
The St. John’s city council live blog: the 21st century intruding on a council trying to stay in the 20th.
O’Keefe’s here and the meeting has started.
We have a delegation for fire prevention week. The theme for this year is smoke alarms, “the sound of safety.”
They want to make sure everyone has good inspection routines for their own homes fire safety equipment.
On Oct. 9th there will be an open house at the central fire station. Be safe everyone, make sure you check your own alarms regularly.
Gerry Colbert is the only councilor missing. All others here, in fine form.
We now have a proclamation for the Thanksgiving Food drive by Metrobus and VOCM cares.
They are trying to stuff a bus (or two), full of food. Many food banks have bare shelves, so be generous people.
There will be boxes on Metrobuses, and in Sobeys around the city. Please give some food if you can people, more and more people need it.
Some land on Old Bay Bulls Rd. was rezoned to Residential Low Density (RLD) after no one submitted any written objections to the change.
If they schedule a public meeting, and no written concerns are submitted before a certain date, they will cancel the meeting. This is why it is important to put your concerns on any proposal or change in writing (email is fine).
Tom Hann has taken objection to comments made in an editorial which he says unfairly characterizes city staff.
The man from Toronto the called our city staff lazy, and Hann says this is unfair. He checked on it, and the staff were on a break.
Hann wants a letter sent to the man, and O’Keefe also wants to send a letter to the Telegram also.
O’Keefe is upset that this was put in the Telegram, when they made no effort to contact the city to check their facts.
Paul Mackey from Public works is also disappointed, and calls the timing “unfortunate”, and is “demoralizing” for city staff.
City staff have been out working hard to clean up since Igor. All of council is pretty riled up about the letter from a Torontonian.
Yellowbelly Brewery wants to put a convenience store on Bond St. There were several concerns, which staff want to review. It has been deferred
There is a proposal for a Food Delivery service on Sterling Cr. There were 5 written concerns to this, mostly about parking and traffic.
The application for Sterling Cr. has also been deferred.
Sandy Hickman wants to thank city staff for their work on Igor. If you need a pickup for fallen trees, call 311.
Public works says that they already have hundreds of requests for this, so it may be a few weeks for them to get around.
Hickman says that the city spent $6mil this year on roads, but they need much more. We have a huge capital works deficit.
We need to be spending 5% (I assume of the budget), to upkeep the roads, and in the last several years it has only been 2.3%.
Hann says that it is striking to “see it in black and white” that what we need $9mil to fix our roads.
O’Leary is happy to see that the Golden Broom award will be looked at by SJ Clean and Beautiful. This is an award for clean businesses.
Duff wants to see what the direct impact on our operating budget will be from Igor. Apparently there is some relief funding available.
There is a report from city staff about financial support for the arts community. In 2009 it was $880k, in $914k.
This includes a wide array of programs and grants. O’Keefe says it is clear we support the arts here in St. John’s.
There is also a note on the report that council accepted a recommendation to increase funding by $100k in the next 2 years.
This recommendation is nice, but will be put to the 2011 budget first.
Duff says that we are very generous, but the numbers in this report include amounts for the Geocentre, and the Junos.
Hann says maybe we could look at a different way of supporting the arts such as helping them plan events, and access other funding.
Hann says we have to support the arts, but we also have to be prudent with taxpayers money. Especially in a tight budget like next year.
Hanlon says we may be able to help take artists to the next level, by helping them get into international markets, etc.
O’Keefe is looking at some rules coming out of a 1998 committee meeting which govern council. This is coming out of a few heated debates.
These rules cover decorum at meetings, and Galgay thinks that they have all broken some of these rules, but just wants it to be fair.
O’Keefe says that there has to be some flexibility in the rules, but he hopes people will police themselves.
Collins: “If they were as long working as they were talking, they would get more done” Wally says that people need to get to the point.
Duff says that the core part about the meeting should be debate, and each councilor should have the opportunity to explain their vote.
O’Leary says that one of the reasons she ran for councilor at large was to be able to bring forward ideas from other municipalities.
Hann says that he has seen video cameras used, and even a dog in the gallery, which would not be allowed in provincial legislature.
Hann also says that it should be a privilege to sit in the gallery. He also said that he has seen councillors be “ambushed” by reporters on the floor of council.
These comments scare me a little bit, as I already see council as being a bit inaccessible, and moving towards more control in council chambers would not help this.
Breen is mentioning that an area to improve on in communication with the public is through technology.
The city has approached the Province to see if there is anything we can do to help, by providing equipment, staff, etc. to help other towns.
