The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
8
Like

When is it ok to tell someone their child’s behavior is unacceptable?

asked this question on Tuesday at 10 am.

When is it ok to tell a parent that their child is behaving completely unreasonably in public?

ie: Last week I was out for dinner with a friend and someone’s small child (around 3 or 4) was continually running over to our table, hiding under it, taking things off our table, and even attempted to take food from my plate. The parents watched this happening and did nothing, then called me a “Selfish B***h” when I went over to them and told them I didn’t appreciate the behavior and asked them to please refrain their child from interrupting our meal. Was I out of line?

Thanks!
-Bean

Asked by Bean

 

14 Responses

  1. avatar
    AAR Says:

    I don’t think you were out of line at all, those people were being terribly inconsiderate. You paid money to be there, and it is rude for anyone to disturb your meal, children are no different. Maybe you phrased your concern in a way that got their back up, I don’t know as I wasn’t there, but politely asking someone if they would mind preventing their kid from disturbing your meal certainly wasn’t out of line, I would have done the same. Not sure why people think it’s ok for their kids to run amok in public. You go to a restaurant to eat a meal, not to babysit and entertain other people’s kids. There is a level of disruption that can be tolerated, but the kid taking things from your table and hiding under the table is way over the line for me, lol.

  2. avatar
    Erin Says:

    Asshole kid, Asshole parents..yeesh!

  3. avatar
    Ana Says:

    You were most certainly not out of line and you handled the situation far better than I would have! Hiding under your table and trying to take things (including food!) off of it? I would have let out one resounding NO! to the children, and then gone straight to the restaurant management to request that they and their miserable excuse for parents be asked to leave.

    Oh how I wish St. John’s restaurants would start implementing a child-free night!

  4. avatar
    Emily Martin Says:

    This is such a big, common and anger inducing issue that I went ahead and consulted a REAL expert. My sister. She has two wonderful but very willful and sometimes terrifying children. She has come up with an entire “Parental Right of Eminent Domain Code of Ethics for my (and Others’) Children”
    She thought it would be too long to post but it is so good that I will post it all. I am also going to use it from now on. Thank you Sister Manners!

    ” ***If at the house in which the children live, try the following advice but you can also leave. If it’s at your place, try the following advice and/or kick them out. If it is a public place you must try harder and then, if unendurable, complain to management (this is a last resort and not always possible if it’s somewhere like a park)***

    ADVICE (in order of attempts):

    1. It is important to communicate to the child first. If the child is old enough to speak, speak politely and firmly to them and ask them to respect your space/property (insert specific detail relative to your situation). If they cannot yet speak, use gentle physical language (hand signs, GENTLE pushing, etc., nothing that would upset the parents too much) to stop their unpleasant activity.

    2. If the child can talk, but does not respond to polite requests, you may resort to stricter methods. These may upset parents; use caution and don’t do anything mean or physically harmful. These could include threatening to tell their parents, calling management, physically picking them up (if possible) and moving them, or simply talking loudly and sternly and in no uncertain terms to make your point that they are bothering you. [note: it IS fine to upset someone's parents but try to avoid this as it can be unpleasant for everyone]

    3. If (1) and (2) fail, then ask the parent politely to assist you in removing the annoying child. [note: do not resort to stricter voices with parents as they only respond negatively to this].

    4. If (3) fails: If it is a space owned by someone, call management. If it is a more public space or you do not want to go this far into confrontation then I guess you just have to leave. Sometimes kids are REALLY annoying. In that case, it may be that their parents are also being REALLY annoying. Do you want to start a big scuffle? No. Give up. Complain to your friends after you leave.

