The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
5
Like

Help us grade the St. John’s city councillors (2011)

asked this question on Thursday at 1 pm.

We’re getting ready for our annual evaluation of elected officials at St. John’s city hall, and are looking for input.
 
Which councillors are willing to raise issues? Who sticks to their guns? Who reads the materials for themselves, and who takes the city staff’s word for it? Who attends meetings? Who uses media to educate and inform the public? Who listens to good ideas from ordinary citizens? Who has vision? Who has passion?
 
Mayor – Dennis O’Keefe
Deputy-Mayor – Shannie Duff
Ward 1 Councillor – Danny Breen
Ward 2 Councillor – Frank Galgay
Ward 3 Councillor – Bruce Tilley
Ward 4 Councillor – Debbie Hanlon
Ward 5 Councillor – Wally Collins
At Large Councillor – Gerry Colbert
At Large Councillor – Sheilagh O’Leary
At Large Councillor – Tom Hann
At Large Councillor – Sandy Hickman
 

 

20 Responses

  1. avatar
    Phil Says:

    I’d like to note that the majority of council meetings seem to be spent explaining to councillors the by laws and rules of the motions before them. Perhaps a grade of D for anyone who does not spend the time getting to know the city’s by laws and procedures.

  2. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    I think Mayor O’Keefe gets an F. I’ve been at numerous meetings where he has been fooling around with paper, staring at the wall, and even using his cell phone, while councilors were talking or discussing issues. Not what I’d expect from a Mayor. He also avoids answering questions in many cases, and just talks around it instead.

    Everyone else gets a D because they are all supposed to work together to make the city better. Regardless of who is to blame, as a group they are not always making the right decisions, so they all get the same grade.

  3. avatar
    Tony Says:

    This City need an all new Council..Most of this crowd have been there toooo long.Just listening to the debate about the sign for the school turns me off…

  4. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    Dennis O’Keefe doesn’t know the first thing about running a city and seems to treat the job like some part-time post-retirement hobby. If he wants to keep busy in his retirement he should go take a job as a Wal-Mart greeter and leave running St. John’s to people who actually know what they’re doing and actually give a damn about the city. The fact that he’s double-dipping into the public trough and adding 100 grand a year onto his teacher’s pension just adds insult to injury. F!

    I’ll admit that Shannie Duff is committed to what she does, but in this case that isn’t a good thing. Shannie Duff is a dinosaur who’s stuck in the 1800′s, she only stays on council to pursue her own backwards agenda, fighting tooth and nail to keep this city from evolving. She’s a nuisance, and she’s the main reason why I think we should have term limits for city councilors. F!

    Gerry Colbert is nothing but dead weight, he just doesn’t do anything, he wont even show up to council meetings, and to make matters worse he even defends this practice. As far as I can tell he thinks he’s retired, and he only stays on council for the extra cash to finance several trips down south every year. I don’t know why people vote for him. He’s another example of why we need term limits. F!

    I’m not going to go through everyone individually. As far as I’m concerned the council as a whole fails. They’re either incompetent, uninformed, lazy, using the council to pursue their own personal agendas, treating our municipal government like some kind of game, or some combination of all those things. We absolutely need term limits. There are lots of competent people out there who actually want to serve this city, but no one pays attention to them because everyone knows we’re just going to get stuck with the same clowns anyway. The only time we ever see a new face on council is when a current councilor resigns their seat, and these fools know it, they take advantage of it to the extreme by slacking off and not doing a goddamn thing for this city.

  5. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    What do you think about Danny Breen?

  6. avatar
    Jordan Says:

    So do you think anybody who is retired should be banned from running for public office?

  7. avatar
    Jordan Says:

    I would say that Bruce Tilley and Debbie Hanlon were the best councillors of the year. Both look at development in the city sensibly, unlike a certain deputy mayor and at large councillor who oppose for the sake of opposing.

    I have also been really impressed with Hanlon’s dedication to speaking out on reforming the council. Even though she has taken slack from her fellow councillors, and some of the public, she is still advocating for a review of council.

  8. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    Elling, I’ll admit that I’m not familiar with every councilor, particularly the ward councilors like Danny Breen, so I’m not going to comment about him specifically. The councilors I mentioned are the ones that stand out, but I’m simply not satisfied with council overall because they just don’t seem to accomplish anything. Basically I agree with the first three comments in this thread.

