PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.
39 Reader Reviews of Yellowbelly Brewery & Public House
I’ve eaten there twice and haven’t been disappointed. I had really good service and the atmosphere was really inviting. The food (which is basically real fancy versions of pub food; burgers, fries, pizza etc..) was very tasty and satisfying. I don’t remember it taking very long, of course I don’t really remember it being particularity fast either. My lamb burger with cherry compote was very juicy and scrumptious. I would recommend it for people looking for a comfortable medium priced dining experience.
I’ve dined at this restaurant twice. It’s been an experience in mediocrity both times.
Positives: The beer is pretty good. Atmosphere/decor is nice. One waiter we had was quite attentive (perhaps a little too attentive).
Negatives: Food service is generally VERY slow. Food isn’t that great for the price. The burger I ordered was a pretty dry, and the pizza has nothing on Pi.
I want soooo badly to give this restaurant a good rating. The atmosphere is nice, the beer is pretty good…..BUT – we had to wait for 25 minutes before it actually got to our table. I understand this (to a certain extent) if the place was busy, but there were empty tables and plenty of staff standing around doing nothing. I made a special request with my mussel order – no bacon – and was told it was not a problem, but when they arrived (20 minutes later), sure enough, there were big chunks of bacon throughout. I sent them back, and also sent back my cold falafel. My dining companion said his burger was over-cooked, and his sweet potato fries were dried out, as if they had been sitting under a heat lamp for hours. I know he spoke the truth, since i tried a couple – while i continued waiting for my falafel to re-appear (another 15 minutes). I wish I didn’t have to say it, but – THIS WAS THE WORST DINING EXPERIENCE OF MY LIFE. PLease, Yellow Belly, do something to rectify your problems! So much potential and good beer deserve better food and service.
Having been there 3 times now for lunch, I’ve received great service and enjoyed the unique menu; not a place for a fast lunch, but a nice interlude while downtown. Their beers brewed on site are quite nice.
The food is ok but expensive. Same as the other comments…the beer is good. I found the service fine the 6 times I was there. But the food is not worth the money. $20 burger? It was nice to go there a few times, but too many other places in the city to go. I found myself getting the same burger everytime I went, which the bun falls a part everytime.
It just doesn’t have enough selection of food. When I am spending $60+ for a meal I want more selection than burger, pizza, and fish cakes. “Gourmet” or not, it is what it is.
One more thing…Don’t get the fries!
However, I do recommend everyone try this place once.
NEVER AGAIN! I was very much looking forward to having a late lunch with some friends today at The Yellow Belly. After an extremely long wait, our order came out to us and the meal was somewhat cold. We ordered burgers as we had found all the menu items to be quite pricey! We did have a very pleasant waitress, although she neglected to inform us that there were no free refills on the soda pop. Of course, when she came to our table each time, asking “would you like another pop”, as the wait was extremely long, we assumed the refills were free. When we received our bill, there was $26.00 charged to the bill for refills (7 soda pops) for 3 people. I did, upon paying the bill, indicate that I had assumed there were free refills. She apologized and said she never thought about telling us….Something that I figure we should have been made aware of before hand…apparently they have canned drinks and not fountain drinks. The waiting staff should be informing customers of this!!!! First and last time, unfortunately, for us and everyone of our friends.
If you are going out for a few pints I would give Yellowbelly a 5/5. Their beers are great and well priced. Try the sampler : 4 mini-pints, one of each of the 4 microbrews.
The food however, is overpriced and not great. I have eaten there 6 times and tried a good selection of from the menu. The pizzas seem to be your best bet. i would advise against the burgers. They are nothing like the delicious description you will read in the menu. They also seem to have a problem with getting food to the tables while it is still hot. I’d give the food a 2/5.
Stick to the beer and you will have a great experience. The atmosphere is amazing and I found the staff to be polite and fun.
I don’t drink beer so the only positive comment I can make is about the atmosphere, which was nice. The service was very slow, pizza was “scrawny” and very overpriced. The burgers were OK but unfortunately cold and also overpriced. Never again!
I wasn’t sure about going here due to all the negative reviews on this site. I went anyways on Wednesday and was actually extremely impressed.
Our waitress was very down to earth, friendly, and efficient.
I ordered the brewery’s red beer (forget the name). It was giant. It was a bit bitter at first, but really grew on me. I think I will order it again when I return.
I had the ceasar salad appetizer ($10) which was huge. I was actually pretty full after it. Then I had the smoked salmon pizza, and my friend had the wild mushroom goat cheese pizza (both around $13-15). I can’t describe how delicious these were, especially the goat cheese one. The crusts were amazing too. I will definitely be going back soon.
