Pi
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice.
More detailed terms here.
August 14th, 2008 at 9:53 am
Oh, yum. Yum, yum, yum.
The pizza dough at Pi is so soft and stretchy and chewy, with magical little crispy spots, that they could put a rubber boot on it and still have a better-than-average pizza on your plate.
Luckily, they’ve left the boots in the closet and have chosen to put artichokes, roasted almonds, red onion and pear compote, Gouda cheese and fennel bulbs instead.
They even have decent, casein-free vegan cheese if you need it.
I’m salivating just thinking about it.
September 1st, 2008 at 6:02 pm
Pizza and me were about to call it quits in this town (Venice aside) but then Pi came around. I’d eaten at Giovanni’s when it was open, and the decor and atmosphere was a distraction to the pizza, which was high quality, with high quality ingredients. How do you make such good pizza and have no idea how to dress a place to enjoy it? It’s part of the deal. And Pi knows this…..
Between the pizza and the environment of the restaurant, it’s a one-two punch of delight. Thin crust pizza. Delicate, flavorful toppings. Lots of surface area. This with a bottle of Storm raspberry wheat, a candle on your table, and a date, is basically an orgasm waiting to happen.
September 26th, 2008 at 2:20 am
As someone who was on the Executive Council for a Math Society, I can assure you that Mathematicians approve of this place.
The Pizza is amazing. As you would expect it’s a bit more pricey than anything the sloppy slices you’ll get on George Street, but it’s well worth the extra dough (yeah, yeah).
My friend is a Caesar Salad fiend and she thinks they have the best in town.
January 17th, 2009 at 2:29 pm
Pi is my favourite!! I love all the toppings options :) It is a bit pricey, but is definitely worth it. My husband and I will go there when we want to have a nice dinner date. You can’t say that for many other pizza places.
January 21st, 2009 at 10:19 pm
Not only the best pizza I’ve ever had, but maybe the best meal I’ve ever ate. Beautiful decor and great service! I’ve been telling all my friends to try it!
June 20th, 2009 at 2:04 am
This place was a real godsend on our trip home last year. We’d just discovered that our 12 year was getting migraines from milk products. We figured eating at a pizza place just wouldn’t work. A friend found this place, and it was a delight. Our daughter loved her own pizza, and everyone else loved theirs as well. We ended up there three times on the two week trip, and everyone was happy. She also loved the vegan fudge cake. WONDERFUL! Highly recommended. As a mathematician, the theme just added to the fun.
June 20th, 2009 at 9:13 pm
I ate at Pi twice. Where’s the sauce?! They were the driest pizzas I’ve ever had! I’m all for fresh ingredients but I need some sauce to lube them on the way down.
June 25th, 2009 at 9:44 pm
Awesome Pizza. The staff pick’s are sooo damn good they should be on the menu. also try the tortellini hayden and artichoke cream…mmmmm.
July 22nd, 2009 at 6:59 pm
A great spot to go for pizza if you’re looking for something a little more fancier/classier/interesting than pizza hut. Really cool decor and vibe in the restaurant, there was even a live musician playing some mellow instrumental guitar. Lots of different types of pizzas, not like you would find elsewhere. My only complaints were I found it a bit pricey and it was a little cold in there when I went (it was in February, so perhaps to be expected!)
July 25th, 2009 at 4:22 pm
great pizza, but i find the toppings are a bit sparse and there isn’t enough sauce. i like the unique pizza types. if they stepped up the toppings, they’d be an extraordinary pizza joint.
July 27th, 2009 at 6:53 pm
Such a great little spot. Very Kitchy. Pizza is amazingly good. Huge list of toppings and almost infinite combinations. Dinner for two plus appetizer, dessert, wine and coffee will run about 60.00 plus tip. Not bad – we came home with two half pizzas!
August 9th, 2009 at 12:11 am
I went there because of all the positive reviews here on The Scope, I didn’t think it was anything special. Maybe I’m not into thin crust pizza, but I’d rather just get a pizza from Pizza Delight or somewhere else in town. The restaurant as a whole was pretty meh for me, from the smediocre service to the bleh decor and atmosphere to the location.
