Is there something about beer that requires they be bottled in glass bottles? And why are most of those bottles brown (or green) and so few clear? Does it make a difference in the quality, or is it merely tradition?
Asked by
Anonymous asked this question on Tuesday at 3 pm.
Is there something about beer that requires they be bottled in glass bottles? And why are most of those bottles brown (or green) and so few clear? Does it make a difference in the quality, or is it merely tradition?
Asked by
August 16th, 2011 at 6:45 pm
I’m no expert, but, I would say that most are brown/green due to the fact that long exposure to light makes beer go bad. The brown/green shade helps it last longer. As for why some are clear? Well, I guess its just a matter of marketing.
My question is, why does Newfoundland beer have short necks?
August 16th, 2011 at 7:41 pm
UV light can cause beer to go ‘skunky’. Brown or amber coloured bottles reduce the amount of UV light getting to the beer.
August 17th, 2011 at 11:46 am
“My question is, why does Newfoundland beer have short necks?”
tradition. I don’t know how it started initially but thats why they keep them short.
August 17th, 2011 at 1:13 pm
Beer in bottles is the current norm for consumer trade packages although plastic and aluminium bottles and cans are becoming more popular in certain markets. Cans and plastic have certain advantages to the brewer but consumer acceptance is often difficult.
I personally like glass bottles for beer. When you drink from an aluminium can, you are actually drinking out of plastic (plastic liner inside can). As I generally don’t like putting petroleum based products near my mouth as a rule, beer for me comes in stainless steel (kegs), glass or wood.
As to the colour question, beer is packaged in brown glass to protect it from light. There is a reaction of certain hop compounds to UV-B light which leads to the formation of a compound known as 3-methyl-2-butene-1-thiol (or 3-MBT). This compound is very ‘skunky’ in aroma and is detectable by most at the level of 4 parts per trillion. It is one of the most powerful flavour/aroma compounds found in beer.
3-MBT is also more commonly formed in beer bottles by the excitiation of riboflavin molecules by visible light (blue-green, 490-500 nm wavelength) to their triplet state which then cascade into a reaction with certain hop compounds leading to 3-MBT in the bottle. This reaction can happen in less than a second in full sunlight.
Wow. That last paragraph was seriously geeky.
Brown bottles protect beer better at this blue-green wavelength. The worst is flint glass (clear) followed by green and blue bottles (too close to call), followed by brown and then black. Aluminum cans are of course, opaque to light.
Pax.
Liam
August 19th, 2011 at 9:30 pm
a man who knows that much about beer! <3 it, and <3 to take you for a beer. Glass bottle or pint of course.