The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Piatto Pizzeria and Enocteca

Piatto Pizzeria and Enocteca

  • 3.923.923.923.923.92
68 reviews (write your own)

377 Duckworth Street
726-0909
www.piattopizzeria.com

Go back to the restaurant list
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.

68 Reader Reviews of Piatto Pizzeria and Enocteca

(52 positive, 11 negative)
  1. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    saltine Says:

    I just tried Piatto as well–fantastic, simple pizza in a gorgeous warm (atmospherically and temperature-wise, because of the wood-burning oven) space. This is what pizza should be. Yum!

  2. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Lanie Doe Says:

    I visited Piatto for the first time today for lunch. Walking into the place, it felt like a restaurant that had been already established in the city for years. Rustic wooden floors, simple tables, and tasteful mirrors were some of the things that caught my eye. The space is cozy and warm, yet chic and modern at the same time.

    The second thing I noticed is how good the service was. We were greeted by the manager, who was fantastic, to say the least. She explained the menu, chatted a bit, and made us feel right at home.

    My lunch date and I had the salad with cranberries, gorganzola and walnuts. It was extremely fresh, and enough for two of us to enjoy.

    We then had the cheese pizza, as my friend is a vegetarian. It arrived in less than 10 minutes, with gorgeous blobs of Gorgonzola, Ricotta, Parm, and a cream base. The wine was served in a regular glass, instead of your typical wine glass, which I very much liked.

    This apparently is a family run business. And judging by how we were treated and fed today, this place will be around for quite some time.

    Saving the best for last, the prices are great. Two of us had a very hearty lunch for less than 30 buckaroos. I will be returning on Saturday to test out dinner seating.

    Nice to see such a place exist here. Pizza should be simple. And boy, do they ever do it well at Piatto.

  3. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Emily Says:

    We just got back from dinner at Piatto, and I can safely say that if you’re looking for the best, most authentic pizza in town, you’ll find it here. The dough is tasty and cooked to perfection in the wood burning oven, and the toppings are simple, delicious and piping hot. I haven’t had pizza this good since I was in Naples a year and a half ago!
    We had the bruschetta served on freshly made focaccia, a pizza with fresh mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, roasted red peppers and caramelized onions (both wonderful!) and finished the supper off with some of the tastiest macchiatos in town. Yum!

  4. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    meh Says:

    Avoid this place if you are vegan or vegetarian.
    Trust me.

  5. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Peggy Says:

    Fabulous first experience at Piatto’s yesterday! We have been long waiting for something resembling good, simple authentic Italian here in St. John’s. Fabulous pizza – very much like what we’ve had in Italy! We tried a couple of the antipastos, which were really fresh and tasty. And the service was super-duper – what you don’t get at many other places in the city these days. And all at very reasonable prices. Wow – we are happy with this place.

  6. avatar
    saltine Says:

    Meh says to avoid if vegan or veg, but actually they make everything to order so both can be accommodated. Dough is vegan and there are lots of veg toppings. If you don’t eat cheese ask them to leave it off. Salads are mostly vegetarian or can be adapted to be.

  7. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Elliott Says:

    Totally pleased with the quality of Piatto. The wood fire gives the pizza a wonderful flavour that’s completely unlike anywhere else you can go in town. We went on opening night and, despite being busy, the staff did NOT seem like they were working their first night. I also don’t think I’ve seen management so genuinely enthusiastic, which was certainly refreshing.

    Bottom line: Service is prompt and professional, pricing is more than fair (MUCH unlike Pi, which has a habit of breaking the bank for no good reason), and the product is phenomenal. If you’ve yet to go, do so.

  8. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Tys Says:

    By far the most unique dinning experience in the city.
    The pizza is superb, the service and atmosphere are all top notch.
    A lot of buzz is being generated about Piatto, which is a great sign for a restaurant just starting out. The only criticism is that the menu seems fairly limited, but i’m sure that won’t be a problem.

  9. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Servicecritic Says:

    I was quite excited to try piatto, always excited for new food in this city. We arrived at 5pm on Saturday, restaurant wasn’t too busy. We didn’t receive much of a greeting, just “sit wherever you like”. The server was flat and didn’t seem too exited that we were in the restaurant for the first time. No explaining of the menu or about the restaurant. I would expect my staff to welcome guests with some enthusiasm seeing that the are newly open. The rest of the time was much the same, basic service and lackluster. Service in this city is so off. It doesn’t take much to wow customers. Give them your best and SMILE. This is a fault of management not training their employees. The food redeemed the service but I will hesitate before I spend $75 for one app, a coke , water and one cappuccino and pizza for two adults and one child. I want so badly for a restaurant to give great service. I love to eat, shop and spend money. Make it easier please. I know that this is a one off but it is my FIRST impression. Make it great.

