Muskrat Falls
“Muss-crat Falls by”, “Musquart Falls”, “Muskrats keep falling on my head”, “muskrat effing falls.”
Runner Up: The weather
Other Answers: “Arguing over building heights”, “Kathy Dunderdale’s weight loss”, “Mainlander’s complaints”
We are all sick to death of hearing about Muskrat Falls. Nobody wants to hear about it and nobody wants to talk about it anymore. For, against, whatever; you bring it up in polite company and the very words grate like gravel in the throat.
But since a multi-billion dollar hydroelectric project in Labrador is sort of a big deal, it’s probably worth going over at least one last time.
In November 2010, former Premier and future hockey magnate Danny Williams inked a partnership agreement between our province and Nova Scotia energy corporation Emera Inc. to develop build a dam on the Lower Churchill at the Muskrat Falls site. From there, they would run power cables across the Strait of Belle Isle into the Newfoundland electrical grid, and then further on down across the Cabot Strait into the Maritime Provinces, bypassing the villainous Hydro-Quebec on its way to American energy markets. Within a couple weeks of signing this, Williams was out and Kathy Dunderdale was in to carry the torch for the province’s latest go at a megaproject on the Churchill River. Despite many twists and turns, this remains the gist of the plot.
‘Muskrat Falls’ has since become all things to all people. For its proponents, there is much to recommend it. Jerome Kennedy—certainly the most eloquent of the project’s spokespeople in government—has repeatedly affirmed that Muskrat Falls will satisfy the province’s growing need for power, and that it is the least-cost option to satisfy this demand when compared to developing an ‘isolated island’ alternative. This is the position reiterated endlessly by Nalcor, the province’s crown energy corporation, and over the course of the last two years it has commissioned a slew of reviews from consultants like Manitoba Hydro, Ziff Energy, and Navigant that all confirm Muskrat Falls is indeed the bee’s knees. Muskrat Falls means a source of clean, renewable energy to replace the dirty oil burned at the Holyrood power plant, and it will provide the energy needed to expand lucrative mining operations in Labrador. We would create over a hundred thousand hours of employment in the trades while building it, and with this dam we would break the power of Quebec over Newfoundland forever.
But others would suggest that this picture is not nearly as rosy as government and its paid consultants like to insist. Despite being proffered as a green project necessary to meet the province’s energy needs at the lowest cost, a 2011 joint federal-provincial review panel failed to endorse it on either end. When the Public Utilities Board also failed to endorse the project in early 2012 citing insufficient information to make a decision, the government banished them forever from having anything to do with it in a move that turned out to be surprisingly unpopular with the Irish Descendants (or at least Con O’Brien). A public policy supergroup named Energy 2041 emerged to issue a flurry of press releases warning that Hydro-Quebec’s going to sue us into oblivion, and we learned that Richard Cashin’s favourite book is the Cole’s Notes to Nineteen Eighty-Four.
Other policy experts and interested observers have variously prophesied that there will be no export market for Muskrat electricity, and that the federal government giving money to flip off Quebec like this is probably not how the country is supposed to operate. Innu elders (including Peter Penashue’s own mother) have raised concerns about the impact that building the dam might have on the local ecosystem and their traditional hunting and trapping grounds. The estimated cost of all this has also risen from $6.2 billion initially to over $7.7 with little accounting for potential cost overruns which, if incurred, will show up on your electric bill.
These are some of the more sensible criticisms. If you follow the social media fringe all the way down the rabbit hole, you’re liable to discover that ‘Kathy’ is an anagram for ‘Stalin’, that Ryan Snoddon gets his weather reports directly from the Office of Public Engagement, and that Stephen Harper is in league with the Bilderberg Group to sell Labrador to Europe. Brad Cabana is even gone to court arguing that the project is a violation of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Muskrat Falls has become a Rorschach test for your very own political neurosis.
A lot of the public discontent with the project stems from the fact that by almost any metric, the political process was handled about as poorly as possible by everyone involved. Government officials (and many critics) openly mocked and disparaged the credibility of anyone who disagreed with their stated position to the extent that the word ‘expert’ became effectively meaningless. Regulatory oversight was marginalized seemingly out of spite, and the provincial government played fast and loose with our legislative process. When they struck the Public Utilities Board out of the review process, they promised to make up for it with a special debate in the House of Assembly. They later obstructed this debate by refusing to allow the testimony of expert witnesses in the House (despite the fact that this happens regularly, as a matter of due process, in every other legislature in Canada). At best, it was cynically cutting institutional corners to accelerate a resource development; at worst, it was an arrogant disrespect for the basic institutions of representative democracy.
Muskrat Falls carries a lot of emotional baggage. Collectively, we’re still not over how sour everything went the last time we built a dam on the Churchill River, and government consciously tapped into those feelings in order to sell this project to the public. It’s a funny coincidence that Kathy Dunderdale officially sanctioned the project on December 17th, 2012—the 21st anniversary of Joe Smallwood’s death. The significance of this has yet to be fixed in history, but eventually we will be able to look back and say that was the day we either exorcised his ghost forever or reaffirmed that he still haunts the eighth floor of Confederation Building, rattling the chains of hubris and paternalism.
So, now the chips are down and there is nothing left to do but see how Muskrat Falls plays out. In the meantime, can we please talk about something else?
Drew Brown




2013
Best of St. John's