PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.
$35 for 2 burgers, fries and pepsi. I would happily pay the price again, except for the fact that the burgers were nothing to write home about. Expect a small white bun (no different than the ones served at other popular fast food chains), and a tiny portion of overcooked and greasy fries. I had he L.A. is my lady – 2 tiny slivers of avocado, roasted peppers (I found none on mine, but the bottom bun was bright pink – like it had been stained by beets or something – was that supposed to be the peppers?), basil pesto (from a tube) that was mixed with watery (not “creamy”) goat`s cheese. Tasted ok – but not worth $15+. My spouse had “The Great One” – a very pedestrian mixture of cheddar cheese, bacon & roasted garlic mayonnaise. What made it gourmet exactly? The type of garlic mayo that can be purchased at any common grocery store these days? We won’t be back. When I think of “gourmet” burgers, I think of places like Signature Burgers in Toronto that prices their burgers based on the type of meat you choose – ie: black angus, organic or kobe beef ($8 – $17) – with topping like “smoked” cheddar or gruyere, truffle oil, rosemary sea salt, and yes a full slice of avacado! Another fav of mine – also in T.O. unfortunately, is the Gourmet Burger Company which has similar ingredients to Relish but much less expensive. Yes, it`s nice to have a new burger joint in St. John`s – but lets not get so excited that we forget how much we`re being fleeced. Relish is another chain restaurant gone wild!
After a walk of quidi vidi and signal hill I usually end up downtown looking for reward. So one day a friend and I decided to check out this new burger joint. As we waited in line we perused the menu and decided.
Being a cook makes eating out a challenge quite often, realizing that you have a certain set of ideas, flavors, likes and dislikes from tastes, ambiance and service, but you still try things to have an opinion. For a burger though I am strictly looking for the burger.
Relish, for about 20 bucks a combo left a lot to be desired. My first thought was the 20. Yeah a lot for a burger and well let’s face it, nothing that special. Opening comment to my friend was `I could have fired up the barbie…`…BUT we were eating out as a well deserved treat….I had emailed a sister restaurant earlier asking the following; do you grind your own meat, make your own onion rings and french fires and really all the answers were `no, BUT….`..anyhow it was ok but nothing to write home about. I still crave that charbroiled burger and Relish was basically using a flattop (breakie griddle)…not a very big burger either and a so so bun. The fries are few and a real seller would have been home made onion rings like we found at Keith’s Diner in the Goulds….
They could also (may have already) put the actual prices of the sides/extras on the menu board.
I was really looking forward to this place opening because I love a good burger but it’s not that good. The meat has a an odd spice in it and it’s not a juicy patty at all. The toppings are ok, but all the burgers come with ‘relish’ which is purple in color and tasted ok but kind of overpowering. I want to actually taste the meat! If your specialty is burgers, I believe it should be a GREAT burger and this sadly is not. I think that Greensleeves or even Yellowbelly has a much better burger and definitely more gourmet.
The sides were also terrible, frozen fries and onion rings at a burger joint? And when we got them, they were cold. I don’t believe there is any excuse for frozen sides, especially at a burger joint. If I want frozen fries I can make those at home. The price didn’t deter me, it was about $32 for 2 people, burgers sides and drinks which is fair IF it was actually good. Really wanted it to be, but it’s not.
My experience at Relish closely resembles the previous reviews. Expensive and entirely ordinary. The first thing I noticed about the burger when I took a bite was how it seemed to have an odd spice in it which I wasn’t crazy about. Plus, the fries were cold. This place is a one-visit restaurant for me. Never again.
I figured can’t be as bad the above , and although not terrible I agree for a gourmet burger , jungle jims has better value abd still tastes quite good!
the burgers are decent size but not huge , the portions of fries leave a lot to be desired, there are some unique toppings , but for 17.03 I could have ordered the infamous headhunter burger at JJ’s and if I could finish it – get half off the next one on my next visit!!
I did find it tasty(it being angus beef) , but places in t.o. like the ones mentioned above as well as craft burger and burger priest do it much better for same or better value. hell, craft burger even make their own gourmet ketchups and garlic aoli…..certainly can be improved on and glad to see restaurant demographics going wider…
I am the owner of relish St Johns and just wanted to touch base with you to regarding your review. Here are a few points that you reflected on
1. The bun we were using when you ate at relish has been replaced by our signature bun which was in the final stages of development from weston bakery. We had to open with the “imposter” bun for a two week period until the new bun was launched which we now have.
2. The Pesto is not from a tube
3. The pink was our signature relish made from a mixture wish contains beet which is why the bun was pink
4. Our roasted garlic mayo is made in house daily. I can assure you this and will show you the recipe should you like to see it
5. The goat cheese dressing is also made in house and is typiccally not watery.
6. All of our beef is AAA black angus which has not been frozen.
As for price i think it a fair comparison if you look at various other locations for their burger prices or a comparison. I recently had a burger combo at a local establishment and paid 14 for a frozen patty, fries and then had to pay 2.00 for fountain pop. feel free to email me at chefroger@relishyou.ca
Hello Freddy chef. I would love for you to contat me via email so we can chat. I have a long history in the local food scene and would like to chat about your relish experience. Would love to know where you cook and why you feel the $20 you paid was overpriced. Being a fellow food industry person i would like to talk more.
We do not grind our own meat however we do use fresh triple AAA angus which is much more costly then frozen due to the shelflife as you can appreciate. Charbroiling burger is a preference. With regards to our system the griddle is much more efficient and is quite common in burger restaurants. Drop me a line to chat. chefroger@relishyou.ca
Roger Andrews
Sorry to here we did not meet your expectations. The frozen fries and onion rings is actually a corporate decision which I have tried to change. It is more complicated then just making home fries. Our store would not be able to handle the volume we require due to limited storage and refridgerator space. Not to mention the increased labour cost which would add to the overall cost of the product. Just to let you know the majority of large restaurants are not doing homemade fries and onion rings. Perhaps smaller restaurant doing small numbers are however we are doing 400 people a day.
We do have a spice mixture in our meat, which should help bring out the beef flavour and compliment it. Like all foods I guess it is not for everyone.
I found the burgers fine but I was disappointed this was another chain and not a local concept. Also, the server was rude and she snapped when I asked a question. I have found the best place in town to get homemade onion rings is the restaurant at the Clovelly golf course. It is open to the public and these onion rings are made from scratch and the best I have ever tasted.
Well, I’m sad to see all of the negative feedback. Most people only take time to complain and I wish more people would write to tell how much they love Relish (I have heard nothing but great things) and other local establishments!!! I will be going back for my 3rd time next week and I am really looking forward to try another flavour! The prices are reasonable compared to other local fair..I was at a restaurant tonight and the burger & fries combo was $16 and it was good but Relish burgers are FABULOUS! I love the gravy and the sweet potato fries. All of the ingredients are made fresh & your burger is prepared to order. I encourage all readers to try it for yourself. Also, if you like something,food,local retailers,hotels and so on, please take time to tell other how much you love them. For every negative review there are 100 positives. Be good to local business:)
I have been dissapointed by nothing the four times I’ve eaten here in the 3 weeks they’ve been open. My burger is cooked upon order, not some frozen patty or precooked and held over and dried out. The juice is running down my fingers it so fresh. Where else can you get caramelized onions and brie on your burger? I think that certainly is gourmet! The onion rings are not greasy, the fries are perfectly done , the slaw is so light and fresh, not that gooky , creamy junk you get everywhere else, not to mention no fountain drinks! Real soda at no extra charge! This place is kick a$$!
There are certainly some good burgers, but the few i’ve had have been covered in sauces, despite requests to go light on it. Throw in the combo and it’s not really saving anyone anything. co’mon, $3 for a 600ML bottle of soda? I’ll bring my own next time. A handful of fries for the cost of a bag of fries? Nope, won’t fool me next time.
Also, leaving a couple of perfect 5-star reviews, possibly staff-written, to try and beef up the star rating on review sites? That’s low. How’s about addressing complaints head on or with a collective action, like lowering your prices or handing out better portions? Newfoundlanders are sometimes said to be very keen on saving a dollar, so please work a bit harder to have us believe your product is worth them.
I was very excited to try Relish burgers and finally had a chance to pop down with a friend for lunch yesterday. The staff was very pleasant and the service was quick. I had The Great One and really enjoyed it, though the bottom bun was a tad soggy and the fries were lackluster. I don’t mind paying a bit extra for a great burger but $3 for a bottle of pop was a bit much. Next time I’ll likely just spring for a burger and skip the extras.
And yes, I will go back to try more burgers…super tasty.
The only thing at Relish that was really a turn-off was the cleanliness of the ladies washroom. At least that can be easily remedied with more frequent bathroom checks during busy lunch hours.
Thanks for the feedback and we are taking your advice on increasing the portion sizes of the side dishes. I doubt that staff wrote those ratings and reviews. I am the owner and read the reviews to get criticism to fix our system and see what people are saying. I have been responding to disgruntled patrons from day one and appreciate your feedback
I’ve been to Relish twice since their opening and have been pleasantly surprised. I think the negative comments left by no means reflect my experience! I have tried the LA is my Lady and the harvest jazz. My husband has had the big Texas and The Diablo. All burgers were fresh and unique. It doesn’t compare to any fast food restaurant Ive tried! I wouldn’t even put them in the same category. I’ve eaten at many restaurants in the city and quite enjoy how different this place is and what it has to offer. I’ve had the sweet potato fries and onion rings and tried the regular fries from my husbands order. All were excellent. I think it’s unfair for people to pass harsh judgement on a newly Opened restaurant and maybe turn others away from trying it. Like everything there are always kinks and certain types of food are not for everyone. I think the toppings on the burgers are not overpowering but a perfect blend to compliment the burger. I’ve had both the beef and turkey burgers and enjoyed bOth, even though I don’t Particularly enjoy turkey burgers I was pleasantly surprised. The cost doesn’t bother me considering it’s something different, fresh and delicious. :)
My partner and I really loved our burgers and fries (Jersey City and Le Nordique). I think the pricing is fair, given how much you have to pay for brie in a grocery store in NL. And I really loved the relish with beet root in… mmmm. We will be back to try out the rest of the menu. Oh, just one thing… could you perhaps add a few more tables?
Firstly, I’m really glad that this chain has come to St. John’s, and I truly hope it does well. However, I have just a few comments which I hope will improve the Relish experience. Someone brought up the spices in the burgers. There IS something odd in them, cloves maybe?? I don’t know, that’s the only thing I could compare it to, although that’s probably not it, as I can’t imagine why anyone would think that cloves should go in a burger. And I guess that is just a matter of taste, but obviously many have had issues with it. I also agree with the above comment that the burgers should be charbroiled, I think it’s safe to say that everyone would appreciate that more than fried. On the plus side, I do really like the wide variety of toppings you can get on the burgers, and the way in which Relish combines them. The inside of the restaurant was also very nice, colorful and fun. Staff is pretty nice as well, needs to stay on top of the cleaning though! Our table was in need of a wipe-down when we went. And one more thing, the poutine. It’s called “gourmet” poutine, but I didn’t see anything gourmet about it. The gravy had the same odd flavour that the burgers had, and appeared to have peppercorns in it? Again, I can only take a guess, it could have been peas for all I know. Also, very stingey on the cheese curds, and home fries would be a huge improvement!
