The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Wha? - Questions and answers about St. John's Ask a Question Hi! | Home | | | | See more Questions
avatar
12
Like

Can the City be sued for injuries related to uncleared sidewalks?

asked this question on Sunday at 5 pm.

When the City doesn’t clear the sidewalks pedestrians are forced to walk on the road. If a pedestrian gets hit by a car, or slips on a slippery street, can he or she hold the City responsible for compensation for injuries? Could many people come together to file a class action law suit?

Asked by Jill
 

 

25 Responses

  1. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    No, and nor should the city be held responsible. I’m no fan of St. John’s snow clearing but winter does happen and yes it does cause dangerous road and sidewalk conditions, we cant expect everything to be 100% snow and ice free all the time, we live in a northern climate, that’s life. It would set a bad precedent if the city started compensating everyone who slips on an icy sidewalk, I can only imagine the frivolous lawsuits and other nonsense they would have to put up with. They don’t compensate motorists who’s cars are damaged during the winter, and they shouldn’t compensate pedestrians either.

  2. avatar
    John Says:

    There are no icy sidewalks, there are no sidewalks, that’s the point. Other cities make their citizens clear the sidewalks for people, it can be done. It shouldn’t take a person slipping and falling under a vehicle for it to change. It’s insane that every year we just expect people to risk their lives every day, there’s no need, public safety should trump all.

  3. avatar
    juicey box party Says:

    I like how you insinuate that cars are more important than people.

  4. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    So how about this.. a driver hits a massive crater of a pothole which was caused by city plows and hidden underneath snow because the city hadn’t managed to completely clear that section of road yet, it demolishes the wheel and tire, the driver loses control and smashes into another car. People in both vehicles are injured. Do you think the city is going to take responsibility? No they are not. No one should expect a municipal government to hold them by the hands and babysit them all the time. Winter is a bitch for everyone, deal with it. It would be complete chaos if everyone sued the city over winter-related problems. And if the city did start offering compensation, where do you think that money is coming from? It wont be coming out of any councilor’s pocket, I can promise you that. It would be coming from the taxpayers, and these sorts of lawsuits would hinder the city’s ability to deal with day-to-day issues. The city cannot afford this sort of nonsense. The frivolous lawsuits that would come out of this would just be a complete mess.

    And I use the damaged car example because the OP here seems to be making this out to be an us-vs-them, pedestrian-vs-motorist issue, as Scope readers are sometimes prone to do especially at this time of year, and my point is that winter sucks for everyone. There is certainly some room for improvement in snow clearing, but St. John’s is a difficult city for that, and most of the time I believe that the city workers are doing the best they can with the resources that they have. Lawsuits against the city are not the answer.

  5. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    I like how people are so quick to jump in and say you cannot sue the city. You can absolutely sue the city, and it happens in other cities all the time. Here’s a quote from this article: http://www2.macleans.ca/2011/03/17/down-shovels-the-city-should-clear-the-sidewalks/

    *****

    According to a 2000 Ontario Court of Appeal decision that has been cited nationwide, “snow and ice accumulating on public sidewalks . . . are the legal responsibility of the municipality, not the property owner.” And this holds regardless of bylaws or fines. The city owns the sidewalk and is ultimately responsible for keeping it clear.

    Beyond the financial or legal issues, however, the attitude of a city toward its sidewalks says a lot about political commitment and public concern. Nearly every Canadian city has recently made some sort of pledge in support of active transportation or becoming “pedestrian friendly.” A city that refuses to clean its own sidewalks makes a mockery of such commitments.

  6. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    Show me some credible information saying you cannot sue the city…. I’m fairly certain you can, as it happens elsewhere in Canada on a regular basis.

  7. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    By the way, not everyone that sues for slipping is just trying to get money. But the potential for ANY lawsuit would be significantly lower if the sidewalks were cleared properly.

    The sidewalks could be cleared for less than the cost of a lawsuit or two, so it doesn’t make sense to leave the sidewalks in the mess that they do.

  8. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    Just as further evidence of my last post, check out this page: http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/article/577174

    “Peter Noehammer, director of transportation services, made clear that more recent figures show liability claims against his department costing the city about $12 million.”

    If you cannot sue a city why did Toronto end up paying out 12 Million dollars?

    When people ask a question, and you decide to answer, you should be answering with correct information, not made up information that fits what you would like.

  9. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    I’m not saying you cant sue the city. You can certainly try, but in this case you are not going to win, and it’s extremely counterproductive. The city would sooner take steps to limit the services they are obligated to provide rather than face an ongoing barrage of frivolous lawsuits.

