I hate being asked for my phone number/postal code/email address every time a buy something, but I always give it anyway because I feel rude saying no. Ms. Manners, what is the polite way to decline?
This has been a pet peeve of mine ever since stores started doing it six or seven years ago.
When they ask, “can I get your postal code?” I answer nicely with a “can I refuse?” The cashier is always fine with it. I’m sure it’s irritating for them to have to ask.
Don’t worry about refusing. It’s your information. I always refuse – just say no or no thanks. When retailers amass a large amount of information about customers, they have to store and safeguard it, but there is a long of history of retailers doing a poor job of this. There have been major privacy breaches involving customers’ personal information where such information has gotten into the hands of organized crime, and this is now a multi-billion dollar worldwide thing. Things like your postal code or phone number may seem relatively innocuous, but combined with credit card numbers or other information which may be obtained through the same retailer or other sources it can lead to identity theft and years of financial headaches. They’re asking you for this information for their own marketing purposes. You’re the customer, and they should be glad to have you. If they insist, walk away and bring your business elsewhere. Privacy of personal information is your right, and you should not be afraid to claim it. Really, the clerks don’t give a shit anyway.
I used to work retail and we had to ask for postal codes for statistics on where the store’s demographic was coming from. I hated doing it because as a customer I feel weird when asked for mine (same goes for email/phone #). I have to say, no one who declined sounded rude, and most people just said something like “I’d rather not, actually”, and it wasn’t an issue! :)
Yeah, this really isn’t that big of an issue. Just say ‘no thanks’. I’m sure they’re not going to glare at you or anything, I’m assuming the cashier doesn’t give a flying fadoo either way, and are just asking cause they got to.
I’m also annoyed that every place now has to tell you about some damn survey. Went to the mall one day with a female friend of mine, and she went to about 4-5 stores, and each place gave her the spiel of the survey.
I just politely say I’d rather not, any cashier I’ve encountered has never batted an eye about it, I know that they are only asking because they are supposed to and could care less if you do or don’t give it to them.
Giving out your postal code can’t narrow down your place of residence since it can encompass the entire side of your street or entire apartment block etc. They use it only to figure out where their customers are coming from. No big deal.
Phone and email are private and subject to spam. If someone asks for my phone number I simply say “it’s unlisted.” (Which it is). And if they ask for my email I say I only use email for business.
Your postal code can reveal your address if it is combined with another piece of information such as your name (from your credit card, for example) or particularly your phone number. If there are 10 John Smiths listed in Canada 411 and one of them gives their name to a store along with a postal code, you know which John Smith you’re dealing with. Furthermore, outside of urban areas, a single postal code is sometimes used for an entire community. A name and postal code tells you what town in NL the person is from, and if there is one person with that name there, you’ve identified them.
Dear Privacy,
Saying “no” is NEVER impolite, though we are sometimes trained to think that it is. I now enjoy being asked for my personal information in these settings because I see it as an opportunity to practice saying “No.” “No.” “No.” “Lordy, no.” “Gosh, no.” “Oh my! No.” “Noooo.” “Um…definitely not”. “Not right now.” “I prefer not.” This is also a great example of one of the few times where you can even leave off the “thank you.” The very fact that the situation makes so many people feel pressured to give personal details away to a complete stranger against their better judgement means that this request is in no way a favor, so no thanks necessary.
Go ahead, do your holiday shopping and, though you cannot control the crowds, crappy merchandise or over-gifting, you can have quite a little burst of fun by saying what we rarely get to say: lovely lovely little “no”.
I feel this would make a great scene in a musical: lots of empowered shoppers pursing their lips and harmonizing to keep their private parts of town private with a chorus of exquisitely empowered “no!”s
I have NO problem saying no, however when asked for my name or phone number I usually say the first two names that come to mind and give a fake phone number….today I’ll be Connor Mackentire, 646-4374. It’s more entertaining for me.
I’ve been doing Xmas shopping and have been asked for my phone number, e-mail address and/or postal code at about ten stores. I refuse to give out this info or give fake info. My default postal code is for 24 Sussex Drive, my default phone number is for the local Rogers store where nobody speaks English, and I have a Yahoo account set up for spam.
When cashiers or managers give me a difficult time – at HomeSense, a head cashier once refused to let me purchase more than $75 worth of merchandise! – I take my business elsewhere and let them know that their conduct is unprofessional and intrusive!
A few years ago, I lived with a roommate who worked in marketing. It is scary what companies do with your personal info. They track down demographics (age, where you live, how much you spend, median income) and use it to send junk mail or spam. Since many stores are part of a chain, ex. Winners is the same company as Homesense, so giving your postal code to Winners means you will also get marketing junk from Homesense. Companies also share customer information with business partners, so businesses you may not frequent will also have your demographics and shopping habits on hand.
What abouta an attitude you get from cashiers? Particularly LCBO is pretty bad in general.
I wouldn’t be surprised if LCBO gets legitimate rights to require your postal code in order to complete transaction.
When I bring bring empty beer bottles to the corner store they ask me to sign my name to their copy of the receipt. I tell them straight up that any information I give them will be fake, the cashiers don’t care at all, they just have to ask as part of their job. I don’t get annoyed with it, I just have fun thinking up ridiculous names to sign, and I think the store clerks get a kick out of it too.
Don’t worry about being rude – they are rude for asking that. Just tell them you don’t disclose that information. Note: you should never give them this information if you are paying by credit or debit card.
TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.
November 10th, 2011 at 10:02 am
This has been a pet peeve of mine ever since stores started doing it six or seven years ago.
When they ask, “can I get your postal code?” I answer nicely with a “can I refuse?” The cashier is always fine with it. I’m sure it’s irritating for them to have to ask.
