The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site

Portobello’s Restaurant

  • 2.72.72.72.72.7
25 reviews (write your own)

115 Duckworth Street

579-7050

Go back to the restaurant list
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.

25 Reader Reviews of Portobello’s Restaurant

(12 positive, 11 negative)
  1. avatar
    Jason Hajek Says:

    best spot in town

  2. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Mary Dwyer Says:

    Beautiful decor.. FABULOUS VIEW
    I believe we had the best table in the place
    We dined on Saturday night, the food was superb.
    However the service as prompt as it was … we did feel very rushed !!!
    I do not believe that someone should in any way feel rushed toward the end of their meal. It makes one feel that “hurry up …get out we have others waiting for the table”
    But having said that we will be back!!!

  3. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Michelle Says:

    At best, Portobellos was a high-end fast food restaurant. The decor was cheap looking and had no fluidity or atmosphere. The open staircase was a conversation piece as you could see straight up the ladie’s skirts. Biancas and Atlantica far exceeded Portobellos. There simply was no comparision. Other patrons also complained the same night we were there. I would never recommend this restaurant. The view was ok but nothing exceptional.

  4. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Scott Says:

    This place has finally been put to good use. I didn’t know what to expect since last time I was there, it was to buy a snack pack. The restaurant is adequately decorated but I’d like to see more interesting original local art on the walls. But I was not there to look at art. The food was very good. I had the smoked chicken penne. Good portions too. The server was a little abrupt, but did her job. Average prices for good food.

  5. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Alice Says:

    I went there for my birthday a couple of weeks ago. I really enjoyed what I ordered and the restaurant itself was very visually appealing. I think the service could have been a little better but overall a decent experience.

  6. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Byron Jones Says:

    Went on a Thursday evening. Decor was nicely balanced and the view was a perfect view of St. Johns Harbour, it is not a city view so I did not expect to see one.

    We had the Sirloin steak with potatoes. it was the most flavourable meal I have eated in a while. I would definately recomend this meal.

    On the down side, the place was FREEZING (and I am a man) I felt bad for my beautiful lady. We asked to turn the heat up a bit but I don’t think that happened. I did feel warm for about 10 mins so if he did turn up the heat someone with a hot flash quickly put an end to our comfort.

    The service was reasonable but not award winning. We were seated beside the bar and that was a little noisy and distracting but all in all it was a wonderful dinner.

    We will be back.

  7. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    g Says:

    I went to Portobellos recently to celebrate a birthday. Decor was nice, simple albeit. We ordered two appetizers to share; the thai shrimp, and the goats cheese. The shrimp were delicious, but the goats cheese was lacking excitement, along with crostini that were stale. For my main, I ordered the Filet Mignon. Upon receiving it, it was overcooked and unappealing. I sent it back, and then waited no less than 30 minutes before a new one arrived. My company was already finished! That said, a member in our party had the Chicken Roulade, and it was delicious. Our server was really apologetic, which was nice. However, when we got the bill I was charged for my steak. It is my belief that at a “Fine Dining” establishment, if your order is wrong, and then takes a long time to be replaced, you shouldn’t have to pay for it. All in all, it was an okay experience, but nothing that stands out in my mind. Would I recommend Portobellos? Based on my experience, I don’t think so.

  8. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Georgie Says:

    WOW! OVERPRICED! I have eaten at a lot of high end restaurants in this city, but this one misses the mark. No one took my coat, no one filled up my water, had to ask for a dessert menu. When you pay $100 for a meal (three course), this is unacceptable. Not to mention, decor is lacking – did not like looking into the kitchen on arrival. Food was average – tasty but lacking imagination. This place is no comparison for Aqua, 7, Gypsy Tea Room or Bianca’s.
    When you charge high end prices, high end service and food should follow!