September 2nd, 2009 at 11:38 am
I love the pizza, but my absolute favorite is the pasta carbonera (even though it too is a bit pricey). This is the best pasta dish I’ve ever found dudes. Comes with awesome homemade garlic bread, too.
October 4th, 2009 at 1:28 pm
OK FOOD, WORK ON THE CUSTOMER SERVICE
I enjoy Pi but find it’s going a bit downhill in quality both food-wise and ambiance-wise. The owner is sweet but always looked frazzled, put out and upset and sometimes doesn’t realize she makes customers feel like they’re being an inconvenience to her. She seems too overworked to be able to coherently deal with the public. Leave the customer part to the serving staff – they are great with people and really make the place. Decor is great. I’ve brought 15-20 people there in groups over the summer but will be avoiding it a while until the quality comes back up and the vibe less frantic. The crusts have been too dry (often burnt) and toppings too sparse over the last couple of months – I go there 2 sometimes 3 times a week, so can see the sliding downwards. I’ll spend my money and time elsewhere this fall until I see some improvement.
December 5th, 2009 at 5:37 pm
First of all, the service at Pi was horrible. We had a reservation and still had to wait twenty minutes for a table. The waitress didn’t come take our orders for another twenty minutes after we were seated, even though we already looked at the menus. After waiting forever for the food, we had to wait yet again for the waitress to come back to the front of the restaurant to give us the bill so we could finally leave.
I can’t say anything for the food. I was told by multiple people that Pi had gluten free pizza, but when asked they said they did offer gluten free dough before, but not anymore. Everyone with me said the pizza they had was good, and it smelled good too, but I had to eat a badly made salad because there wasn’t anything else on the menu without gluten. The waitress even got my order wrong, but I didn’t want to wait any longer so I ate around the crap they put in it.
Overall it was a pretty horrible experience, the only thing saving the night was the company.
January 19th, 2010 at 5:06 pm
AMAZING pizza! One of the funnest restaurant experiences I’ve had in a while- trying to choose toppings for your pizza is a serious challenge, as there are so many good ones to pick from. Everything is so fresh and yummy. The dessert was unreal too- gingerbread cake with a rum topping. My only complaint would be that it is definately pricey, but hell, totally worth it if your in the mood to have a real pizza for once.
January 19th, 2010 at 8:09 pm
I wish I had more money so that I could eat there every night!!
The pizza is amazing and the service is outstanding. I love the atmosphere and the decor. If you go here you are not going to a pizza joint, you are going to an upperclass restaurant.
Two thumbs way up!! Everyone should go check out this place!
February 10th, 2010 at 3:18 pm
both the food and service is always great!
February 22nd, 2010 at 6:22 pm
Pi does not = 3.14159265358979…
Pi = love.
(Credit to Fur Packed Action for pi to 14 decimal places)
March 7th, 2010 at 5:08 pm
Lovely decor, great atmosphere, and friendly staff. I went twice shortly after it first opened and found the pizza tasteless.I am a person who would have gourmet pizza any day before Pizza Hut, but I was disappointed the pizza didn’t have more flavor. When you go ask for extra topping or cheese or sauce.
Thought I’d give it a second chance and went again, ordered a different pizza and had the same experience. My friend’s milk separated in her glass (kind of worrying), it was warm day, but even so…
I’d say try it though and make your own opinion.
March 18th, 2010 at 11:03 am
Gourmet Pizzas to die for… well worth the money, high quality food. Have been back several times.
April 3rd, 2010 at 3:08 am
A couple of my friends and i have made it a friday evening tradition to go out to dinner, a few months ago we were introduced to Pi, and havnt gone anywhere else since. The food is absolutely amazing!! we normally have the same waitress and somehow in the hustle and bustle, she remembers our favorite pizza, that one of us orders a caesar salad as an appetizer, and our beer preference. that to me is wonderful service, and when the food on my table is just as wonderful i am sold.
April 25th, 2010 at 11:30 pm
Horrible pizza, horrible service. The owner was very unpleasant, when we came in she said “Do you have a reservation?”, I said no, she said “Oh, well you’re lucky then today” in a very snotty tone.
