff, who is controlled by the city’s small band of far-left wackos. They should both be turfed from office. I agree with the comment above. I didn’t like Ellsworth either, but if I had my time back I would have voted for him.
December 15th, 2010 at 2:35 pm
I have to say, I don’t know the background behind the whole Cellist comment, or what the story is there, but I agree that it sounds ridiculous. Especially as in Toronto they won’t even be putting dollars back into the St. John’s economy.
Outside of the more extreme examples such as that, I am generally in favour of the Grants program. As other councillors pointed out, the entire grants program is something like $100k (I may be wrong on this, I will check the budget when I have a chance), and is a tiny fraction in a massive budget like we have.
The benefit of supporting local artists, non-profits, and community groups far outweigh the small cost in my opinion. The trick is that it is so difficult to measure such benefit, as it is not a direct cost-savings or profit-generator. The benefits of these grants come in cultural and social forms, which do indeed translate into economic ones through a vibrant community which people want to visit, and come spend their money in. Ask any shop-owner, tour guide, or hotel owner if they benefit from the unique culture of our wonderful city.
I definitely agree that some sort of review needs to happen, but hopefully not at a cost of $250k, which is a number O’Keefe threw out there. Finding efficiencies within departments seems like something which could (and should already) be done in-house, or with limited expertise brought in from an external party. Running a department as efficiently as possible should be the job of the management structures within city staff, not that of council, who are not experts in the fields they would be looking at.
Danny Breen pointed to the problem that in the budgetary process, they can only approve or deny full programs. For example, when they are looking at a program such as the operation of the Bannerman park pool, there will be a cost associated with the program, say it is $100k (I have no idea how much it actually is). They either must approve the program and set aside $100k for it, or deny it, and not have the pool open. There is no opportunity to fund the program at a lower cost, such as saying they will give $80k, and operate with reduced hours.
This all or nothing approach does not give council much room to be creative with the budget, or work to find efficiencies within programs. They have to trust this has happened before it came to the budget. Obviously some councillors do not feel this has happened to a degree they are happy with.
How they manage to change the budgetary process, or the inner workings of the cities finance is still up in the air. Danny Breen also mentioned that in the new year he will be making a motion to expand the mandate of the audit committee to help find efficiencies. We will see exactly how he will do this, but it sounds like a good start that does not require $250k, and works within the existing structure with few changes required.
As far as term limits, I don’t really think they are necessary. If we had a limit of 2 or 3 terms, we would lose almost half of council. If some of the longer-serving members of council were that unpopular, then why do they keep getting voted in? Don’t get me wrong, as someone who ran in the election against an incumbent of 3-terms, I am all for new blood in council. If the majority of people are discontent with a stale council, then they need to voice this discontent through the only voice that matters in representative democracy, the ballot.
December 16th, 2010 at 1:22 am
Term limits are a controversial idea, I’ll give you that, and there are certainly two sides of the debate. However in this case I really cant believe that these councilors stay in office due to their popularity. I think it has more to do with voter apathy. Very few people are satisfied with the way the city is being run, however there seems to be this attitude of “Well, Shannie Duff and Gerry Colbert (etc) are just going to get back in anyway, so who cares?”. I also think that this attitude discourages sensible people from making serious runs for municipal office. Why put a lot of time and money into a losing campaign when you realize that most people aren’t even going to pay attention to you?
You say you’re all for new blood on council. However it seems that the only time we ever get “new blood” is when the people have no choice but to vote for new councilors, meaning whenever current councilors retire or resign to run for mayor or deputy mayor. Shannie Duff and Gerry Colbert in particular treat municipal elections like a game of musical chairs. Colbert, for example, knew he was about to be driven out of the deputy mayor’s job a few years ago by Dennis O’Keefe, so rather than defend his job he decided to run for a safer councilor-at-large seat. That isn’t right, he should have moved on so we could have a new face on council.
I think that in this case term limits could invigorate democracy in the city. I think that more voters would actually take an interest, and that more candidates would be willing to make serious campaigns. The last bi-election and general election were relatively interesting, but only because the current councilors had to shake things up a bit after Mayor Well’s resignation, particularly with Shannie Duff and Keith Coombs resigning to run against each other for deputy mayor. I think that we should make the occasional “shake up” of council mandatory.
December 16th, 2010 at 1:30 pm
As far as voter apathy, I checked yesterday, and in the last municipal election, there was a 48.38% voter turnout, which was actually much higher then I thought it was, and is actually quite good for a municipal election. Obviously it is still disappointing that we cannot convince half of the population to vote, but I think that a bigger issue is a lack of debate, and information about municipal issues.
In the last election, the only real issue was that the mil rate should be decreased, which no candidate I was aware of disagreed with. I would argue that the candidates who got in largely did so because of their name, rather than any real issues (perhaps excluding the deputy-mayor, and mayor races, where you do see much more legitimate debate).
As a new candidate, what I found frustrating about the process was that there was no opportunity to give the public a chance to compare where the candidates stood on issues that were important to them. Also, because the election is run through mail-in ballots, 3/4 of the votes were already cast with 2 weeks left in the campaign. This only gives a couple of weeks really to get your name out there as a new candidate, let along have time to inform the public about where you stand on issues.
I think what we really need is for more people to pay attention to city council, and bring some accountability to the process. If people are unhappy with how things are being run, they need to let someone know on council. If you don’t tell them what you want them to do it, you cannot reasonably assume they will.
I think if council tried harder to engage the public, we could have a lively, robust debate on important municipal issues, and we would all feel more accountable for the decisions which are made. Instead, I think people feel like they have no effect on the system, so they ignore it. The public input council does solicit feels forced, and disingenuous in most cases, as a regrettable hoop to jump through at the end of a process after a decision has already been made. The public needs to be involved earlier, and more often in all municipal matters.
If we did this, the question of term limits would probably not matter, as our council would more accurately reflect the opinions of the public.