The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site

The Club

  • 3.943.943.943.943.94
17 reviews (write your own)

223 Duckworth Street
726-2582 (CLUB)
www.theclubrestaurant.net
Facebook: www.goo.gl/wD6Ok

Go back to the restaurant list
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.

17 Reader Reviews of The Club

(16 positive, 1 negative)
  1. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    NG Says:

    My friends and I dined there for the first time this past Saturday and we had a great time. The atmosphere was lovely, very relaxed with a good selection of music that was just the right level as we could easily talk but still enjoy the good tunes. The servers were friendly, attentive and one of them demonstrated he could also carry a tune. As for the food, all of us at the table agreed that it was tasty and that the portions were good. In fact, my only complaint would be that the portions were a little too good as I had trouble finishing my surprisingly big sandwich. I particularly liked the pomme frites and as for the prices, they were pretty reasonable. I felt I got my money’s worth and I will be checking this place out again.

  2. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Ruth Says:

    Some friends and I ate at The Club on opening night and we were not disappointed. We had been waiting patiently for this resto to open ever since we heard talk of it.
    The atmosphere was great – rustic chic. But best of all, the food. I agonized over my food selections (because it all looked so so good) but ended up with some oysters, a scotch egg, then steak and the brussel sprouts. All was delicious. Cannot wait to return and sample the rest of the menu.
    My friends all loved their food as well. No one went hungry, and everyone was highly satisfied.
    This resto is fantastical!

  3. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    freddychef Says:

    went to this new place Friday night without a reservation, a beer sodden whim and it was fun. we sat at the bar, ordered drinks and oysters. A very warm ambiance with the back wall/drape removed opening it up a bit….while we require to go back to try the menu properly all in all fun….all new places need to work out the kinks and the main suggestion I had was if you offer oysters(only Malpeques I was told) then a trio will want to share and it took a very long time to get the first dozen as the person shucking had little or no experience—baptism by fire with a rookie nick in the works!!—all in all though a treat and will be back to try again….the baby stanley cup (oyster delivery) though was over the top for sitting at the bar…a platter would have been more suitable for the space limits…..I was also told that the owner is looking towards a gastropub feel and if so should get a few quality beers on tap…good luck and I’ll try again….

  4. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    FB Says:

    I ate here for lunch after hearing great reviews. The food is delicious and very creatively prepared and presented. It seemed like there was a lot of thought put into all the details. The only thing that bugged me was the hour-long wait for food. I REALLY hope this is a new restaurant thing that will go away once the kinks are worked out. I can’t really afford that much time at lunch during a workday and ended up rushing my meal.

  5. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    JB Says:

    Went here with the boys for some drinks and apps. We all loved the food. It’s a cool place to have a few beer and the food was totally awesome.

  6. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Emma Says:

    Amazing. My boyfriend brought me here for an early Valentine’s dinner and everything was perfect. The ceviche was served in a martini glass – more filling than I thought it would be – and I had the hanger steak and grilled local bacon. Brought about half of it home and can’t wait to have it for leftovers! The molasses flavored butter served with the rolls was unexpected but nice. We tried a couple of oysters and they were tasty too.
    It was crowded and noisy but it was a Friday night so it’s to be expected. Looking forward to going back.

  7. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    cd Says:

