The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
0
Like

Republic of Doyle: What’s the verdict?

asked this question on Thursday at 1 pm.

The show hit the airwaves last night. What did you think?

If you missed it, you can watch it on the CBC-TV website.

 

13 Responses

  1. avatar
    Foghorn Says:

    I know that as a Newfoundlander I’m supposed to be all moon-eyed over the prospect of a show being made here. But that show fucking sucked!! The show is not only a failure but a failure on every measurable level. The writing was high school production bad, dialogue hackneyed and predictable. The narrative managed to plod as well as confuse. Sure St. John’s looked great but it always does. If they managed to make Mt Pearl look good that would have been an achievement worthy of a Juno or Gemini or whatever the fuck.

  2. avatar
    Matt Says:

    Wasn’t bad but I hope it gets better. The fact that is was filmed here was pretty much the only thing that kept me from changing the channel.

  3. avatar
    Jordan Says:

    I stopped watching halfway through. St. John’s did look alright and I actually think thats quite the tough task because downtown St. John’s is ugly.

  4. avatar
    areeno Says:

    I turned it off halfway through as well. It was a great tourist commercial, but holy stiff actors batman! It can only get better.

  5. avatar
    Leyna Says:

    I thought it was awesome. The shots of the city were great and it didn’t play on the Newfoundland stereotypes that so often cloud any impression people might get of us. Yeah it was a bit cheesy and the acting isn’t phenomenal, but I think it’s the best type of show to film in this city because it includes action, drama, and humour, plus sexy car chases that you probably got to see being filmed. Plus it’s a lot funnier and more entertaining than CSI Miami :p

  6. avatar
    unclerodsknife Says:

    A lot of reviews and comments (not exclusively on this site) have referred to it as “just” a cop show, or “just” a show from a man’s perspective, or “just” a light comedy.

    I find that all a bit silly, because it suggests that unless a show is unearthing deep cultural ills or exhibiting constantly provocative, varied viewpoints, it is wasting our time. A show airing on network TV in the 21st Century is often none of these things; lord knows that CBC in particular has seen a wide array of very bad television in the past few years that didn’t aspire to any of these goals.

    I don’t think there is any reason for RoD to be anything more than it is. It is well-executed, funny enough, and capably acted. The setup is intriguing, the production is tight, and the characters have a lot of room to move as the plotlines progress.

    There is ample space in independent film, on cable and on the stage to cater to specific ideas of what humor or good writing or fair representation is, and I think that what Hawco et al. have accomplished is the creation of a show that will be popular without pandering and watchable without being saccharine or shocking.

    I am not making a case for the lowest common denominator here, just saying that as much as I and those around me want to be cynical, we are generally admitting that the product is pretty damn good.

    If we want to see Allan Hawco and Sean Panting being heartfelt and profound, we will watch Love and Savagery. If we want to see Jordan Canning’s work beyond Script Supervision, we will watch Pillowtalk or Thick & Thin, and if we want to see great Newfoundland acting, directing, composition and writing we will go to Rabbittown or the Hall or any number of other places.

    However, if we want to relax on a Tuesday night, have a laugh, and/or avoid Trivia Night, we will be watching Republic of Doyle.

  7. avatar
    Amy Says:

    Uncle Rod and Leyna’s comments were dead-on. I think we’re too spoiled by Hollywood dramas that have millions invested in production and marketing budgets. Canadian productions will never have the glitz and glam those shows so overtly project (and in my opinion is overrated). If you want to support local artists and productions, you have to get over the bias that we have become accustomed to.

    The show represents Newfoundland so well. For people across Canada who think we still live in fishing villages with hardcore bay accents, it gives a good reality check – not only is the place rustic, quaint and beautiful, but it is also modern, young, and full of positive energy, pride, and smart talented people. It’s lighthearted, fun, and doesn’t play into typical Newfoundland stereotypes – it gives a good representation of our culture.

    If you’re looking for overpaid actors, story lines that come from drone writers, and scenes shot with super HD cameras that are needed to make the places look half as nice as St. John’s, stick to your HBO and Showcase shows.

    And really, can one million viewers be wrong? I guess we’ll see next week.

  8. avatar
    Dora Says:

    I liked it well enough, tho I didn’t make it quite through to the end. I thought the actor who played Malachy was Very Good, also the actress who played his partner. I liked the plot, it was believable for the size of our town. There was too much yelling for me, the doctor character always seemed on the edge of hysteria. I’d worry about her if she was my doctor. And someone is awfully fond of that screeching-tire sound effect, it almost seemed to start before the car door closed, and it happened way too often. Maybe they want it to be some sort of catchphrase, but I didn’t care for it. Also, the colours seemed unnaturally bright in the outdoor scenes, like the tourist ads.
    But all in all pretty good, I’d say.

  9. avatar
    Tanya Says:

    The 2nd episode was an improvement, other than kristin pellererin’s HORRIBLE accent. I thought she said on out of the fog that she was from mount pearl and doing a pearlian accent, but this was the oddest accent on the show. Sounded like she was trying to be irish, and not even southern shore irish. I am born and raised in mount pearl and know NO ONE from that city that has that accent. It actually would take me out of the show when she would speak.
    Though other than that, big improvment from the 1st eps.

  10. avatar
    boots Says:

    I think we can all agree that the second episode was stronger than #1. Better story, better direction, better script. And I really feel like they’re just going to keep getting better.

    Give it a chance. Sometimes it takes a full season for a show to really get its stride – and this is true for plenty of great American shows too. Episode two was already light years ahead of the pilot, so let’s have a little faith that it’s a good sign of things to come.

    Just wanted to correct something in Tanya’s comment. Krystin’s accent on the show is not supposed to be a Mount Pearl accent – the character is from Labrador.

  11. avatar
    Penny Says:

    I’ve never met anyone from Labrador who spoke that way. I found her accent really annoying and out of place. that said its not the first time i’ve heard local people irish up their accents for tv, etc. Otherwise i thought the second episode was great.

  12. avatar
  13. avatar
    Jambit Says:

    This show is terrible.Enough said.Stop wasting money on a show if you cant even make it slightly interesting.please take this show off of television.


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.