I very much appreciate your suggestions. We do put a spice blend in our burgers which give it the unique taste you speak of. It is a recipe developed by our corporate chef Ray henry. As much as I enjoy a charbroiled burger we have to follow the system that is relish and how they do the burgers. We cannot charbroil our burgers and the store in halifax griddle theirs so it is matter of consistency amongst stores.
We have made a few changes to our systems to stay on top of the cleaning of the dining room. As for the gravy it contains a reduction of green peppercorns red wine and shallot. I am guessing the peppercorns are the flavour you are getting and possibly the wine
again thanks for the suggestions we will definitely be addressing some of them
Jersey city is my personal favourite. Unfortunately we are unable to fit more tables in there. Fire commissioner tells us the seating we are allowed to have based on a formula on national building codes and size of space. Hopefully if we keep doing the business we are doing we will be looking at opening a store in the east end and mount pearl to alleviate some of the restrictions we have in our downtown locations
First off I have to say that burgers are one of my favorite meals so I was very excited to try it. So the following are a few things I noticed.
-The meat was really nothing special. Tasted like it had some spices in it that didn’t really play to my tastes.
-The bun was very underwhelming
-The relish was very over powering and took away a lot of the flavor of the burger.
-Two of my friends had the fries, I had the onion rings. I honestly could not believe the poor quality of both. As a burger joint your sides have got to be banging
-I personally don’t mind the price. It is fair with other “gourmet” burger joints
-Small menu. It didn’t really appear that there was make your own burger selection including list of toppings etc.
-Pretty cool atmosphere but doesn’t make up for the burger.
As i said, if you’re going to have a burger joint only, it has to be money every time and this fell short for me. I heard a rumor that the works was coming to town. If you want a burger. That is the place to go.
I’m really surprised by the negative feedback about Relish. I have had nothing but a great experience the 2 times I’ve been there so far. The burgers were AMAZING!! I had the Turkey versions of Harvest Jazz (my fave) and the L.A. Lady. I was skeptical about a gourmet burger joint, especially when I heard about the prices, but both were flavourful and delicious, high quality and worth the money. During my first bite into the Harvest Jazz I made an audible “mmmm”, LOL!! The combination of walnut pesto and blue cheese was PERFECT.
I love the unique ingredients, especially the flavourful cheeses. If you want a regular char-broiled burger, then go get one at your favourite greasy spoon for $5. If you want a memorable gourmet burger with quality ingredients, then go to Relish. And no, I’m not a staff member, I work in the downtown area and have been there for lunch a couple times :)
I recently had a great meal at Relish and I would strongly recommend the restaurant . My experience was fabulous because of the quality of the meal,the friendly and accomodating staff and the atmosphere . I have trouble believing the negative comments based on my experience and the experiences of my friends . Anybody who has had a positive experience at Relish should contact this site . By the way I recommend the Signature burger if you like your Sunday dinner .
I am another person with positive feedback! Woot! Having to live a gluten free lifestyle, I was very excited to have another place offering GF choices! I enjoyed the burger I had!
I would like to suggest that you keep your fries cooked seperate if possible or provide another type of fries or a diner type side dish besides coleslaw and maybe making your gravy with cornstarch to be GF to offer more GF choices for real “burger joint” meal as, us people eating GF do not get to enjoy these simple pleasures such as fries and gravy as others do :)
Keep up the good work!!
Very pleased overall. LA Lady burger (beef patty, of course – no turkey or meatless for me!) was a taste sensation! That was a solid 5/5, one of the best burgers I’ve ever had. The different flavours complemented each other very, very well. The fries could use some work and the price is a tad steep. Eating area is a little loud with the yelling of names, which I think is a nice and unique touch, but the others I was dining with disagreed on that. One more little criticism, the table we snagged was still dirty from the previous patrons, and we had to wait a little bit for someone to clean it. Overall it is all about the burgers, which are a home run, but the other factors take it down a peg to a 4/5 – Recommended with room for improvement.
Our family recently dined at Relish and were completely impressed with the meal – and the staff were amazing! …Can’t wait to going back to try the “Sunday Dinner” burger which we’ve heard is “the best!”
Awful. I went after the Relish – St. John’s facebook page described their ‘burger of the week’: Jalapeno Hottie. It sounded delicious. When I went to the counter the person had no idea what I was talking about and didn’t seem to feel the need to check with anyone.
I replied to the facebook status talking about the feature of the week writing that it didn’t seem to be available. When I checked the page later that afternoon, the status had been deleted without so much as an apology. Pretty douchy, Relish.
Is it possible some people fib when they comment??We visit the city about a dozen times a year and we have been looking for a good burger as we generally have children with us attending and playing sporting events.Relish was reccomended to us,we each ordered something different and no one was disapointed.Delishious.Praise to the staff for checking on our two year old,making sure there were no alergies because of the different condiments.We also had fries,onion rings,poutine and slaw.All the staff were welcoming and pleasant.My husband ordered the Sunday dinner and can’t wait to order it again when we return.Harvest jazz for me.Yep,we definitly been relished.Love the gluten free bun,and fresh prepared relish,just love, love, love the whole meal deal.Also we were full.
I also have a hard time believing these negative comments, but of course, as was mentioned above, people love to complain! I however have nothing but positive things to say about Relish Burger. Best burgers in NL if you ask me. Love the fresh, delish toppings and awesome burger buns. My new addiction!!
last week my husband and I were really looked forward to having a great burger. We new going in that the burger was pricy, but willing to pay for a good meal.
With small kids, and a child with allergies, we make an effort to go out to lunch together just the two of us every couple of weeks.
We both know good food, from good fast food, good street food, to good fine dining.
I have to say, our trip to Relish was so underwhelming. The building it’s self is loud. Plastic chairs and the open concept does not create a welcoming enviroment. it reminded me of eating at that chinese buffet on Stavanger Drive.
The wait was very long, for having four front staff working one flat top, and a couple of fryers.
We watched while ours and everyone elses burgers were cooking. The flat-top was not cleaned between orders, and left over burn-on food was all over the grill.
Once we received our order, the burger was “ok”. Nothing I would say “OMG I have to come back ASAP”. The real dissapointment where the sides. I had onion rings, and my husband had fries. My rings were dripping in grease, and my husbands fries were soggy. Meaning the fryers are not set at high enough temperture. Deep frying at a correct temps will have both non-greasy rings, and crisp fries.
We will try it again, because we both believe if giving all resturants a second chance. But first impressions = dissapointment.
Having eaten at other gourmet burger restaurants around Canadaand Relish is by far better or equally priced and much better quality food! I’ve eaten there twice and both times have been incredible- by far the best burger I’ve ever eaten. The turkey patty was moist and delicious, unlike many others I’ve had elsewhere and the giant bun it came served on was awesome. The portions are huge and the burger itself is super filling and left me wanting nothing else to eat! I had the “cool slaw” and it was delicious- totally different than any other slaw I’ve have. I don’t understand how people are complaining about the price. if you go to other sit down restaurants in the city and order a burger combo (which won’t include a drink and you get a premade frozen patty) you’re looking at paying anywhere from $12.99+ and then add a fountain pop to that and you’ve got an $18-20 bill. At least at Relish the burgers are freshly made, the buns are fresh, all toppings are fresh and the atomsphere is fun and laid back what more can you ask for?! Can’t wait to go back and try other burgers! Keep up the good work guys!
I had heard about Relish burger from a friend and couldn’t wait to try it on my next trip to the city. I love a good burger, and IMO, Relish has served me one of the best burgers i have ever eaten. What a great addition to the St. John’s dining experience! Needless to say I will be back.
Recntly returned to the city and visited Relish again .I had a great meal as did my wife and son . I can’t believe the negative comments based on my families experiences and have concluded that most of these negative comments have come from competitors . Keep up the the good work Relish ! We will be returning to your restaurant .
We decided to try Relish Burger after being encouraged to try it by some friends, and I have to say, we are very impressed with our experience.! I am not typically a fast-food/burger type person, but this was definately not fast-food, and not your typical burger. I will definately be returning to this restaurant. Loved the goat cheese dressing!
I thought feedback was supposed to be a good thing. The people with negaive comments are giving their opinion just as the good comments are. I am not a competitor and my experience was bad. Too high priced for what you receive, fries should be homemade and as for serving 400 ppl in a day ever been to ches’s on a good friday and their fries are homemade. Any long established takeout in this city has homemade fries and onion rings and it can be done. Dont critize ppl for bad comments that was their take on it and after paying 30plus dollars for 2 burgers and fries and drinks I believe I earned the right to say what is wrong as well as if it were any other restaurant.
I really liked Relish the one time I was there. I’ve pondered what I would rate this place for the last 20 minutes. I found the burger pretty tasty, I had the Texas burger. The relish on the bottom was something I would have liked to have on the side in case I didn’t like it, but that wasn’t an option. I had onion rings and my husband had fries. I believe I had 5 or 6 onion rings, which was really not what I had envisioned after paying $38 for our two combos. We wanted to share our sides so we could try both the onion rings and fries, but there was hardly enough to share. For the price, there should literally be double. My husband loved his burger. I would have preferred fountain pop because it would have had ice, and subsequently been cold. I didn’t like the bottled variety. The chairs and tables are kinda cheap and uncomfortable. Also there was a hearing-impaired guest there ahead of us and when they were yelling out her name she didn’t know. So her food sat there for a couple of minutes before she went to check on it.
Tsk, tsk. I don’t understand people. My family and I have eaten at Relish and found it quite satisfactory. THe “Sunday Dinner” burger was unique and delicious! Yes I would like to see more fries (who wouldn’t) but the burger was so filling the amount of fries was enough for me. I found the onion rings really delicious. For those people complaining about the price, I don’t think there is much difference in Relish prices and those of other restaurants in the city. If you factor in having to purchase a fountain drink (which is what most restuarants sell)with your meal at other restaurants as opposed to a “real” pop at Relish there is no comparison. I think the price is fair. Also I like that the price includes your meal and beverage and you are not obligated to give a 15-20% tip like you have to at other restuarants. Now the price doesn’t seem so much, does it. I like the friendly greeting and the Relish experience. I will be returning there this weekend with great anticipation!!! As for the long lineups, tell me what restaurant you can go to in St. John’s and not wait to get in. Hasn’t happened to me yet. Keep up the good work Relish and good luck with the burger business. Remember you can’t please everyone. :)
As someone whose travelled quite a bit and eaten in all types of restraunts, I can say that I found Relish to be average at best. The burgers were alright, certainly nothing special, the sides were mediocre and the fact that the drinks aren’t included in the price made it a one time experience for me. The price was also an issue, don’t get me wrong I’ll gladly pay any price for good food but for what I got and the price I paid I was disappointed. I probably won’t be back as there are other places in the city where I can get a better deal on a better burger.
