The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site

Oliver’s Restaurant

  • 3.743.743.743.743.74
28 reviews (write your own)

160 Water St.

754-6444

Go back to the restaurant list
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.

28 Reader Reviews of Oliver’s Restaurant

(19 positive, 4 negative)
  1. avatar
    halibut Says:

    The Scope’s 2008 Breakfast Face Off Results:
    $11.19 for traditional breakfast with free coffee refills. Served Saturdays 10am-4pm and Sundays 11am-4pm. Recommended breakfast: Florentine Frittata consisting of an open faced omelette with feta. Price includes tax.

  2. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    David Says:

    I didn’t want to go there,but my friend liked the look of the specials posted outside (and the Ship was out of fishcakes).

    Problem #1-my friend ordered the special and did not get what she ordered-they offered her a modification of sorts,which didn’t really cut it-AND the entire meal was freezing cold.

    Problem #2-my meal Fish Cake breakfast was pretty much inedible. There was NO fish in the fish cakes. The scrambled eggs would be more at home in a hamster cage as wood chips they were so dry and overcooked,read-premade and left in the oven for hours.The toast was plain old white Sunny Bee bread.

    I didn’t even bother to complain about mine-never said a word. My friend did complain about the myriad problems with her meal.

    The waiter said he “spoke to the manager” and she said to take 25% off each meal.This manager(if there was one) must work at “PR for Dummies”. Why offer a discount to someone who has not complained? Oh-because two crappy discounts sounds better/costs less than comping a full meal.

    Two words: NEVER AGAIN

  3. avatar
    ooglyboogly Says:

    In response to David’s review: I used to work at Oliver’s, so I feel it’s my duty to let you know that 1) they don’t pre-scramble their eggs and then leave them in the oven, they make their eggs to order. 2) Their bread is from a local bakery. The multi-grain variety is pretty good. The white and whole wheat are fairly standard and lackluster. 3) Your waiter phoned the manager. They do so any time there is a complaint. Your meal may have been discounted because you didn’t eat very much of it and the waiter noticed. If you did eat it, then it was likely discounted because they (waiter and manager) felt bad about your friend’s meal. As for comping meals, if a customer complains right away (or sometime during the meal), then a new dish is made for them. Otherwise, if the customer eats the meal (or a significant part of it) and then complains at the end, it’s their loss. If you think about it, it kind of makes sense.
    All that being said, Oliver’s is just not very good for brunch. It’s a lunch and dinner place. They have one of the best wine lists in town (and one of the most reasonably priced) and that’s why you should be going there. Get the table in the window sometime in the late afternoon or early evening, get a pile of appetizers to share and enjoy some good wine. That’s the best way to use Oliver’s.

  4. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    David's lunch mate Says:

    Dear ooglyboogly,
    How in god’s name you knew that the waiter called the manager that day is beyond me… other than the fact that you are either that waiter or the manager…. now THAT makes sense.
    I was that other person with David for brunch. I did complain at the beginning of the meal….. the waiter had given me the wrong meal….I was to have the smoked salmon eggs benny but ended up with ham (I hate ham) so to avoid him taking my entire meal back, I graciously told him that I would hang on to my meal and take the ham off myself, while he went to get me the smoked salmon. When he returned I had already started to eat and noticed that the eggs benny (sans ham) was stone cold. I complained again and told him that if I wasn’t weak with hunger I would send the works bach and he apologized and walked away. I didn’t finish my meal either. David (and my) point was, why would you give David a discount also????? He didn’t even complain about his meal. For all the waiter knew, David’s meal was fine (which it wasn’t). Soooooooo by NOT complaining about his meal, David was rewarded a 25% discount as well??? You cannot tell me that that makes sense (even kind of). Having worked in the restaurant industry for 20 years, I have learned that if you want customers to return to you restaurant, you have to listen to and respect them. That being said, I won’t return.
    p.s. A good wine list does not constitute a good restaurant. The Casa Loma could have an excellent wine list but that does not make it a good restaurant. What is wrong with people???????????

  5. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    A1C_Gastro Says:

    I have eaten at Oliver’s on 5 occasions now and have been completely satisfied on each occasion. I have brought friends and family and have also recommended Oliver’s to numerous others with nothing but glowing feedback. Every occasion I visited was for supper, so I cannot speak to their breakfast/brunch offerings. However, from my numerous experiences I can say that service was great but the food was the attraction along with the cozy and warm atmosphere. I thoroughly enjoyed the appetizers, entrees (including seafood, chicken and steak dishes) and desserts as well as their excellent wine list. I have and will continue to recommend Oliver’s as one of my favourite restaurants in the city.