    After hearing such good reviews of the place, A group of us “foodies” tried to give it a whirl. After barely getting a reservation on weekend we opted for the a late reservation, When we got there the place was crowded and we waited patiently at the bar for them to get our table ready. We were pretty pumped about the décor and seating–then we noticed how dirty the cups were with red wine stains and lipstick marks. Our server wasn’t very pleasant, nor did she seem to remember our drinks. The menu is quite complex with very little description about “hotness”. I ordered the stuffed potato soup which tasted like no potato I have ever tried–it was over seasoned and way too spicy for my liking. My fiancée got chicken wings which were suppose to come with carrot and celery sticks but they “substituted” (without telling us)it with an raw onion based coleslaw with was very potent. He said it ruined the rest of his night–he likes onions too–but the flavour was so strong it ruined the rest of his meal. Our friends had onion rings that were dried off and were seating in oil so bad they looked like they weren’t drained at all. Our reservation was for 8:30pm and we didn’t receive our main dishes til a little after 10, at this time it must become a club because the music was so loud we couldn’t engage in conversation. The meals them else looked sloppy, rushed and had horrible flavours on them. Our friend ordered the brussel sprouts which we assumed were uncooked because we all tried them and couldn’t chew them. Overall worst restaurant experience ever, and when we told our server, she just kinda shrugged. The hostess at the front offered us a gift card but we declined–the food was not worth a second attempt. I feel bad for the manager because it didn’t look like any one responsible was running the place.

    We also witnessed one of their employees bring with his buddies at the bar and run back and forth the whole night between kitchen and bar, All I can say is very unprofessional.

  8. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    freddychef Says:

    Made it back for a proper meal a couple weeks ago. All in all I found the lunch menu a bit limited and not very creative. Opted for a burger but as I am a food separator had to spend time keeping the runny slaw from attacking my fries and sogging my bun–maybe a nappe dish would help. The burger was fine but found myself pulling bits of bun off-a sure sign for me that it was too big…but still….mouth feel, the grind seemed very very fine, almost too much. Reminded me of a german mettwurst or something similar…

    My buddy had the moules et frites and found them good, although he could of past on the fries and had a larger portion of mussels. The service, at that time of day was fine, quick, not too intrusive but I did have a laugh at the pepper mill coming to the table…this large oversize mill…reminding of so so Italian restaurants from the 80s….if the food isn’t already seasoned properly……anyhow all in all a good time.

    My only observations as a cook was that a cook or two(?) kept coming out of the kitchen, one of them smacking kisses on someone sitting at the bar, greasy apron, no real uniform. From that point of view I would think leave your apron in the kitchen if coming out into the restaurant, wear a proper uniform, or really don’t bother. Getting the mix between an upper end eating establishment and easy going can be trying but then, that should be half the fun.

    I have always had some funny rules for eating out; if you see a sandwich board out front riddled with spelling mistakes–don’t go in; if you see the cooks/chefs outside, greasy aprons, jeans, smoking–don’t go in; if the staff spend more time hanging out at the bar–walk out; if a server rolls their eyes as you inquire about the menu, get up, walk out……

  9. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    r393 Says:

    Have been twice and enjoyed it both times. The service is a bit wonky (1 or 2 checks to make sure things are good is sufficient, 5 to 7 is a bit much) and the wait times can be long. Adore the Moksha (portobello) burger on the lunch menu, hope they will add it (or a few more vegetarian options) to the dinner menu. The bread with molasses-infused butter is a nice touch. They get bonus points for décor and music choice.

  10. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Asolene Says:

    There are some very solid points at which the Club thrives, but there are also downsides. The food was decent, and portions were generous. The decor is rustic but comfortable. However, the staff leave something to be desired. Many of them seem unprofessional, coming and going as casually as you please. It took too long for our meals to come, and service as a whole was slow. The only thing that came swiftly enough was the drinks. There were about 5-6 people around, including the bartender, but I only saw two actually doing something. The others were wearing civilian clothes, coming and going, and I actually wondered what they were doing there. Are they even employees, or just friends there to hang out? Maybe if they’d been doing their jobs, service would have been better. Also, the chosen configuration of the tables made things a bit crowded. When you can’t get out without excusing yourself constantly from the minute you leave your seat, it’s a bit much.