  10. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Yummy Says:

    I ate at Piatto twice in 4 days. Now that’s what I call good pizza! Unlike the poster above, I found the service to be quite doting. Particularly, the manager ensures you have enough water and wine in your glass, and checks back to see how you like the meal. I love the atmosphere too… very classy and fitting for the Italian theme. The prices are very fair too- for a bottle of wine, an appetizer, 2 pizzas and tip, the bill came to about $80. I can’t wait for the dessert menu to be developed! I’m sure it’s going to be just as delicious as the pizza.

  11. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Karen Says:

    The food was excellent and I liked the atmosphere. They had a limited wine and beer selection (and it was a tad expensive). I went on a Friday evening and it was pretty empty on arrival but really filled up quickly. By 6:30 the place was packed and people were waiting for tables to finish so they could be seated. The waitstaff were friendly but a little overwhelmed by the business. I tried a great pizza with artichokes and olives as well as the caprese salad. The mozza cheese they use is awesome!

  12. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Josh Says:

    i was so excited to try piatto and i was building it up so much in my mind that i caused it to really let me down. yes it is priced well, service is normal and the food was tasty; but if i spend 30 and still leave hungery im not very happy. there was not much to choose from and no desert. from talking to people there it seems like that is not going to change (except maybe desert). yes i may eat there again but i wouldn’t put it near the top of my list for restaurant’s or pizza in the city.

  13. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Amelia Says:

    I went to Piatto this evening for the first time, and I can quite honestly say that I experienced the WORST customer service in my whole life (and I have had my share of bad service).

    We originally had a party of 12 for a birthday gathering and wanted to make reservations in advance but were told we could not. The staff at Piatto said they would call when they could accomodate us, which was fine. They called and we went there. Upon arriving, the wait staff was told that we would require three extra chairs because three more guests would be arriving later. They said okay.

    One of the guests wanted a Smirnoff cooler, but they do not serve any type of coolers at Piatto. She asked the waitress to come back to her for her drink order in a moment, after getting the other orders at the table. The waitress did not return for her drink order until a half hour later. By this time, our appetizer orders had not been taken. The wait staff was reminded that we required three extra chairs, as the rest of the party would be arriving soon.

    A half hour later, the three extra guests arrived (appetizer orders had still not been taken), and the extra chairs had not been supplied. The guests stood in the middle of the restaurant awkwardly waiting to be accomodated. A waitress came over and told them that only bar stools were available, and the guests said that would be fine, they would take them until chairs became available. (There were unoccupied chairs throughout the restaurant.) The waitress said okay, walked away, and we all assumed she was going to fetch bar stools. She returned with a jug of water and walked away. There was an empty chair by the entrance of the restaurant nearby our table, so one of the guests got the chair and brought it to the table. The other guest fetched a bar stool, as it was better than standing in the middle of the restaurant. As the guest was bringing the stool to the table, he was stopped by a waiter who said he could not use the bar stool at the table. Meanwhile, a waitress literally pulled the chair from under the other guest and said that the table could not accomodate another chair. The patrons were again left standing and feeling embarrassed. I noticed other people in the restaurant look toward the wait staff in shock. The wait staff may have been trying to keep up the “posh” atmosphere by not overcrowding tables, but it clearly made everyone in the room feel uncomfortable. At this point, I, the three guests who arrived late, and another guest at our table (who had been there all along) decided to leave, as friends of ours were being treated very poorly by the wait staff. We went to another restaurant and met up with the rest of the party after. Those who ate at Piatto went directly to McDonald’s afterward because they were still hungry.

    We all felt terrible for the bad service, because the guests who arrived later were not catered to at all. Our table seemed to be ignored throughout the first hour we were there anyway, as our orders were not taken in that entire time.

    Some of the patrons did enjoy the pizza, but many were dissatisfied with the quantity of food; they left Piatto still feeling hungry.

    The experience at Piatto left a ‘sour taste’ in the mouths of 15 people who regularly go to restaurants. I will NEVER return to Piatto under any circumstance and will be more than willing to share my story. It is sad that the service was so terrible it was able to taint the birthday celebration of a patron.