November 10th, 2011 at 11:43 am
Don’t worry about refusing. It’s your information. I always refuse – just say no or no thanks. When retailers amass a large amount of information about customers, they have to store and safeguard it, but there is a long of history of retailers doing a poor job of this. There have been major privacy breaches involving customers’ personal information where such information has gotten into the hands of organized crime, and this is now a multi-billion dollar worldwide thing. Things like your postal code or phone number may seem relatively innocuous, but combined with credit card numbers or other information which may be obtained through the same retailer or other sources it can lead to identity theft and years of financial headaches. They’re asking you for this information for their own marketing purposes. You’re the customer, and they should be glad to have you. If they insist, walk away and bring your business elsewhere. Privacy of personal information is your right, and you should not be afraid to claim it. Really, the clerks don’t give a shit anyway.
November 10th, 2011 at 12:31 pm
I used to work retail and we had to ask for postal codes for statistics on where the store’s demographic was coming from. I hated doing it because as a customer I feel weird when asked for mine (same goes for email/phone #). I have to say, no one who declined sounded rude, and most people just said something like “I’d rather not, actually”, and it wasn’t an issue! :)
November 10th, 2011 at 1:03 pm
Yeah, this really isn’t that big of an issue. Just say ‘no thanks’. I’m sure they’re not going to glare at you or anything, I’m assuming the cashier doesn’t give a flying fadoo either way, and are just asking cause they got to.
I’m also annoyed that every place now has to tell you about some damn survey. Went to the mall one day with a female friend of mine, and she went to about 4-5 stores, and each place gave her the spiel of the survey.
November 10th, 2011 at 3:21 pm
I just politely say I’d rather not, any cashier I’ve encountered has never batted an eye about it, I know that they are only asking because they are supposed to and could care less if you do or don’t give it to them.
November 10th, 2011 at 7:08 pm
I never give my address, phone # or email address to retail stores. I simply say “no thank you” when they ask and it’s no big deal.
November 13th, 2011 at 6:50 pm
Giving out your postal code can’t narrow down your place of residence since it can encompass the entire side of your street or entire apartment block etc. They use it only to figure out where their customers are coming from. No big deal.
Phone and email are private and subject to spam. If someone asks for my phone number I simply say “it’s unlisted.” (Which it is). And if they ask for my email I say I only use email for business.
November 14th, 2011 at 10:15 am
Your postal code can reveal your address if it is combined with another piece of information such as your name (from your credit card, for example) or particularly your phone number. If there are 10 John Smiths listed in Canada 411 and one of them gives their name to a store along with a postal code, you know which John Smith you’re dealing with. Furthermore, outside of urban areas, a single postal code is sometimes used for an entire community. A name and postal code tells you what town in NL the person is from, and if there is one person with that name there, you’ve identified them.
November 14th, 2011 at 3:55 pm
Dear Privacy,
Saying “no” is NEVER impolite, though we are sometimes trained to think that it is. I now enjoy being asked for my personal information in these settings because I see it as an opportunity to practice saying “No.” “No.” “No.” “Lordy, no.” “Gosh, no.” “Oh my! No.” “Noooo.” “Um…definitely not”. “Not right now.” “I prefer not.” This is also a great example of one of the few times where you can even leave off the “thank you.” The very fact that the situation makes so many people feel pressured to give personal details away to a complete stranger against their better judgement means that this request is in no way a favor, so no thanks necessary.
Go ahead, do your holiday shopping and, though you cannot control the crowds, crappy merchandise or over-gifting, you can have quite a little burst of fun by saying what we rarely get to say: lovely lovely little “no”.
I feel this would make a great scene in a musical: lots of empowered shoppers pursing their lips and harmonizing to keep their private parts of town private with a chorus of exquisitely empowered “no!”s
- Ms Manners
PS no
November 16th, 2011 at 9:29 am
I have NO problem saying no, however when asked for my name or phone number I usually say the first two names that come to mind and give a fake phone number….today I’ll be Connor Mackentire, 646-4374. It’s more entertaining for me.
November 20th, 2011 at 6:17 pm
I’ve been doing Xmas shopping and have been asked for my phone number, e-mail address and/or postal code at about ten stores. I refuse to give out this info or give fake info. My default postal code is for 24 Sussex Drive, my default phone number is for the local Rogers store where nobody speaks English, and I have a Yahoo account set up for spam.
When cashiers or managers give me a difficult time – at HomeSense, a head cashier once refused to let me purchase more than $75 worth of merchandise! – I take my business elsewhere and let them know that their conduct is unprofessional and intrusive!
A few years ago, I lived with a roommate who worked in marketing. It is scary what companies do with your personal info. They track down demographics (age, where you live, how much you spend, median income) and use it to send junk mail or spam. Since many stores are part of a chain, ex. Winners is the same company as Homesense, so giving your postal code to Winners means you will also get marketing junk from Homesense. Companies also share customer information with business partners, so businesses you may not frequent will also have your demographics and shopping habits on hand.
October 18th, 2012 at 8:23 pm
What abouta an attitude you get from cashiers? Particularly LCBO is pretty bad in general.
I wouldn’t be surprised if LCBO gets legitimate rights to require your postal code in order to complete transaction.
October 19th, 2012 at 3:21 pm
When I bring bring empty beer bottles to the corner store they ask me to sign my name to their copy of the receipt. I tell them straight up that any information I give them will be fake, the cashiers don’t care at all, they just have to ask as part of their job. I don’t get annoyed with it, I just have fun thinking up ridiculous names to sign, and I think the store clerks get a kick out of it too.
October 19th, 2012 at 6:26 pm
where do you live, 1970′s Poland?
April 7th, 2013 at 10:31 am
Don’t worry about being rude – they are rude for asking that. Just tell them you don’t disclose that information. Note: you should never give them this information if you are paying by credit or debit card.