The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site

The Reluctant Chef

  • 3.693.693.693.693.69
16 reviews (write your own)

281 Duckworth Street
754-6011

Go back to the restaurant list
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.

16 Reader Reviews of The Reluctant Chef

(12 positive, 4 negative)
  1. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Darryl Cooze Says:

    We went her the other night …totally “knowing ” what to expect with a tapas style restaurant…Nothing but disappointment …all the “courses” could hardly fill one plate…no plates offferd to us when bread (simple white) and shared apps on one plate arrived….pulled a lenghty hair from my mouth on the third course(I am balding) never changed the silverware after that…offered a glass of wine for the inconvenience by a long haired server HMMMM…three of the “courses” had the same vinaigarette …like eating the same course over and over I have eaten all over st john’s and have travelled extensively (europe, mexco, cuba jamaica etc) as were the guests we were with …I have never seen such small portions (the trout portion was no longer or wider than my pinkie , the final pork portion was two small bites …and we all figured that they must of used one fillet of trout for the whole retaurant …50 dollars per person and we had to eat something on the way home to stave off the hunger …toatl of over 150 dollars with two glasses of wine each for each couple …very disappointing …

  2. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    lyly Says:

    Can’t wait to go myself. I am vegan and it is so hard to go out to celebrate or just indulge once in awhile…and that restaurant caters to vegans! I have friends who go there regularly and they love it. This restaurant is very new and the formula still evolving so I expect that it will only get better and better. This approach to the restaurant experience is a good addition to this city

  3. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Sarah M Says:

    This place is a gem!

    I love the tasting menu style, this city needed an alternative to Raymond’s. Plus, The Reluctant Chef is tastier and much more affordable! The food is interesting, fresh ingredients, freshly made and well put together. My husband and I really enjoyed that the chef came to serve and speak with us, it gave the evening a personal touch.

    I wish they were open every night of the week!

  4. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Jay Hamilton Says:

    I would really like to give this restaurant 3.5 stars but I can’t on this site…I really enjoyed my meal at The Reluctant Chef and I think it is a worthy and interesting addition to the St. John’s dining landscape. The portions are small (perhaps a little too small) but the flavours and combinations are unusual (the octopus is spectacular) and I really like the fact that the chef will adjust the menu on any given evening to accommodate vegetarians and vegans. I also like sitting down to a meal that is a surprise at each course (9 on the night we went) – it’s a bit like being at someone’s home – if your friend happens to be a great cook. It has its flaws (I don’t like having to keep my cutlery – that should be worked out) and the portions are a bit small, but all in all, it’s a good meal in a nice room and has a really cosy feel…just what you want on a blustery winter night.

  5. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Michael Says:

    One of the Five Restaurant’s currently in St. John’s Tied for First Place!

    Artisan Tasting Menu (NOT Tapas) that can be made to your taste after chatting with Chef!

    A complete adventure every meal – and we have eaten there three times already.

    Although the portions are small, we expected them to be small, as they are supposed to be small…to taste…But is certainly adds up! In fact, my wife requested smaller portions after a bit so she could taste more of the dishes (I think there were 8 or 9). We were both stuffed after the meal.

    Fifty Dollars is a complete steal…we have paid $150 in Rome, London, & San Fran for similar tastings.

    Cannot wait to go back!!!

  6. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    lynn Says:

    I have greatly enjoyed The Reluctant Chef. I can’t help but poke huge holes in Darryls unfair “review”. His “knowing what to expect of a Tapas bar” really says, he had his mind
    made up before he went in the restaurant. The definition of a “tapas” bar is a “wide variety of appetizers or snacks in Spanish cuisine”. This restaurant is not advertised as a tapas bar. Not sure this mistaken identity qualifies him as a restaurant reviewer.

    As for a hair in food, I also have been to restaurants in Europe and many in the United States and, the more experiences you have, the more you know it happens and it’s never intentional. Professional efforts were made I am sure to make up for the human error and he should have let it go.

    As for “simple white” description of bread served, has he ever heard the most beautiful food is that which is simply done but properly prepared. France and Italy make hundreds of styles of “simple white” and we pay over $4 dollars for a simple, beautiful French Parisian loaf at Georgetown Bakery-if you are lucky to get there before they are sold out! Obviously there is something to simple white bread.

    At the very least he should have given this burgeoning restauranteur another chance before trashing his efforts.

    He most certainly was not “starving” after 2 plus hours dining on 9 courses of beautifully and thoughtfully prepared food in a relaxed manner (not kicked out to turn over the table).
    Of course the portions were small–there were nine courses. As for his insulting comments
    about the price, where can you eat 9 courses for $50 a head? If he wants a feed for 4 people,
    go to one of the “higher rated” rib and fries joints with frozen vegetables on the side.