    (I was forced to rate this restaurant 1 star, but I really would give it 0 stars.)

  14. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    stacey Says:

    I’m sorry, but honestly, you cannot expect any restaurant decent restaurant in this city, or anywhere, to accommodate 15 people at one table, especially when they don’t all arrived at once, and especially when they said there where 12 of them. Good ideas for birthday party meals are: buffets, your own house, (or mcdonalds, which I guess you like).
    Piatto’s staff may have not done the best thing, but you didn’t either.
    Additionally, I think that restaurant reviews should be posted by people who have actually eaten the food at said restaurant.
    I, for one, think Piatto is the best new place to eat in town. Go there and eat, and you’ll see why.

  15. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Matt Says:

    I had lunch at Piatto today and found the food and service to be absolutely fantastic. The pizza crust was like one I have never tasted before; crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. The decor was beautiful and trendy. Finally I would just like to say the service was spot on. The server was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. She answered all the questions I had about the menu.
    I don’t know where all the negative reviewers ate but it certainly wasn’t at Piatto. I highly recommend trying this place and forming your own opinion.

  16. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Emma Says:

    New favorite restaurant!

    After hearing and reading good reviews, I decided to surprise my boyfriend with dinner here for his birthday this past Friday night. We walked in and immediately felt at home – saw a few people we knew, the atmosphere was warm and cozy, and the service was prompt and friendly. (On the way in I whispered to our host that it was my dinner partner’s birthday, and when he left the table for a few moments later in the night she appeared quickly and asked what type of dessert he would like.)

    We had the fresh mozza and prosciutto appetizer (my favorite!), the bruchetta, and split a pizza and a bottle of wine – the Pinot Grigio was lovely – and the entire meal including tip and taxes came to $80. It was plenty of food; we couldn’t even finish the pizza. So worth it! We can’t wait to return.

  17. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Justin Says:

    Yes, the service was great, and yes the atmosphere was nice. The food however, sub-par. My salad was basically old lettuce with a vinaigrette dressing that left much to be desired. The pizza had clearly been left in the oven for too long, as there were multiple burnt bubbles in the crust (some very large ones that dominated a slice). The toppings were horribly spread, with some slices having just a dab of tomato sauce and a single mushroom (that clearly came from a can, by the way). I was hoping that the taste would overshadow the presentation, but it was nothing special. I wanted to like this place, I really did, but with the competition offering such fantastic tasting food I see no reason to dine here again.

  18. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Smokey Says:

    Burnt bubbles are the best.
    This is as authentic as it gets for traditional-style pizza in St John’s.
    If you like stuffed crust and cina-sticks, this is not the place to go.

  19. avatar
    Justin Says:

    I didn’t have pizza delight in mind when I said “competition”, but maybe I should have been more clear. I may also just be spoiled by the almighty Pi (thin crust, but not quite traditional).

  20. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Niki Says:

    Pi take note.

  21. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Gail Says:

    $80 for pizza and a bottle of wine?

    Just a little high priced dont ya think?

  22. avatar
    Emma Says:

    If you want to pay 15 bucks for a jumbo pizza and 2L of pop (and get dead bugs as an extra topping) there’s a little pizzeria in centre city that should suit you just fine. You’ll get your money’s worth.

    The $80 that we paid included taxes, a generous tip, a bottle of wine and more food than two of us could finish (two apps and a pizza).

    I suspect you haven’t eaten at Piatto and you’re basing your low rating on what you’ve read in others’ reviews.

  23. avatar
    Lanie Doe Says:

    Justin, I am willing to place money on the fact that you didnt find a canned mushroom on Piatto’s pie.

    From what I understand, their cheeses and meat and veg all are imported, so I highly doubt they are gonna scrimp and give yo No Name canned ‘shrooms on your pizza.

    Maybe it was a carmelized onion?

  24. avatar
    Gail Says:

    Its so obviuos that the staff here are placing all these reviews and posing as customers. It’s funny how a place that is opened about 3 months, has more reviews than The Keg ( which does about 6 million in annual sales ). I have yet to see anyone dining in here, but somehow it has over 20 reviews. And yes $80 is outrageous for Pizza and wine, I dont care what you are putting on for toppings.

  25. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Shtdstrbr Says:

    Could have also been sour grape.

