A lot of academic writing is very “which” heavy, but I’ve heard that it is not always being used properly, that “that” should be used instead. Is this true? Why? What is the proper use of them?
Asked by
Morgan Murray asked this question on Tuesday at 10 am.
A lot of academic writing is very “which” heavy, but I’ve heard that it is not always being used properly, that “that” should be used instead. Is this true? Why? What is the proper use of them?
Asked by
October 11th, 2011 at 3:44 pm
The snow that fell last night has melted. [As opposed to the snow that fell this morning, which is still around.]
The snow, which fell last night, has melted. [Presumably, it's the only snow worth mentioning.]
‘That’ introduces a defining clause. In other words, it’s making the statement even more specific. We’re not just talking about any snow, only the snow that fell last night. ‘Which’ is for non-defining clauses, where no further specification is needed. These kinds of clauses are often set apart from the rest of the sentence with commas. It’s adding new information about the snow, (i.e., it fell last night) as opposed to clarifying which snow you’re talking about.
People will tend to use ‘which’ in situations where they think they need a greater degree of formality. While I won’t go so far as to say that this is altogether wrong, it has a certain sloppiness, which means you have to rely simply on the punctuation to tell if a defining or non-defining clause is meant. This may work well enough for written English; in speech, it can be virtually impossible.