The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
0
Like

Do we need to pay for damage when most of it happened before we moved in?

asked this question on Sunday at 8 pm.

I moved out of my apartment last week, but instead of getting our damage deposit back we got a list from our landlord of damages adding up to 2300 bucks! How is that even possible?? The list includes over $700 for cleaning carpets after a pipe broke. Aside from a hole or two in the wall from hanging up pictures we didn’t cause any damage ourselves; most of it was there when we moved in. Can he really charge us for this and is there any chance we will get our damage deposit back?

Asked by

Damaged

 

3 Responses

  1. avatar
    Andrew Harvey Says:

    Hey there,

    This is unfortunately all too common of a problem. I know a lot of people who end up getting a huge list of charges right before, or right after they move out. As in your case, many of them are for things which are none of your responsibility, such as carpet cleaning after a pipe break like in your case.
    Anything which is considered to be upkeep or maintenance is always the landlords responsibility.

    For any repairs, the only case in which the tenant would be responsible is if they are due to willful damage, or negligence. This means that your landlord can probably charge you for repairing the holes you put in the walls, but not for the carpet cleaning, unless you broke the pipes yourself, which caused the break.

    Also, as far as anything which was broken before you moved in, if you are really lucky/smart, you took pictures when you moved in, and can use those to prove you did not cause them. If not, maintain that it is not your responsibility, and if it ever comes to it, the landlord would have to prove the damages were caused when you were there, which obviously they couldn’t.

    In response to your questions:
    If you did not cause the damages the landlord is trying to charge you for, no, they cannot charge you, or keep your security deposit for this.
    As far as your security deposit, your landlord has 15 days after you terminate your rental agreement to return your security deposit, or make a claim for some or all of it. Unless you come to a mutual agreement on this, they will have to itemize this, and submit a claim to the Residential Tenancies Division(RTD). If they have not done this in 15 days, you should submit a claim form asking for the return of your deposit, you serve a copy of this to your landlord (preferably in person, with a witness, or by registered mail), and put a copy into the RTD. Your landlord then has 10 days to file a counter-claim for the deposit if they have not already. If they do not file a counter-claim in the 10 days, then you get your deposit back! If not, you will probably have to go to a hearing, where the RTD will determine who owes who what. If you have to go to a hearing, bring all the evidence you can, any receipts, written correspondence, and if you have any notes of when you tried to contact your landlord, etc. bring all this along.

    Anyways, in short, a huge list of bogus charges is often a scare tactic by slum landlords whoa re trying to scare you off the deposit they rightfully owe you, because they don’t think you will go the distance, and follow the process to get your money back. The sad thing is, most of the time this is true, people don’t think it is worth it, and drop it.

    So please people, if you are legitimately owed your security deposit, don’t drop it, follow the ridiculously tedious steps, and get your money back. Don’t let your landlord dirtbag you.

    (Note – If you did cause lots of damage, don’t expect your money back. If your landlord has a legitimate claim for the deposit, they will get to keep it. The system only works if you are in the right.)

  2. avatar
    Corey Says:

    After one bad landlord, I got into the habbit of going over every inch of an apartment I move into and take pictures, with the landlord. A landlord should never just hand you the keys without touring the apartment with you to point out any prior damages and either note it somewhere for him/her to sign, or take pictures of it with them in the picture.

  3. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    ^This. When I moved into my apartment about a year ago there was a bunch of stuff in the lease about professional cleaning, responsibility for damages, and all that shit. The place was already dirty, there were stains on some of the carpets, and a few dings in the walls here and there. I went through the place top to bottom with the leasing agent, keeping a record of all of these problems, and we revised the lease accordingly before either of us signed. Read the small print, inspect the apartment, and be careful about what you sign.


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.