  11. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    g Says:

    I went to this restaurant with my boyfriend after wanting to try it for a long time. I had heard really great things about the food and as an adventurous eater, was excited to try a bunch of different things. We ordered the moules frites, the lobster mac and cheese, beef tartar, and ceviche. The mussels were done in your standard garlic and white wine, and they were huge! Seriously the biggest mussels i’ve ever had. The mayo that came with the fries had a citrus kick to it and was really tasty. The lobster mac and cheese was awesome too. Really creamy and cheesy, yum. Now, it unfortunately goes downhill. The beef tartar was really bland. I had a couple bites and was just not feelin it. My partner liked it, but like me, felt it lacked flavour. The ceviche was HORRIBLE. The presentation was cool tho, in a martini glass. I love ceviche, I make it myself and this was the weirdest one i’ve ever had. It had green olives in it, which definitely did NOT work well. There was hardly any lime in it, and besides the taste of olives, it literally had no taste at all. It was gross. It made me urge. My boyfriend felt the same way and it remained untouched. It really surprised me when the server came to clear our table, she did not ask if we had enjoyed it. As a server myself, if I see an untouched dish coming back, I would assume that there was an issue, and would seek to resolve it. Definitely put me off. I saw a couple burgers going out, and they looked delicious. I wished I had ordered one instead. So, overall, a little disappointing. I would go back and give the burger a try.

  12. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    bolo Says:

    Service: 2.5/5
    Food: 3/5
    Atmosphere:4/5

    Pros – nice bathroom, great onion rings, no rush
    Cons – server with a bad attitude, mushroom burger

    Might go again, and if I do they will make much more money from me if they provide a server who will ask if I need more beer.

  13. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Sarah Says:

    I’m giving The Club 4 stars for one reason only, and it might be a little unfair, because I guess it’s not really their fault.

    I went with a friend a couple nights ago, we split our food and had the moules frites, the smoked salmon, oyster, the NY strip and the lemon cream cheesecake.

    Mussels – A really large portion of mussels, tasty and simple in garlic and white wine. I’m not crazy about mussels but these were done well.

    “Pommes frites” – They’re french fries guys. They’re french fries, and calling them pommes frites doesn’t make them fancy. That being said, these were hands-down the best french fries I’ve had any where. Browned perfectly, crispy on the outside, fluffy inside, not too greasy. Excellent overall, my only complaint is that the salt was applied with a heavy hand.

    Smoked salmon – This was great, really tasty, served with cream cheese and “crackers”. My only complaint was that the slices were really thick, which made it challenging to bite any off, you kind of have to cram the whole thing in your mouth, and it was quite chewy.

    NY strip – Much like the french fries, one of the best steaks I’ve ever had. It was cooked perfectly, red all the way through but hot right to the center, perfectly browned on the outside yet not overcooked on the outside. Served with a couple asparagus spears, which were a little bitter, but frankly, when the steak is this good, no one cares about the vegetables.

    Cheesecake – delicious, served with berries on a wooden platter. It must have been amazing since we managed to keep eating after ordering so much. Sweet but not too sweet, rich, savoury, awesome. Only complaint is that it was on the firm side.

    Now for the harsh part. Unlike some other reviewers, I didn’t really have a problem with the staff. I like to see happy cooks hanging around and I like the look of the staff at The Club – all black with company tees and some personal flair. Whoever said that seeing cooks smoking outside is a sign that you should take off has apparently never been to Paris.

    My complaint is about the other people who were eating there. Call me crazy, but I got a vibe of pretentious hostility from most of the people that I encountered eating at The Club, so much so that it really put a damper on my meal. I don’t think I’ve been out of the social loop so long that many of the rules have changed in my absence, and I’d like to make a public announcement to restaurant patrons of St. John’s: Don’t stare at other people while you eat. Yes, I know, you’re dressed really hip and you’re eating somewhere really trendy, but that doesn’t give you a license to exude eau de prick. I’ve eaten all over St. John’s and never have I felt so socially out of place than my experience at The Club.

    So, go for the food, stay for the service, leave quickly to avoid the other shitty diners.

