The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
2
Like

In companion planting, how close is close?

asked this question on Monday at 11 am.

A lot of books on companion planting will say things like “do not plant onions close to pole beans,” but they never give any specific definition of “close.” Do you have a rule for keeping enemy vegetables apart? Or is it all hogwash anyway?

Asked by Dreae

 

One Response

  1. avatar
    Judy Lien Says:

    I do agree with attention to companion planting. It provides some organization for a garden, and a lot of gardeners agree that it’s beneficial.

    You asked about distances: My rule is to plant a friendly crop as a buffer between unfriendly vegetables, at least two rows. The soil is greatly influenced by the root activity of plants — where they feed, what they produce, what they attract or repel. My happiest success with companion planting was in soil that harboured clubroot. By mingling marigolds with my cauliflower plants in this particular area of my garden, I lost no cauliflower plants and ended up with a fine crop, so I continued the practice. Also, in my greenhouses, tomatoes and basil THRIVE when intercropped.

    One additional note, considering your ‘hogwash’ query: In the case of carrots, which are often challenged by the rust/carrot fly, in my experience companion planting with sage and the onion (Allium) family did very little to repel them. And this is through trials repeated several years, and row cover was the only successful deterrent that I’ve found. I guess we’re all continually trying to provide optimum conditions for our yearly gardening adventure here in Newfoundland!


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.