I wasn’t sure what the atmosphere would be like since it was on George Street. If you sit upstairs, it is actually a pretty classy place, better than the usual pub dining.
I’ve eaten there a number of times now, and each time the service and the food gets better! Last night I ordered their Greek Burger and Sweet Potato Frieds – delicious. I was most impressed with the waiter we had (I believe his name was Rod). He was attentive at the right times, was pleasant and talkative and the wait was minimal, especially for a sit down service. I’d give 8/10 for the food, 9/10 for the decor and 10/10 for the waite staff
I’ve had a number of good experiences at Yellowbelly, but not so hot last time. Food took a really long time to come, and a couple burgers were cold.
The thing that stood out was that there was a band doing sound check for a Christmas Party 3 floors up, and we could hardly hear each other. Just a bit strange.
I’m more than willing to write this off as the exception to the rule, and my Caesar was, as always, fantastic.
I enjoyed a visit to The Yellow Brewery and O’Reillys this past summer.The service was excellent and people were just wonderful.
What better place to relax and share memories of the past with fellow Journalist from the USA and Australia.They are still making reference to their visit and can’t wait to return again.
Not impressed. No one at our table liked their food and they were really, really pushing us to buy wine by the bottle to the point that it was uncomfortable. For a bottle of wine, onion rings and a turkey burger, my bill was $100.00 before tip. I couldn’t even eat the burger because the burger kept slipping out of the bun. I ended up eating the burger patty with a fork and knife and left the bun. For that kind of coin, I want to eat ALL my meal! The food is insanely overpriced. Appetizers aren’t as unreasonable as main courses but I think their salmon dish costs about the same as Atlantica and they are definetly not in the same league.
The beer here is decent enough, downright enjoyable in fact. However, the service is pretty slow, if that matters to you, and the falalfel is without a doubt the worst I’ve ever had, especially for the price. I’m not even positive that it was fried, it may have just been a chickpea mash scooped in balls inside of a tortilla. I need to give them some credit for their beer, which was some of the best I’ve had produced in St John’s so far, but fudging up falafel this poorly and charging an arm and a leg for it is a sin.
Went there with hubby a few nights ago. Both of us walked away feeling we could have spent our 60 bucks at Costo. The food is bland. No other word to describe it. Maybe dry would also be applicable. The atmosphere was really nice and our server was very good. But the food…ugh. I had a 4 cheese chicken ceasar flatbread and there was so much flour left on the bottom i nearly choked. Hubby said his fries were like cardboard and the burger was bland. This was our 2nd visit. 2 strikes, Yellowbelly…you’re out.
I went here on a second date, the pizza was good and fresh and the beer tasted good. Yes I would agree the servers could learn to take the initiative more. But overall I would go back, I love the old look of the place.
I have been there twice after and both with a group of 6 and we were turned away when I could see tables available. Perhaps that place needs a floor manger or if there is one, they should take an initiative. If I owned that place I would hate to see money walk out the door.
I keep going back in the hopes that the food will get better. It hasn’t.
Everything that my Husband and I have tried on the Menu was awful.
Otherwise I love their beer and the ambiance is great.
Not a huge fan of the place. The atmosphere is good and their beer is excellent.
However, the service was downright awful. We waited at least 25 minutes for an order to be taken. The drinks came maybe 3 minutes before the food came out (which must’ve took half an hour). By the time the food came out, it was cold, the fries were soggy. At 20 bux for the burger and fries, it better be a dang good burger. How the heck it won best burger in town is beyond me. Even the Celtic Hearth makes a better burger and it’s priced at $8 less (if only the food there was consistent…but that’s for another review).
If you’re going for a pint or two, it’s grand. But stay far far away from the food.
I keep going back in the hopes that the food/service will improve, it hasn’t. The service is the worst and the food is still bland.
Today my husband and I walked out while waiting for someone to take our order, the waitstaff was completely oblivious to us. After 25 minutes of trying to flag someone down without success we left and they weren’t even busy. That was definitely our last time at Yellowbelly.
Such a shame because they have great beer.
The only thing that has brought me back to this place is the atmosphere and the beer. My last visit will be my last. The service, quality of the food, and the price all failed. We finally got a nice warm, sunny day for lunch and a beer on the deck. We waited almost an hour for our food. My pizza then came out scorched. The salad was brown and wilted. I can’t understand how they would even let it leave the kitchen. Once we were done and ready to leave it took 45min to pay the bill. We threatened to walk out and were told we should understand since it is busy. Call in more staff!! I really hope the management can turn this place around because it has a lot of potential but seems to go further downhill everytime we go there.