    And, I haven’t even began to talk about the passion and knowledge of food that “The Reluctant Chef” displays in each course. I advise Scope readers to make up their own minds about this charming and very satisfying new addition to downtown dining.

  7. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Sam Says:

    I would not go back or recommend to anyone. Very small portions, took @4 hours to get served what amounted to a plate of food. Hot courses were only slightly warm. The room itself was cold. Too many tables squeezed in back room, noise level once full was unpleasant. Raymond’s is more expensive but I leave there satisfied. Be very reluctant about heading to The Reluctant Chef.

  8. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Mark Says:

    My wife and I had an amazing anniversary dinner tonight and the Reluctant Chef was fantastic. A truly unique experience with a great atmosphere, some really impressive food and the wine pairings were perfect. The nicest lamb I have ever had.

    Plan your time and enjoy this great experience, we WILL be back!

  9. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    john hannaford Says:

    is the reluctant chef barrier free ???

  10. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Shona Crisby Says:

    AMAZING! That’s the first word that comes to mind, I’ve been thinking about writing this review for a couple of weeks & have been struggling with what words to use to describe how fantastic it actually was- there aren’t any! There are no words that will do justice to how superb it was, from the atmosphere to the staff to the food, the whole experience! I’m still totally amazed that I had this dinner in a little restaurant in St. John’s Newfoundland!! People like Darryl Cooze & Sam who do not give this place & its terrific staff a 5 star rating… well – they must be just small minded people with very little dining experience!(who don’t mind making themselves look stupid by writing such rubbish) Our party was even a little over demanding with one vegetarian to please & one dinner with very limited menu due to a medical condition however all four of us were served an exceptionally great 5 course dinner that words cannot describe! As far as price is concerned, I’ve spent more in a pub for an evening out & of course not received the awakening of my taste palette nor the memories that The Reluctant Chef provided! Keep up the good work guys, I will most definitely be visiting you again on my next trip to Newfoundland!

  11. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Anna Says:

    We ate at the Reluctant Chef last week and came away very disappointed. It was our first time and will be our last. We had a 6 course meal at a cost of $60 per person. One course was one scallop and another was one small fish cake, which means $10 per course. We have eaten at fine dining restaurants but have never left hungry. The owners need to increase the size of the servings and to offer more bread throughout the meal. We spent almost $600 that night and had to go home and get something to eat.

  12. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Fact setter Says:

    You know that the reluctant chef offers an extra course if you’re still hungry after your course before dessert. You just have to communicate these things. I’ve had nothing but great experiences.

  13. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    tina s Says:

    well tonight was my birthday and what a disappointment in the portion sizes! I actually thought about stopping on the way home for something to eat. The experience and the service was undeniable superb but when you spend 250+ on a special meal you expect to somewhat filled. Raymonds offers much better value than the reluctant chef, not to mention atlanticia with a room would be 350!! when they serve a dessert and its the same width as a package of sugar something is wrong! Get it together chef you may get return hungry customers

  14. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    DM Says:

    I really wanted to love this after reading the reviews. The idea is sound, they are working hard to bring an interesting new experience to St. john’s. We had the 5 course tasting menu, 7 if you count bread and dessert. Service was okay, they explained everything, but felt a little like a second class citizen when we didn’t opt for the wine pairing, if you love wine and want to pay $70 dollars each for the pairing this might be the place. The bread was nice but after we were done, they brought two humus, but never offered to give us more bread. The soup was okay, too much nutmeg and no mushrooms, the one highlight was the one mushroom, it could have been amazing. Scallop tar tar with fried wantons was nice strong in lime, which over powered the sweet scallop. Next was sole wrapped around veg – Amazing, but the fish was cold after being reheated. The next was an alligator with a butter curry, best dish of the night, perfect. The final dish was moose gnocchi, I didn’t like at all. The pasta was like lumps of mashed potatoes and moose was like an under seasoned bottle moose that had been so over cooked. Dessert was chocolate cake with sherry, was one bite. For $200 for everything, a pop and two drinks off the drink menu we came away full but a little underwhelmed. No one first nor last asked how things were.

  15. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Jim Says:

    Stumbled upon the Reluctant Chief while we were on holidays this summer (mid July). The food and service were great! The wine pairings were a good match. I do not understand how anyone could be left hungry??
    Try the Caesar, they add their own spin to it and it’s one of the better ones I’ve had.
    If you ever think of opening a second location, please do it out here in BC (even if it’s done reluctantly).

  16. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    J&J Says:

    I have read all the reviews above and can’t believe people left hungry. My husband and I received a 6th course after my husband said he could eat more. The food was excellent (we went for the surprise!). I, myself, hate leaving a restuarant feeling like I’m gonna barf so this was an excellent choice. For me, leaving a restuarant feeling perfectly satsified for the price we paid was amazing!

You can write a review right away below or you can log in here. (New user? Sign up here!)


    • Don't have an account? . Takes just a minute or two.

  • Leave a Review