  9. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Sharon Says:

    I was recently at this restaurant and was very diasppointed with the service and the food.Celebrating two special occasions we decided to try Portobellos. We waited two hours for our main course. One of the meals was filet mignon which was supposed to be medium rare however the blood was flowing out on to the plate. We were not charged for it however it did spoil the evening. We were also no given a dessert menu so I cannot comment on that aspect. I noticed other tables were given wet towels once they were finished….our party of 9 were only given the bill. I would not recommend this restaurant.

  10. avatar
    Carol & Thomas Says:

    Food was OK , not great, just Ok. Steak was undercooked and cold. The service was slow and really bad. Sat at a table in the bar area not even in the main dinning area. This area is a walkthrough for the servers and a waiting area for customers. Could not hear a word my partner said to me over the staff talking at the bar and the sounds of a busy bar. One of the waiters actually laid his rear end on my table while pushing bar stools back to the bar and joking with the bar staff!

    It was 1 hour and 20 minutes before we saw any food. We asked 3 times were the food was and kept being told ” 1 Minute” We were offered a new table during our entree but at that point our next movement was out the door!

    In an attempt to make up for the really bad service they did not charge us for the wine but a evening out to celebrate a special event was ruined

    There simply should not be a table in this location. Having worked in a restaurant during college I understand ever table is income however this table is a money loser!

    Simply put will not return!

  11. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    George R. Says:

    I have dined at this restaurant at least once a month since it opened at the old location in 2007. It is far and away the most personable and best valued restaurant in the city. The food is fantastic. The chef there only uses fresh ingredients and the service is always top notch. And the view, what can I say it doesn’t get any better.No, I agree the presetation is not the artistic plates that you receive at other restaurants but these guys never set out to do this in the first place. The food is always neatly presented and the portions are substantial for the value. There are no dessert menus at Portobello’s the server always gives them to you verbally. When my wife and I dine out there is no other place.

  12. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Caloo Says:

    My wife and me have been there some days ago for lunch and have been truly satisfied. First of all, the prices for lunch are not overpriced, then the courses was fine, scallops in a fence of crusty asparagus was cooked at perfection. As entrées we choosed each one a different fish, again it was fine. A french white wine called “Ardeche” added to our delight.
    Too bad that the view on the harbour includes at foreground the waste coming from the off-shore activity; not inviting but not plainly the resto’s fault

  13. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    tom Says:

    My girl friend and i eat there about 3 weeks ago,, K F C when it was there had classier staff and least they smiled ,,the food was ok but tasted much better in the city the price was a little high so i though and as one person on here i 2 felt rushed ,,think i was still chewing the steak when i payed the bill,,, Girl’s if you want to make good tips you have to give good servive if not go to macdonalds..

  14. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    4Real Foodie Says:

    I have eaten here a total of 5 times and have to say,I was not overly impressed on eother visit. Why did I return so many times you might ask? I always give restauarants a second chance,sometimes a third,the other times I just could not get parking anywhere else and was in a rush. My last visit was the worst. We (a table of two) had the misfortune of sitting next to a party of 20.Big tables like these suck the life out of the wait staff and the kitchen,so guess who has to suffer. We ordered a salad that arrived without dressing,seafood crepes that arrived without the cream sauce. Found a hair in the crepes,found a hair in creme brulee. Service was less than adequate (and I really do not expect too much,especially for lunch service). I had high hopes for this place,but that’s what happens when you get too big too fast. Portobello’s will never be what The Cellar is: a fine dining restaurant. I usually don’t care to much about the decor,but will say,the bathrooms are really nice and that tacky pink fountain in the foyer needs to go-it looks like a prop from an Ed Wood movie.

  15. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    scotman Says:

    we’ve been to portobellos several times since they relaocated, and once prior, and each experience has been varied. The food itself is consistently good or great. Mains & specials both were well prepared and appetizers not too large. However, the service has been very inconsistent, on a single occasion the server was excellent,- helpful in menu choices, quick checks during the meal for drink refills etc, on the others, not so much. The latest visit required flagging our server down to get a cocktail, and then a 15 minute wait to actually get it, minimal revisits, with the evening ending with a 30 minute wait for the check. I realize many servers struggle to balance frequent visits with being too interrupting, but when the table is full of empty glasses and plateware, an interruption is called for. It may take a while for this place to hit it\’s stride, in the meantime, be prepared that the overall experience may not hit the mark. Now after the service “rant” the food was great, the maple chicken was a hit with all that tried it, the cajun steak was bang on, and the “firtini” is recommended. Overall rating – food: solid 4, service; struggling 2, average 3.

