The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
7
Like

What do you think of the new Woolworths proposal?

asked this question on Friday at 10 am.

With debate raging on about the proposed Fortis development on Water Street, an 11-storey proposal for further up the road may just be something both sides of the height restriction debate can agree on. It has the approval of some of the most strict followers of the Municipal Plan, including the oft-called-anti-development councillor Shannie Duff. Councillor Wally Collins says they might as well go and get the lumber for it. What do you think?

 

30 Responses

  1. avatar
    Dreae Says:

    Bring it. Water and Waldegrave is one of the most depressing corners in town. A perpetual tire fire would be an improvement. Honestly. And look, they have 4 trees!

  2. avatar
    Dreae Says:

    Seriously, though, perhaps we could reorient the downtown over time, and create a business dictrict (say, anything west of bank corner), and an arts district (east of there). Lots of cities have the same. With the convention centre and city hall and everything, west = business seems to make sense, no? And then the arts orgs can keep their offices in the eastern half. Shopping throughout. Everyone meets at Atlantic Place. I think it would be grand.

  3. avatar
    Jordan Says:

    That whole block is absolutly horrible looking. Hopefully city council can try to hurry this proposal along, the quicker it goes up the better. I think the building looks great and maybe the other buildings and the land around it will either be re-developed or developed soon.

  4. avatar
    jackie Says:

    Do it up. That whole block is an embarrassment and a dump.

  5. avatar
    davelane Says:

    I’m all for it. I also understand the design is not finalized, which means we can have some say.

    But here are the benefits: it is not altering a heritage area; it is not demolishing existing businesses; it is near wide-lane traffic and highway turnoffs, keeping congestion out of the core; it’s still downtown; it’s livening up a “dead zone”; it will have PARKING for both tenants AND the public; it will have street-level merchant space; it respects the intent of the Municipal Plan.

    This is the type of development that is a win-win for everyone involved. Except maybe a couple of families of mice and pigeons :(

    THINK OF THE MICE AND PIGEONS, PEOPLE

  6. avatar
    davelane Says:

    holy crap i didn’t even notice the trees!! hurrah!

  7. avatar
    kevin Says:

    this won’t even kill my view of the cranes. this artist rendering here; do you think that’s looking from harbour drive?

  8. avatar
    Breen Says:

    Give’r bickies, bys.

  9. avatar
    Dave H Says:

    I like the proposed development on the corner of Water and Prescott Streets better, however this proposal is probably more palatable to St. John’s City Council.

    I hope they just get on with it, and not debate it ad nausem.

  10. avatar
    Bryh Says:

    Hey Kevin, I think the view is from the standpoint of the harbour. Looks like the post office across the steet.

  11. avatar
    HBeez Says:

    How fast can this be built??

  12. avatar
    Monosyllabic Girl Says:

    I say go for it. There is always complanits about people having to move from Newfoundland to get work. By this building going up it will give work for the trades people, not only will it give work for people to run the place after.

    And it’s not like we haven’t seen building like this downtown anyway, I mean look at Atlantic place. or even the Delta! This can be a great thing for St. John’s and all people can do is complain about it.

    I say get over yourselves and try and look at the pros for once.

  13. avatar
    George Says:

    Now build the Fortis project and we really have a booming downtown area. I hope that people realize that there is also a 75 million dollar project waiting on the opposite corner. Build them both and revive the downtown area. I hope the protesters keep away from both projects. It seems whatever Shannie says the masses of protesters will follow even though its over 4 levels. Now do the same for the other corner and let Fortis do their thing.

  14. avatar
    concerned citizen Says:

    Dave Lane loves a parking garage design but not the Fortis design which looks much better. He spear heads the protesters group towards Fortis but is quick to jump on the bandwagon with a development that will cost the taxpayers a 10 million dollar subsidy?

  15. avatar
    Bill Hickey Says:

    I was appalled to see the arts groups out in force singing this is our town at the public meeting regarding development in our city. Its everyones city and we are sick of protesters interfering with the progress of St. John’s particularly in the downtown area. You do not represent the larger segment of the population and most dont drink coffee at Hava Java Daily . It is a city and not a town anymore! Stop living in your dreamworld and get with the times. People are waiting for trades jobs and the citizens are sick of tax increases caused by delays in development by the very same people who play the heritage flower children card. Bring in more prosperity, modernization,jobs etc…. and make a future for the rest of us. Playing the guitar and painting doesnt feed many people in St. John’s.

  16. avatar
    Zippybear Says:

    I like it. It’s time to get rid of the old, decrepit structures that plague downtown (Water st. and Duckworth).

    I fear the public parking in this proposal will go private/rented in a very short amount of time.

  17. avatar
    Jack Says:

    This design is UGLY and lacks imagination, other than that I am in favor of redeveoping this site. The whole block as far as Templeton’s should be developed as one comprhensive “Landmark” site, all it takes is to get the other parties to work together to develop a concept that will make a statement.