Turns out we weren’t so lucky. Wearing pajamas and in a very bad mood, she came back 10 minutes later to take our orders. Turns out she doesn’t believe in soft drinks (?), but they still had Coke and a few others that I didn’t like. Tried a lemon-lime punch of some sort, it was awful. Asked for water, she madly brought a very small glass and grunted as we thanked her.
The pizza took forever to come, and it was just as well if it didn’t come at all. It was extremely thin, dry, had no taste whatsoever, was burned on the top and not cooked enough on the bottom (pure white on the bottom with a doughy taste). It was very expensive and probably the worst pizza I have ever had.
I will never be coming back to Pi.
August 26th, 2010 at 1:14 pm
This colourful and quirky spot has become one of my favourite places when I want something tasty and fresh. The mediterranean salad is excellent and is a nicely sized individual portion. It’s served with a tasty house-made dressing. The Pizzas are thin and delicious. If you are looking for thick, cheese-murdered pizzas, Pi is not for you. The ingredients are unique, fresh and creatively put together. Prime colours is my favourite with chicken, fresh mushrooms, hot peppers and Parmensan. I also love the Mushroom crostini which is a meal in itself.
They also have a broad selection of home made desserts. I have usually been too full to try them.
The decor is young, bright and artistic. It’s clean, comfortable and spacious.
The service has been mostly very good but occasionally there is one female host who acts like she’s disappointed you showed up. I have noticed this on 2 ooccasions and it sticks with me because it’s the same gal.
Besides Miss Grumpy-pants, the food is excellent, the service has been prompt and helpful and the overall experience keeps me going back time and again. The price is fantastic for fresh quality food.
This is a great spot for a romantic date or well-suited to a family dinner.
Check it out! http://www.gourmetpi.com/
September 25th, 2010 at 8:00 pm
Great food. Crazy toppings. I try to eat gluten free and they have a rice flower crust that’s amazing. Great place to eat.
October 4th, 2010 at 2:59 am
The most over-rated and self-important resto in the city.Taste has been forgotten for cute topping combo’s and the service is shit.Not to mention everything being wildly over-priced.
Too bad Folly’s closing because they have better pizza and staff.Maybe Piatto’s will put a good scare into the Pi crowd and things will change,but if Piatto does it better I won’t feel guilty for never going to Pi again.
oh.almost forgot.I know what the employee’s discount is and it only left me with a deeper impression that Pi’s customers are being gouged big-time.
October 7th, 2010 at 7:08 pm
I was a big supporter of Pi early on, but feel the quality has gone far downhill. There is so much salt in there that I awake in the middle of the night gasping for water. And there are seasonings used in great doses (thyme?) that have no place on a pizza. Disappointing. I am looking forward to Piatto opening to see if a better pizza is on offer.
October 12th, 2010 at 2:50 pm
Agree with some comments here. Rave reviews as the best pizza in the city. I have had frozen pizza that tasted better. The biggest thing I found were the staff were OK. They didn’t do anything to really sell the pizza or make the experience. But the pizza itself was way to thin, and they hardly put any toppings on the pizza. For the price you pay it’s not worth it. Add some more toppings. Smile once an awhile. If your going to charge 27 bucks for pizza have some toppings.
October 14th, 2010 at 5:22 pm
I have to disagree with some of the people who say the pizza is awful. I’ve been eating there since it was Giovanni’s and I love, love, love their food.
They have a lot of vegan/vegetarian options and TON of topping options.You also get a choice of pizza base. My personal favourite pizza there is the cheese pizza with crushed walnuts and cherry tomatoes! Yum!
The service can take a little while sometimes, and the pizza is best when you eat it there (not take-out, it can get soggy). It is a bit pricey, but if you want a unique pizza (and in my opinion the best in the city) give it a try!
Also, for dessert, their Kaluha Fudge cake is to DIE for!
December 16th, 2010 at 9:58 pm
Andrew I have to agree in terms of the comments about the owner. I recall when she started with Giovanni Caboto’s – she seemed friendly and upbeat, but in my only interactions with her in the past few years she seems like a real grump. Maybe she’s great at making pizzas, and if so she should stick to that and stop serving customers, because she’s harming her business. I’m a long time customer, but it’s really hard to keep liking a place if you don’t feel welcome or appreciated as a customer.