Well i finally made it to the yellow belly,so last yesterday evening me n my friend strolled in for a brew n a feed,have been reading the reviews, im not a fan of fancy dining or burgers, so i went with the pizza n beer,, who can go wrong with pizza or beer,,beer was awesome, wondering if i can get after sales on it, n the pizza was wicked, best pizza i ever eaten,
I had read the negative reviews of the place beforehand but I always say not to judge something until you try it yourself. Lesson learned. I could see it being a fun place to go and have some drinks with friends, but in terms of going somewhere and having something to eat and a conversation, forget it, it’s very loud and obnoxious, which is great if you’re in the mood for that, I just wasn’t at the time. We waited about 20 minutes for the server to come over, who asked for our drink order, I got mine but my girlfriend didn’t get hers, the server said he would be right back but never appeared, I tried to flag him down but he didn’t respond. He came back eventually to take our food order, she mentioned the beer, he apologized and said he’d be right back with it, still nothing…
Then we waited a long time for our food, over 30 mins, when that finally came she mentioned the drink again, he walked over to the bar and grabbed it within seconds, something he could have done long before that. The food itself wasn’t bad, but was very overpriced, especially for the time we had to wait, we watched other tables around us get seated and served after we had arrived which made it worse and made us feel very unwelcome, like we weren’t worthy of their attention for some reason. I did get the impression that the server was overworked, which isn’t his fault, but his forgetfulness in terms of the missing drink was very irritating.
The place was also filled with obnoxious tourists talking about living in New York and how cute it was that St. John’s has a bus system, not the fault of the pub at all, but listening to that while hungry and feeling like we were being ignored made for a very crappy experience. Will not go back. Ever.
The beer is excellent. One good reason to go to the place.
But food and service…
No by.
Like many reviews, we wanted to like it and tried it to death.
The food is hit and miss and often cold.
The service is brutal for the most part and particularly so last night. It doesn’t seem to matter how busy the place is. It’s impressive how bad it can be actually.
The joint is just way too pricey to be this crappy.
Whatever you think of the beer, the restaurant stinks. The food is horribly overpriced, the service is slow and in my case extremely rude / standoffish.
When YBB first opened I was back and forth all the time… great atmosphere, service and of course the beer! Sadly, management has let its standard of service slip BIG TIME! Whip your staff into shape fast, because word is getting out that YBB is NOT THE PLACE to drop in for a bite and drink unless you like feeling like an unwelcome, irritating guest… very disappointing.
Went for lunch a few weeks ago with two others. We go regularly for decent mussels and good beer. Two of us ordered mussels, and when they came I started eating until I had a particularly uncooked salt watery mussel. I poked around some more and determined there were quite a few uncooked ones. The others were halfway through lunch so i waited until the server came to check on us and I mentioned the mussels were not cooked, he offered to replace them but I declined as we had some where to be and the guys were almost done. Waiter brought over bills and mine has had a 10% discount applied to the mussels. I point that out, and that they are expecting me to pay for uncooked shellfish that I didnt eat. He apologizes and goes to talk to his manager, comes back with a bill with 50% off on it. I said hey if thats what you guys do, fine, but not cool.He leaves and now the manager comes over and explains their policy ……… and offers me 10% off again, I was annoyed with the bargaining and said you do what you think is appropriate, where by she offered me 50% off, and then sensing my annoyance said they would take care of it. I am not in the habit of bargaining for uncooked food at a restaurant. So….. in an effort to save a few bucks, like 5$ worth of mussels YB has lost weekly customers. Very poor management!
Check out the “underbelly” while you are there. The food is good but not great. The Beer is awesome and the atmosphere is great. I think this is one of the oldest buildings still standing in St. John’s and it really shows in the old stonework.
Great beer…. But they have their own special time zone that is off Newfoundland time by 20 minutes. The potentially awesome HH special (4$ pints from 4-6pm) is ruined by a glitch in their system that they refuse to fix where their registers say 6pm at 5:40. We tried to order our HH pints just before 5:45 and were told we couldn’t. We protested (very politely) and the manager came down and re-iterated that 5:40 is 6 at YellowBelly. We asked her if she could over-ride the glitch and her response was, “I could not serve you.”
I wish they didn’t suck so completely because I really like their beer. But our time zone is awesome and their attitude isn’t.
Slow service and mediocre food will be the death of this beautiful location. Ordered onion rings for $8 and got an handfull of Price Club or M&M Meatshop rings…for $8 they’d better be hand made and have some flavour. Then they charged me extra for dip to add some flavour to them. Ordered 2 burger meals that were okay at best…nothing to rush back for.
