The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site · Time machine
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
1
Like

Why is it then that we routinely see landlords advertising rental properties with things like “no children”, “50 and over” or “female only”?

asked this question on Tuesday at 9 am.

The Human Rights Code of Newfoundland states that you cannot be discriminated against for things like age and sex when it comes to many things, including rental property. Why is it then that we routinely see landlords advertising rental properties with things like “no children”, “50 and over” or “female only”? Doesn’t stating things like this in rental ads violate the Human Rights Code? How come its tolerated, and what can be done to fight this?

Asked by

Corey

 

2 Responses

  1. avatar
    kerri Says:

    Good question!
    I once saw an ad that said “no deep frying” — I’m pretty sure prohibiting someone from cooking up fries is a Charter violation. Kidding. You have a great point, Corey. The provincial legislation that protects landlords and tenants, the Residential Tenancies Act, only kicks in after you make a rental agreement, so nothing in there prevents the situation you describe. I believe landlords can be far more picky because of the crazy housing market in this city. If they don’t like you, there’s dozens of others they can choose from.

    I’m interested to hear Mr. Harvey’s take on it.

  2. avatar
    Andrew Harvey Says:

    Hey Corey,

    It is pretty much along the lines of what Kerri said. Technically this type of discrimination is prohibited, but the issue comes with enforcement. Landlords have no obligation to rent their property to anyone. Like any business, they reserve the right to refuse service (or in this case, rent their property) to anyone.

    To prove that the reason why you did not get a property was because of your age, gender or religion, would be nearly impossible. This is because you are getting into inferring someone’s motive for a decision, which is flimsy ground to stand on in court. The only way I could see this working would be somehow convincing a landlord to admit in court, or possibly in writing, that the reason why they did not rent you the place was your age/gender/what-have-you. Not too likely, and even if they said it to your face, it probably would not stand up in court.

    As Kerri also said, in a rental market like this, landlords usually get their pick of the bunch. If someone wants to be a racist/bigot, there may be little to be done.

    I have encountered this problem in the past, but luckily it does not seem to be too widespread. Most people are reasonable, and not bigots.

    The other thing is that even though some people will advertise a rental looking for a 20+ female (or what it might be), they are not always closed to idea of other tenants. Landlords are usually looking for a type of tenant, and those who fall outside of the rigid definitions of our society such as age or gender.

    My advice is to call anyways, and try to convince them you are the type of tenant they are looking for.


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.