  6. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Ellepower Says:

    I find this restaurant a little gem !!
    The seafood chowder was the best I have had.The bread was as good and freshly baked.Many dishes had a local flavor and my daughter had an amazing vegetarian meal made just for her.They had fresh ingredients and the decor has recently been updated. I would highly recommend Olivers

  7. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Sarah Says:

    My experience at Oliver’s was absolutely wonderful! I started with the almond goat cheese which was by far one the best appetizers I have ever had. I can not wait to have it again! I had a spinach salad as my main course. The salad was delicious. Everyone else at the table also enjoyed their meals. I highly recommend this restaurant!

  8. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Jennifer Says:

    Oliver’s is a great restaurant,
    I have eaten numerous occasions and always have been blown away by food, atmosphere and service…
    Recommend always!

  9. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Samantha Says:

    I have eaten at many restaurants around the city and love trying new places and new food. My boyfriend and I decided to try Oliver’s and absolutely loved it! We started off with the almond goat cheese appetizer, it was beyond delicious, there was nothing left on the plate! For my meal I had the balsamic chicken and proscuitto fettuccine and loved every bite. It was unlike any pasta dish I had ordered before. The sauce was so delicious and the pasta and chicken were cooked perfectly! The service and atmosphere was exactly what I was looking for for a nice date out! I absolutley loved it and would recommend it to anyone!!!

  10. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Ashlynn Says:

    I have been to Oliver’s several times for breakfast lunch and supper. The weekend brunch is great with interesting options that taste amazing. I have gone out to eat with vegetarians several times and the chef has always been extremely accommodating often making suggestions for substitutions etc. For appetizers the beet salad with goat cheese at Oliver’s is amazing! I would definitely recommend this place for a date or with a group of friends!

  11. avatar
    A & R Says:

    Our meals at Oliver’s were delicious! The mussels we had as an appetizer were the best I’ve had in the city so far. This restaurant was the first to cook my steak exactly the way I like it, and I admit I’m a bit fussy when it comes to steak! My boyfriend had one of the specials which was fish with a Bailey’s sauce and it was amazing!
    I would definitely recommend Oliver’s to anyone, especially to people who are up for trying something new. Every time we walk by the restaurant the specials look so good and there’s always something different!

  12. avatar
    Diana Whalen Says:

    On a recent trip to Newfoundland my friend and I had a wonderful lunch at Olivers. The food was delicious and the atmosphere was warm and cozy. It was my birthday and they brought me a mouth watering chocolate cake! Recommend to all!

  13. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Dayle Says:

    This is a great restaurant, under-recognized. I’ve only ever had great experiences and great food there. Service is good, really nice selection of wines, and a menu that is really pescatarian-friendly (ie. if you’re a vegetarian who also eats seafood, this is your spot). The almond goat cheese appetizer is heaven. Simple, creamy, savoury and a little sweet… I would give five stars except I think their crab cake appetizer is way too salty (so order the goat cheese already! Do you really need another reason?), and because the last time we went, the complimentary bread was sticky in the middle (although it was a terrific recipe, spicy and hearty). Also, I wish they would bring back the mulligatawny, because I remember that being gorgeous. So really, if four and a half stars was an option, that would be the score, says me. Overall a really nice place to have a nice, head-buzzy, drawn-out, romantic meal.

  14. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    scotman Says:

    Enjoyed olivers brunch/lunch over the weekend. A goupr of us were there, I had the crabcakes with scrambled eggs and hasbrowns from the brunch menu – crabcakes were good, moist and crispy, and the eggs were way better than the standard breakfast ourfit by a long shot. Others had unch items – the seafood chowder id one of the best in the city, the clubhouse sandwich was a hit as well. Service was somewhat slower than would be expected, good, but slow … 1 1/2 – 2 hours for the total time – 1 appetizer, mains, no desserts. Overall a good experience and good quality fare, but not a place if you dont have time to spare.

  15. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Aiden Says:

    Just had brunch at Oliver’s today. Great prices for brunch items – comparable to all breakfast places in town if not better prices for better food. Had the special – eggs bennie with havarti and chanterelle mushrooms. There were five of us and food was delicious. Loved by all. Service was good too. The restaurant was over half full and we were eating not long after our order was placed.

    Overall great experience! Will be returning again soon.