    Jordan, I don’t necessarily think that electing retirees is a bad thing, in some cases it could be a good thing. My problem with O’Keefe is that he just doesn’t seem into this. He has no vision, doesn’t seem to have any real opinions (other than his support for amalgamation), he doesn’t seem interested in connecting with the people of this city, it’s like he’s just sort of going through the motions. It leads me to believe that he’s just passing the time while topping up his pension, and I think that this city deserves a real leader.

  9. avatar
    Jimmy Says:

    Anonymous…….its better to have DOC in that seat than a certain other member of council…IF that person ever gets in the Mayor Seat again we as a CITY will be royally F**KED!

  10. avatar
    Jimmy Says:

    As for grading the current council they all would get a huge F marked on their report card if I were their teacher! We need term limits for council members including the mayor. I suppose we can not expect any better when we have an aging population in St. John’s.

  11. avatar
    Jeff Marshall Says:

    There certainly needs to be some new blood on council. The youngest council member right now (as far as I know) is in their late 40′s. Don’t get me wrong, we need middle aged people as well retirees on council, as they will have a unique point of view. But, I hope that in the next election someone under the age of 30 and someone in their 30′s are elected. Younger people would bring new ideas and points of view. They also have a more vested interest in how this city will run in 10,20,30,40 years. For their lack of long term vision, I would take serious marks away from the entire council.

  12. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    As for O’Keefe, I’ve seen first-hand what you are talking about,he doesn’t take the job seriously. There have been numerous times that, while another councilor is speaking, he will play with his cell phone, or start tearing paper out of a book. Behaviour like this has not place in council chambers, especially from the Mayor.

    Also, whenever you ask him a serious question, he either talks all around it, and doesn’t answer, or ignores it outright.

    He is also not honest all of the time either. Here’s just one examplem in this article (http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/story/2011/02/10/nl-okeefe-sidewalks-210.html) it says:

    “Mayor Dennis O’Keefe said that section of Topsail Road (near the Village mall) is considered a highly-travelled area, which means it is targeted for clearing faster than other locations.”

    But, wait, what’s this (http://www.stjohns.ca/cityservices/snowclearing/sidewalk/sidewalkListing.jsp), on the city’s own website is says that same section is a priority 3, and it is not a top priority at all.

    I asked him to clarify if that area was a high or low priority, since there is conflicting information, however he just ignored my question and hasn’t answered.

  13. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    Mayor Dennis O’Keefe

    - Doesn’t pay attention while councilors are speaking.
    - Plays with his phone, and tears paper, while councilors are speaking.
    - Doesn’t answer questions when put on the spot.
    - Is not always completely honest and up-front. (See my above post)

    Deputy-Mayor Shannie Duff
    - Stuck ‘back in the day’.
    - Would rather see the city stay exactly the same, rather than grow and develop.
    - Likes to complain when she doesn’t get her own way.
    - Does things that make no sense, like oppose a pedway (sky-walk) on a street that already has two just down the road, and suggest that their should be guidelines around the use of discretion, which totally defeats the purpose of discretion in the first place.

    Councillor Frank Galgay

    - Not really sure, nothing he says really stands out.
    - Makes comments at the roundtable portion of the council meetings that are out of place. When asked if he has anything to say he will often pass, and say something like “gotta go home, supper is ready” or “going home to watch TV”.

    Councillor Debbie Hanlon

    - Has welcomed me to meet with her to discuss issues on many occasions.
    - Will answer questions promptly when e-mailed or sent on Facebook as well.
    - Was smart enough to suggest a review of council, even though other councilors didn’t agree. (Makes me wonder what they are hiding if they are afraid of a review)
    - Is very involved with the community, and is always involved in something or another.

    Councillor Wally Collins

    - Is completely out of touch. I’m not even going to waste my time on this one. He stood there and said that he doesn’t think there are any hazardous effects from pesticides, because people don’t “go out and lick the grass”. Has said that all the information that is available on the subject is “rubbish”. Regardless of which side you take on the pesticide issue, to stand there and say that all of the information that science has produced is nothing but junk is just playing dumb.