  16. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Margaret Says:

    Gosh, I have read the above reviews and have to wonder if these people are really dining at the same Portobello’s that I’ve experienced! I find everything about the restaurant superb! In a total of five visits, I’ve had nothing but excellent service and have always been very impressed with the food! It is now my choice of restaurant for any special event and where I take visitors.

  17. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    megn Says:

    Visited Portobello’s for the first time on a Saturday night. I had heard rave reviews and was really looking forward to my meal. Unfortunately I was disappointed in the experience. The hostess was rude when we arrived. Our waitress was friendly but somewhat inept. She couldn’t remember our orders, one of our party received the wrong side dish, and she messed up the bills in the end. The person who brought out the meals confused the order and did not ask who had which dish, so we had to switch them ourselves and the plates were extremely hot.
    The view and decor of Portobello’s were lovely but the atmosphere left much to be desired. There were several very loud groups in the dining room, which made conversation at my table very difficult. A room divider or something would be a good idea. Also, there was a strong draft coming from the vents in the ceiling and I was freezing cold the whole time. And it wasn’t just my seat – this affected the entire table of 6.
    As for the food, my chicken dish was very good although I wasn’t keen on the side dish. For dessert I had banana bread pudding which was rubbery and had tough slices of banana in it. The other desserts, especially the creme brulee, looked fantastic.
    I will return to Portobello’s when it is less busy, but for that price tag I would rather eat at one of the many superior restaurants in St. John’s.

  18. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Rob Says:

    Our party of six arrived at Portobellows at 7:00 PM on a Saturday evening recently. We had made the reservation on the previous Tuesday. It was our first time there and we were walked through the main dining room to a smaller room which seemed to be at the end of the restaurant. When we entered there were 5 tables and the room was empty. We were seated at a window table and were quite pleased with the view. The food served including appetizers, and entre were quite good.
    However our whole evening was spolied whtn a party of about 20 people came into the room to sit a large table that had been prepared for a large group. This group of 20 was unbelievably loud, banging thier feet on the floor, shouting from one end of their table to ther other, and banging their chairs around. They were obviously there for a party and had no concern for the other 4 groups who were quietly dining at other tables. Each of the couples at our table complained to the head waiter but we received no support or help from him. We were told that they had been partying in the downtown area since 6:00 PM and they were celebrating.
    Never have I heard such a “racket” in a fine dining restaurant. We literally could not be heard by the person sitting next to us. The resuaurant made no attempt to ask these patrons to keep their voices dolwn at all. We were basically left to feel that it was our problem.
    When asked about tea/coffee etc, we obviously had none, and left as quickly as possible – by that tinme our ears were “ringing”.
    I have never heard such a noise even in a bar or fast food restaurant.
    The moral of the story is NEVER let them sit you in that small room at the end of the restaurant unless they can guarantee you that it will not be used a “party room” during you stay. We had been given no warning and no reason to expect anything diffrent in that room than in the main restrarurant. For this reason we will not return.

  19. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    East End Boy Says:

    Truly been hit or miss for me; food is quite good, but service is never consistent. Dined(had appetizers, entrees with a good bottle of wine and cocktails and dessert)with 6 guests over the summer and we all felt that, for the money we spent, the experience wasn’t worth it. *Also, I was surprised the only coffee option is filter-drip coffee(cheap-tasting at that…) (no espresso, cappuccino etc) ~ for a restaurant claiming to be somewhat high-calibre, one wouldn’t expect a server to respond “oh, no, we don’t have anything like that” when a customer requests a cappuccino.

