The $50-million six-storey tower being constructed at the former Woolworth’s spot downtown was covered in an article in the Telegram recently and a swooping video flyover was included. It sure does look shiny, but what do you think?
Elling Lien asked this question on Tuesday at 11 am.
The $50-million six-storey tower being constructed at the former Woolworth’s spot downtown was covered in an article in the Telegram recently and a swooping video flyover was included. It sure does look shiny, but what do you think?
January 24th, 2012 at 2:55 pm
I’m in favour of what appears to be street-front shops / office-space. It would have been nice if they made the same effort on the harbourside. Parking is so ugly.
January 24th, 2012 at 3:53 pm
I like it, although it could be taller. I don’t consider this to be a “tower”.
January 24th, 2012 at 4:39 pm
Aside from the fact that the model seems to be for city as flat as Saskatoon, it still looks like the back end of a prison. Could they not have tried to have a visually interesting building?
That part of Water is going to be a major hub in a few years. They should be bold with the designs. It seems that the convention centre (another back end of a prison design) has set the bar so low for innovation that imagination seems to be a liability.
January 24th, 2012 at 4:58 pm
uninspired. Looks like any other cheap 1990 building design anywhere.
January 24th, 2012 at 5:00 pm
push the autocad template a little will ya?
January 24th, 2012 at 6:09 pm
You can b*tch and moan forever that the design isn’t perfect and not as visually pleasing as one had hoped. However, it is better than what was there before, it will provide much needed parking and office spaces and some more retail space, which are all wonderful! Not to mention the added tax revenues for the city, again much needed.
January 24th, 2012 at 6:35 pm
Jon, I’m not saying not to build it. I’m just thinking that with all of this development money around it would be nice to see some current thinking in design. The fact that the building is using harbour water to heat it is amazing. I also wouldn’t be averse to adding a few storeys of living space so that the building has at least some function after 5pm.
Have you seen the new police station? the plans for the Star of the Sea site? the old CBC site? All they offer to the street is boredom.
Personally, I was even in favour of the Fortis expansion on Water except for the fact that was so ugly. Can you imagine if there was an international competition to build a landmark building that houses Newfoundland’s biggest economic success story? I use this overblown term as that was Fortis’ rhetoric for why they should be allowed to build whatever they want.
All I want, is to live in an interesting city. The capital is here, now bring on the ideas.
January 25th, 2012 at 12:06 pm
Ok, so what exactly is going in there anyways? Anybody know?
January 26th, 2012 at 12:02 pm
an interesting take
http://brighttypewriter.tumblr.com/post/16414237096/a-video-rendering-of-351-water-st-at-the-corner#disqus_thread
January 31st, 2012 at 10:56 pm
Man, that has to be one of the cheapest-looking, most halfhearted video renderings I’ve seen. You have to wonder who it was aimed at, since I can’t think of anyone it would really impress. Perhaps its blandness and topographic ridiculousness is meant to distract from the uninspired design of the building. It’s not the worst they could do, but surely they could have paid a little extra for something actually interesting.
February 1st, 2012 at 12:53 pm
Did you expect a million-dollar-budgeted CG animated feature film from Pixar? That video was probably rendered by an engineer in an hour based on existing city layouts.
It’s meant to be a proof of concept and a visual launch-pad for potential tenants and investors. It’s most definitely enough for those types of people to work with.
You can’t please some people in this city.
February 1st, 2012 at 1:32 pm
About time St. John’s got some up-to-date architecture, but ANYTHING would have been better than what was there. Developing the west end of Water St. with more high rises and condos is an excellent idea, it will redevelop the area, despite what the “boo-hoo don’t change the view” crowd say. Redevelopment means more employment and higher property values. Both are good,
February 1st, 2012 at 2:59 pm
I say screw the view. The downtown core of any city needs high-density living and commercial space to prosper and thrive. We’re shooting ourselves in the collective foot to deny that.
All the tourism growth in the universe won’t offset the revenue that offshore oil, mining, banking and other high-worth sectors are begging to bring to downtown St. John’s. Stop the NIMBY attitude and get with the times of today.
St. John’s is such a throwback to the 1850s.
We’re not a fishing outport any more, let’s act like what we are, and could be.
February 1st, 2012 at 3:02 pm
To boot, the better view is across the harbour, looking north-west across the whole city.
If you want serious property value, buy over there and build big. Sit on it, and wait and see.
February 1st, 2012 at 4:14 pm
Anon…..are you serious, for the love of god person……you should know the first sign of development across the shit bubble, and you’ll have Peg, Ron, Shannie, Shelia, and the rest of the ilk out with the pitchforks wanting to burn the developer at the stake!
February 1st, 2012 at 10:05 pm
“That video was probably rendered by an engineer in an hour based on existing city layouts.” — sums it up nicely. All I was wondering was who it was supposed to impress. If potential tenants and investors are impressed by that kind of half-hearted fluff, then more power to them. If I was a potential investor or tenant, I would rather have a professional-looking illustration than an amateurish video. But that’s just me.
“About time St. John’s got some up-to-date architecture”. — I guess you could call it that, but it’s still boring.
“Redevelopment means more employment and higher property values. Both are good” — I agree that employment is good, but increased property values only benefit those who own property now and are planning to sell. For those looking to move to the city, it’s toxic, and for those who own their home and planned to live in it forever, artificially inflated housing prices just mean higher property tax rates that they often can’t pay on their fixed incomes.
“the better view is across the harbour, looking north-west across the whole city.” — I’ve always been baffled by how little development there is on the southside hills.
For some reason, you seem to have the impression that I’m against this project. I’m not. I’ll be happy to see it built. The artificially inflated housing prices mean I could never afford a house with a view anyway. I’m also glat that there are several other projects about to start in the same area, since that’s what will really get things shaking. I think that end of Water is a great spot to develop — much better than the spot Fortis originally wanted to build.
Oh, and I should address one more point: “The downtown core of any city needs high-density living and commercial space to prosper and thrive. We’re shooting ourselves in the collective foot to deny that.” — I wish I still thought that was true. But I’m coming to see that most people don’t give a flying flip about the downtown area. Certainly it’s hard to live down there any more without a car, since it lacks such basic amenities as a grocery store. Head-up-your-ass single-use zoning in all these sprawling subdivisions is poisoning North American cities. When you have thousands of houses but can’t legally open even a corner store, it should be obvious that things need to chance. But no, instead they’re building yet another BigBox plaza over by the airport, since apparently Kelsey and Stavanger aren’t enough. I would rather dense population, localized amenities, walking, community, mixed spaces… But I’m afraid that downtowns as places to live are going extinct…