I like to eat out and get a meal that I couldn’t easily make at home.
Yellowbelly, complacency will kill you in the restaurant business…leave the location, location, location to be the big seller in Real Estate.
I’ve eaten here several times and though the place has a great ambience the service is unfortunately a “hit” or “miss” and food can be slow even on a non-busy day.
My last experience wasn’t pleasant as our waiter was in my opinion rude and inattentive seating other patrons without reservations (like us) before us (same number in party), I had to remind him we were still waiting for a table and then he gave us attitude. But what he lost in service points was redeemed by the bartender.
I’m a beer and pub food fan. On that note, here’s what I disliked about Yellowbelly:
-noise level. A pub is a pub, but you don’t need the music that loud. It’s a pub, not a dance bar, when I go out to eat and have a few beers I want to be able to hear my friends talking to me, not have to yell over radio music. A better selection of music would go a long way too.
-Beer. I’m just not that big a fan of Yellowbelly’s beer. I like their idea, I like their bottling, I want to like their beer, but I always find it bitter.
What I liked: I had the Yellowbelly burger with sweet potato fries and aioli. It was a good meal, one of the better burgers I’ve had. My only complaint would be that the bun is advertised as an artisan bread, but it looks and tastes like a grocery store bun. Otherwise the patty and toppings were great. The fries were decent, no complaints at all, especially with the aioli
The inside is nice, interesting look and decor. It was busy when we were there but the wait staff was prompt.
Wow! Where do I start!? Went in to eat here last week, and was seated upstairs. Terrible lighting; I couldnt see what I was eating. The poor beer selection had me drinking their awful beer which is way too strong, and no option for anything else or a comp. The menu is SO boring, with standard pub food and overpriced entrées of simple fare. Portion sizes are small. Extra charges for little measly dips for nachos does NOT fly with me either. When we received our meals, I could barely see what I was eating. Are we trying to hide the visual aspect of the meal? (We ate at 8pm, and the lighting was so dark that I could hardly tell what was on my burger). Luckily, my girlfriend was kind enough to trade her meal with me and enjoyed that. They get 1 star for the kind server we had, but please: update the menu, fix your lighting problem, as those are killers in the restaurant business.
My girlfriend came here about a month ago when our favourite downtown spot was packed, I had been here before and the food was okay so I figured we would give it a shot.
I REALLY wish I hadn’t. My meal was mediocre, and as for my girlfriend, even less than mediocre. She ordered the chicken caesar pizza (being a caesar salad lover) and after a few bites she almost choked on a sharp chicken bone. When our waiter came back I told him about the issue politely and showed him the bone. I naturally was expecting good service but instead he simply said “you should expect that it’s pulled chicken”, he didn’t even replace her pizza which at that point she didn’t even want to eat. I thought his actions were beyond rude seeing as I have worked in the service industry and I know that some times these things happen, all I expected was a simple “I’m sorry we will take that off of your bill.”
When he returned I asked what he was going to do about the issue and he said again it’s pulled chicken so that happens sometimes, I then got rather ticked off and explained that I have worked in the service industry before and that all we wanted was a simple apology and not to be brushed off. He then told me he would call his manager and I watched him go over to his colleagues and talk about us then pick up the phone.
The compensation I received was my happy hour beer taken off my bill, no apology. That was all.
I don’t suggest going here if you plan on paying good money for a meal with chicken bones and ignorant waiters.
April 13th, 2009 at 12:57 pm
I’ve eaten there twice and haven’t been disappointed. I had really good service and the atmosphere was really inviting. The food (which is basically real fancy versions of pub food; burgers, fries, pizza etc..) was very tasty and satisfying. I don’t remember it taking very long, of course I don’t really remember it being particularity fast either. My lamb burger with cherry compote was very juicy and scrumptious. I would recommend it for people looking for a comfortable medium priced dining experience.
May 4th, 2009 at 11:50 pm
I’ve dined at this restaurant twice. It’s been an experience in mediocrity both times.
Positives: The beer is pretty good. Atmosphere/decor is nice. One waiter we had was quite attentive (perhaps a little too attentive).
Negatives: Food service is generally VERY slow. Food isn’t that great for the price. The burger I ordered was a pretty dry, and the pizza has nothing on Pi.