  14. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    rodney skanes Says:

    Me and five of my main rough riders (chainsaw, bruiser, kuncklehead, home run and gary) bopped on down here for a feed and dat. As soon as we bopped our heads in the atmosphere tripped us right out. it was sick!!!! our server was a rocket and best kind and all dat. knucklehead tried to drag her off but she let him down easy. like i said, best kind. for drinks, me n the bys got at some sangria. it was mental! the bartender kept us good and liquored up on dat like a boss. let me tell ya it was wild. so anyways for appetizers i had the scotch egg. it flipped me out!!! an egg in a sausage…like whaaaaaaaat?!?!?! deadly. home run would have got the wings but i let him have some of me egg because i owed him a fin. after a few sips and a scattered dart and dat we ordered up a scoff of steaks. THE BEST STEAK IVE EVER HAD THE PRIVILEGE OF THROWING IN ME GUTS! it was burnt! i went back and shook hands with the top dog who cooked it up. the other by’s feeds looked nuts. the burger was so jacked that gary couldnt fit it all down his beak. had to get a doggy bag, best kind. even though i was pigging out all night i wanted a little sumthing for me sweet-tooth. let me tell you the by’s are weapon at apple crumble. i ate it like a savage so i didn’t have to share with home run because i still owed him a loon. it was about time to get out of dodge. i was gonna chase a skirt and maybe hit the sheets with her. we went to settle up and the bill totally didnt blade us out,
    i loves this place it is gangster.

    ps i’d like to shout out to me cousin jay sick and me uncle dario
    peace

  15. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    B Says:

    WORTH THE HYPE.

    Went last Friday, no reservation so we had to sit at the bar. Usually sitting at the bar sucks a little but not here, it was best kind! I had some seafood get-up in a martini glass, when I saw it I thought there was no way it was going to be any good it just looked too fancy… but I was super wrong. It was to die for! My friend let me try her steak and it was so good I stole another bite when she wasn’t looking! It wasn’t even done the way I like steak but it was still one of the best I’ve ever tasted.

    The service and atmoshpere was the best part. Our server was really friendly, they all appeared very genuine. Unlike most resturants where you know the staff are putting on fake smiles and taking shit from customers, the staff here really appeared to be enjoying their job. Where the fuck do servers actually look like they enjoy work? No where but here!

    Great spot, I’ll be back again and again and again. I want to try everything. I don’t think I’ll even bother with yellowbelly or any of those other places again.

  16. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    B.A.S Says:

    Stopped by The Club last night and we were not disappointed. At first we were taken back a little by the loud music, it was not what we were expecting, but we quickly got over it. The service was REALLY good. I ordered a Q.V Light and was brought an India. I like India so I didn’t even notice. The waitress came by and she quickly noticed it and told me it was coming off the bill. Very nice.

    The Food, oh my god… Amazing. TASTY steaks!!!!
    Certainly worth a visit.

  17. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    freddychef Says:

    After a few too many one slow tuesday night I had the pleasure of taking a couple of friends back to The Club for what is becoming our favorite late night beer soaker treats..moules – frites..it was late for a tuesday but the guys sat us down, knowing we had a few and with my friend and I both heading to sea for a while we needed this!..Anyhow they treated us with fine service and food and no complaints. We had a great meal and few more beers and called it a fantastic end to a fun night.

    Sidenote,and nothing to do with The Club, I still think that to see servers and cooks in the front of a restaurant (any restaurant) smoking with, untidy uniforms and greasy aprons is a standard I never held up in 20 years in the business. No matter what city or country.

    Professionalism of an establishment can be seen not only from the inside but on the outside as well. If management thinks it is ok that the appearance of slovenly workers may be seen as representative of their product then I for one am avoiding that establishment. Just an opinion.

You can write a review right away below or you can log in here. (New user? Sign up here!)


    • Don't have an account? . Takes just a minute or two.

  • Leave a Review