I was super excited for the opening of relish but my excitement soon dwindled. I have had “The Great One” twice – as I believe it takes a pro to make a basic burger. If you can’t make a basic burger you certainly an’t make a gourmet burger.
The burger was okay but I could have made better at home. Your cooks have got to stop pushing down on the meat when it’s cooking – pushes all the flavour and juices out!! As a burger joint, I feel that you should already know this! The patty itself was pretty dry and there wasn’t much moisture to the burger overall despite having asked for extra mayo.
The fries I was served were greasy and cold. The onion rings my husband got came from a book that was sitting on a rolling cart that had garbage on it – he didn’t eat them for sanitary reasons. Overall this restaurant was pretty lacking for me. I definitely wouldn’t mind paying the price ($20 a combo) if the food was up to par. I’ll take an AQUA moose burger over this ANYDAY.
I am not a big burger person but I really enjoyed it. We have been back twice since. It is a little pricey but you get what you pay for and that’s good quality food. It is more then enough food for one person, the garlic mayo is delicious, loved the fries especially dipped in garlic mayo just wish there was more of them :P Definitely looking forward to trying more new flavours! Good luck Andrew! :)
Thanks again racheal foR your feedback. I agree that feedback is good and we have used feedback to make a few changes to our system. Relish is a franchise and has to conform to the systems of the corporate office and that is the reason we cannot do homemade fries. Trust me i checked into it. I apologize for appearing to criticize bad comments however i do not do so to negate your comments just to explain why we do things the way we do as well as protect my investment. There are competitors out there who have been know to flame new restaurants. Thanks again for the advice. Like I mentioned we have used both negative and positive comments to change some things
Went to Relish for the 1st (and probably last time) on August 13th….Had the Cabo Diablo – there wasn’t much taste to the burger itself (which was luke warm at best), all I could taste was the overpowering relish! Another thing was that all the tables were dirty. I could understand if it was super busy, but there were only 2 other tables of people there. We had to clean off the table ourselves. Needless to say, we were less than impressed for the lack of service and subpar food we paid $40 for.
Ate there two weeks ago. I was expecting more I guess. I do not know why people can’t throw some onion soup mix (something!)into their burgers.Had Le Nordique. No real flavour. The relish was soggy and most of it slid out of the bun. The onion rings were good but I’ve made better in my oven at home. The buns need to be more substantial to hold up to all of the toppings. The toppings need to stand out. The meat needs to be seasoned.
I’ve gladly paid more than 15-odd dollars for a stand-out burger. Also, asking for the tip before we’re served is sneaky. Until this place develops and settles I won’t be back.
I was there a couple of weeks a ago and I have to say I will be back again the service was excalant, the food was nice and hot and tasted great love the different combanations of flavors on the burgers. Howerver I don’t agree with putting the tip option on the debit mechaine before you get you food and when you have to come up and get your food your self, after its cooked its all self-serve.
Definitely not worth the money paid. The burger was good, but not 18 dollars good. It was worth no more then 12 dollars.The fries were absolutely pedestrian. They reminded me of the fries Wendys used to have, before they switched. Big, Boring and Limp. It was kind of a let down.
My husband and I were really looking forward to Relish opening and we gave it a try after the crazy lineups settled down. We’ve been to lots of different burger joints in the US and Canada including everything from gourmet to a quick and easy fast food burger. Because Relish is gourmet, we had an expectation set before making our visit. We went later in the day and ordered the Big Texas and the LA is My Lady – just burgers, no sides.
First off, I was shocked at the price. We paid $24 for 2 burgers. Again, no sides, no drinks; just burgers. Asking for a tip before you’ve been served is a little backwards too… I did tip $2, but how would I even know if I want to leave a tip before I’ve had my meal? I’ve paid the same amount for burgers at a gourmet burger joint in Montreal that’s delicious, where I will go every time I visit there. So I expect something comparable at Relish.
After waiting for 30 minutes without hearing our names called, it was brought to our attention that our order got lost. Or given away to someone, or something. Instead of throwing in a side for our excessive wait, or even a $5 coupon for our next visit, all we got was a ‘sorry’.
Finally, we got our burgers and took them home to devour. At this point, I am ravenous. We both agreed that while the burgers did taste good, they weren’t anything special and certainly were not worth the price. I can grill my own burger and put toppings like avocado and goat cheese at home, for much cheaper, and it would taste just as good. We did enjoy the signature relish on the burgers, but we don’t feel like that’s enough to keep us coming back.
I agree with the many reviewers who were not impressed with their experience at Relish.
-too expensive for the lack of quality
-the beet relish was overpowering
-the seasoning on the burger is strange
-i ordered the diablo, which is supposed to be spicy, it wasn’t
-the fries were few and cold
Good on ya, Roger! I believe I started to see your responses to reviews here just as I hit “Submit” on my comments. Thanks for taking on our concerns! underneath the criticism and complaining, we only want the place to be bestkind for everyone and a place of great value to go.
I have had Relish burgers once since it opened and have to say I’m not a huge burger girl but I was very impressed. At first I thought it was a bit pricey but when you think about what you’re paying at McD’s or other fast food joints, I didn’t mind paying extra for a freshly made burger. I loved the experience and the staff were very friendly and seemed like they were having a great time which adds to the whole atmosphere and mood of the restaurant. My only complaint would be the available seating but it is understandable in a small establishment. Roger – I was very surprised to read your postings here, it’s great to see an owner who clearly cares about the service being provided to your customers. Great job with the business, looking forward to having Relish again as well as visiting any future locations.
Had my first Relish Burger last night (finally!), it was fantastic! I had the veggie LA is my Lady and husband had the beef patty Simpleton. The veggie patty was really good, not too filling and a tiny bit spicy. I was told the Simpleton was really good too. We shared an order of fries but I’ll be getting my own order next time. Really good meal made with love by chef Dale! We will be back! :D
My boyfriend and I ate at Relish, I had been to the one is Saint John, New Brunswick and it was fantastic so I couldn’t wait to go, we were very disappointed, small portions but the worse thing was they mixed up the ingredients in both our burgers and some of mine was on his burger and his on mine, we couldn’t tell which burger was which and we ended up not liking either because they were both made incorrectly.
There were about ten people in the line up so we ddn’t have the patience to bring them back. :-(
I just wanted to give a shout out to Relish, I was there yesterday with 2 friends and the overall experience was awesome! You were greeted as soon as you walked in the door and through the entire order and pick up process treated awesome. I’ve had the burgers a few times before and I’ve yet to have a bad one. I feel the price you pay is very fair all things considered because everything is house made. I’m a cook and I understand the food cost that restaurants need to take into account. Keep up the good work guys, ill sure to be back again and bringing a new crowd with me!!
My girlfriend and I actually really liked Relish. We had a Big Texas and a Nordique with sweet potato fries and onion rings. We also had the goat cheese dipping sauce with the fries. We both thought these were the best burgers we had ever tasted.
We’ll definitely be back. We want to try all of the different kinds of burgers.
Yummy, but side dishes (fries, onion rings and sweet potato fries) were ridiculously over-salted. I can always add more if I need it, but I can’t take it off, and this was verging on inedible, especially on the onion rings, I don’t think I’ve ever had them salted before.
went to relish today for the first time – best burger and fries i’ve ever had – hands down – the wife had the same opinion ( and we are food snobs-lol)
My Husband and I were really excited to try Relish. We LOVE to eat-out and having the opportunity to try a new place in the city is a real treat! We went on a Saturday afternoon in August – very few people in the restaurant and we were greeted and served very quickly!! The decor immediately caught my eye, even as we were walking towards the place – love the color scheme! However, the place was in BAD need of a wash cloth and a little elbow grease. We had quite a hard time finding a clean table to sit at, even though the place was almost empty and there were 5 staff standing behind the counter! That kind of inefficiency bothered me right away – no need!!!
I cannot remember what we ordered, but we had two different burgers with poutines as our sides and two drinks. We were a little taken aback by the price – $37!! But when we finally got our order, it looked sooo delicious and we kinda forgot what we were shelling out for it!! We were very quickly disappointed….the Burger was extremely underwhelming (hates the bun – tasted old) and the poutines were FREEZING cold! (I don’t mean just luke warm, I mean COLD!) There was definitely a strange taste on the burger and I’m not sure if it’s the “purple stuff” or is it strange spices in the meat?! Either way, it’s not a BAD taste, but definitely not the level of delicious that I had expected! Anywho, I didn’t finish my burger so I handed it off to my Husband to finish and he was very surprised to find that, though we had ordered two very different burgers, MY burger tasted EXACTLY like his!!
We walked out kinda iffy on the whole experience…..I’m not going to say we will never go there again….but I definitely think this place can be done a whole LOT better!!! They’ve got a super location and a really neat idea that I think could do very well here! And nothing about Newfoundlanders being cheap (I disagree with that whole-heartedly) we are serious about our food and personally, I would be fine paying that $37 over and over, provided I leave with a full belly and a smile on my face!! :)
Was so looking forward to our girls nite out to the icecaps game tonite.We always plan on having something to eat when we go out,so tonite we pick your burgers.Well the 20 bucks did not bother me,but i was so disappointed when i got my burger only to bite into it and it was raw.Needless to say i brought it back to you cook,he ask me if i would like another,but unfortually i could not try another.When i bite into raw meat i amturn off eating.But i think the biggest disappointment was that your staff never said sorry or even offered me my money back….so needless to say 20 bucks for frozen fries and a pepsi will not be getting me to return to your store.Only given a 1star because i have too…not because i think you deserve it.
I just recently had my third visit to Relish and once again had an awesome experience . Since I live out of town I only get in St.Johns occasionally
but Ihave found my restaurant of choice in Relish .This time I had the Simpleton with cole slaw as my side dish . I enjoyed every bite that I took .When I get back to the city in two months time I shall return to Relish.
Tried Relish for the first time today and was totally let down. No parking!! Thirty-five dollars for two combos was a bit much. Burgers lacked taste and luke warm at best. Fries and onion rings were ok. Audio was so loud in building made it impossible discuss menu with cashier unless you were in each others face. Adding a dollar for onions when its one of the sides?? Can’t say I’ll visit again.
Like a lot of other people here, I wasn’t terribly impressed. Thirty five dollars for a pair of mediocre-at-best burgers and fries/onion ring combos?
The menu options were creative but hardly haute-cuisine enough to justify the cost, and certainly nothing I couldn’t prepare better myself at home on the barbecue to feed ten for half the price that I paid for two.
There was a long lineup and a longer wait, and I was extremely surprised at the lack of wait staff, given how much it cost to eat there and the up-front expectation to tip at the register.
For that kind of money, I can think of a lot better places to eat and Relish definitely left a lot to be desired. That’ll be my one-and-only visit.
First time visit. Location doesn’t have much parking. Phone order was taken. Food was ready as promised. Had a great one with fries and two Nordiques; one with sweet fries and the other with onion rings. Onion rings could be better but burgers and fries were great. Very unique beet relish which I and my friends really enjoyed. My friends had visited several times and were happy with each trip. I will definitely return. No turnoffs for my $ 43.00. Keep up the good work!!
