PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.
Wonderful service, extremely delicious food, fair prices, large portions! We had a great meal, albeit with a bit of a draft from the window above my daughter’s seat. Will return.
I LOVED this place. I must admit, walking by it all these years I thought it was pompous and never went in but it’s AWESOME!!!!! The staff are friendly and good at their jobs and oh the food!! it’s sooooo delicious and the portions are HUGE. Completely worth the money…and it’s priced fair. Mmmmmmm, I WILL be going back. Besides a great place for apps and supper go there for wine and desert. MMMMmmmmmmmm. I can’t say enough.
Had a horrible experience at this place. We had late reservations so maybe they weren’t happy about that or something. The interaction with the waiter wasn’t good at all. He acted all impatient if we asked a question. Pretty well ruined the dining experience there. Won’t be going back. Lots of nicer places than that.
Ate there recently, first and last time. Very long wait for food, seated at a table upstairs in the back where the lighting was so poor we could barely see our food. Food was okay, but nowhere near worth the price. Lots of other choices in this category here in town, we’ll try somewhere else next time.
Might get more customers if the name didn’t sound like a law firm, for which I believed for 10 years! [passed it all the time on the bus, but never looked it up to see exactly what it was]3 Star rating because I have to rate it, and I am undecided.
There was some good and some bad. First the good. We were promptly seated on arrival and all the staff were very courteous. While the menu was quite limited in selections (approx 5 each of appetizers, salads, and entrees), there were almost as many specials available. All the entrees and appetizers were good to excellent. The fillet was bigger and tastier than The Keg’s. The special mushroom soup was delicious. Now the bad. While the host took our drink orders, they didn’t arrive before the waiter again asked about drinks. The dessert selection was a little limited and we chose the banana creme brulee with white chocolate. It came out watery and the crust was way too thick. Finally though, don’t come thirsty. My son and I each got 2 refills on our Pepsi’s and the tab for the drinks was $15! Our tab was $140 including tip (and no alcohol). Overall I gave it 3 stars out of 5 because the good and the bad sort of balance each other out.
This is our favorite spot for consistently excellent food and service that is very professional yet not stuffy.
We always love their rack of lamb but were a bit disappointed last time that it didn’t seem like the same tender cut they’ve had in the past. Also, we enjoy dim lighting but this is almost a little too dim to see your menu or your food!
The fish soup is to die for and could easily be a meal in itself. They also always do an amazing job on the huge halibut filets that they serve. A fave dessert is the nutty filo thingy served with ice cream. Mmmm, I could go on.
But we will be back for sure because this is usually our safe bet for an excellent meal when we want to go out and relax, spurge and enjoy.
For a quick choice on where to go, this turned out to be one of the best meals I’ve had in a long time. The menu may be limited but the specials make up for it. I will be going back, if only for the gnocchi! A great spot!
Went to their old location several years ago, waited over an hour at a dimly lit table for overdone food, never went back until now. Had a very similar experience. Went there Saturday evening, August 4th. Took over an hour for our entrees, despite being told that it wasn’t one of their busier Saturday nights. It seems like there are two main floor dining rooms, one on the right and one on the left. The one on the right looks like it is not used very much. It was dimly (and poorly) lit by two overhead light fixtures, walls appeared (in the dim light) to be dark grey and not a single piece of art. Sort of like jail, I’d imagine. Food was somewhat overcooked by the time we received it. I can’t believe we shelled out $150 bucks for 2 people for a long, annoying restaurant experience. Also noticed that there was a video camera mounted on the wall in the room. There was no cash register or other reason why people there should be monitored and possibly recorded while eating. Major turnoff, will not be back.
Tried out the new location for the first time just a couple weeks ago. Always loved M&G and we loved our apps and mains this visit. Neither of us were thrilled by our desserts.
We were a bit disappointed by the new location! A musty smell, too brightly lit and the small tables for two are just squeezed too closely together – it was actually awkwardly close the the couples on either side of us. We ended up speaking to both of them…not so much becasue we wanted to chat, we actually kind of didn’t, but things happened and we were so close that it would have been awkward not to speak/ acknowledge. (i.e. woman dropped her fork and it landed on my foot)…Having said that, the new bar downstairs is gorgeous.