  26. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Mark Says:

    As someone who works in the service industry, I get a little annoyed at how some people in this city think that they should be treated like some sort of royalty every time they grace the doors of a restaurant. I mean, do you really think that a waiter/waitress is going out of their way to give you terrible service? They do work for tips after all. I ate at Piatto a couple of nights ago, and yes I did have to wait a little while to get served, but that’s life people. Are you really in that much of a hurry? If your answer is yes, there’s a quarter pounder combo with your name all over it. However, you might not want to upsize, I hear that takes longer. Everybody at Piatto, from the chefs, to the wait-staff, to the bartender, were doing their darndest to keep up with the volume of customers, and doing quite a bang-up job from what I could see. From my experience, a busy restaurant is a good sign. Maybe if you want someone to tend on you hand and foot, there are more suitable options availible; like perhaps getting your significant other to feed you grapes whilst you lounge on the lanai. The pizza was amazingly authentic, tasty and very reasonably priced. The atmosphere was top notch. This is definitely a restaurant you should put on your list of places to try. And as you walk home from downtown with a belly full of Italian deliciousness, be sure to flash a smile and a wave to the Royals sitting at the window table of Biancas.

  27. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    lovestoeat Says:

    My Mom and I went there today for lunch. We usually eat lunch together downtown every two weeks and it was our first time at Piatto. We had heard great things from cabbies and friends and we were not disappointed. We got there at 1pm and the place was hopping. Wait staff was warm and welcoming and not flustered by the tempo. I had the prosciutto and fresh mozzarella app and my mom had the corn chowder, they were both delicious. Then we split a pizza. We were both full as eggs when we left. The wine, which was inexpensive for a restaurant, was lovely and went wonderfully with the meal. Having worked in the service industry, I really appreciated the attentive service. The quality of the food and the ingredients was wonderful. Well done folks and I wish you continued success.

  28. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    unclerodsknife Says:

    Went to Piatto tonight, had great pizza, tasty inexpensive bottles of wine and timely service. What more do people want for below-average prices? Try a resto in another large Canadian city if you’re not ready for this.

  29. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Lizzie B Says:

    Such a lot of fuss! Anyone not liking change should read the menus and prices at the door of a new restaurant and move on if you’re unsure. This is unlike other food and service here in town, and that’s Okay! I’m not a big fan of Champagne or caviar but I have tried both and appreciate cost/value even if it’s not to my taste.
    Piatto’s dough is worth at least one try; it is so good! Mmmmm to the burnt bits, mmmmmm to the under-loaded toppings. Any may I say, good by to almightly birthday tables of 12-15. You should stick with restaurants where you can make a reservation and who cater to larger parties. I’m glad you didn’t come to my restaurant!
    Thank you Piatto for bringing Italy to St. John’s.

  30. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    ejb Says:

    Went to Piatto and can say I’ve never had pizza like this before. The crust is well-made and the toppings are fresh…. A note to other pizza vendors: your dough shouldn’t be thick as a loaf of bread! Learn by example here.

    I like their decision to be a pizzeria and not an Italian restaurant, it lets them focus their attention (and ours!) on something they do incredibly well. The wine list is concise but there’s definitely something there for everyone. The bar has pretty much all the staples, though that is definitely not the main attraction here.

    I think the best thing to get here is the Diavola made as a calzone, caramelized onions are a wonderful thing.

  31. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Sonja Says:

    I ate at Piatto earlier tonight and I wasn’t that impressed. It wasn’t bad but based on the reviews I was expecting a lot more. We arrived around six, and there was only one other couple there. The waitress was quick to take our drink order, however I was less than satisfied with their selection of beers and wines. Then I started to browse through the menu and I was disappointed. I can understand not wanting an enormous menu, however, it was very very limited. I found that the only difference between some of the pizzas were one topping swapped for another. We ordered the Napoletana Foccacia for an app. It was ok, fairly dry, and somewhat bland. I had the Diavola pizza. As already mentioned here several times, the crust was amazing! However the sauce had no flavour and the spiciness of the salame overpowered the flavour of the caramelized onions. Toppings were sparse as well, and not evenly distributed. I found myself taking onions off one half and putting them on the other to even it out so I wasnt eating a slide with just cheese, and one slice didn’t even have any cheese… I did eat my meal and it was more than enough food, and it didn’t taste bad but I wasn’t impressed with the flavours. The prices were reasonable. Our meal came to $65 for an app, 3 beer, and 2 pizzas. Will I go back again? maybe… if someone asked me to go with them sure, but I wouldn’t make a point to go back.