Unfortunately, I live out of the city so I’ve only got to try Relish once, but I definitely enjoyed my experience and burger when I was there! The Greek Tycoon was delicious and personally I loved the signature relish on the bottom! I had the “cool slaw” as my side, which was different but tastey! I definitely will try Relish again the next opportunity I have, all the options look so yummy it’s hard to pick out which one to try next!
My experience at Relish (I’ve been there three times) has been nothing but positive. The parking is the same as any restaurant downtown. As for the prices, the quality of the burgers are much better than restaurants of equal price (ex. Montana’s). You can tell the ingredients are fresh and the meat is higher quality. The staff was nothing but polite and friendly. Also, I like the fact that they offer gluten free options. I would recommend!
First time this evening and everything was fantastic! I had the turkey burger Greek style with onion rings and tzatiki on the side with a side of slaw. Best idea ever! Everything was so flavorful and fresh. Can’t wait to go again!!
love the idea of a burger only joint, however ~$20.00 for burger, fries, and soda leaves me feeling that this place i overpriced. I dont mine paying extra for quality and something different. but for some reason I left this place feeling somewhat jipted.
my wifes burger was cold (meat patty and bun), and my burger’s patty seemed pretty thin for a place specializing in burgers. I know that the patty doesnt have to be huge for the burger to be good, but i felt like this resturant was skimping on beef. when Im paying 20$ plus for a burger combo i shouldnt feel that any skimping is taking place.
again, great idea/concept but with such high prices I dont see myself returning often.
I think if this place had combos in the area of 10-12$ it would be on wheels constantly.
Ive been to other burger joints in canada were the prices on avg are 9-12$ for a combo. great burgers and a reasonable price, 20$ a combo is just too much..
Me and my wife were looking forward to trying Relish for a while now. I had heard mixed reviews so we were waiting a while for them to get all the kinks worked out.
I liked the atmosphere and feel of the place. The music was a good volume, the place seemed clean and service was friendly.
Our burgers were okay but not great. They were served luke warm, bordering on cool. I feel the price would have been about right if the burgers were what I had been expecting. A burger should center around the ground beef but the taste of the patty was completely lost amongst the toppings and I found it difficult to discern any meat flavour at all.
The portion size of the sides were pretty large however I was very disappointed that the french fries were fast food quality frozen french fries. Onion rings were run of the mill. With a gourmet burger I expect gourmet sides.
I don’t mind the price they are charging, however, when you charge that much people will expect you to deliver an exceptional burger. There are much better burgers to be had in St. John’s for a similar price (The Club, Blue on Water, Aqua for example).
I will probably try Relish again but I would skip the sides all together and maybe try a something with less toppings or a turkey patty on my burger.
Ate there once, too much money for very little quality. Would never recommend or revisit. Between this place and the poutine shop it has been a disappointing year for franchises in the downtown. Price the burger combo between 10-12 dollars and you might remain in business. Otherwise this location will be open for lease within 2 years.
Obviously, they have fixed some things. We had big burgers, lots of sweet potato fries. All tasted fine. Atmosphere and details like ketchup packets, cola coolers, etc. lessen the experience. And no – I don’t want my full name shouted out when my food is ready. All in all not good enough for the price, but could be with more tweaking. Won’t say never again, but not going to rush back.
Totally agree with you on the prices. I like the burgers here, but the price point is too high for the burger thet you get. If they lowered the cost of the combos by even $2, they would get a lot more business at lunch, IMO. I’ll stick to Aqua if I want to pay that much for a delicious burger.
Waited 30 minutes, realized everyone else was being served. I asked how long until ours was ready, they said ’2-3 minutes’.
Waited ANOTHER 30 minutes, realized everyone was eating but us. Went to ask where our food was, they said there wasn’t one and argued with us we never ordered DESPITE the fact we were sitting there and I chatted with the cashier.
Demanded our money back, tried to short change us. Never bothered to offer us anything to make up for it other than a lousy $2 off next visit.
Worst service I’ve ever had. Inlaws were in town and it was a sour note on their visit.
We went to Montanas and after they heard about our visit they went out of their way to brighten our day. Can’t thank them enough after what Relish Burger put us through.
Ate at Relish recently. Burgers were good, however the were served with kettle chips that were cold and soggy. The restaurant was also cold. When ordering $20 burger combos, one would expect more. Poor quality, with very little value for your money.
Tried Relish for the first time this evening. The veggie patty was very tasty, and the Harvest Jazz combination was good. Was looking forward to trying the slaw a friend had recommended, but they were out of it at the time. The fries, like others have said, were not good. The peppercorn gravy, however, was great.
The service was excellent.
I’ll probably try a different burger again but will pass on the combo.
I ate at Relish on Friday and I was anything but impressed! I was there for the first time shortly after they opened; I found the food only so-so, but very overpriced. I decided to give Relish a second chance on Friday and I will not be back. The food was mediocre at best, specifically the burger was bland and the poutine was extremely salty. The wait time was also unacceptable. I went during my lunch break and I waited over 40 minutes for my order; it was lunch time but it wasn’t extremely busy. The worst thing is I comment on their FB about my issue and my comment was deleted and I was never contacted by a manger. IMHO, Relish shows total disregard for their customers.
In summary, the food is mediocre and overpriced, the wait time was unacceptable and the managers/ owners show total disregard for the customers.
Well, I tried Relish and I absolutely loved it! Loved everything about it, but my favorite was the poutine! Just delicious! It was all delicious! I can’t wait to go back!!!
Went to Relish last week. Had a fantastic meal. My wife and I throughly enjoyed our burgers and sides, the staff were super freindly and we enjoyed the atmosphere. Lack of parking was a little bit of a concern but thats to be expected downtown. I thought the price was fair and I feel if i can feed myself with something so delicious for under 20 bucks….its worth it. Great job!
dear roger andrews,
I just want to congratulate you on serving 400 people a day, I didnt realize that many people in st. Johns are willing to pay 20$ or more for a mediocre burger.
Today I was really really looking forward to having a deadly burger, so I indulged in your prices and I seriously regret not going to Wendy’s. I regret it so much I went looking for an outlet to vent.
And its not all about the price, I dont mind paying for things if I feel like I am getting the value. You cant fool your customers, you cant convince me that your prices are justified. There are fancier restaurants with double the staff and double the menu options and their prices are much lower. To spend 20$ on one meal, you should be able to get service at your table, good atmosphere (not like a cafeteria), and be blown away by the ingredients. And maybe have a liquor license.
Just got back from Relish and was totally delighted…again. I had the Nordique, husband and kids had different kinds. Everybody loved the food and said it was quite a feed. I notice some people have complained about the price..but it certainly is not far off from what you pay for getting combos at fast food joints. The only think I would like is if the music was a bit lower….almost didn’t hear when they called out our name. ….Also, like to add that each time the staff have been spectacular. I’ve have been at fast food ‘restaurants’ when the servers have been down right rude. I worked in restaurants as a teen and really appreciate that kind of service…Bravo!
The first time we went we were unimpressed. There was nothing spectacular about the burgers, we ordered fry dip and didn’t get it, asked for no beet relish and ended up with it, and the sweet potato fries were cold. That visit was within 1-2 weeks of their opening so we figured they were just working the kinks out and agreed we’d try it again sometime. Almost a year later the Hubby decided that for Father’s Day he wanted to give it another go and again, we left unimpressed and will likely not be back anytime soon. $50 for three combos that we agreed were ‘edible but nothing special’. 6.99 for a kids mini-simpleton and the drink wasn’t included.
However, the wait wasn’t long and the staff were friendly but the food is just ‘okay’.
Tried Relish for the first time today and was met with a huge disappointment. Food was quite over priced, nearly $60 for lunch for 3 people. I’m not opposed to spending more for good food, but the element of quality was definitely lacking. We had a turkey, a beef, and a veggie between the three of us. While the veggie patty was tasty, it didn’t hold together, and the meat patties were quite thin, overly greasy and nothing special. We also tried the curry mayo with the sweet potato fries, and this dip had no flavour at all and was an odd texture – our mention of this concern with staff was rudely received. We will not be returning, and wouldn’t recommend it to anyone.
Sorry to say, but I don’t see this establishment lasting long once ‘The Works’ burgers opens down on George Street – their menu and quality puts Relish to shame.
My wife and I live out of town and have missed trying Relish a number of times on our trips to St. John’s. Finally had a chance a while back and it was very much worth the wait. Really enjoyed the quality of the burgers and thought they were very tasty. My wife especially liked the fact there was a vegetarian option. Would certainly recommend it to anyone and will be going back again soon! Keep up the good work!
July 31st, 2012 at 1:36 pm
$35 for 2 burgers, fries and pepsi. I would happily pay the price again, except for the fact that the burgers were nothing to write home about. Expect a small white bun (no different than the ones served at other popular fast food chains), and a tiny portion of overcooked and greasy fries. I had he L.A. is my lady – 2 tiny slivers of avocado, roasted peppers (I found none on mine, but the bottom bun was bright pink – like it had been stained by beets or something – was that supposed to be the peppers?), basil pesto (from a tube) that was mixed with watery (not “creamy”) goat`s cheese. Tasted ok – but not worth $15+. My spouse had “The Great One” – a very pedestrian mixture of cheddar cheese, bacon & roasted garlic mayonnaise. What made it gourmet exactly? The type of garlic mayo that can be purchased at any common grocery store these days? We won’t be back. When I think of “gourmet” burgers, I think of places like Signature Burgers in Toronto that prices their burgers based on the type of meat you choose – ie: black angus, organic or kobe beef ($8 – $17) – with topping like “smoked” cheddar or gruyere, truffle oil, rosemary sea salt, and yes a full slice of avacado! Another fav of mine – also in T.O. unfortunately, is the Gourmet Burger Company which has similar ingredients to Relish but much less expensive. Yes, it`s nice to have a new burger joint in St. John`s – but lets not get so excited that we forget how much we`re being fleeced. Relish is another chain restaurant gone wild!
August 8th, 2012 at 2:33 pm
After a walk of quidi vidi and signal hill I usually end up downtown looking for reward. So one day a friend and I decided to check out this new burger joint. As we waited in line we perused the menu and decided.
Being a cook makes eating out a challenge quite often, realizing that you have a certain set of ideas, flavors, likes and dislikes from tastes, ambiance and service, but you still try things to have an opinion. For a burger though I am strictly looking for the burger.
Relish, for about 20 bucks a combo left a lot to be desired. My first thought was the 20. Yeah a lot for a burger and well let’s face it, nothing that special. Opening comment to my friend was `I could have fired up the barbie…`…BUT we were eating out as a well deserved treat….I had emailed a sister restaurant earlier asking the following; do you grind your own meat, make your own onion rings and french fires and really all the answers were `no, BUT….`..anyhow it was ok but nothing to write home about. I still crave that charbroiled burger and Relish was basically using a flattop (breakie griddle)…not a very big burger either and a so so bun. The fries are few and a real seller would have been home made onion rings like we found at Keith’s Diner in the Goulds….