I really hope they can cozy up the main dining area we were in a little! We didn’t enjoy the setting at all. And no one does a cod or halibut dish like M&G so we want to keep going…!
Horrible experience. I sat at the bar and was ignored for five minutes by the bartender who was busy stapling checks. I eventually ordered the beef tartare, which was flavourless, served with downright soggy brioche, followed by their duck confit wanton nachos. After three bites my mouth was burning from the salt. Those suckers were just absolutely drowned in soy sauce. I actually thought someone was playing some kind of cruel joke on me. I asked the bartender for a wine reccomendation with each course and he merely ran through the six or so varieties of house wines. 70 bucks including tip, a beer, a glass of wine, and one whiskey. I won’t be back.
I’ve been to M&S’s bar a couple times since so far this year and have had a great experience there! Staff are super friendly and helpful. We’ve eaten the mussels (super tasty and spicy!) and the duck confit nachos (which are the best thing I’ve eaten in a while!!! Salty, sweet and crunchy and fresh all at the same time). Looking forward to return visits. Thanks!
We decided to try the new location for our anniversary and had a lovely evening. Like another reviewer commented, we did notice a funny smell when we walked in. We both had the fish soup as an appetizer. The half portion is enough for a light meal. It was tasty and had a great variety of sea food. I had the lobster salad as my second course (actually an appetizer) and found it delicious. Hubby had the rack of lamb which I sampled. Excellent! Warning to the ladies – the portions at M&G’s are very generous – suitable for teenage boys. I went with two appetizers and that was just right. We shared a tiramisu for dessert, also very nice. Hubby paid so I can’t comment on the price but I imagine it was what one would expect to pay for fine dining. In our experience eating out anywhere in St. John’s is pricey but we certainly enjoyed our meal at M&G’s.
October 21st, 2008 at 5:58 pm
Amazing food, great service. I will definitely return. Oh yeah, and the best halibut of my life.
March 15th, 2009 at 8:42 am
Wonderful service, extremely delicious food, fair prices, large portions! We had a great meal, albeit with a bit of a draft from the window above my daughter’s seat. Will return.
March 21st, 2009 at 8:33 pm
I LOVED this place. I must admit, walking by it all these years I thought it was pompous and never went in but it’s AWESOME!!!!! The staff are friendly and good at their jobs and oh the food!! it’s sooooo delicious and the portions are HUGE. Completely worth the money…and it’s priced fair. Mmmmmmm, I WILL be going back. Besides a great place for apps and supper go there for wine and desert. MMMMmmmmmmmm. I can’t say enough.
September 25th, 2009 at 4:24 pm
Had a horrible experience at this place. We had late reservations so maybe they weren’t happy about that or something. The interaction with the waiter wasn’t good at all. He acted all impatient if we asked a question. Pretty well ruined the dining experience there. Won’t be going back. Lots of nicer places than that.
October 7th, 2009 at 11:34 pm
Ate there recently, first and last time. Very long wait for food, seated at a table upstairs in the back where the lighting was so poor we could barely see our food. Food was okay, but nowhere near worth the price. Lots of other choices in this category here in town, we’ll try somewhere else next time.
February 20th, 2010 at 2:39 pm
Might get more customers if the name didn’t sound like a law firm, for which I believed for 10 years! [passed it all the time on the bus, but never looked it up to see exactly what it was]3 Star rating because I have to rate it, and I am undecided.
June 9th, 2010 at 1:26 pm
There was some good and some bad. First the good. We were promptly seated on arrival and all the staff were very courteous. While the menu was quite limited in selections (approx 5 each of appetizers, salads, and entrees), there were almost as many specials available. All the entrees and appetizers were good to excellent. The fillet was bigger and tastier than The Keg’s. The special mushroom soup was delicious. Now the bad. While the host took our drink orders, they didn’t arrive before the waiter again asked about drinks. The dessert selection was a little limited and we chose the banana creme brulee with white chocolate. It came out watery and the crust was way too thick. Finally though, don’t come thirsty. My son and I each got 2 refills on our Pepsi’s and the tab for the drinks was $15! Our tab was $140 including tip (and no alcohol). Overall I gave it 3 stars out of 5 because the good and the bad sort of balance each other out.