February 23rd, 2011 at 9:56 pm
Pi pizzeria was a delight when it first opened. The very first time was great, pizza was delicious, and that was the only time it ever happened.
Once we were seated at the table with dirty dishes and while waiting to be brought water and menus we realized that everyone else was waiting on something – getting their water, food, bill, or their tables cleaned up. After about 20 minutes of waiting for the waitress to come to us, we observed enough and went to Sun Sushi across the street.
Gave it another chance- this time service wasn’t so slow, because there was only one more table besides us. But our romantic night was not so romantic, as it was spoiled by waitress who was wearing extremely loud high heels and doused herself in perfume that made it hard to enjoy our food. I also watched the waitress cut my bread and place it with her unwashed hands on our serving plate, right after she dealt with cash.
Service is always so slow, as there is always only one waitress. Seems that the owner tries to save money on having only one person on the floor.
We decided to give one last chance and ordered for take-out. Well, it seems they only use half of the ingredients if pizza is to go out. We ordered for take out twice and it’s always the same story- skimping on ingredients!
If you walk into the place and there is no one there, you will most likely get normal service and your pizza will be good. You just never know if you’re in luck or not.
Don’t let the funky walls fool you. You can’t just redecorate the place and expect customers to eat it up.
February 27th, 2011 at 2:39 am
I waited to post this comment until I ate at Piatto which I did tonight. You are still the best St. John’s has to offer. Love your staff, your service, your prices and especially your pizza. The decor is pretty cool too. Thanks :)
March 28th, 2011 at 4:55 pm
Flavor, I’d give them a 3.5/5
Service, I’d give them a 2/5
Value, I’d give a generous 3/5.
I didn’t hate my experience, but I don’t think I’ll be going back.
April 9th, 2011 at 6:07 pm
GROSS! The service was terrible. THe guy preparing the food had a big beard and hair and did not wear a hairnet or gloves. When I got my pizza it had a big hair in it. Would never go back under any circumstance.
July 16th, 2011 at 8:49 am
Great pizza and service, will go back
September 18th, 2011 at 1:52 pm
Love the decor! So colorful and cute inside, and the pizzas are named after mathematicians! Very exotic ingredients, that I’ve never seen anywhere else, for a reasonable price! I love that you can be adventurous at Pi, and the food is fresh & delicious. and to drink, try their black cherry fruit spritzer!
January 28th, 2012 at 9:18 am
Things like this have happened to me at Pi too many times. The first time I tried Pi, my mother and I went for lunch. The owner was working alone, took our order, made our pizza, delivered it to our table, and took our money without once washing her hands. The second time I tried Pi I felt like we were forced out. We arrived at 9 pm when the store hours say open until 11. By 930 the lights on one side of the restaurant were turned off, along with the music, and all the staff sat around in front of the cash where we could hear them complaining that we were in the building still. The third time I decided to give Pi a whirl, the owner and a staff member got into a viscous argument that resulted in the staff member storming out of the building and the owner walking around bawling behind the cash and making a spectate, cursing the employee and saying terrible insults about him loud enough for most of the tables to hear. That’s enough for me. Never again will I eat at Pi.
February 27th, 2012 at 11:48 am
I love their Caeser salad. It’s so delicious! Had it to go so no comments on atmosphere and serving times.
The Caeser is cheaper than Bistro Sophia’s and tastes a lot better.
March 4th, 2012 at 3:28 pm
I really want to like this place so my husband and I have given it 3 tries. Each time we received a very bland, soggy pizza. Had to ask for some salt to put on the pizza so it wouldn’t be so tasteless. Very disappointing, we won’t be back ever again. (unfortunately I cannot submit a rating with 0 stars)
March 4th, 2012 at 6:48 pm
Wow! I don\’t care what pizza you are eating, but if it has any cheese, pepperoni, sauce, etc, it has plenty of salt. Maybe you need a more budget pizza where they whack the salt to it. I find a lot of pizza (and other convenience foods) too salty. I\’m not saying Pi is all that, but salt?