    Not to mention the greed involved here. You slip on an icy sidewalk, so your response is to seek compensation from the city, thus further limiting their abilities to properly deal with snowclearing? Once again, where do you people think this money comes from? The city does not have infinite resources, and this isn’t some multinational corporation. Like I said, for the most part the city is doing the best they can with the resources that they have, and unnecessary lawsuits would further limit those resources. What exactly would that solve?

  10. avatar
    nanny Says:

    “we cant expect everything to be 100% snow and ice free all the time, we live in a northern climate”

    man! I live in Halifax, not so far away and the snow clearing here is AMAZING. They have these little dinky sidewalk tractor plows that I see on many of the main streets. Last week we had our first real snowfall and I was amazed! The majority of the main sidewalks seemed to be cleared and those that were not done straight away, they got to eventually. They know what’s up in terms of snow clearing.

  11. avatar
    John Says:

    If the city had to pay out the ass due to a lawsuit, then they would clear the streets from then on, guaranteed. The problem is they are not willing to try, the people making the decisions never have to walk more than the length of their driveways so they have no idea what it’s like trying to navigate the streets in the winter months, sounds like you don’t either.

  12. avatar
    anon Says:

    “And I use the damaged car example because the OP here seems to be making this out to be an us-vs-them, pedestrian-vs-motorist issue..”

    Nowhere in the original post does it say anything about that.

    In my days of walking and getting the bus I had to make the choice between walking in the busy streets or climbing a rock hard ice chunk formerly known as a sidewalk. Its a hard choice. I usually walked in the street as you tend to be more in control than if you slipped/fell off a snow bank into the road. Both are very dangerous options.

    But now that I’m a driver I realize how hard it is from the other side of the coin as well, especially in poor conditions or in the dark. For instance a few days ago there was a young boy in dark clothes running along the street in my lane in the dark. I didn’t see him until he was he was in front of my car and I barely avoided him. Is it his fault? no, there was nowhere to walk on the sidewalk – his only option was to walk in the road. Thankfully there was nobody in the lane next to me or I might have caused an accident swerving out to avoid a kid running along the road in my lane.

    I think its irrelevant if you are a driver or a pedestrian. Its dangerous for everyone involved and we should all be concerned. For now though if you are a pedestrian walking around the streets at night please please wear something bright so drivers can see you. Drivers please be considerate – there really is no other options besides walking in the roads

  13. avatar
    William Says:

    As said above, your safety is your issue. So, as a result I will walk the same way I bike in this city, in the middle of the road. There is simply not enough room for pedestrians and cyclists to safely share the road with drivers in the winter(or summer). I have been hit by drivers when I was “cycling properly” at the edge of the road. They thought they had enough space to go around, but unfortunately for me they didn’t.
    So, as a result I take that decision away from drivers. I walk and cycle in the middle of the road, and overtaking traffic can slow down to my speed and wait until I feel it is safe for them to pass me.

    You would think drivers in this city would want the sidewalks cleared just as much as pedestrians. The huge financial risk to drivers that pedestrians being forced to use the street creates is outrageous. Having been involved in a cyclist vehicle collision I know first hand the cost for drivers. I was hit from behind in a situation that was mostly due to narrow roads and heavy traffic, not poor driving. I was mostly uninjured, but a cash settlement of 3500$ from the driver was cheaper than the predicted insurance payout of over 12k, that would have almost doubled her premiums.
    Perhaps this situation is a part of what causes Newfoundland insurance rates to be almost twice other provinces?! Whether the we pay for it in city taxes or in health care costs or in insurance premiums, we still pay for it.

  14. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    You’re all over the place here. First you said “No, and nor should the city be held responsible.” when asked if someone could sue the city. They you say “I’m not saying you cant sue the city.” So, um, which is it?

    And you keep saying “but in this case you are not going to win” when the evidence and court history all across Canada shows otherwise. I’ve asked for you to provide some credible source that says you will not win a lawsuit against the city. So far, you’ve shown nothing. I’ve provided just one link showing that Toronto alone faces something close to $12 million a year in “slip and fall” lawsuits. And I’m sure Toronto is not the only city facing the same thing. SO again, what evidence do you have that you will not win? Clearly many people do win.

    And stop saying that greed is the only reason people sue, that’s entirely incorrect and rather judgmental to say the least. If someone doesn’t have a car, and needs to go get groceries, but doesn’t have $40-$50 to get a cab to the store and back, the only choice is to walk in most cases. (And yes, I know you can take the bus, but how do you get to and from a bus stop…. you walk)

    So when this person, who could be a single mother with low income, slips in front of a car while walking on the road, who is to blame?? It’s easy…. the city. They have provided a service, the sidewalks, and like anyone else that provides any kind of service they are responsible to ensure that the service is provided safely.