    5. If there are no parents present and (1) and (2) fail, then treat the child as an adult (keeping in mind the possible vocabulary limitations and lacking of life experience)

    6. If you are in the TERRIBLE situation when none of the above actions works AND you are unable to leave (ie. airplane, train, Doctor’s waiting room), keep in mind that you were once an annoying kid too and someone put up with your crap. Try your best to protect yourself from sticky little hands and then go with the flow of life and don’t have a heart attack over it. Remember: kids and babies cry more easily than (some) adults and cannot always be made to shut up; harsh words can also make kids cry; the parents don’t like it either when the kids are crying; the kids/babies are obviously not really happy. Sometimes it takes cleverness, time and extreme patience to deal with kids/babies.

    ***YOU CAN ASK KIDS TO RESPECT YOU AND YOUR SPACE BUT YOU CANNOT FULLY CONTROL THEM AS THEY ARE FREE HUMAN BEINGS. ALL HUMANS ARE ANNOYING AT TIMES. IF YOU GO OUT IN PUBLIC, YOU ARE BOUND TO ENCOUNTER IRRITATING HUMANS.*** ”

    There you have it. And a note from me: fighting bad manners with bad manners is like fighting fire with fire: Maybe it sounds bold but just try it and see how your tinderbox rowhouse neighbors react (ie calling someone an Asshole for calling someone a Bitch is silly at best).

    -Ms Manners

  5. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    I totally disagree with Emily Martin on this one. It is never a good idea to get directly involved in a situation like this involving strangers and their children, it’s a shit storm waiting to happen. Don’t talk to the child, definitely don’t try to discipline the child no matter how gently, and don’t try telling the parents how to raise their child. Go straight to the manager. This is their restaurant and it’s their responsibility to deal with the problem. In this situation I would even expect a free meal.

  6. avatar
    anon Says:

    yeahhhh i don’t know how kindly parents would react to someone politely asking for their assistance AFTER gently pushing or picking up their kids…

  7. avatar
    Ana Says:

    Emily Martin – Are you (and your sister) SERIOUS?

    If I am out enjoying a meal with my husband and/or friends WHY in HELL should I have to deal with anyone’s children on any level? That’s what the PARENTS are for!!

    I don’t for one second buy into this “it takes a village” crap. If I wanted to raise/educate/discipline children I would have had them. Someone else’s children are NOT my responsibility.

    As for speaking to the child, or in the case of non-verbal children (and what the hell are children that age doing wandering about unaccompanied in the first place?!) or touching them (gently or not) I agree with Anonymous above who says “it’s a shit storm waiting to happen”. Yes, that’s just what I want to accompany my now-already-ruined night out – some pissed off parent in my face, screaming at me for daring to lay a hand on their precious little darling.

    Parents – it is YOUR responsibility to ensure that your children are well behaved and if they are too young (or you are too lazy) to be well behaved then either stay home with them or hire a babysitter. If you can’t manage that, then you better believe I will be asking the management to escort you and your brood out.

  8. avatar
    Steveo Says:

    Wow, you’re cranky. Maybe you need a nap. I think Emily Martin’s suggestion was what to do as soon as the little tyke manages to slip away from their table and arrives at your table. I take my two pre-schoolers out to restaurants regularly (not Raymonds or anything like that, just regular family restaurants) and they’re very well behaved. Nine times out of ten they are in their seats the entire time and they don’t yell or scream or lose their tempers. One time in ten though, the littler one will get impatient at the end of the meal and need to squirm out of their seat. This usually involves me either picking the child up and strolling away from the dining area so as not to disturb the other guests. Also, probably less than one in ten visits, one of them will get upset about something they’re being given / not getting to eat. My approach is to do everything possible to resolve it within 30 seconds or so, and if that doesn’t happen, I remove the child from the dining area, and only bring them back in when the behaviour has ended. All that being said, and I hope Ana that my family is good enough for you to eat near, there is always the possibility that one of them will get away (particularly the 2 year old) and run over to a nearby table and give the people a big grin and try to talk to them. This usually results in cutesy talk from the people at that table to my child, I usually exchange some pleasantry and say sorry and they usually don’t mind at all.