  32. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Elizabeth Says:

    Don’t be paranoid. I ate there tonight and commented. It was okay and I expected to pay the price because it is a higher end restaurant. People, I think, comment because we are so deprived here in St. john’s with regard to restaurants and when people find something they have never had before they go crazy and think it’s the best thing ever. If you have nothing to compare it to but know there is something better than take-out pizza out there, you will give it a rave review. If you have only take-out pizza to compare it to and don’t know there is anythng better, you are shocked at the price, and like you did, will leave a bad review. I have eaten at restaurants in Italy and in many Italian restaurants in Europe and as I said, Piatto is okay but it is not authentic and it is not the best, just the best that we have. I really don’t think that the staff are posting the comments here…I mean really! :) And as for The Keg…way overrated and way expensive, but again, the best we have.

  33. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Paul Says:

    I heard about Piatto a few weeks back, and my girlfriend and I decided to try it out last night for the first time.

    For the most part, it’s a really great new restaurant. The waitress was really concerned and helpful with everything, so the service was great. As well, the pizza had a very distinctive, unique taste to it (because Piatto cooks their pizzas in a 900-degree oven for less than two minutes). And for anyone looking for vegetarian/vegan options, they’ve got it. The food was really good; the price very reasonable.

    The only downside would be the god-awful Blue Rodeo music playing in the background for about an hour. I’ve been at Pi, they play the Smiths, and they have incredible service and salmon pizza, to boot.

    So, if you’re looking for a vegan pizza or an evening experience, it’s Piatto. If you’re looking for a great lunch, service and music, it’s Pi. At least for me, anyway.

  34. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    yowsers Says:

    We have gone to piatto about 7 times since november. The food there is absolutly amazing. We have gone there to eat AND taken the pizza home.. both are fantastic but the pizza is a little better when you can actually sit there and eat it (so fresh!)
    Their ceaser salad has one of the most unique tasting ceaser dressing that I have ever tasted.. it’s worth the 7 bucks!
    The service is friendly. However, the last girl we had was so giddy that every time she would take our dishes away she would spin and hop away, literally. We had a little chuckle at it, none the less.
    I would recommend this restaurant to anyone that wants to enjoy a great meal in the cozyness of downtown.. a 10 out of 10 for sure!
    * And as for the person who commented about them not being able to seat 15 people. You need to stop writing reviews. It’s a good thing no one can see your name and recognize who you are, I would be so embarssed to write that if I were you!

  35. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Julia Says:

    Why are people in St. John’s so in love with the Keg!? Yes the food is alright but nothing special and really overpriced. I’m not a staff member of Piatto, just a resident of St. John’s that thinks people need to get over franchise restaurants like The Keg, BP, Montanas, etc.

  36. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Food Says:

    Ate there a while back, the place was full so we had to go up stairs and wait, what a waste of space, there should be more tables up stairs as the guy working up there told us we were the first people he saw all night up there. They also didn’t have the ability to transfer a beer upstairs to our bills down stairs, really?

    The pizza was good, but I was starving when I left.

    Pi is much better in terms of taste and value and friendly service!

  37. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    LA Says:

    By chance, we had supper there tonight. It was excellent. The place was packed so we went upstairs in the lounge. It is very cosy and a great spot for a drink while you wait. We split the olive/ proscuitto/ pepper platter ~ fresh & delicious, great for 2 We had 2 glasses of house white and split a Sicilian pizza which was tasty and rich. For dessert panacotta & a tiramisu which was the best I have ever tasted. I might go back just for this alone. The service was prompt, friendly and helpful. The black/ white/ grey/ red decor scheme is classic and contemporary. When this resto was under previous owners, the room was quite cold, perhaps the huge pizza oven remedies this. Overall, it was an excellent evening for under 70.00 including tip. WE WILL BE BACK!

  38. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    beaver Says:

    Had piatto a few nights ago. Service was fine, and nice decor/atmosphere, but out of the 3 times I’ve been there i’ve never had a pizza i’ve overly enjoyed. Its ok, but i dont think its all what people make it out to be. Definitely not worth the price they charge.

    I’m not a foodie, but I am an adventurous eater. This just wasnt my thing i guess. The cheese on the quattro fromaggio (spelling?) tasted like feet. maybe thats how its supposed to taste, but Im not sure why people enjoy that taste. doubt i’ll be back.