May 5th, 2009 at 9:10 pm
I want soooo badly to give this restaurant a good rating. The atmosphere is nice, the beer is pretty good…..BUT – we had to wait for 25 minutes before it actually got to our table. I understand this (to a certain extent) if the place was busy, but there were empty tables and plenty of staff standing around doing nothing. I made a special request with my mussel order – no bacon – and was told it was not a problem, but when they arrived (20 minutes later), sure enough, there were big chunks of bacon throughout. I sent them back, and also sent back my cold falafel. My dining companion said his burger was over-cooked, and his sweet potato fries were dried out, as if they had been sitting under a heat lamp for hours. I know he spoke the truth, since i tried a couple – while i continued waiting for my falafel to re-appear (another 15 minutes). I wish I didn’t have to say it, but – THIS WAS THE WORST DINING EXPERIENCE OF MY LIFE. PLease, Yellow Belly, do something to rectify your problems! So much potential and good beer deserve better food and service.
June 27th, 2009 at 1:18 pm
Food is average and highly overpriced. Service was slow and unresponsive. I have been here twice and each time I had a similar experience.
I guess you have to be a beer drinker in order to truly appreciate the place.
July 1st, 2009 at 11:36 am
Having been there 3 times now for lunch, I’ve received great service and enjoyed the unique menu; not a place for a fast lunch, but a nice interlude while downtown. Their beers brewed on site are quite nice.
July 28th, 2009 at 11:30 am
The food is ok but expensive. Same as the other comments…the beer is good. I found the service fine the 6 times I was there. But the food is not worth the money. $20 burger? It was nice to go there a few times, but too many other places in the city to go. I found myself getting the same burger everytime I went, which the bun falls a part everytime.
It just doesn’t have enough selection of food. When I am spending $60+ for a meal I want more selection than burger, pizza, and fish cakes. “Gourmet” or not, it is what it is.
One more thing…Don’t get the fries!
However, I do recommend everyone try this place once.
August 29th, 2009 at 10:30 pm
NEVER AGAIN! I was very much looking forward to having a late lunch with some friends today at The Yellow Belly. After an extremely long wait, our order came out to us and the meal was somewhat cold. We ordered burgers as we had found all the menu items to be quite pricey! We did have a very pleasant waitress, although she neglected to inform us that there were no free refills on the soda pop. Of course, when she came to our table each time, asking “would you like another pop”, as the wait was extremely long, we assumed the refills were free. When we received our bill, there was $26.00 charged to the bill for refills (7 soda pops) for 3 people. I did, upon paying the bill, indicate that I had assumed there were free refills. She apologized and said she never thought about telling us….Something that I figure we should have been made aware of before hand…apparently they have canned drinks and not fountain drinks. The waiting staff should be informing customers of this!!!! First and last time, unfortunately, for us and everyone of our friends.
September 18th, 2009 at 1:32 pm
If you are going out for a few pints I would give Yellowbelly a 5/5. Their beers are great and well priced. Try the sampler : 4 mini-pints, one of each of the 4 microbrews.
The food however, is overpriced and not great. I have eaten there 6 times and tried a good selection of from the menu. The pizzas seem to be your best bet. i would advise against the burgers. They are nothing like the delicious description you will read in the menu. They also seem to have a problem with getting food to the tables while it is still hot. I’d give the food a 2/5.
Stick to the beer and you will have a great experience. The atmosphere is amazing and I found the staff to be polite and fun.
October 4th, 2009 at 6:44 pm
I don’t drink beer so the only positive comment I can make is about the atmosphere, which was nice. The service was very slow, pizza was “scrawny” and very overpriced. The burgers were OK but unfortunately cold and also overpriced. Never again!
October 9th, 2009 at 5:32 pm
I wasn’t sure about going here due to all the negative reviews on this site. I went anyways on Wednesday and was actually extremely impressed.
Our waitress was very down to earth, friendly, and efficient.
I ordered the brewery’s red beer (forget the name). It was giant. It was a bit bitter at first, but really grew on me. I think I will order it again when I return.
I had the ceasar salad appetizer ($10) which was huge. I was actually pretty full after it. Then I had the smoked salmon pizza, and my friend had the wild mushroom goat cheese pizza (both around $13-15). I can’t describe how delicious these were, especially the goat cheese one. The crusts were amazing too. I will definitely be going back soon.
I wasn’t sure what the atmosphere would be like since it was on George Street. If you sit upstairs, it is actually a pretty classy place, better than the usual pub dining.
October 30th, 2009 at 12:51 pm
I ate there last night… the pizza was awesome and the service was great.
December 6th, 2009 at 8:26 pm
I’ve eaten there a number of times now, and each time the service and the food gets better! Last night I ordered their Greek Burger and Sweet Potato Frieds – delicious. I was most impressed with the waiter we had (I believe his name was Rod). He was attentive at the right times, was pleasant and talkative and the wait was minimal, especially for a sit down service. I’d give 8/10 for the food, 9/10 for the decor and 10/10 for the waite staff
December 16th, 2009 at 6:13 pm
I’ve had a number of good experiences at Yellowbelly, but not so hot last time. Food took a really long time to come, and a couple burgers were cold.