    Would it be greedy for that low income single mother to sue the city because she can no longer work and provide for her child? Absolutely not. Had the city ensured that they put safety as a top priority it could easily have been avoided.

    You also say the city is doing the best it can with the resources they have, but again provide no evidence to back up your claims.

    Seems to me like you’re just making a bunch of random assumptions and passing them off as if they are fact.

    One last thing. You also said “unnecessary lawsuits would further limit those resources” but you are failing to see the bigger picture. You are seeing a person falling, filing a lawsuit, which then limits resources. So you are putting the blame on the person for suing after being injured.

    The way I see it the city could do a proper job, then nobody would fall, and there would be no lawsuits, and money wouldn’t be wasted. So I put the blame on the city for failing to ensure their sidewalks are safe.

    Please, if you are going to reply, especially as ‘Anonymous’, provide some credible sources for the claims you make, because so far they have all been incorrect.)

  15. avatar
    Brian Says:

    Oh put a cork in it sherwin flight. Don’t you think if you could sue the city for every slip and fall, everyone would sue???

  16. avatar
    Brian Says:

    Go back doing your ranting and roaring on facebook

  17. avatar
    Brian Says:

    Sherwin….. By those facts I can slip outside your door and sue you

  18. avatar
    anon Says:

    you can.

  19. avatar
    bean Says:

    I like how that was the only thing you could pull out of the argument Juicy, as the other person was completely accurate.

  20. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    No, not everyone would. In fact many of these incidents are not reported at all. My point was that ‘Anon’ said categorically that you cannot sue the city, when you certainly can, and it has happened here in St. John’s as well. Someone slipped in Bowring Park and sued, and won. And in that case the city was on the way to salt the area, but the judge said it took them too long to do it.

    You guys can argue with me all you want, I know for a fact that millions and millions are spent across the country on slip and fall incidents each year.

    I can provide all sorts of evidence, unlike you guys that just keep repeating the same thing and telling people to be quiet, without ever backing up a single thing you say.

    All I keep asking is prove what you are saying. I can prove beyond a doubt that people successfully sue cities all the time. Just because most people wouldn’t do something doesn’t mean it can’t be done.

  21. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    Hahahaha, so funny to see people talk about stuff they have no idea about. There is something called Occupiers Libiality, and it means you need to keep your property safe for others, even people that may be trespassing. Check this out: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupiers%27_liability_in_English_law

    We have the same laws here as well. So, if you happen to come to my house, and I haven’t cleared the snow and ice, you can sue me, yes!

    Why is it so hard for people to provide the evidence necessary to back up what they say. This is a question of law, and there is a ton of stuff out there on this topic that answers the very question that the OP asked. So stop knocking me for not agreeing with you when it comes to something that is written in black and white, and is not a matter of belief. It’s a law, in black and white, that applies to us all.

  22. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    So Brian, since you are so sure, find me some information that says you cannot sue the city for uncleared sidewalks, and find some info that says you can’t sue someone for slipping on their property.

    Had you actually looked into both of these issues before posting you would have realized that both of these things happens on a regular basis and we could have avoided this whole discussion.

    I never said it was easy to win in all cases, but you certainly can sue, and people win all the time. But if you want you can keep plugging your ears and ignoring the facts, just remember when someone slips on your property or injures themselves somehow “ignorance of the law is no excuse” and you yourself could easily be sued.

  23. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    And as for your comment “Go back doing your ranting and roaring on facebook”, it just shows what is a known tactic for people that are wrong but are too full of themselves to admit it.

    FYI, stating solid facts is nowhere near ranting and raving. I would consider trying to insult people by stating things as facts when they are not true.

  24. avatar
    Brian Says:

    Sherwin provide me details on people in st. Johns suing for unclear sidewalks.. Not in Toronto or other parts of canada. St. John’s. Besides the one in bowering park

  25. avatar
    Sherwin F Says:

    Again you’re missing the point. Just because people here haven’t been so quick to do it makes no difference to the legal aspects of it all. The question was “can the city be sued for injuries related to uncleared sidewalks?” and the answer is yes.

    It’s funny how you rule out the Bowring Park case, what’s wrong with that one? It’s exactly the same thing we’re talking about, city not clearing snow/ice properly, someone slipping, and suing, and they won. You can’t rule out a case because it proves my point.

    If the city COULD NOT be sued, as you said, then how was this case won?

    I know for a fact that you can sue the city for a slip and fall, so since I keep asking you for proof of what you say and you keep ignoring it, you show me something that say’s the City of St. John’s cannot be sued.

    I’m not sure why you think St. John’s is so much more special than any other Canadian city, because they can all get sued, but according to you St. John’s can’t. Doesn’t really make sense.


TERMS OF USE: Wha? is intended as a tool for people who have questions, answers, and things to say. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflamatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.