  16. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    katiekatt Says:

    My boyfriend and I went to Oliver’s just this past week. I was not overly satisfied with my meal, I ordered the seafood crepes which included salmon, cod and shrimp and it was not what I expected. I expected something along the lines of a seafood crepe and instead I got what seemed to be a creamy seafood stew piled over a tiny crepe that wasn’t even visible to me at first. It was very bland, the shrimp were extremely tiny and not what I expected. The sauce was a very one dimensional dill cream sauce. Halfway through my meal I discovered a risotto cake under my “stew” and that was delicious.

    My boyfriend had pasta (can’t remember what kind) but it was delicious. We had bruschetta and crab cakes as appetizers and they were both very good. I do believe that I simply made the wrong choice for my entree, but I do think that the seafood crepes should be taken off the menu. Sometimes it only takes one poorly executed dish to make me think twice before going back to a restaurant.

  17. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Foodie Says:

    I think that Oliver’s is a very nice place to eat. All of their bread is made fresh, and their desserts are made in house, as well as soups, crab cakes and table bread.
    That being said, there are currently 4-5 chefs working in the kitchen and, therefore, the food can change/differ slightly on a day to day basis.
    I would always recommend trying a restaurant more than once before you write it off entirely, and brunch isn’t exactly a “fine-dining” experience.

  18. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    vegan Says:

    I was at Oliver’s last week for a friends birthday. I was appalled by how poor the service was. The waitress was very sharp, unwelcoming, and rude. I am a vegan and when I inquired about a vegan option there was little interest in actually trying to accommodate. My friend asked for a well done stake to which the waitress replied, “That’s going to take a long time” in a rude voice. I had the Mushroom wellington (with no cheeses) and it was the worst food I ever ate, but was my only option on the menu. When I was paying for my meal the waitress mechanically took my visa and put it in the machine not even speaking to me. There was a large group of us and as people were paying they were taking mints next to the cash. After about half the people had paid she moved the bowl of mints behind the counter. Bad food and terrible service!

  19. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    VeganChef Says:

    To Vegan:
    Just in case you didn’t notice, Oliver’s isn’t exactly a vegan friendly restaurant. It’s hardly even Vegetarian friendly…
    But on some days there is actually a vegan chef in the kitchen, who would gladly have whipped you up something more exciting than a puff pastry wellington – which isn’t actually vegan, as puff pastry has butter in it, and you should probably know that, being a vegan, and all.
    As far as a well-done steak goes, it does take forever, and it was likely more a warning than an insult. And more than likely, because you are a “vegan” in an carnivorous restaurant, you were already on edge which can exasperate the entire experience.
    Believe it or not, waitresses are people too, and perhaps had you been more vocal about your displeasure and need for something actually vegan (you have now eaten cow bi-products, by the way) she would have been far more helpful to you and yours.
    Honestly, if you’re not going to speak up and speak out (as vegans are known for) than perhaps you should stick to The Sprout…In December, alone, four very satisfied vegans had meals at Oliver’s. You are the only one who seems to have any complaints, and insults to the food and for the service at Oliver’s Restaurant.
    Either try it again and speak up – be vocal about the fact that you have dietary restrictions or head up to The Sprout, and eat bean burgers and fries to your heart’s delight.
    Sincerely, The Vegan Chef.

  20. avatar
    Vegan Says:

    Thanks for you response but I feel that you need more information before you can make those remarks. While it is possible that if I had spoke with the chef they may come up with another option, but customers deal with waitresses, that is how it works at a restaurant. I asked the waitress for any vegan options, she then went into the kitchen to speak with the chef to see what options were possible. The response was that the only option was the wellington and assured me that it was made with oil and NOT butter. (Being vegan is something I feel very strongly about and please do not attempt to accuse me of not understanding it).

    On the point of Olivers not being a “vegan” restaurant I feel, and know that many people would agree with me that at restaurants customer service and satisfaction is a priority and they should have tried to accommodate. Even as you said, ” would gladly have whipped you up something more exciting than a puff pastry wellington” so i do not feel I was imposing by asking or should be held responsible for bad customer service.

    Regarding, “because you are a “vegan” in an carnivorous restaurant, you were already on edge which can exasperate the entire experience.” I live in st. johns! The concept of not being in a carnivorous restaurant as you put it is near impossible. I am well aware of what I expect when I enter such a place, and I feel that it is wrong of you to make such a harsh assumption!

    On your comment regarding the steak, the tone of voice is the most important thing. A harsh and rude tone was what we revived, nothing near a friendly warning. The entire experience was unwelcoming. I have felt more welcomed in fast food restaurants than I did at olivers.

    The reason you accused me of not believing that waitresses are people too is beyond me. I believe that people who work in the service industry should be warm and inviting. My only comment regarding the staff was unfriendly service, I never made any attempt to put the people down personally as you have done to me in your response.