The thing that stood out was that there was a band doing sound check for a Christmas Party 3 floors up, and we could hardly hear each other. Just a bit strange.
I’m more than willing to write this off as the exception to the rule, and my Caesar was, as always, fantastic.
December 26th, 2009 at 3:46 pm
I enjoyed a visit to The Yellow Brewery and O’Reillys this past summer.The service was excellent and people were just wonderful.
What better place to relax and share memories of the past with fellow Journalist from the USA and Australia.They are still making reference to their visit and can’t wait to return again.
June 7th, 2010 at 6:26 pm
Not impressed. No one at our table liked their food and they were really, really pushing us to buy wine by the bottle to the point that it was uncomfortable. For a bottle of wine, onion rings and a turkey burger, my bill was $100.00 before tip. I couldn’t even eat the burger because the burger kept slipping out of the bun. I ended up eating the burger patty with a fork and knife and left the bun. For that kind of coin, I want to eat ALL my meal! The food is insanely overpriced. Appetizers aren’t as unreasonable as main courses but I think their salmon dish costs about the same as Atlantica and they are definetly not in the same league.
August 7th, 2010 at 3:20 pm
The beer here is decent enough, downright enjoyable in fact. However, the service is pretty slow, if that matters to you, and the falalfel is without a doubt the worst I’ve ever had, especially for the price. I’m not even positive that it was fried, it may have just been a chickpea mash scooped in balls inside of a tortilla. I need to give them some credit for their beer, which was some of the best I’ve had produced in St John’s so far, but fudging up falafel this poorly and charging an arm and a leg for it is a sin.
January 16th, 2011 at 11:13 pm
Went there with hubby a few nights ago. Both of us walked away feeling we could have spent our 60 bucks at Costo. The food is bland. No other word to describe it. Maybe dry would also be applicable. The atmosphere was really nice and our server was very good. But the food…ugh. I had a 4 cheese chicken ceasar flatbread and there was so much flour left on the bottom i nearly choked. Hubby said his fries were like cardboard and the burger was bland. This was our 2nd visit. 2 strikes, Yellowbelly…you’re out.
March 7th, 2011 at 12:57 pm
I went here on a second date, the pizza was good and fresh and the beer tasted good. Yes I would agree the servers could learn to take the initiative more. But overall I would go back, I love the old look of the place.
April 18th, 2011 at 12:28 pm
I have been there twice after and both with a group of 6 and we were turned away when I could see tables available. Perhaps that place needs a floor manger or if there is one, they should take an initiative. If I owned that place I would hate to see money walk out the door.
May 15th, 2011 at 9:33 pm
I keep going back in the hopes that the food will get better. It hasn’t.
Everything that my Husband and I have tried on the Menu was awful.
Otherwise I love their beer and the ambiance is great.
June 25th, 2011 at 3:35 am
Not a huge fan of the place. The atmosphere is good and their beer is excellent.
However, the service was downright awful. We waited at least 25 minutes for an order to be taken. The drinks came maybe 3 minutes before the food came out (which must’ve took half an hour). By the time the food came out, it was cold, the fries were soggy. At 20 bux for the burger and fries, it better be a dang good burger. How the heck it won best burger in town is beyond me. Even the Celtic Hearth makes a better burger and it’s priced at $8 less (if only the food there was consistent…but that’s for another review).
If you’re going for a pint or two, it’s grand. But stay far far away from the food.
June 25th, 2011 at 12:24 pm
You waited 52 minutes for drinks?
June 27th, 2011 at 4:06 pm
I keep going back in the hopes that the food/service will improve, it hasn’t. The service is the worst and the food is still bland.
Today my husband and I walked out while waiting for someone to take our order, the waitstaff was completely oblivious to us. After 25 minutes of trying to flag someone down without success we left and they weren’t even busy. That was definitely our last time at Yellowbelly.
Such a shame because they have great beer.
July 2nd, 2011 at 4:48 pm
The only thing that has brought me back to this place is the atmosphere and the beer. My last visit will be my last. The service, quality of the food, and the price all failed. We finally got a nice warm, sunny day for lunch and a beer on the deck. We waited almost an hour for our food. My pizza then came out scorched. The salad was brown and wilted. I can’t understand how they would even let it leave the kitchen. Once we were done and ready to leave it took 45min to pay the bill. We threatened to walk out and were told we should understand since it is busy. Call in more staff!! I really hope the management can turn this place around because it has a lot of potential but seems to go further downhill everytime we go there.