There is a public meeting this Wed 7-9pm on the Cities Economic roadmap. Hanlon encourages everyone to come by and give input.
Collins: “I guarantee you some of those guys, if they had of been issued 2 sets of oilskins, they would have worn both of them out”
Collins on city staff during Igor.
That’s all folks, tweet you next week.



September 28th, 2010 at 10:10 pm
More urban sprawl has been approved!!!
What happened with the approval of 351 Water Street? As well last week you mentioned a proposal for Harvey Road being deferred, do you know anything else about it?
September 29th, 2010 at 11:53 am
Hey Jordan,
For 351 Water St, I believe that no formal approval has been given because of the changes which are required to the municipal plan. These changes are well underway (if not completed), and the formal approval for the site will have to wait until the changes are in effect. I know it has to go to the province for inclusion into the provincial law which governs all municipalities. As far as I know this hasn’t happened yet.
All I know about the Harvey Rd proposal, was that it was a proposal which was apparently discussed at the committee level, but was not included in the minutes, and Tom Hann brought this up, asking why it was not. The consensus was that although the committee had originally looked to approve it (I gathered, and I may be wrong), city staff realized after that there was something about the proposal which was outside of regulations in some way, and asked them to remove it from the report, as it would no longer be approved.
That’s about all I know about this, and this is simply my own memory of the discussion from 2 weeks ago, so take that as you will.
I have emailed Tom Hann about this, and will try to get more details. I will share these as soon as I get them.
Thanks, as always, for reading and becoming engaged in the discussion Jordan.
September 30th, 2010 at 9:38 am
Tom Hann got back to me, and told me that his understanding was that the proposal went to the Heritage Advisory Committee, which recommended approval with some changes, but then after the initial meeting, city staff had discussions, and made the decision to defer the approval and discuss it at a later meeting. This should be coming back to council soon.
Hope this helps Jordan.
September 30th, 2010 at 12:11 pm
Ms Duff is right, there needs to be more time devoted to discussing issues.
September 30th, 2010 at 12:39 pm
Hey Jack,
I would tend to agree, this whole discussion over what councillors discuss, and for how long has been going on for some time now in council. Several times Dennis O’Keefe has stopped Shannie Duff when speaking, stating that it is either not on topic, or unnecessary.
I understand both of their points, as O’Keefe has the sometimes difficult job of keeping the meeting on track, and moving along. They technically each have 5 minutes to speak every time they stand, but as O’Keefe points out, they would be there an hour just to go around to each councillor once.
What Duff has taken exception to in the past weeks/months is that she has been cut off when she feels it is fully within her rights to be speaking on an issue. The last time this happened, she was giving an update on the progress of the bike plan when discussing a motion to approve a committee report which made recommendations about the cycling plan. In this case, I found the information she was providing to be very useful, and was in the middle of typing something about it in a tweet for the liveblog when O’Keefe stopped her, stating that she was off topic. Not only did I not get any more information out to the public about the cycling plan at that point, but they then went on for several minutes arguing whether or not she should have been able to be discussing what she was.
The much more sensible discussion they had on the matter last week seemed to come to the general consensus that the best scenario would be for people to try and regulate themselves more often, with no one wanting to have to be cut off, or have to cut off anyone. They presented a report from way back in 1998 which outlined guidelines for streamlining council meetings, which state what is, and is not allowed to be discussed at council meetings. I have a hard copy of this as it was included in the minutes for the meeting, but if you would like to see this, I would suggest contacting a member of council.
In general, I hope we can move beyond this fighting, and get back to orderly, productive business, without the fighting… like adults.
October 1st, 2010 at 12:29 pm
The fighting is my favorite part, I only tend to watch if I know a fight happened.
Any mention of the size of the Harvey Road proposal?
October 1st, 2010 at 12:56 pm
The fighting is exciting, I will give you that Jordan, but from a city productivity point-of-view, it is preferable to have more reasonable discussion to deal with the pressing issues at hand for the city.
Many of the disagreements in council stem from ideological differences between councillors, which is fine, and desirable in a well-rounded council, but it is when things become personal that it stops being about finding common ground, or compromise, and starts being a thinly-veiled insult-hurling competition.
I hope the councillors continue to have the fire which drives them to be passionate about the issues which they argue about, but hope that they can be civil when they do so.
October 1st, 2010 at 12:58 pm
P.S. I have no idea any other details about the Harvey Rd Proposal, I don’t even know what type of building it was for, although if I had to guess, I would say condos. They are a pretty safe bet these days in DT St. John’s.