The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
2
Like

How come Quidi Vidi Lake is not used for swimming?

asked this question on Wednesday at 1 pm.

It looks like the perfect place for a dip to be honest, lot’s of room. People swim at Sunshine Camp and there’s plenty of ducks around there so wouldn’t it be ok to swim in Quidi Vidi Lake too?

Asked by Anonymous

 

20 Responses

  1. avatar
    LouLou Says:

    My guess would be that it’s due to the narsty pollutants being poured into it by the Country Ribbon Chicken factory next to the lake. I don’t know if you’ve ever walked past there, but the smell is horrendously unpleasant.

    This could, however, have nothing to do whatsoever with the reason you don’t see people swimming there. Just a shot in the dark! :)

  2. avatar
    Mallory Knox Says:

    I see a fuckton of wildlife thriving there, trout jumping every morning and evening, lot’s of ducks and the occasional visiting bird that rarely comes here, and of course the goose. If there was anything wrong with the water in Quidi Vidi Lake than don’t you think there would be no wildlife there whatsoever?

  3. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    As long as I can remember it’s been an accepted fact that Quidi Vidi is polluted. There is wildlife there, people fish there all the time, but it’s strictly catch and release. No one eats anything that comes out of that lake. I know I wouldn’t take a chance on a lake that’s right next to a massive chicken factory, and I also don’t like the idea of whatever is flowing into Quidi Vidi from the Rennies Mill river. That river literally smells like shit at times.

  4. avatar
    Mallory Knox Says:

    Well it’s a shame then really that such a beautiful lake and river are ruined. Also, you’d think people would be putting up a big stink about how the chicken factory is dumping pollutants into the lake though wouldn’t you? It’s pretty awful.Why the hell is that factory there anyways, it’s a terrible place for a chicken factory! Don’t we have industrial parks for factories?

  5. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    Not to mention the runoff from white hills

  6. avatar
    Just Me Says:

    I’ve jumped and swam in Quidi Vidi a few years ago when I use to row, and I’m still alive to tell the tale. My guess is the bad stigma about run off, country ribbon, and that there’s no where to really get into the lake with out walking threw duck poop, or getting in the way of rowers. But if you wanted to take a dip might I suggest that just down from the boat house, there is a floating dock that perhaps might be a little clean and easy to get into the water from.

  7. avatar
    J Says:

    I wouldn’t swim in anything that receives runoff from storm drains.

  8. avatar
    overcast skies Says:

    uh, hmmm, on a not entirely unrelated note….if the chickens were being reared humanely there wouldn’t be any putrid “run off”. I believe the question you should be asking (instead of “why the hell is the factory there anyways”) is why the hell does that type of factory exist? Are you saying it is more appropriate to move the factory to a location where you cannot witness the atrocities of factory farming and pollute the water elsewhere?
    Oh bliss.

  9. avatar
    mhmm Says:

    i imagine a turd or two has made its way over their from the harbour

  10. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    This type of factory farming is a necessary evil. It’s funny how the same bleeding heart liberals who oppose this sort of thing are the same people who claim to be champions of the poor. A lot of people just cant afford to buy these organic free-range corn-fed chickens or whatever else it is that (meat-eating) hippies eat. I know that there are arguments to what I just said, like “everybody should just live off bean sprouts and soy” or something, but it isn’t realistic. This factory, a local business, provides healthy and relatively cheap food. The company also provides very good paying jobs to a lot of people in this province. The animal rights crowd wont like to hear this but believe it or not I care more about people than I do about chickens.

  11. avatar
    Sport Says:

    I would say it’s because of the Quidi Vidi boating snots. No one allowed in the water unless your ass is in one of their boats. I don’t think you’re even allowed to canoe in the packin’ lake.

    The Regretta Committee are so pretentious it makes me sick.

  12. avatar
    JB Says:

    I’d say the close proximity to the dump has a lot to do with it. Also, I’ve been told people have developed rashes from the duck feces (not sure how accurate this is) and I’m sure it would be pretty dangerous, given that there are crews practicing on the lake during almost all hours of daylight during the summer.

  13. avatar
    Ruu Says:

    What, organic, cruelty free chickens don’t shit?

  14. avatar
    B Says:

    Man, that place stanks in the summer. I used to work across the street (before the building got condemned) but it smells like shit and Chinese food!! naaasty.

  15. avatar
    anon Says:

    “…I know that there are arguments to what I just said, like “everybody should just live off bean sprouts and soy” or something, but it isn’t realistic.”

    It is pretty realistic. I’ve been vegetarian for going on 6+ years. I recently got a blood test for an unrelated reason and the doctor said all my levels are fine! light reading :) – http://www.flex.com/~jai/articles/101.html

  16. avatar
    Lennart Nyman Says:

    There is no need to bring a chicken factory into the debate over why people won´t swim in Quidi Vidi Lake. A vegetarian world would no doubt reduce pollution, but why not set higher standards on removing the pollutants discharged from any factory causing pollution? If environmental standards are taken into account, any number of factories could encircle the lake, and its water would still be fine to live in (for fish) or swim in, for humans and birds. On the other hand this may not take care of the most evident problem for the lake – it´s too cold for most humans to swim in! Finally, do also remove all pollutants entering the lake from Rennie´s River and Virginia River – two fine trout streams that may be improved quite a bit if present pollutant emissions were to be stopped.

  17. avatar
    poobrains Says:

    Not to mention this thing I’m mentioning.

  18. avatar
    Newfie Says:

    We did tests on the lake.. It’s full of ecoli, salmonella and campylobacter… I wouldn’t touch it let alone swim in it. It’s not related to the ducks. The country ribbon run outfall is a huge part of the pollution but so is the Virginia outfall and rennies mill river outfall as well. I wouldn’t even let your dogs drink from it or go in it.

  19. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    Not that I doubt you, but who’s “we”?

  20. avatar
    D Says:

    I’ve personally run testing on the bottom-sediments for a university-level chemistry course. I wouldn’t be caught dead in that water or eating the fish in there.

    It’s full of arsenic, mercury, lead, cadmium, hydrocarbons- a whole bunch of nasties you don’t want to get involved with, and the extremely elevated levels probably owing to “old” St. John’s and lead paint, leaded gas, coal heating, and whatnot.

    Also, consider that the Rennies River watershed starts up above the Avalon Mall and drains through the entire eastern half of the city into that lake. My project took this into account and tracked (and saw) the levels increasing from up near the old Avalon Computer location all the way to Long Pond, then onwards past Rennies’ River Elementary, through Quidi Vidi and out past the gut.

    It has plenty of time to collect all sorts of disgusting chemicals along the way. Don’t swim in that.


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.