  18. avatar
    Tommy Says:

    Wicked, about time. Jack: the developer has stated the facade of the building hasn’t been decided yet. The released drawing is only to show height and size of the building to appease those who worry about their view. Old Woolworth’s gone, lots of parking, closer to Pitts Memorial, not even too tall to block a lot of the view, developer said it might even have a pedway to the Convention Centre and Mile One (more parking for Mile One!)… all looks good to me.

  19. avatar
    Jonathan Kennedy Says:

    Despite the obvious environmental and overall city health implications, I think I could get behind a perpetual tire fire.

  20. avatar
    Jordan Says:

    I think it’s great – I support the Fortis proposal as well, but this one especially because the Water/Waldegrave area is so run-down.

  21. avatar
    Gavin Murphy Says:

    I think we need development on that site. I don’t mind the building and the car park on the harbour drive side is okay, but I think a car park on the water street level will be unappealing. From eye level on the water street side all we would see is cars parked and we would have to endure the smell of their exhaust. This is unattractive. The Water Street side should have walk in retail space to promote local business.

  22. avatar
    The Scope Says:

    By e-mail from Barbara De Land:

    I completely agree with “Jack” that that the 11-storey building design is UGLY. A true example of the “trojan horse” idea discussed at the last parking meeting.

    Also, Eleven- storey approval will violate the height restriction for that area. Allowing it will open the whole street to multi-multi storey buildings.

    Instead of using extra parking to get their building approved (which will just encourage more cars downtown – something cities all over the world are trying to discourage and halt), wouldn’t it be great for them to enhance the downtown by including a movie theatre or library in their building which would attract a wider range of users?

    Barbara

  23. avatar
    John R Says:

    I think this proposal and the Fortis proposal should be built as sson as possible. We are in the middle of an emerging oil and gas industry and need the space downtown to further our business partnerships with big companies. More development and office space – means more jobs and more tax revenue for the city.The addition of extra parking will also be a boost to local business especially during the weekends and for events at mile 1 as well.

  24. avatar
    ARTSY Says:

    I think this is a great proposal but I cant see why a certain segment of our citizens are protesting the Fortis proposal which looks much better! Build both of them and put St. John’s back on the map. We are a have province and deserve these developments and investments in our downtown area. For years we never had the investors knocking at our doors and now its time to bring in the millions of dollars worth of investment into the downtown area. Remember when Premier Peckford said “the sun will shine and the day will come when have not will be no more” Well its here and I think all Newfoundlanders should be excited about our good fortune finally coming our way. Danny Williams is helping us become an oil and gas centre of excellence so give up the complaining and make this happen.

  25. avatar
    reality Says:

    Its time to rebuild the downtown area. Fortis is also investing 75 million into the downtown area so make both developments happen. The time has come to finally get the benefits we deserve from our oil and gas industry. Create employment , tax revenue and clean up the downtown area all at once.

  26. avatar
    anon Says:

    I say we go underground. Knock down Woolworth’s and build an 11-level underground office and shopping bunker. No restricted views, no need to fuss about designs and facades, and some faceless monolith of a corporation gets its much needed office space. Everyone’s happy, and we can use that giant taxpayer subsidy to begin research into transforming the citizens of downtown St. John’s into a race of nocturnal mole people.

  27. avatar
    davelane Says:

    Hey bro / sis,

    Please read my comment again to understand why I am for one and not the other.

    Essentially, the location of the “parking garage” one is much, much better for the reasons i mentioned (and more!).

    Dave

  28. avatar
    davelane Says:

    I hear you, Bill, and honestly most people in this city appear to feel that we need development. I am included in this group, whole-heartedly.

    The argument is not that we should keep things as they are, the argument is that there are certain aspects of that tiny stretch of downtown that are important not just to our heritage but to our small merchants and quality of life.

    Small, individual buildings like the ones that exist there now encourage people to stroll and shop and interact. There are no other places like this in the city, and many other cities are trying to recreate this type of atmosphere (and it’s hard to do!)

    So, we’re saying Please involve us in the plans for this part of our city, and make responsible developments. We’re working to encourage the development of these buildings a few blocks down the road, like the proposal in this article.

  29. avatar
    davelane Says:

    I agree, Artsy, except that if the Fortis proposal gets approved as is, they will satisfy the forecast demand for office space in the city for years. This means that any other companies that wish to build office space will have more trouble finding tenants.

    Danny has indeed done well for us, and I’m a huge fan! We need to take his example now and stand up for our city; we’re not going to turn away businesses just because we want them to build a little to the left, and little lower. We need to have some faith in the attractiveness of our city.

  30. avatar
    Irene Duma Says:

    This is a mistake. The building needs retail space on the ground floor or a cafe with a patio to make it desirable to pedestrians. Large stretches of buildings with no retail are death to walk by – the dead zones on Water street are precisely because of the banks or highrises with no retail space or warehouses that offer nothing for viewers.

    With the post office on the other side of the street, this will just put a nail in the coffin. No one will want to walk here at night. Or the day.

    Put a restaurant and a couple of stores with direct access to the street and you will increase the walking traffic, add energy and also desirability.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VsrqBHEOT0k


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.