They could also (may have already) put the actual prices of the sides/extras on the menu board.
August 9th, 2012 at 9:59 am
I was really looking forward to this place opening because I love a good burger but it’s not that good. The meat has a an odd spice in it and it’s not a juicy patty at all. The toppings are ok, but all the burgers come with ‘relish’ which is purple in color and tasted ok but kind of overpowering. I want to actually taste the meat! If your specialty is burgers, I believe it should be a GREAT burger and this sadly is not. I think that Greensleeves or even Yellowbelly has a much better burger and definitely more gourmet.
The sides were also terrible, frozen fries and onion rings at a burger joint? And when we got them, they were cold. I don’t believe there is any excuse for frozen sides, especially at a burger joint. If I want frozen fries I can make those at home. The price didn’t deter me, it was about $32 for 2 people, burgers sides and drinks which is fair IF it was actually good. Really wanted it to be, but it’s not.
August 9th, 2012 at 3:46 pm
My experience at Relish closely resembles the previous reviews. Expensive and entirely ordinary. The first thing I noticed about the burger when I took a bite was how it seemed to have an odd spice in it which I wasn’t crazy about. Plus, the fries were cold. This place is a one-visit restaurant for me. Never again.
August 10th, 2012 at 9:14 am
I figured can’t be as bad the above , and although not terrible I agree for a gourmet burger , jungle jims has better value abd still tastes quite good!
the burgers are decent size but not huge , the portions of fries leave a lot to be desired, there are some unique toppings , but for 17.03 I could have ordered the infamous headhunter burger at JJ’s and if I could finish it – get half off the next one on my next visit!!
I did find it tasty(it being angus beef) , but places in t.o. like the ones mentioned above as well as craft burger and burger priest do it much better for same or better value. hell, craft burger even make their own gourmet ketchups and garlic aoli…..certainly can be improved on and glad to see restaurant demographics going wider…
August 10th, 2012 at 3:08 pm
Hello Deb,
I am the owner of relish St Johns and just wanted to touch base with you to regarding your review. Here are a few points that you reflected on
1. The bun we were using when you ate at relish has been replaced by our signature bun which was in the final stages of development from weston bakery. We had to open with the “imposter” bun for a two week period until the new bun was launched which we now have.
2. The Pesto is not from a tube
3. The pink was our signature relish made from a mixture wish contains beet which is why the bun was pink
4. Our roasted garlic mayo is made in house daily. I can assure you this and will show you the recipe should you like to see it
5. The goat cheese dressing is also made in house and is typiccally not watery.
6. All of our beef is AAA black angus which has not been frozen.
As for price i think it a fair comparison if you look at various other locations for their burger prices or a comparison. I recently had a burger combo at a local establishment and paid 14 for a frozen patty, fries and then had to pay 2.00 for fountain pop. feel free to email me at chefroger@relishyou.ca
August 10th, 2012 at 3:15 pm
Hello Freddy chef. I would love for you to contat me via email so we can chat. I have a long history in the local food scene and would like to chat about your relish experience. Would love to know where you cook and why you feel the $20 you paid was overpriced. Being a fellow food industry person i would like to talk more.
We do not grind our own meat however we do use fresh triple AAA angus which is much more costly then frozen due to the shelflife as you can appreciate. Charbroiling burger is a preference. With regards to our system the griddle is much more efficient and is quite common in burger restaurants. Drop me a line to chat. chefroger@relishyou.ca
Roger Andrews
August 10th, 2012 at 3:25 pm
Hello Nicky
Sorry to here we did not meet your expectations. The frozen fries and onion rings is actually a corporate decision which I have tried to change. It is more complicated then just making home fries. Our store would not be able to handle the volume we require due to limited storage and refridgerator space. Not to mention the increased labour cost which would add to the overall cost of the product. Just to let you know the majority of large restaurants are not doing homemade fries and onion rings. Perhaps smaller restaurant doing small numbers are however we are doing 400 people a day.
We do have a spice mixture in our meat, which should help bring out the beef flavour and compliment it. Like all foods I guess it is not for everyone.
August 10th, 2012 at 5:59 pm
I found the burgers fine but I was disappointed this was another chain and not a local concept. Also, the server was rude and she snapped when I asked a question. I have found the best place in town to get homemade onion rings is the restaurant at the Clovelly golf course. It is open to the public and these onion rings are made from scratch and the best I have ever tasted.
August 10th, 2012 at 9:14 pm
Well, I’m sad to see all of the negative feedback. Most people only take time to complain and I wish more people would write to tell how much they love Relish (I have heard nothing but great things) and other local establishments!!! I will be going back for my 3rd time next week and I am really looking forward to try another flavour! The prices are reasonable compared to other local fair..I was at a restaurant tonight and the burger & fries combo was $16 and it was good but Relish burgers are FABULOUS! I love the gravy and the sweet potato fries. All of the ingredients are made fresh & your burger is prepared to order. I encourage all readers to try it for yourself. Also, if you like something,food,local retailers,hotels and so on, please take time to tell other how much you love them. For every negative review there are 100 positives. Be good to local business:)
August 10th, 2012 at 9:35 pm
I have been dissapointed by nothing the four times I’ve eaten here in the 3 weeks they’ve been open. My burger is cooked upon order, not some frozen patty or precooked and held over and dried out. The juice is running down my fingers it so fresh. Where else can you get caramelized onions and brie on your burger? I think that certainly is gourmet! The onion rings are not greasy, the fries are perfectly done , the slaw is so light and fresh, not that gooky , creamy junk you get everywhere else, not to mention no fountain drinks! Real soda at no extra charge! This place is kick a$$!
August 11th, 2012 at 12:18 pm
There are certainly some good burgers, but the few i’ve had have been covered in sauces, despite requests to go light on it. Throw in the combo and it’s not really saving anyone anything. co’mon, $3 for a 600ML bottle of soda? I’ll bring my own next time. A handful of fries for the cost of a bag of fries? Nope, won’t fool me next time.
Also, leaving a couple of perfect 5-star reviews, possibly staff-written, to try and beef up the star rating on review sites? That’s low. How’s about addressing complaints head on or with a collective action, like lowering your prices or handing out better portions? Newfoundlanders are sometimes said to be very keen on saving a dollar, so please work a bit harder to have us believe your product is worth them.
August 11th, 2012 at 6:42 pm
I was very excited to try Relish burgers and finally had a chance to pop down with a friend for lunch yesterday. The staff was very pleasant and the service was quick. I had The Great One and really enjoyed it, though the bottom bun was a tad soggy and the fries were lackluster. I don’t mind paying a bit extra for a great burger but $3 for a bottle of pop was a bit much. Next time I’ll likely just spring for a burger and skip the extras.
And yes, I will go back to try more burgers…super tasty.
The only thing at Relish that was really a turn-off was the cleanliness of the ladies washroom. At least that can be easily remedied with more frequent bathroom checks during busy lunch hours.
August 13th, 2012 at 5:37 pm
Hey Adam,
Thanks for the feedback and we are taking your advice on increasing the portion sizes of the side dishes. I doubt that staff wrote those ratings and reviews. I am the owner and read the reviews to get criticism to fix our system and see what people are saying. I have been responding to disgruntled patrons from day one and appreciate your feedback
Roger Andrews
August 14th, 2012 at 9:47 am
Wow. My experience was not as above. My burger was fabulous and my fries were delish when I was there.
August 14th, 2012 at 9:17 pm
I’ve been to Relish twice since their opening and have been pleasantly surprised. I think the negative comments left by no means reflect my experience! I have tried the LA is my Lady and the harvest jazz. My husband has had the big Texas and The Diablo. All burgers were fresh and unique. It doesn’t compare to any fast food restaurant Ive tried! I wouldn’t even put them in the same category. I’ve eaten at many restaurants in the city and quite enjoy how different this place is and what it has to offer. I’ve had the sweet potato fries and onion rings and tried the regular fries from my husbands order. All were excellent. I think it’s unfair for people to pass harsh judgement on a newly Opened restaurant and maybe turn others away from trying it. Like everything there are always kinks and certain types of food are not for everyone. I think the toppings on the burgers are not overpowering but a perfect blend to compliment the burger. I’ve had both the beef and turkey burgers and enjoyed bOth, even though I don’t Particularly enjoy turkey burgers I was pleasantly surprised. The cost doesn’t bother me considering it’s something different, fresh and delicious. :)
August 14th, 2012 at 9:21 pm
My partner and I really loved our burgers and fries (Jersey City and Le Nordique). I think the pricing is fair, given how much you have to pay for brie in a grocery store in NL. And I really loved the relish with beet root in… mmmm. We will be back to try out the rest of the menu. Oh, just one thing… could you perhaps add a few more tables?
August 14th, 2012 at 10:49 pm
Firstly, I’m really glad that this chain has come to St. John’s, and I truly hope it does well. However, I have just a few comments which I hope will improve the Relish experience. Someone brought up the spices in the burgers. There IS something odd in them, cloves maybe?? I don’t know, that’s the only thing I could compare it to, although that’s probably not it, as I can’t imagine why anyone would think that cloves should go in a burger. And I guess that is just a matter of taste, but obviously many have had issues with it. I also agree with the above comment that the burgers should be charbroiled, I think it’s safe to say that everyone would appreciate that more than fried. On the plus side, I do really like the wide variety of toppings you can get on the burgers, and the way in which Relish combines them. The inside of the restaurant was also very nice, colorful and fun. Staff is pretty nice as well, needs to stay on top of the cleaning though! Our table was in need of a wipe-down when we went. And one more thing, the poutine. It’s called “gourmet” poutine, but I didn’t see anything gourmet about it. The gravy had the same odd flavour that the burgers had, and appeared to have peppercorns in it? Again, I can only take a guess, it could have been peas for all I know. Also, very stingey on the cheese curds, and home fries would be a huge improvement!
August 15th, 2012 at 2:46 pm
Thanks Katie,
I very much appreciate your suggestions. We do put a spice blend in our burgers which give it the unique taste you speak of. It is a recipe developed by our corporate chef Ray henry. As much as I enjoy a charbroiled burger we have to follow the system that is relish and how they do the burgers. We cannot charbroil our burgers and the store in halifax griddle theirs so it is matter of consistency amongst stores.
We have made a few changes to our systems to stay on top of the cleaning of the dining room. As for the gravy it contains a reduction of green peppercorns red wine and shallot. I am guessing the peppercorns are the flavour you are getting and possibly the wine
again thanks for the suggestions we will definitely be addressing some of them
August 15th, 2012 at 2:48 pm
Thank you so much for your support glad you enjoyed your experience
August 15th, 2012 at 2:51 pm
Thanks beth
Jersey city is my personal favourite. Unfortunately we are unable to fit more tables in there. Fire commissioner tells us the seating we are allowed to have based on a formula on national building codes and size of space. Hopefully if we keep doing the business we are doing we will be looking at opening a store in the east end and mount pearl to alleviate some of the restrictions we have in our downtown locations
August 15th, 2012 at 7:51 pm
Thanks for your reply. Best of luck!!
