The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
2
Like

Why did the scope remove the comment voting feature?

asked this question on Saturday at 6 pm.

Whats is this, notreddit?

Asked by

 

19 Responses

  1. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    The honest answer:

    We’re planning a few improvements to the site and after a beer I decided to try to implement one without testing it first. It seemed like it was working but then we think because of a bug in the plugin it borked the database.. or the change cause some kind of javascript conflict. We had to disable it. So… errr… sorry. Ah derpt it.

    I’m hoping to have it fixed in the coming week though, or have something similar in place.

  2. avatar
    chickenworth st Says:

    You’d better fix it soon man, Gordon Gecko is escaping the wrath of downvotes

  3. avatar
    Max Zorin Says:

    People will “vote up” a comment because they actually like it (which is good). People will “vote down” a comment just because they can (for no legitimate reason). No big loss if the voting system doesn’t come back because it’s not really that accurate anyway.

  4. avatar
  5. avatar
    Max Zorin Says:

    I bet if you removed the anonymous commenting system and used the Facebook plug-in only there would be less nasty comments on the site as well. It wouldn’t stop completely, but it would cut it down considerably.

  6. avatar
    Stumper Says:

    Some people have jobs which limit their ability to participate in discussion of public issues, and they would not be able to do so if they were forced to identify themselves, particularly if the issue involved something controversial or political. While you do get haters, you also get a lot of well reasoned, and sometimes unusually well informed comments from anonymous commenters. So, I’m agin Max’s idea.

  7. avatar
    anon3 Says:

    you know, if you want to comment on 22minutes, or on the Lang Oleary exchange (both CBC shows) you have to join facebook, as there is no place to discuss on the CBC’s site. As a canadian taxpayer and forever hater of all things F-book, this deserves a challenge in terms of “Charter of Rights and Freedoms”.
    Why has CBC cowed to the societal pressure of the Facebook overlords?
    leave Facebook out of the scope.
    people (even doctors) smoked for years ‘because everyone does’. they were all wrong.
    same applies to F-book, you just don’t know it yet.

  8. avatar
    Max Zorin Says:

    Participation in a discussion isn’t required.

  9. avatar
    Max Zorin Says:

    How is “optional commenting” a violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms? No one is forced to voice their opinion(s) on the internet. That being said, the “right to remain silent” is a right that a lot of people should start practicing.

  10. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    Bringing up the Charter is a bit wacky, but other than that I agree with anon3. An alternative newspaper like the Scope should not lower itself to screening commenters through Facebook. It’s a sinister website and I hate the way it keeps infiltrating more and more parts of society, getting to the point where having a FB account is practically a social obligation. Those of us who see FB for what it is and refuse to sign up are already excluded from enough, the Scope doesn’t need to go there.

  11. avatar
    Max Zorin Says:

    I agree it wouldn’t solve the trolling problem completely, it would certainly limit it. The way the Scope operates now is like running a PC without virus protection…it’s wide open. One doesn’t even need to enter a real email address to submit a comment. It’s a trollers paradise.

  12. avatar
    BOB Says:

    Facebook hasn’t infiltrated society any more than text messaging has. Sign up or don’t sign up, it’s your choice.

    Very moot point Gordon, I expected more from you.

  13. avatar
    Troll Says:

    Gekko doesn’t want any part of this because he/she thinks Facebook is sinister. Sound pretty solid.

  14. avatar
    Stumper Says:

    Bob is missing Gordon’s point, which is connected with the original post. More and more in today’s society, if you want to participate in what is going on around you, you are being forced to join Facebook. Yes, no one is forcing you to join Facebook, but the consequence of that choice, more and more, is social exclusion, as well as the curtailing of the right to participate in dialogue on public issues, which is a core democratic right. Even these sometimes inane discussions on Scope are part of that right, and if we were forced to join Facebook in order to continue to participate, where your information can be used for all kinds of purposes beyond your control and where even information which you thought was private may not be, that is an unfair impediment to accessing that right.

  15. avatar
    BOB Says:

    Stumper:

    This is not nearly as complicated as you and Gordon are making it. Create a bogus Facebook account with fake information and comment away. Problem solved. I’m not sure where the big privacy invasion is in that.

  16. avatar
    Stumper Says:

    Bob,

    Max Zorin was proposing Facebook as a way of eliminating anonymous commenters. If I can simply make up a fake identify, then the whole point of going to Facebook is moot. Therefore, why not simply maintain anonymous commenting on Scope!?

  17. avatar
    BOB Says:

    Stumper,

    I’m suggesting a way for those who don’t wish to reveal their identity to continue to comment. I’m not picking up for Max. Believe it or not, it is completely possible to create a bogus Facebook account. Just don’t input your own personal information. For those who already have Facebook accounts, just change your name (yes, it is that easy). It’s the same thing as going to Hotmail or Yahoo and making up bogus email accounts, which is done all the time.

  18. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    I’m well aware that one can remain anonymous even on Facebook, however I am opposed, on principle, to any further integration of Facebook into public/online discourse. My reasons for this have already been briefly outlined by myself and others here. Let Facebook be Facebook, but don’t bring that nonsense onto other non-affiliated websites such as the Scope.

    More importantly, I don’t think this site has a “trolling problem”. From what I have seen of it the “I Saw You” section can be a bit a trashy at times, but for the most part even the trolls here are relatively civilized. Nothing needs to be done, the site is fine the way it is.

  19. avatar
    Max Zorin Says:

    Gordon & Stumper,

    It’s pretty evident that your personal disgust for Facebook and its integration into society is stronger than your reasoning behind why it shouldn’t be integrated into society. Your personal disgust isn’t a valid reason.

    You both tried to use the issue of privacy to support your argument, which isn’t really an issue at all according to BOB’s suggestions. The concern of privacy can be essentially zero if you desire it to be. I stand by my point that it would essentially help to weed out trolls and grammar police, because people who aren’t serious about providing constructive input to an issue probably won’t take the time to create the required accounts.

    I won’t be reading or providing anymore input on this thread because it has turned into a show of personal disgruntlement with social networking.

    I see the Scope has already implemented an optional Facebook commenting plug-in on some areas of their website, so you might as well accept it. Good luck with it. Maybe you’ll win the next one.


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.