April 3rd, 2011 at 3:18 pm
This is our favorite spot for consistently excellent food and service that is very professional yet not stuffy.
We always love their rack of lamb but were a bit disappointed last time that it didn’t seem like the same tender cut they’ve had in the past. Also, we enjoy dim lighting but this is almost a little too dim to see your menu or your food!
The fish soup is to die for and could easily be a meal in itself. They also always do an amazing job on the huge halibut filets that they serve. A fave dessert is the nutty filo thingy served with ice cream. Mmmm, I could go on.
But we will be back for sure because this is usually our safe bet for an excellent meal when we want to go out and relax, spurge and enjoy.
October 19th, 2011 at 12:29 pm
For a quick choice on where to go, this turned out to be one of the best meals I’ve had in a long time. The menu may be limited but the specials make up for it. I will be going back, if only for the gnocchi! A great spot!
August 8th, 2012 at 10:28 am
Went to their old location several years ago, waited over an hour at a dimly lit table for overdone food, never went back until now. Had a very similar experience. Went there Saturday evening, August 4th. Took over an hour for our entrees, despite being told that it wasn’t one of their busier Saturday nights. It seems like there are two main floor dining rooms, one on the right and one on the left. The one on the right looks like it is not used very much. It was dimly (and poorly) lit by two overhead light fixtures, walls appeared (in the dim light) to be dark grey and not a single piece of art. Sort of like jail, I’d imagine. Food was somewhat overcooked by the time we received it. I can’t believe we shelled out $150 bucks for 2 people for a long, annoying restaurant experience. Also noticed that there was a video camera mounted on the wall in the room. There was no cash register or other reason why people there should be monitored and possibly recorded while eating. Major turnoff, will not be back.
December 2nd, 2012 at 10:43 pm
Tried out the new location for the first time just a couple weeks ago. Always loved M&G and we loved our apps and mains this visit. Neither of us were thrilled by our desserts.
We were a bit disappointed by the new location! A musty smell, too brightly lit and the small tables for two are just squeezed too closely together – it was actually awkwardly close the the couples on either side of us. We ended up speaking to both of them…not so much becasue we wanted to chat, we actually kind of didn’t, but things happened and we were so close that it would have been awkward not to speak/ acknowledge. (i.e. woman dropped her fork and it landed on my foot)…Having said that, the new bar downstairs is gorgeous.
I really hope they can cozy up the main dining area we were in a little! We didn’t enjoy the setting at all. And no one does a cod or halibut dish like M&G so we want to keep going…!
December 26th, 2012 at 6:13 pm
Horrible experience. I sat at the bar and was ignored for five minutes by the bartender who was busy stapling checks. I eventually ordered the beef tartare, which was flavourless, served with downright soggy brioche, followed by their duck confit wanton nachos. After three bites my mouth was burning from the salt. Those suckers were just absolutely drowned in soy sauce. I actually thought someone was playing some kind of cruel joke on me. I asked the bartender for a wine reccomendation with each course and he merely ran through the six or so varieties of house wines. 70 bucks including tip, a beer, a glass of wine, and one whiskey. I won’t be back.
April 24th, 2013 at 12:01 pm
I’ve been to M&S’s bar a couple times since so far this year and have had a great experience there! Staff are super friendly and helpful. We’ve eaten the mussels (super tasty and spicy!) and the duck confit nachos (which are the best thing I’ve eaten in a while!!! Salty, sweet and crunchy and fresh all at the same time). Looking forward to return visits. Thanks!
May 5th, 2013 at 2:48 pm
We decided to try the new location for our anniversary and had a lovely evening. Like another reviewer commented, we did notice a funny smell when we walked in. We both had the fish soup as an appetizer. The half portion is enough for a light meal. It was tasty and had a great variety of sea food. I had the lobster salad as my second course (actually an appetizer) and found it delicious. Hubby had the rack of lamb which I sampled. Excellent! Warning to the ladies – the portions at M&G’s are very generous – suitable for teenage boys. I went with two appetizers and that was just right. We shared a tiramisu for dessert, also very nice. Hubby paid so I can’t comment on the price but I imagine it was what one would expect to pay for fine dining. In our experience eating out anywhere in St. John’s is pricey but we certainly enjoyed our meal at M&G’s.