July 5th, 2011 at 4:21 pm
Well i finally made it to the yellow belly,so last yesterday evening me n my friend strolled in for a brew n a feed,have been reading the reviews, im not a fan of fancy dining or burgers, so i went with the pizza n beer,, who can go wrong with pizza or beer,,beer was awesome, wondering if i can get after sales on it, n the pizza was wicked, best pizza i ever eaten,
August 3rd, 2011 at 11:04 am
I had read the negative reviews of the place beforehand but I always say not to judge something until you try it yourself. Lesson learned. I could see it being a fun place to go and have some drinks with friends, but in terms of going somewhere and having something to eat and a conversation, forget it, it’s very loud and obnoxious, which is great if you’re in the mood for that, I just wasn’t at the time. We waited about 20 minutes for the server to come over, who asked for our drink order, I got mine but my girlfriend didn’t get hers, the server said he would be right back but never appeared, I tried to flag him down but he didn’t respond. He came back eventually to take our food order, she mentioned the beer, he apologized and said he’d be right back with it, still nothing…
Then we waited a long time for our food, over 30 mins, when that finally came she mentioned the drink again, he walked over to the bar and grabbed it within seconds, something he could have done long before that. The food itself wasn’t bad, but was very overpriced, especially for the time we had to wait, we watched other tables around us get seated and served after we had arrived which made it worse and made us feel very unwelcome, like we weren’t worthy of their attention for some reason. I did get the impression that the server was overworked, which isn’t his fault, but his forgetfulness in terms of the missing drink was very irritating.
The place was also filled with obnoxious tourists talking about living in New York and how cute it was that St. John’s has a bus system, not the fault of the pub at all, but listening to that while hungry and feeling like we were being ignored made for a very crappy experience. Will not go back. Ever.
August 29th, 2011 at 9:56 am
The beer is excellent. One good reason to go to the place.
But food and service…
No by.
Like many reviews, we wanted to like it and tried it to death.
The food is hit and miss and often cold.
The service is brutal for the most part and particularly so last night. It doesn’t seem to matter how busy the place is. It’s impressive how bad it can be actually.
The joint is just way too pricey to be this crappy.
That was the last time for me. Fer sure.
October 31st, 2011 at 4:56 pm
Extra star for nice decor.
Whatever you think of the beer, the restaurant stinks. The food is horribly overpriced, the service is slow and in my case extremely rude / standoffish.
Won’t be darkening the door again.
December 11th, 2011 at 4:46 pm
When YBB first opened I was back and forth all the time… great atmosphere, service and of course the beer! Sadly, management has let its standard of service slip BIG TIME! Whip your staff into shape fast, because word is getting out that YBB is NOT THE PLACE to drop in for a bite and drink unless you like feeling like an unwelcome, irritating guest… very disappointing.
March 2nd, 2012 at 9:09 am
Went for lunch a few weeks ago with two others. We go regularly for decent mussels and good beer. Two of us ordered mussels, and when they came I started eating until I had a particularly uncooked salt watery mussel. I poked around some more and determined there were quite a few uncooked ones. The others were halfway through lunch so i waited until the server came to check on us and I mentioned the mussels were not cooked, he offered to replace them but I declined as we had some where to be and the guys were almost done. Waiter brought over bills and mine has had a 10% discount applied to the mussels. I point that out, and that they are expecting me to pay for uncooked shellfish that I didnt eat. He apologizes and goes to talk to his manager, comes back with a bill with 50% off on it. I said hey if thats what you guys do, fine, but not cool.He leaves and now the manager comes over and explains their policy ……… and offers me 10% off again, I was annoyed with the bargaining and said you do what you think is appropriate, where by she offered me 50% off, and then sensing my annoyance said they would take care of it. I am not in the habit of bargaining for uncooked food at a restaurant. So….. in an effort to save a few bucks, like 5$ worth of mussels YB has lost weekly customers. Very poor management!
April 13th, 2012 at 3:34 pm
Absolutely delicious burgersr & pizzas!! Everything is hand-made and fresh. Get the margeurita pizza if you go… simple but fresh!
April 13th, 2012 at 3:42 pm
Check out the “underbelly” while you are there. The food is good but not great. The Beer is awesome and the atmosphere is great. I think this is one of the oldest buildings still standing in St. John’s and it really shows in the old stonework.