    Councillor Sheilagh O’Leary

    - I’ll continue on with the pesticide issue. Councilor O’Leary should take a look at her priorities and make sure they are in-line with what residents are looking for. While people are complaining about lack of snow clearing, lack of affordable housing, and other important issues, O’Leary just pushes forward on her own agenda, even though that agenda is not what residents are asking for. I’ve heard a lot of people complain about the snow, but have yet to hear one person actually complain about pesticides. So why would the pesticide ban be such a priority for her, and other major issues are just left behind. While I do agree with a cosmetic pesticide ban there are other more serious issues to address.

    Councillor Tom Hann

    - Has many of the same characteristics as O’Keefe.
    - He doesn’t answer tough questions when asked, he’ll just ignore them.
    - Doesn’t always seem to know what’s going on. I have been asking for months when the consultants report on Metrobus will be completed and presented to Council. In October he told me by the end of November. Now he is saying sometime in December. This is despite the fact that it has been well over a year since this report was started, and almost a year since it was resumed after the strike. As the chair of the transportation commission I would have expected him to know a little more about what’s going on.

  14. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    I’d also like to include a dishonorable mention for whoever is directly in charge of snow clearing. Have they started complaining about how they “weren’t prepared” yet? Just like they do every other year when we get our first snowfall? There’s absolutely no reason for most of the city to be shut down all day, this wasn’t even that bad of a storm and the worst of it was over by 7am.

  15. avatar
    Street and Snow Fearin Lassy Says:

    MMMM? Well, Mr. O’keefe must go! I would like to see Debbie Hanlon, Shielagh O’Leary And Shannie Duff stay on. And Not cause their women but because they have proven they are willing to stand up speak their mind… And they tend to stay focused on the issues for the most part when they are raised. I wouldn’t mind seeing Greg Malone run again for mayor or deputy mayor either.. and this guy Sherwin, he’s got this site started up called public transit is essential.. he’s on top of things.. and sees to (based on the writing here) be involved with council meeting .. i would like to see Andrew Harvey and Mark Wilson come back for another go as well. these are three young and innovative , smart caring guys there.

  16. avatar
    Street and Snow Fearin Lassy Says:

    http://www.facebook.com/#!/groups/publictransitisessential/281435788565185/?cmntid=281449485230482

    link to public transit is essential.. hope it goes through

  17. avatar
    Chris Says:

    I find it amazing that 4 out of the 7 names you mentioned are the people who are dead set against development and would rather live in 1911 rather than 2011.

  18. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    It is Paul Mackey, the Director of Public Works.

  19. avatar
    guy123 Says:

    I find alot of these people say thay will do stuff thay say but don’t do this and its becoming a problem. Don’t want to bug,be mean but really something needs to be done with the road’s in my opinion. I know its a lot of money and time to do yes i know but alest like the biggest of pot holes could be fixed i was driving down the highway and i almost hit another car from a pot hole it was maybe big as a car tire and im sure it might end up to a crash from them and alot from around the city then hole is the highway comming from (cbs) to (st.john’s) and maybe it could be fixed and if maybe you could do something about that and the roads it would help thank you.

  20. avatar
    Katherine Says:

    Dear Mr. Mayor,

    I think you are doing a great job with the city, but there could be some changes in our town. First of all, I would like to start off as a student at a school in St. John’s, our sidewalks are unfit to be walking on, we have snow everywhere, and he don’t have anywhere to walk on the side walk, so we have no choice to walk on the road. It’s not a good way to start off the year.
    Second thing, I would like to say that if you wanted to have a got town, there won’t be any litter around the streets, parks, or the bus enterances. It’s actaully kind of gross. We need more garbage cans, and recycle bins too, if you want out town to like nice and good. So I think that we should get a start on that!
    Also I would like to state that your town is a nice place, but our buses. Our buses are never on time they are always late or they are to early for anyone to get them. And no one gets to there destination until a long time. So if you could get a start on that it would greatly be thoughtful of you.
    And fianlly, I have to talk about our roads. Our roads are crazy, they have potholes everywhere, and it doesn’t look nice at all. I think out City Counil should fix them up. They are super bad, and it’s not fix for any car to be on the roads driving like that. Think about all the money they people have to spend on there cars, it’s crazy! But, I really think that the city Counil should change that. But this is pretty much I have to say and that, you guys should really get a start on it. It would be good for out town, and that we could have more visters coming here! Thank-you! And I hope it all works out for our town, the city of St. John’s! :)


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.