August 16th, 2012 at 1:05 pm
First off I have to say that burgers are one of my favorite meals so I was very excited to try it. So the following are a few things I noticed.
-The meat was really nothing special. Tasted like it had some spices in it that didn’t really play to my tastes.
-The bun was very underwhelming
-The relish was very over powering and took away a lot of the flavor of the burger.
-Two of my friends had the fries, I had the onion rings. I honestly could not believe the poor quality of both. As a burger joint your sides have got to be banging
-I personally don’t mind the price. It is fair with other “gourmet” burger joints
-Small menu. It didn’t really appear that there was make your own burger selection including list of toppings etc.
-Pretty cool atmosphere but doesn’t make up for the burger.
As i said, if you’re going to have a burger joint only, it has to be money every time and this fell short for me. I heard a rumor that the works was coming to town. If you want a burger. That is the place to go.
August 16th, 2012 at 2:49 pm
I’m really surprised by the negative feedback about Relish. I have had nothing but a great experience the 2 times I’ve been there so far. The burgers were AMAZING!! I had the Turkey versions of Harvest Jazz (my fave) and the L.A. Lady. I was skeptical about a gourmet burger joint, especially when I heard about the prices, but both were flavourful and delicious, high quality and worth the money. During my first bite into the Harvest Jazz I made an audible “mmmm”, LOL!! The combination of walnut pesto and blue cheese was PERFECT.
I love the unique ingredients, especially the flavourful cheeses. If you want a regular char-broiled burger, then go get one at your favourite greasy spoon for $5. If you want a memorable gourmet burger with quality ingredients, then go to Relish. And no, I’m not a staff member, I work in the downtown area and have been there for lunch a couple times :)
August 17th, 2012 at 5:25 pm
I recently had a great meal at Relish and I would strongly recommend the restaurant . My experience was fabulous because of the quality of the meal,the friendly and accomodating staff and the atmosphere . I have trouble believing the negative comments based on my experience and the experiences of my friends . Anybody who has had a positive experience at Relish should contact this site . By the way I recommend the Signature burger if you like your Sunday dinner .
August 19th, 2012 at 11:40 am
I am another person with positive feedback! Woot! Having to live a gluten free lifestyle, I was very excited to have another place offering GF choices! I enjoyed the burger I had!
I would like to suggest that you keep your fries cooked seperate if possible or provide another type of fries or a diner type side dish besides coleslaw and maybe making your gravy with cornstarch to be GF to offer more GF choices for real “burger joint” meal as, us people eating GF do not get to enjoy these simple pleasures such as fries and gravy as others do :)
Keep up the good work!!
August 19th, 2012 at 4:25 pm
Very pleased overall. LA Lady burger (beef patty, of course – no turkey or meatless for me!) was a taste sensation! That was a solid 5/5, one of the best burgers I’ve ever had. The different flavours complemented each other very, very well. The fries could use some work and the price is a tad steep. Eating area is a little loud with the yelling of names, which I think is a nice and unique touch, but the others I was dining with disagreed on that. One more little criticism, the table we snagged was still dirty from the previous patrons, and we had to wait a little bit for someone to clean it. Overall it is all about the burgers, which are a home run, but the other factors take it down a peg to a 4/5 – Recommended with room for improvement.
August 19th, 2012 at 11:16 pm
Our family recently dined at Relish and were completely impressed with the meal – and the staff were amazing! …Can’t wait to going back to try the “Sunday Dinner” burger which we’ve heard is “the best!”
August 20th, 2012 at 8:29 am
Awful. I went after the Relish – St. John’s facebook page described their ‘burger of the week’: Jalapeno Hottie. It sounded delicious. When I went to the counter the person had no idea what I was talking about and didn’t seem to feel the need to check with anyone.
I replied to the facebook status talking about the feature of the week writing that it didn’t seem to be available. When I checked the page later that afternoon, the status had been deleted without so much as an apology. Pretty douchy, Relish.
August 20th, 2012 at 10:20 pm
Is it possible some people fib when they comment??We visit the city about a dozen times a year and we have been looking for a good burger as we generally have children with us attending and playing sporting events.Relish was reccomended to us,we each ordered something different and no one was disapointed.Delishious.Praise to the staff for checking on our two year old,making sure there were no alergies because of the different condiments.We also had fries,onion rings,poutine and slaw.All the staff were welcoming and pleasant.My husband ordered the Sunday dinner and can’t wait to order it again when we return.Harvest jazz for me.Yep,we definitly been relished.Love the gluten free bun,and fresh prepared relish,just love, love, love the whole meal deal.Also we were full.
August 20th, 2012 at 10:36 pm
I also have a hard time believing these negative comments, but of course, as was mentioned above, people love to complain! I however have nothing but positive things to say about Relish Burger. Best burgers in NL if you ask me. Love the fresh, delish toppings and awesome burger buns. My new addiction!!
August 21st, 2012 at 11:08 am
last week my husband and I were really looked forward to having a great burger. We new going in that the burger was pricy, but willing to pay for a good meal.
With small kids, and a child with allergies, we make an effort to go out to lunch together just the two of us every couple of weeks.
We both know good food, from good fast food, good street food, to good fine dining.
I have to say, our trip to Relish was so underwhelming. The building it’s self is loud. Plastic chairs and the open concept does not create a welcoming enviroment. it reminded me of eating at that chinese buffet on Stavanger Drive.
The wait was very long, for having four front staff working one flat top, and a couple of fryers.
We watched while ours and everyone elses burgers were cooking. The flat-top was not cleaned between orders, and left over burn-on food was all over the grill.
Once we received our order, the burger was “ok”. Nothing I would say “OMG I have to come back ASAP”. The real dissapointment where the sides. I had onion rings, and my husband had fries. My rings were dripping in grease, and my husbands fries were soggy. Meaning the fryers are not set at high enough temperture. Deep frying at a correct temps will have both non-greasy rings, and crisp fries.
We will try it again, because we both believe if giving all resturants a second chance. But first impressions = dissapointment.
August 21st, 2012 at 11:36 am
Having eaten at other gourmet burger restaurants around Canadaand Relish is by far better or equally priced and much better quality food! I’ve eaten there twice and both times have been incredible- by far the best burger I’ve ever eaten. The turkey patty was moist and delicious, unlike many others I’ve had elsewhere and the giant bun it came served on was awesome. The portions are huge and the burger itself is super filling and left me wanting nothing else to eat! I had the “cool slaw” and it was delicious- totally different than any other slaw I’ve have. I don’t understand how people are complaining about the price. if you go to other sit down restaurants in the city and order a burger combo (which won’t include a drink and you get a premade frozen patty) you’re looking at paying anywhere from $12.99+ and then add a fountain pop to that and you’ve got an $18-20 bill. At least at Relish the burgers are freshly made, the buns are fresh, all toppings are fresh and the atomsphere is fun and laid back what more can you ask for?! Can’t wait to go back and try other burgers! Keep up the good work guys!
August 21st, 2012 at 2:23 pm
I had heard about Relish burger from a friend and couldn’t wait to try it on my next trip to the city. I love a good burger, and IMO, Relish has served me one of the best burgers i have ever eaten. What a great addition to the St. John’s dining experience! Needless to say I will be back.
August 21st, 2012 at 5:09 pm
Recntly returned to the city and visited Relish again .I had a great meal as did my wife and son . I can’t believe the negative comments based on my families experiences and have concluded that most of these negative comments have come from competitors . Keep up the the good work Relish ! We will be returning to your restaurant .
August 21st, 2012 at 11:20 pm
We decided to try Relish Burger after being encouraged to try it by some friends, and I have to say, we are very impressed with our experience.! I am not typically a fast-food/burger type person, but this was definately not fast-food, and not your typical burger. I will definately be returning to this restaurant. Loved the goat cheese dressing!
August 22nd, 2012 at 11:54 am
I thought feedback was supposed to be a good thing. The people with negaive comments are giving their opinion just as the good comments are. I am not a competitor and my experience was bad. Too high priced for what you receive, fries should be homemade and as for serving 400 ppl in a day ever been to ches’s on a good friday and their fries are homemade. Any long established takeout in this city has homemade fries and onion rings and it can be done. Dont critize ppl for bad comments that was their take on it and after paying 30plus dollars for 2 burgers and fries and drinks I believe I earned the right to say what is wrong as well as if it were any other restaurant.
August 22nd, 2012 at 12:02 pm
I really liked Relish the one time I was there. I’ve pondered what I would rate this place for the last 20 minutes. I found the burger pretty tasty, I had the Texas burger. The relish on the bottom was something I would have liked to have on the side in case I didn’t like it, but that wasn’t an option. I had onion rings and my husband had fries. I believe I had 5 or 6 onion rings, which was really not what I had envisioned after paying $38 for our two combos. We wanted to share our sides so we could try both the onion rings and fries, but there was hardly enough to share. For the price, there should literally be double. My husband loved his burger. I would have preferred fountain pop because it would have had ice, and subsequently been cold. I didn’t like the bottled variety. The chairs and tables are kinda cheap and uncomfortable. Also there was a hearing-impaired guest there ahead of us and when they were yelling out her name she didn’t know. So her food sat there for a couple of minutes before she went to check on it.
August 22nd, 2012 at 12:05 pm
Tsk, tsk. I don’t understand people. My family and I have eaten at Relish and found it quite satisfactory. THe “Sunday Dinner” burger was unique and delicious! Yes I would like to see more fries (who wouldn’t) but the burger was so filling the amount of fries was enough for me. I found the onion rings really delicious. For those people complaining about the price, I don’t think there is much difference in Relish prices and those of other restaurants in the city. If you factor in having to purchase a fountain drink (which is what most restuarants sell)with your meal at other restaurants as opposed to a “real” pop at Relish there is no comparison. I think the price is fair. Also I like that the price includes your meal and beverage and you are not obligated to give a 15-20% tip like you have to at other restuarants. Now the price doesn’t seem so much, does it. I like the friendly greeting and the Relish experience. I will be returning there this weekend with great anticipation!!! As for the long lineups, tell me what restaurant you can go to in St. John’s and not wait to get in. Hasn’t happened to me yet. Keep up the good work Relish and good luck with the burger business. Remember you can’t please everyone. :)
August 22nd, 2012 at 12:21 pm
As someone whose travelled quite a bit and eaten in all types of restraunts, I can say that I found Relish to be average at best. The burgers were alright, certainly nothing special, the sides were mediocre and the fact that the drinks aren’t included in the price made it a one time experience for me. The price was also an issue, don’t get me wrong I’ll gladly pay any price for good food but for what I got and the price I paid I was disappointed. I probably won’t be back as there are other places in the city where I can get a better deal on a better burger.
August 22nd, 2012 at 12:25 pm
I was super excited for the opening of relish but my excitement soon dwindled. I have had “The Great One” twice – as I believe it takes a pro to make a basic burger. If you can’t make a basic burger you certainly an’t make a gourmet burger.
The burger was okay but I could have made better at home. Your cooks have got to stop pushing down on the meat when it’s cooking – pushes all the flavour and juices out!! As a burger joint, I feel that you should already know this! The patty itself was pretty dry and there wasn’t much moisture to the burger overall despite having asked for extra mayo.