May 11th, 2012 at 11:01 pm
Great beer…. But they have their own special time zone that is off Newfoundland time by 20 minutes. The potentially awesome HH special (4$ pints from 4-6pm) is ruined by a glitch in their system that they refuse to fix where their registers say 6pm at 5:40. We tried to order our HH pints just before 5:45 and were told we couldn’t. We protested (very politely) and the manager came down and re-iterated that 5:40 is 6 at YellowBelly. We asked her if she could over-ride the glitch and her response was, “I could not serve you.”
I wish they didn’t suck so completely because I really like their beer. But our time zone is awesome and their attitude isn’t.
May 17th, 2012 at 11:39 am
This place is going down hill fast!
Slow service and mediocre food will be the death of this beautiful location. Ordered onion rings for $8 and got an handfull of Price Club or M&M Meatshop rings…for $8 they’d better be hand made and have some flavour. Then they charged me extra for dip to add some flavour to them. Ordered 2 burger meals that were okay at best…nothing to rush back for.
I like to eat out and get a meal that I couldn’t easily make at home.
Yellowbelly, complacency will kill you in the restaurant business…leave the location, location, location to be the big seller in Real Estate.
May 17th, 2012 at 10:32 pm
I’ve eaten here several times and though the place has a great ambience the service is unfortunately a “hit” or “miss” and food can be slow even on a non-busy day.
My last experience wasn’t pleasant as our waiter was in my opinion rude and inattentive seating other patrons without reservations (like us) before us (same number in party), I had to remind him we were still waiting for a table and then he gave us attitude. But what he lost in service points was redeemed by the bartender.
June 24th, 2012 at 6:49 am
I’m a beer and pub food fan. On that note, here’s what I disliked about Yellowbelly:
-noise level. A pub is a pub, but you don’t need the music that loud. It’s a pub, not a dance bar, when I go out to eat and have a few beers I want to be able to hear my friends talking to me, not have to yell over radio music. A better selection of music would go a long way too.
-Beer. I’m just not that big a fan of Yellowbelly’s beer. I like their idea, I like their bottling, I want to like their beer, but I always find it bitter.
What I liked: I had the Yellowbelly burger with sweet potato fries and aioli. It was a good meal, one of the better burgers I’ve had. My only complaint would be that the bun is advertised as an artisan bread, but it looks and tastes like a grocery store bun. Otherwise the patty and toppings were great. The fries were decent, no complaints at all, especially with the aioli
The inside is nice, interesting look and decor. It was busy when we were there but the wait staff was prompt.
September 4th, 2012 at 3:29 pm
Wow! Where do I start!? Went in to eat here last week, and was seated upstairs. Terrible lighting; I couldnt see what I was eating. The poor beer selection had me drinking their awful beer which is way too strong, and no option for anything else or a comp. The menu is SO boring, with standard pub food and overpriced entrées of simple fare. Portion sizes are small. Extra charges for little measly dips for nachos does NOT fly with me either. When we received our meals, I could barely see what I was eating. Are we trying to hide the visual aspect of the meal? (We ate at 8pm, and the lighting was so dark that I could hardly tell what was on my burger). Luckily, my girlfriend was kind enough to trade her meal with me and enjoyed that. They get 1 star for the kind server we had, but please: update the menu, fix your lighting problem, as those are killers in the restaurant business.
January 4th, 2013 at 1:44 pm
Worst. Restaurant. Ever. I felt like I was inconveniencing them greatly by wanting food and a drink.
October 29th, 2013 at 7:03 pm
My girlfriend came here about a month ago when our favourite downtown spot was packed, I had been here before and the food was okay so I figured we would give it a shot.
I REALLY wish I hadn’t. My meal was mediocre, and as for my girlfriend, even less than mediocre. She ordered the chicken caesar pizza (being a caesar salad lover) and after a few bites she almost choked on a sharp chicken bone. When our waiter came back I told him about the issue politely and showed him the bone. I naturally was expecting good service but instead he simply said “you should expect that it’s pulled chicken”, he didn’t even replace her pizza which at that point she didn’t even want to eat. I thought his actions were beyond rude seeing as I have worked in the service industry and I know that some times these things happen, all I expected was a simple “I’m sorry we will take that off of your bill.”
When he returned I asked what he was going to do about the issue and he said again it’s pulled chicken so that happens sometimes, I then got rather ticked off and explained that I have worked in the service industry before and that all we wanted was a simple apology and not to be brushed off. He then told me he would call his manager and I watched him go over to his colleagues and talk about us then pick up the phone.
The compensation I received was my happy hour beer taken off my bill, no apology. That was all.
I don’t suggest going here if you plan on paying good money for a meal with chicken bones and ignorant waiters.