    I don’t think parents should take children to evening fine dining restaurants if they can’t be reasonably counted on to behave, and I do think that parents should remove the child from the dining area if they cannot resolve a problem immediately if said problem involves potentially annoying other diners. The example which spawned this one is, in my experience of spending a lot of time (about weekly) in restaurants with my kids and other parents and kids, is a rather unusual one. It’s far from typical of parents and kids in restaurants, and those parents didn’t act appropriately by not reigning in their kids right away. Again, in the example, the diners were understandably upset, and the parents were entirely in the wrong in calling the diners names rather than apologizing and dealing with it. It does, however, sound like the diners put up with the child’s behaviour for too long – until they were boiling over mad, and perhaps were rude themselves in how they approached the parents, but that’s the only criticism I would make of them. If it’s bothering you, nip it in the bud. Personally, I would have no problem if a 2 or 3 or 4 year old were doing that to me to speak to them, and say clearly and firmly “excuse me – this is my table, not yours. Go back to your table and stay away from this one please because you’re bothering us.” Children are not often used to being spoken to that way by strange adults, and I personally think it would be effective. If that doesn’t work, I would go speak to the parents, and if that didn’t work I would speak to the management. By that time, yes, your evening would be sort of ruined, and you would have reason to get a free meal, because servers and managers should be watching out for this stuff too, and also aim to nip it in the bud by talking to parents of offending children.

  9. avatar
    Ana Says:

    I am not “cranky” Steveo, I am utterly and completely frustrated with parents who think that it is everyone else’s job to look after and out for their children. It is a situation that I encounter far too often and I am sick and tired of it.

    Again I will say – it is NOT my job to police other people’s children. Why should I be the one to have to “nip it in the bud”? I am paying good money to go to dinner, the theater, a concert, a museum, a movie, or a resort.

    I understand that occasionally children (especially pre-school age) get fussy and I truly appreciate the parents who DO deal with it immediately and with regard to others (I appreciate even more the ones who leave their children at home when it is not a “family friendly” event).

    What makes me so angry and frustrated are the parents who blithely sit enjoying their evening while their child screams and wails, throws food, wanders about (endangering themselves and the poor restaurant staff who then have to be hyper-vigilant about not running them over), or talks (or rather yells) non-stop at a volume that makes conversation with my dinner partner, or watching the movie, or enjoying the play absolutely impossible.

    If my evening is already interrupted by rude parents of rude children, I am certainly not going to waste more time on talking to either the child or the parents. Anyone so inconsiderate as to let their child behave like a wild animal in public probably won’t be amenable to my suggestions that they keep it better controlled, now will they?

  10. avatar
    Curtis Says:

    Living in a cave is becoming more and more appealing.

  11. avatar
    Joey Says:

    Even restaurant managers avoid confronting incompetent, inconsiderate, self-absorbed parents (see here for an example: http://goo.gl/a3ljl).

    These parents (and their kids) run the show. I and still see no valid reason why.

  12. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    More high-end restaurants should ban young children. If you want to take the rugrats out you should stick to Swiss Chalet or McDonalds, if you’re going to Raymonds or Portobellos you should be able to afford a babysitter.

  13. avatar
    Observer Says:

    “keep in mind that you were once an annoying kid too and someone put up with your crap”

    WHA’???

    Why do modern parents use this twisted logic seen so frequently in internet debates on this topic, usually expressed as “YOU were a child once” meaning that, on remote possiblity that I was once an annoying child, that I am deemed to deserve some kind of retribution that effects this perverse equity.

    No Emily. I was not “an annoying kid” and no-one put up with my “crap” because my parents were parents. They did not smile on indulgently when I stacked on a turn — it would have been the end of my day out of the house. They did not expect others to find me entertaining and nor were others expected to entertain me. A child misbehaving in public was a source of shame for parents whereas these days modern parents expect waitstaff and retail assistants to be baby-sitters.

    Modern parents need to be reminded that just because their pweshus is the centre of their universe the child is not the centre of everyone else’s universe.

  14. avatar
    anon Says:

    preach it!


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.