The fries I was served were greasy and cold. The onion rings my husband got came from a book that was sitting on a rolling cart that had garbage on it – he didn’t eat them for sanitary reasons. Overall this restaurant was pretty lacking for me. I definitely wouldn’t mind paying the price ($20 a combo) if the food was up to par. I’ll take an AQUA moose burger over this ANYDAY.
I wish that folly was still around….
August 22nd, 2012 at 12:44 pm
Hello Kevin, I will have the special with a Pepsi. Thank you.
August 22nd, 2012 at 12:48 pm
I am not a big burger person but I really enjoyed it. We have been back twice since. It is a little pricey but you get what you pay for and that’s good quality food. It is more then enough food for one person, the garlic mayo is delicious, loved the fries especially dipped in garlic mayo just wish there was more of them :P Definitely looking forward to trying more new flavours! Good luck Andrew! :)
August 22nd, 2012 at 2:25 pm
Thanks again racheal foR your feedback. I agree that feedback is good and we have used feedback to make a few changes to our system. Relish is a franchise and has to conform to the systems of the corporate office and that is the reason we cannot do homemade fries. Trust me i checked into it. I apologize for appearing to criticize bad comments however i do not do so to negate your comments just to explain why we do things the way we do as well as protect my investment. There are competitors out there who have been know to flame new restaurants. Thanks again for the advice. Like I mentioned we have used both negative and positive comments to change some things
August 22nd, 2012 at 3:32 pm
That should read “came from a BOWL that was sitting on a rolling cart…”
August 22nd, 2012 at 3:55 pm
Went to Relish for the 1st (and probably last time) on August 13th….Had the Cabo Diablo – there wasn’t much taste to the burger itself (which was luke warm at best), all I could taste was the overpowering relish! Another thing was that all the tables were dirty. I could understand if it was super busy, but there were only 2 other tables of people there. We had to clean off the table ourselves. Needless to say, we were less than impressed for the lack of service and subpar food we paid $40 for.
August 22nd, 2012 at 4:08 pm
Ate there two weeks ago. I was expecting more I guess. I do not know why people can’t throw some onion soup mix (something!)into their burgers.Had Le Nordique. No real flavour. The relish was soggy and most of it slid out of the bun. The onion rings were good but I’ve made better in my oven at home. The buns need to be more substantial to hold up to all of the toppings. The toppings need to stand out. The meat needs to be seasoned.
I’ve gladly paid more than 15-odd dollars for a stand-out burger. Also, asking for the tip before we’re served is sneaky. Until this place develops and settles I won’t be back.
August 22nd, 2012 at 4:35 pm
I was there a couple of weeks a ago and I have to say I will be back again the service was excalant, the food was nice and hot and tasted great love the different combanations of flavors on the burgers. Howerver I don’t agree with putting the tip option on the debit mechaine before you get you food and when you have to come up and get your food your self, after its cooked its all self-serve.
August 22nd, 2012 at 9:18 pm
Definitely not worth the money paid. The burger was good, but not 18 dollars good. It was worth no more then 12 dollars.The fries were absolutely pedestrian. They reminded me of the fries Wendys used to have, before they switched. Big, Boring and Limp. It was kind of a let down.
August 22nd, 2012 at 10:00 pm
My husband and I were really looking forward to Relish opening and we gave it a try after the crazy lineups settled down. We’ve been to lots of different burger joints in the US and Canada including everything from gourmet to a quick and easy fast food burger. Because Relish is gourmet, we had an expectation set before making our visit. We went later in the day and ordered the Big Texas and the LA is My Lady – just burgers, no sides.
First off, I was shocked at the price. We paid $24 for 2 burgers. Again, no sides, no drinks; just burgers. Asking for a tip before you’ve been served is a little backwards too… I did tip $2, but how would I even know if I want to leave a tip before I’ve had my meal? I’ve paid the same amount for burgers at a gourmet burger joint in Montreal that’s delicious, where I will go every time I visit there. So I expect something comparable at Relish.
After waiting for 30 minutes without hearing our names called, it was brought to our attention that our order got lost. Or given away to someone, or something. Instead of throwing in a side for our excessive wait, or even a $5 coupon for our next visit, all we got was a ‘sorry’.
Finally, we got our burgers and took them home to devour. At this point, I am ravenous. We both agreed that while the burgers did taste good, they weren’t anything special and certainly were not worth the price. I can grill my own burger and put toppings like avocado and goat cheese at home, for much cheaper, and it would taste just as good. We did enjoy the signature relish on the burgers, but we don’t feel like that’s enough to keep us coming back.
August 23rd, 2012 at 11:25 am
I agree with the many reviewers who were not impressed with their experience at Relish.
-too expensive for the lack of quality
-the beet relish was overpowering
-the seasoning on the burger is strange
-i ordered the diablo, which is supposed to be spicy, it wasn’t
-the fries were few and cold
most of this meal was left behind on the plate :(
August 23rd, 2012 at 10:02 pm
Good on ya, Roger! I believe I started to see your responses to reviews here just as I hit “Submit” on my comments. Thanks for taking on our concerns! underneath the criticism and complaining, we only want the place to be bestkind for everyone and a place of great value to go.
August 26th, 2012 at 9:27 pm
I have had Relish burgers once since it opened and have to say I’m not a huge burger girl but I was very impressed. At first I thought it was a bit pricey but when you think about what you’re paying at McD’s or other fast food joints, I didn’t mind paying extra for a freshly made burger. I loved the experience and the staff were very friendly and seemed like they were having a great time which adds to the whole atmosphere and mood of the restaurant. My only complaint would be the available seating but it is understandable in a small establishment. Roger – I was very surprised to read your postings here, it’s great to see an owner who clearly cares about the service being provided to your customers. Great job with the business, looking forward to having Relish again as well as visiting any future locations.
August 28th, 2012 at 12:34 pm
Had my first Relish Burger last night (finally!), it was fantastic! I had the veggie LA is my Lady and husband had the beef patty Simpleton. The veggie patty was really good, not too filling and a tiny bit spicy. I was told the Simpleton was really good too. We shared an order of fries but I’ll be getting my own order next time. Really good meal made with love by chef Dale! We will be back! :D
August 29th, 2012 at 12:53 pm
My boyfriend and I ate at Relish, I had been to the one is Saint John, New Brunswick and it was fantastic so I couldn’t wait to go, we were very disappointed, small portions but the worse thing was they mixed up the ingredients in both our burgers and some of mine was on his burger and his on mine, we couldn’t tell which burger was which and we ended up not liking either because they were both made incorrectly.
There were about ten people in the line up so we ddn’t have the patience to bring them back. :-(
August 30th, 2012 at 7:38 pm
I just wanted to give a shout out to Relish, I was there yesterday with 2 friends and the overall experience was awesome! You were greeted as soon as you walked in the door and through the entire order and pick up process treated awesome. I’ve had the burgers a few times before and I’ve yet to have a bad one. I feel the price you pay is very fair all things considered because everything is house made. I’m a cook and I understand the food cost that restaurants need to take into account. Keep up the good work guys, ill sure to be back again and bringing a new crowd with me!!
September 6th, 2012 at 8:45 pm
My girlfriend and I actually really liked Relish. We had a Big Texas and a Nordique with sweet potato fries and onion rings. We also had the goat cheese dipping sauce with the fries. We both thought these were the best burgers we had ever tasted.
We’ll definitely be back. We want to try all of the different kinds of burgers.
September 15th, 2012 at 6:35 pm
Yummy, but side dishes (fries, onion rings and sweet potato fries) were ridiculously over-salted. I can always add more if I need it, but I can’t take it off, and this was verging on inedible, especially on the onion rings, I don’t think I’ve ever had them salted before.
September 23rd, 2012 at 7:33 pm
went to relish today for the first time – best burger and fries i’ve ever had – hands down – the wife had the same opinion ( and we are food snobs-lol)
October 3rd, 2012 at 1:43 pm
My Husband and I were really excited to try Relish. We LOVE to eat-out and having the opportunity to try a new place in the city is a real treat! We went on a Saturday afternoon in August – very few people in the restaurant and we were greeted and served very quickly!! The decor immediately caught my eye, even as we were walking towards the place – love the color scheme! However, the place was in BAD need of a wash cloth and a little elbow grease. We had quite a hard time finding a clean table to sit at, even though the place was almost empty and there were 5 staff standing behind the counter! That kind of inefficiency bothered me right away – no need!!!
I cannot remember what we ordered, but we had two different burgers with poutines as our sides and two drinks. We were a little taken aback by the price – $37!! But when we finally got our order, it looked sooo delicious and we kinda forgot what we were shelling out for it!! We were very quickly disappointed….the Burger was extremely underwhelming (hates the bun – tasted old) and the poutines were FREEZING cold! (I don’t mean just luke warm, I mean COLD!) There was definitely a strange taste on the burger and I’m not sure if it’s the “purple stuff” or is it strange spices in the meat?! Either way, it’s not a BAD taste, but definitely not the level of delicious that I had expected! Anywho, I didn’t finish my burger so I handed it off to my Husband to finish and he was very surprised to find that, though we had ordered two very different burgers, MY burger tasted EXACTLY like his!!
We walked out kinda iffy on the whole experience…..I’m not going to say we will never go there again….but I definitely think this place can be done a whole LOT better!!! They’ve got a super location and a really neat idea that I think could do very well here! And nothing about Newfoundlanders being cheap (I disagree with that whole-heartedly) we are serious about our food and personally, I would be fine paying that $37 over and over, provided I leave with a full belly and a smile on my face!! :)
October 23rd, 2012 at 11:20 pm
Was so looking forward to our girls nite out to the icecaps game tonite.We always plan on having something to eat when we go out,so tonite we pick your burgers.Well the 20 bucks did not bother me,but i was so disappointed when i got my burger only to bite into it and it was raw.Needless to say i brought it back to you cook,he ask me if i would like another,but unfortually i could not try another.When i bite into raw meat i amturn off eating.But i think the biggest disappointment was that your staff never said sorry or even offered me my money back….so needless to say 20 bucks for frozen fries and a pepsi will not be getting me to return to your store.Only given a 1star because i have too…not because i think you deserve it.
October 24th, 2012 at 1:51 pm
I just recently had my third visit to Relish and once again had an awesome experience . Since I live out of town I only get in St.Johns occasionally
but Ihave found my restaurant of choice in Relish .This time I had the Simpleton with cole slaw as my side dish . I enjoyed every bite that I took .When I get back to the city in two months time I shall return to Relish.
November 2nd, 2012 at 1:35 pm
Tried Relish for the first time today and was totally let down. No parking!! Thirty-five dollars for two combos was a bit much. Burgers lacked taste and luke warm at best. Fries and onion rings were ok. Audio was so loud in building made it impossible discuss menu with cashier unless you were in each others face. Adding a dollar for onions when its one of the sides?? Can’t say I’ll visit again.
