PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.
YUM. The service here was really great and the food was delicious. I had the jiggs dinner, and tasted my friend’s seafood pasta (full of actual yummy seafood) and my other friend’s seafood croissant. All was flavourful and well-prepared. Will be going back.
This place is amazing! Five of us went for a nice dinner this past weekend and it was exactly what we got. Finally nice to see a good restaurant where the old Mag and Stein used to be.
The waitress was nice and helpful. The appetizers were all excellent, especially their salad options. But the best part of all was their sea-food. Man did they ever hit the nail on the head with doneness, presentation, and of course seasoning. Needless to say, I will be coming back to this place again and again if it is this good all the time.
The service is excellent, the decor is smart and tasteful, and the food is excellent. But if you have the “specials” be ready for a significant hit to the wallet. I had the rack of boar on saturday night – $44 – the singular most expensive food item I have ever paid for at a restaurant in St. John’s…was it good? Delicious. Was it $44 good? Not a chance. My wife had a $30 risotto – nobody charges 30 bucks for risotto. I ate at Bobby Flay’s restaurant in New York City cheaper than I ate here. When Saltwater gets its prices in line with its food offering I will be back because it’s a lovely place to spend an evening – minus the sticker shock.
You’re nuts. Do you think boar is accessible and cheap in St. John’s? A risotto for 27-32 is also par for the course in this city. Don’t slander a restaurant just because it’s outside of your price point, nor compare pricing to a restaurant in not only another city, but another country. They have suppliers coming out the wazoo in a place like NYC.
The service was good, price point was good considering the size and presentation of the dishes. That being said, there must have been an issue with one of the main dishes from our table because the rest were colder than they were warm, with a nice “been sitting a long while” look to them. The food tasted decent, but would have been better served hot. Also noted that all the other tables received bread and amuse bouches while they waited… we waited longer than the other tables (even those that arrived after us), and we received neither. Would not return.
I would have given this restaurant 5 stars but I think the price point is a little off. It’s not that I mind spending money on good food, but I’m not sure Saltwater has struck the proper balance. Food is certainly 5 stars for me, it’s absolutely one of the best restaurants I’ve eaten at in St. John’s. However the service/atmosphere aren’t what I would expect for the price.
Went here for my birthday and I can honestly say that I’ve never experienced such AWFUL service. I don’t ever write reviews but it is completely necessary for people to know before they sink $100+ on a meal. We waited over 25 minutes with no menus or water (while every server walked past our table looking at us.. finally we had to flag someone down and ask them if we could have our menus). We also had to grab someone different as they rushed past our table every time we wanted to order another drink or inquire about something on the menu (why they weren’t checking on the table I will never understand). If you want to throw away money on mediocre food/food portions and less than functional service, have a ball – you’ve found your place! Buyer beware.
October 13th, 2012 at 12:48 pm
excellent service and food…
October 30th, 2012 at 3:36 pm
YUM. The service here was really great and the food was delicious. I had the jiggs dinner, and tasted my friend’s seafood pasta (full of actual yummy seafood) and my other friend’s seafood croissant. All was flavourful and well-prepared. Will be going back.
November 26th, 2012 at 11:39 am
Awesome kitchen and wait staff. some of the best food i have ever eaten! cant wait to go back!!!
January 29th, 2013 at 9:54 am
This place is amazing! Five of us went for a nice dinner this past weekend and it was exactly what we got. Finally nice to see a good restaurant where the old Mag and Stein used to be.
The waitress was nice and helpful. The appetizers were all excellent, especially their salad options. But the best part of all was their sea-food. Man did they ever hit the nail on the head with doneness, presentation, and of course seasoning. Needless to say, I will be coming back to this place again and again if it is this good all the time.
Well done St. John’s
March 25th, 2013 at 12:14 pm
The service is excellent, the decor is smart and tasteful, and the food is excellent. But if you have the “specials” be ready for a significant hit to the wallet. I had the rack of boar on saturday night – $44 – the singular most expensive food item I have ever paid for at a restaurant in St. John’s…was it good? Delicious. Was it $44 good? Not a chance. My wife had a $30 risotto – nobody charges 30 bucks for risotto. I ate at Bobby Flay’s restaurant in New York City cheaper than I ate here. When Saltwater gets its prices in line with its food offering I will be back because it’s a lovely place to spend an evening – minus the sticker shock.
April 10th, 2013 at 9:10 am
You’re nuts. Do you think boar is accessible and cheap in St. John’s? A risotto for 27-32 is also par for the course in this city. Don’t slander a restaurant just because it’s outside of your price point, nor compare pricing to a restaurant in not only another city, but another country. They have suppliers coming out the wazoo in a place like NYC.
July 9th, 2013 at 11:53 am
The service was good, price point was good considering the size and presentation of the dishes. That being said, there must have been an issue with one of the main dishes from our table because the rest were colder than they were warm, with a nice “been sitting a long while” look to them. The food tasted decent, but would have been better served hot. Also noted that all the other tables received bread and amuse bouches while they waited… we waited longer than the other tables (even those that arrived after us), and we received neither. Would not return.
September 29th, 2013 at 4:14 pm
I would have given this restaurant 5 stars but I think the price point is a little off. It’s not that I mind spending money on good food, but I’m not sure Saltwater has struck the proper balance. Food is certainly 5 stars for me, it’s absolutely one of the best restaurants I’ve eaten at in St. John’s. However the service/atmosphere aren’t what I would expect for the price.
October 30th, 2013 at 9:35 pm
Went here for my birthday and I can honestly say that I’ve never experienced such AWFUL service. I don’t ever write reviews but it is completely necessary for people to know before they sink $100+ on a meal. We waited over 25 minutes with no menus or water (while every server walked past our table looking at us.. finally we had to flag someone down and ask them if we could have our menus). We also had to grab someone different as they rushed past our table every time we wanted to order another drink or inquire about something on the menu (why they weren’t checking on the table I will never understand). If you want to throw away money on mediocre food/food portions and less than functional service, have a ball – you’ve found your place! Buyer beware.