March 26th, 2012 at 4:02 pm
Enjoy the pizza, bit too expensive especially now that piatto is in town. Will try it again.
And in response to niki: A newfoundlander that wants to put more salt on a pizza? I thought I had seen everything.
April 10th, 2012 at 10:14 pm
“we burnt your pizza, so we ate it.” – waitress at Pi
The pizza is ok, generally over complicated, but the service is awful. I would give this restaurant a 2. If you are looking for good pizza in st.john’s go to piatto.
April 16th, 2012 at 2:49 pm
First time there, the food was good the decor is pretty cool, I would go back. As for the other reviews yes the service could be improved.
April 16th, 2012 at 4:10 pm
I absolutely love this place! If you are looking for your average, boring old pizza this isn’t the place. If you are looking for unique and creative combinations of toppings, this is the place to go. All pizzas are thin crust so they aren’t very filling. I would recommend this to anyone looking for something different. I usually take out so I can’t say much about the service except that it has been good the few times I have been there. It is a bit pricier than your average pizza place but well worth it for the flavours.
April 23rd, 2012 at 10:13 pm
Pi is always a good quality and the selection is mouth watering…definitely St John’s homemade best pizz (aside from my own). Yummy. i recommend as a place you can rearrange when you bring many guests from a conference.
April 25th, 2012 at 10:56 am
The food here is great if you like crispy, thin crust pizza with tons of toppings. There’s a nice selection, so you’re bound to find something you’d like (I usually find myself getting a medium pizza just to have leftovers the next day).
The service is ok…I find it sometimes takes a while to get our orders taken. I’ve been here a couple of times and one thing that’s always bothered me is the waitress (maybe the owner?) that mopes around the restaurant wearing pajamas and an old hoodie. A lot of work has obviously been put into making the restaurant look nice, so why would she insist on dressing like a first year student that just hauled her ass out of bed to get to class?
May 25th, 2012 at 12:31 pm
Although the pizza is truly good stuff the staff truly scare me!
I’d eat there all the time if the grumpy pajama wearing scary girl wasn’t there. Every time I’m in there she makes me feel like I’m bothering her. Not to mention she looks so haggard like she hasn’t washed in a week you cannot help but wonder about how sanitary the restaurant actually is. Yikes.
Show some pride in yourself and your pizza Pi….
July 26th, 2012 at 12:39 am
A disappointment. Pi certainly brings a unique offering to St. John’s — alternative toppings on a pizza not soaking in grease. Unfortunately, these elements do not necessarily make it good. My pizza was a random assemblage of ingredients, sitting on a piece of dough, with nothing to really tie the flavours together. The tomato was overcooked and lacking seasoning, which is a shame, because there are so many spices and seasonings that can bring out the flavour of tomato. Similarly, the sauce was bland and sparse. Without a good sauce to ultimately unify the toppings on the pizza, the food was a pretty underwhelming experience.
While the decor of the restaurant is bright and pleasant, our service was mixed. Our waitress was cheerful and extremely accommodating. Although she seemed to be the only one waiting tables and was obviously strained from having so much to take care of, she never made us feel like we were a problem. Which is more than I can say for the owner. She greeted us as the host, and seemed genuinely disappointed that we were there. She seated us while snapping that every other table was reserved, and at the end of the meal, was elbowing us aside to get our plates off of the table and then rushing us out of the restaurant. I have no idea why this woman feels its acceptable to treat customers this way, and I’m honestly shocked that Pi is still open considering the attitude the owner has towards the people who want to give her business.
Flaws in the formula made the food mediocre, and considering the cost, it isn’t worth repeating the experience.
January 4th, 2013 at 1:49 pm
Awesome if you want to see the owner yell at the staff and burst into tears. Food was mediocre at best. Really surprised people still eat there. Or work there.
July 16th, 2013 at 7:16 pm
Used to like Pi – went there last week and was very disappointed.
The pizza dough was uncooked and very doughy, the ice-tea she served me was warm and the wine was stale, had probably been sitting out.
I sent back my salad because the lettuce was BROWN, I was polite but the waitress was rude and said “it looked fine and she would eat it”.
She also brought me my salad after the pizza was eaten..?