November 2nd, 2012 at 3:36 pm
Like a lot of other people here, I wasn’t terribly impressed. Thirty five dollars for a pair of mediocre-at-best burgers and fries/onion ring combos?
The menu options were creative but hardly haute-cuisine enough to justify the cost, and certainly nothing I couldn’t prepare better myself at home on the barbecue to feed ten for half the price that I paid for two.
There was a long lineup and a longer wait, and I was extremely surprised at the lack of wait staff, given how much it cost to eat there and the up-front expectation to tip at the register.
For that kind of money, I can think of a lot better places to eat and Relish definitely left a lot to be desired. That’ll be my one-and-only visit.
November 4th, 2012 at 7:19 pm
First time visit. Location doesn’t have much parking. Phone order was taken. Food was ready as promised. Had a great one with fries and two Nordiques; one with sweet fries and the other with onion rings. Onion rings could be better but burgers and fries were great. Very unique beet relish which I and my friends really enjoyed. My friends had visited several times and were happy with each trip. I will definitely return. No turnoffs for my $ 43.00. Keep up the good work!!
November 5th, 2012 at 4:56 pm
Unfortunately, I live out of the city so I’ve only got to try Relish once, but I definitely enjoyed my experience and burger when I was there! The Greek Tycoon was delicious and personally I loved the signature relish on the bottom! I had the “cool slaw” as my side, which was different but tastey! I definitely will try Relish again the next opportunity I have, all the options look so yummy it’s hard to pick out which one to try next!
November 5th, 2012 at 8:13 pm
My experience at Relish (I’ve been there three times) has been nothing but positive. The parking is the same as any restaurant downtown. As for the prices, the quality of the burgers are much better than restaurants of equal price (ex. Montana’s). You can tell the ingredients are fresh and the meat is higher quality. The staff was nothing but polite and friendly. Also, I like the fact that they offer gluten free options. I would recommend!
November 12th, 2012 at 2:40 am
First time this evening and everything was fantastic! I had the turkey burger Greek style with onion rings and tzatiki on the side with a side of slaw. Best idea ever! Everything was so flavorful and fresh. Can’t wait to go again!!
December 4th, 2012 at 3:16 pm
love the idea of a burger only joint, however ~$20.00 for burger, fries, and soda leaves me feeling that this place i overpriced. I dont mine paying extra for quality and something different. but for some reason I left this place feeling somewhat jipted.
my wifes burger was cold (meat patty and bun), and my burger’s patty seemed pretty thin for a place specializing in burgers. I know that the patty doesnt have to be huge for the burger to be good, but i felt like this resturant was skimping on beef. when Im paying 20$ plus for a burger combo i shouldnt feel that any skimping is taking place.
again, great idea/concept but with such high prices I dont see myself returning often.
I think if this place had combos in the area of 10-12$ it would be on wheels constantly.
Ive been to other burger joints in canada were the prices on avg are 9-12$ for a combo. great burgers and a reasonable price, 20$ a combo is just too much..
December 7th, 2012 at 1:37 pm
Me and my wife were looking forward to trying Relish for a while now. I had heard mixed reviews so we were waiting a while for them to get all the kinks worked out.
I liked the atmosphere and feel of the place. The music was a good volume, the place seemed clean and service was friendly.
Our burgers were okay but not great. They were served luke warm, bordering on cool. I feel the price would have been about right if the burgers were what I had been expecting. A burger should center around the ground beef but the taste of the patty was completely lost amongst the toppings and I found it difficult to discern any meat flavour at all.
The portion size of the sides were pretty large however I was very disappointed that the french fries were fast food quality frozen french fries. Onion rings were run of the mill. With a gourmet burger I expect gourmet sides.
I don’t mind the price they are charging, however, when you charge that much people will expect you to deliver an exceptional burger. There are much better burgers to be had in St. John’s for a similar price (The Club, Blue on Water, Aqua for example).
I will probably try Relish again but I would skip the sides all together and maybe try a something with less toppings or a turkey patty on my burger.
December 12th, 2012 at 7:26 pm
Ate there once, too much money for very little quality. Would never recommend or revisit. Between this place and the poutine shop it has been a disappointing year for franchises in the downtown. Price the burger combo between 10-12 dollars and you might remain in business. Otherwise this location will be open for lease within 2 years.
December 15th, 2012 at 2:49 pm
Obviously, they have fixed some things. We had big burgers, lots of sweet potato fries. All tasted fine. Atmosphere and details like ketchup packets, cola coolers, etc. lessen the experience. And no – I don’t want my full name shouted out when my food is ready. All in all not good enough for the price, but could be with more tweaking. Won’t say never again, but not going to rush back.
January 22nd, 2013 at 1:18 pm
Totally agree with you on the prices. I like the burgers here, but the price point is too high for the burger thet you get. If they lowered the cost of the combos by even $2, they would get a lot more business at lunch, IMO. I’ll stick to Aqua if I want to pay that much for a delicious burger.
January 22nd, 2013 at 2:27 pm
Why does everything have to be a “price point” these days? Why can’t it just be a “price?”
January 22nd, 2013 at 2:51 pm
Good point. I’ve wondered that too. I’d blame The Apprentice.
February 3rd, 2013 at 8:25 pm
Been here 3 times now and have been underwhelmed each time. I’ve tried 3 different burgers and there’s just no zing.
There are better burgers in St. John’s for less money.
April 1st, 2013 at 11:32 am
I’d vote 0 if I could.
Showed up with inlaws. 4 orders for over $70.
Waited 30 minutes, realized everyone else was being served. I asked how long until ours was ready, they said ’2-3 minutes’.
Waited ANOTHER 30 minutes, realized everyone was eating but us. Went to ask where our food was, they said there wasn’t one and argued with us we never ordered DESPITE the fact we were sitting there and I chatted with the cashier.
Demanded our money back, tried to short change us. Never bothered to offer us anything to make up for it other than a lousy $2 off next visit.
Worst service I’ve ever had. Inlaws were in town and it was a sour note on their visit.
We went to Montanas and after they heard about our visit they went out of their way to brighten our day. Can’t thank them enough after what Relish Burger put us through.
April 2nd, 2013 at 3:51 pm
Ate at Relish recently. Burgers were good, however the were served with kettle chips that were cold and soggy. The restaurant was also cold. When ordering $20 burger combos, one would expect more. Poor quality, with very little value for your money.
April 3rd, 2013 at 12:21 am
Tried Relish for the first time this evening. The veggie patty was very tasty, and the Harvest Jazz combination was good. Was looking forward to trying the slaw a friend had recommended, but they were out of it at the time. The fries, like others have said, were not good. The peppercorn gravy, however, was great.
The service was excellent.
I’ll probably try a different burger again but will pass on the combo.
April 7th, 2013 at 2:12 pm
I ate at Relish on Friday and I was anything but impressed! I was there for the first time shortly after they opened; I found the food only so-so, but very overpriced. I decided to give Relish a second chance on Friday and I will not be back. The food was mediocre at best, specifically the burger was bland and the poutine was extremely salty. The wait time was also unacceptable. I went during my lunch break and I waited over 40 minutes for my order; it was lunch time but it wasn’t extremely busy. The worst thing is I comment on their FB about my issue and my comment was deleted and I was never contacted by a manger. IMHO, Relish shows total disregard for their customers.
In summary, the food is mediocre and overpriced, the wait time was unacceptable and the managers/ owners show total disregard for the customers.
April 11th, 2013 at 9:58 pm
Well, I tried Relish and I absolutely loved it! Loved everything about it, but my favorite was the poutine! Just delicious! It was all delicious! I can’t wait to go back!!!
April 27th, 2013 at 6:43 pm
UPDATE – after a week, the owner of Relish contacted and gave me the manager’s contact information.
May 2nd, 2013 at 1:29 pm
Went to Relish last week. Had a fantastic meal. My wife and I throughly enjoyed our burgers and sides, the staff were super freindly and we enjoyed the atmosphere. Lack of parking was a little bit of a concern but thats to be expected downtown. I thought the price was fair and I feel if i can feed myself with something so delicious for under 20 bucks….its worth it. Great job!
May 30th, 2013 at 11:02 pm
dear roger andrews,
I just want to congratulate you on serving 400 people a day, I didnt realize that many people in st. Johns are willing to pay 20$ or more for a mediocre burger.
Today I was really really looking forward to having a deadly burger, so I indulged in your prices and I seriously regret not going to Wendy’s. I regret it so much I went looking for an outlet to vent.
And its not all about the price, I dont mind paying for things if I feel like I am getting the value. You cant fool your customers, you cant convince me that your prices are justified. There are fancier restaurants with double the staff and double the menu options and their prices are much lower. To spend 20$ on one meal, you should be able to get service at your table, good atmosphere (not like a cafeteria), and be blown away by the ingredients. And maybe have a liquor license.
June 16th, 2013 at 7:37 pm
Just got back from Relish and was totally delighted…again. I had the Nordique, husband and kids had different kinds. Everybody loved the food and said it was quite a feed. I notice some people have complained about the price..but it certainly is not far off from what you pay for getting combos at fast food joints. The only think I would like is if the music was a bit lower….almost didn’t hear when they called out our name. ….Also, like to add that each time the staff have been spectacular. I’ve have been at fast food ‘restaurants’ when the servers have been down right rude. I worked in restaurants as a teen and really appreciate that kind of service…Bravo!
June 17th, 2013 at 1:30 pm
The first time we went we were unimpressed. There was nothing spectacular about the burgers, we ordered fry dip and didn’t get it, asked for no beet relish and ended up with it, and the sweet potato fries were cold. That visit was within 1-2 weeks of their opening so we figured they were just working the kinks out and agreed we’d try it again sometime. Almost a year later the Hubby decided that for Father’s Day he wanted to give it another go and again, we left unimpressed and will likely not be back anytime soon. $50 for three combos that we agreed were ‘edible but nothing special’. 6.99 for a kids mini-simpleton and the drink wasn’t included.
However, the wait wasn’t long and the staff were friendly but the food is just ‘okay’.
July 14th, 2013 at 11:15 pm
Tried Relish for the first time today and was met with a huge disappointment. Food was quite over priced, nearly $60 for lunch for 3 people. I’m not opposed to spending more for good food, but the element of quality was definitely lacking. We had a turkey, a beef, and a veggie between the three of us. While the veggie patty was tasty, it didn’t hold together, and the meat patties were quite thin, overly greasy and nothing special. We also tried the curry mayo with the sweet potato fries, and this dip had no flavour at all and was an odd texture – our mention of this concern with staff was rudely received. We will not be returning, and wouldn’t recommend it to anyone.
Sorry to say, but I don’t see this establishment lasting long once ‘The Works’ burgers opens down on George Street – their menu and quality puts Relish to shame.
September 27th, 2013 at 8:24 pm
My wife and I live out of town and have missed trying Relish a number of times on our trips to St. John’s. Finally had a chance a while back and it was very much worth the wait. Really enjoyed the quality of the burgers and thought they were very tasty. My wife especially liked the fact there was a vegetarian option. Would certainly recommend it to anyone and will be going back again soon! Keep up the good work!