    In your reply you make a number of generalizations that I believe to be totally false and uncalled for, and that you are being very unfair to the sprout in saying they only have bean burgers and fries.

    As for saying I should have spoken up, I don’t believe that you should have to demand service, at a good restaurant or any restaurant for that matter, you should not have to request good service.

    The entire purpose of this forum is to share your experiences and provide a review of you encounters, and that is exactly what I have done. I don’t feel that I should return to expect anything different. I asked the waitress for options, she gave me none and was unwelcoming the entire night, not to mention the poor food quality.

    If you are a representative of Oliver’s I encourage you to read this review with an open mind and not be so quick to write an unprofessional, aggressive response to any negative feedback.

    Sincerely,
    Harassed Vegan

  21. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Clifton Says:

    I have been a long time customer at OLIVER’S restaurant. I have to say this~~~never had any complaints, whether it was the food, service, or atmosphere.
    My most recent visit there was at the end of December. My sister and I enjoyed the delicious chicken, broccoli crepe, with different side dishes.
    As per usual, it was, without any doubt whatsoever, delicious.

    In the past I have been there for lunch, on many occasions, dinner, and brunch on the weekend.
    Each and every time, that I have been there I have never had a complaint.

    I have been to many restaurants over the years, and, can say, without a blink, the food, service, and atmosphere at OLIVER’S, is, without a doubt, top of the line, bar none.

    Some people are born to criticize. You just can’t seem to please some people. They criticize just for the sake of criticizing.

    In regards to Vegetarians. Well, that is another story, in and of itself.
    I won’t really dwell on that. Suffice to say that, there are Vegetarians, and there are vegetarians.
    If I really want a 100% VEGETARIAN meal, I guess I could go to the Sprout.

    I can go to any restaurant, and have veggie food. However, I guess a true and tried vegetarian, should go to the SPROUT, period.
    As I said above, there are VEGETARIANS of different beliefs. A personal choice I guess. To each his own

    Now, in closing, I recommend OLIVER’S restaurant to anyone.
    If you have a problem in any restaurant, complain while you are there. Don’t leave and complain after the fact. No good to vent your frustrations after the horse is gone from the barn, when the door was left open.

    Oliver’s restaurant is, what it is… a great restaurant,excellent food in all different food choices.
    The staff, all through the years have been, nothing short of excellent. I have NEVER had a problem. And, great atmosphere.

    I’ll end by saying this. Attitude, and courtesy is everything. Tell me who your friends are, and, I’ll tell you the type of person you are.
    I only criticize when it is justifiable, not just for the sake of doing so, like a lot of people today.
    As the old saying goes, “My mind is made up, don’t confuse me with the facts” No matter what you do for some customers, they will find something to complain. As I said above, some are born to criticize.
    I remember when I worked in the retail trade many, many years ago, you would get customers that would complain about everything. There is no way to please some people.

  22. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Notafan Says:

    Looks like the employees at Oliver’s have been reading the Scope…..

  23. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Bartender Says:

    I recently had a fantastic meal at Oliver’s, but could barely understand when the cheque came. 2 drinks (martini and cocktail), appetizer, two fantastic entrees (salmon and steak) , one shared dessert and two after dinner coffees..all for $90? Thats half the price I expected to pay!
    On top of the fantastic food and reasonable price, server was perfect. Not too over-bearing which is key for a relaxed place like Oliver’s with such a great cozy atmosphere.
    Will return!

  24. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    tourist Says:

    I ate at Oliver’s this weekend and the food was awesome. My steak was cooked perfectly and the seasoning was exceptional. The service was exceptional and the wine list is incredible. I would definitely return in a heartbeat.

  25. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Erin Says:

    Ate there recently: food was decent, not great. When I received my drink there were lipstick stains on the rim and I had to ask the server to get me a new one….

  26. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Erica Says:

    I thought the restaurant was lovely. The seafood penne marinara pasta was delicious and the scallops and shrimp were juicy and fresh. We had a spinach dip to start which was great in flavour and our waitress provided more bread when we asked.

    It was pricey but it was a beautiful place. That is what you pay for -the quality food AND the experience. and this was both

    :)

  27. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Bee Says:

    Not bad.

  28. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Well now Says:

    All fresh which is awesome. From breads to pasta. I just find it sad that i was told no staff have been there longer than 2 years which shows bad management also that they are cheap pretty sad. its nice when you have a staff that is family .

You can write a review right away below or you can log in here. (New user? Sign up here!)


    • Don't have an account? . Takes just a minute or two.

  • Leave a Review