  20. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    katherine Says:

    I hate to agree with the bad reviews, but alot of this is true. The food was very tasty, that is for sure. But the service, well..First we arrived and waited in an empty foyer for about 20 mins, when the lady arrived she was not even smiling, never asked to take our coats. We walked up a creepy staircase that was open, the men at the bottom could see right up our skirts.. When seated a girl came out in a blue top, it did not even look like she was staff, nothing to set her aside from anyone. The back room we had was very cold and loud, could not heard a word she said, when I asked her could she please repeat the specials she seemed almost mad. When the food did come it was very tasty, I admit that. I just like kind, friendly service, and this restaurant lacks that in many many areas. Sorry.

  21. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    LA Says:

    I’ve eaten here twice. The first time wasn’t a wonderful experience. The view and atmosphere are lovely, the service was excellent, but the food wasn’t great. My husband and I both loved our appetizer and dessert, but our entrees were very disappointing. One was completely overcooked, the other undercooked. I had written the restaurant and praised them were I saw fit, but also said how I expected more accuracy in cooking when paying for a $200 meal (tip incl.). The owner responded to my email very promptly and invited my husband and I back for a dinner completely on them. I thought this was above and beyond, and as I stated in my original email to them I wasn’t looking for anything complimentary. But he said he wanted to prove to us that that isn’t the normal way things are there. We went back for our second meal there last weekend. Everything was wonderful, food and service included. My overall opinion on this restaurant was that customer service is where they absolutely excel. The view is beautiful. I do however think that the food is overpriced. I don’t mind paying that kind of money for a meal, but I expect it to be pretty fantastic, and not on par with something that I could go to Rumplestiltskins and get for 1/3 the price (and they also have a fabulous view).

  22. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    PSLV Says:

    AFter a terrible first experience (overcooked food, beginner service) my boyfriend and I decided to give this a second try. Some friends of our has pleasant experiences and figured, perhaps we just didn’t experience their “A game” the first time. It took no less than 2 minutes for the disappointment as while being taken to our table, the host / owner of the restaurant stopped to talk to another couple that were coming down the stairs, while we awkwardly stood by waiting for the conversation to end (at least 3-4 mins) while this may not seem like a long time, it is when you are just standing there waiting. We were seated, about 10 minutes later our “server” came and asked us for drinks, we ordered wine and our entrees. The food was good, but was brought to us by someone other than our server, who was able to locate him so that we could have another glass of wine. He did not ask how anything was until the meals were about complete. I had to flag down another server to ask for the bill, no desserts or coffee were offered until after that, and another server brought the debit / credit machine. The prices at Portobellos are as high as any other fine dining restaurant, but to be honest, the server I had at Cora’s was better. I will not be returning, or recommending this restaurant to anyone, and will suggest locations such as Raymond’s, Basho or Atlantica for a fine dining experience, with “experienced and friendly staff”

  23. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Nicole Says:

    I ate there last weekend and it was not that great. It IS a beautiful view but the service is lacking; from the person who greeted us and from our waitress. It just wasn’t up to par with other fine dining establishments and it does cost just as much. The food was ok, nothing spectacular and I did feel like it was salty and oily, especially the vegetables. I think the food and service has gone downhill here since it opened even though the prices have gone up. The first few times I ate there, it was fantastic as was the service but this time, definitely lacking.

  24. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Fine Eats? Says:

    Totally agree, the tacky pink fountain is hideous.

  25. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    dee56 Says:

    Service was okay; waitresses were wearing some of the shortest, tightest mini-skirts I have seen… it did not look classy. Food was mediocre; I ate hardly any of my salmon, the veg was okay, but hardly any on the plate.. Cod tongues were poor. salad so-so. The steep stairs were spooky to the women who were wearing heels. I was impressed with the cleanliness of the washroom… I had to go twice. and each time it had been freshly cleaned, with snowy white towels. Desert was good, but meagre. All in all I expected more for the high price that we paid…

You can write a review right away below or you can log in here. (New user? Sign up here!)


    • Don't have an account? . Takes just a minute or two.

  • Leave a Review