  39. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    dick walsh Says:

    pros: food was awesome, having chili oil as well as other extra toppings makes going there seem like a treat or at least something different. the interior decorating was nice, nothing too spectacular. the types of pizza they offered were very good and they all sounded like something I’d like to try in the future. prices were reasonable for the amount of food you get, but perhaps they need a cheaper smaller side, I almost couldn’t finish my pizza yet I didn’t want to pay the full price either, a smaller pizza for like $10-11 would be great.

    Cons: the price, although justified by the quantity, was a little more than I wish to pay as a student, but that’s the type of establishment you know you’re going to so that’s really no big deal. another thing I found was that although I was given a knife it was useless for actually cutting my pizza. now this was my first time there so I wasn’t sure if it was uncouth to eat it with my hands, but I stopped caring about my hand started to ache.

    overall it is a very tasty pizza, it’s something new to the area and I would certainly eat there again in the future.

  40. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Elliott Says:

    I would like to agree with this review whole-heartedly. The food is delicious but sometimes it is definitely too much. Having the smaller option would make me go more often… And in the end, isn’t that what a restaurant needs (now, this season they are pretty busy so I can’t fault them for crowding their restaurant with people who will pay full price rather than giving a cheaper option. Think about this: dollars per hour. Ask for a smaller pizza in the winter!!!)

  41. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Ruby Says:

    We went to Piatto later in the evening on Saturday night. There were 3 adults and one little guy, 1 1/2 years old.

    It took a second for someone to come see us after we sat done, but once they did the service was great as was the food.

    The Caprese salad is great with fresh mozzarella and basil, as well as sea salt and the best balsamic vinegar ever.

    The pizzas were awesome, and so was the wine, and we really appreciated how nice the servers were with the kiddo. They actually took him back to see the oven, let him sit on the scooter in the front window and gave him some dough to play with.

    One of the best spots in town, for sure!

  42. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Allison Says:

    I had Piatto this past Saturday evening – wow! First things first, the decor was top notch. It had this real effortless, casual yet chic European vibe to it. Some people aren’t really too concerned with this, but if you’re a fan of the complete dining experience – great ambience, music AND food – this is the place. We walked in, sat down and I sort of felt like we had all entered into a different city. Were we in St. John’s still?

    We all had the caesar salad to start, and all enjoyed it. It had a tangy yet simple dressing. We also had the selection of cured meats with olives & roasted peppers. I enjoyed it but some felt the cold cuts were a little too waxy (a little personal preference comes into play here). I had the Diavola pizza and it was delish! This, my friends, is real pizza (I’m a lover of thin crust) If you’re a fan of Sal’s or Delissio do yourself a favour and please don’t compare or expect anything remotely like that! We’re comparing chalk and cheese here. I tried somebody else’s Siciliani but wasn’t overly into it. My personal opinion was that the red pepper had sogged the crust a little. I’m thinking if I had have ordered the Siciliani pizza I may not have been ranting and raving. Sometimes your menu choices come into play!

    I passed on dessert but had a lovely cappucino. All in all, a great evening. I would highly recommend!

  43. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Steve Says:

    I went once and only once, they do not know what they are doing.
    It’s Tuscany on the cheap for all the girls I see in there… ha ha.
    Awful pizza.

  44. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Glen & Nicole Says:

    - really good service
    - fast
    - really nice interior

  45. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Glen & Nicole Says:

    Positives
    - Really good service
    - Food was ready fast
    - Nice atmosphere, The Place looked great!
    - Food was delicious, Cooked perfectly
    Negitives
    - Small menu selection (Not alot to choose from)
    - Not alot of variety among the choices (More Veggies!)

  46. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    A Says:

    My boyfriend and I had a wonderful experinace here! We thought we would try our luck on a Saturday evening without a reservation and were told we could eat in the upstairs bar if we wanted to as the downstairs was crazy full! The upstairs area is warm and cozy, very relaxed. We had two glasses of wine that were generous and well priced, a delishious and fresh bruschetta, and two lovely, very filling meals! Not to mention the best flourless chocolate cake I’ve ever had.

    The service? Absolutly no complaints! It was so busy I would have expected to wait a lot longer, and with only one waitress in the upstairs area she totally held her own.

  47. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Morgan Murray Says:

    I don’t get why they don’t take reservations. It sure would be nice to get in once in a while without having to wait forever. They told us they wouldn’t even put us on the waiting list over the phone, but if someone from our party wanted to go down in person they would. Must it be that difficult?

  48. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    W Says:

    I like Piatto. I like it’s simplicity. They don’t have a huge menu, but it does change from time to time and they do have specials on. I don’t think we need 50 things on a menu to make a place good.

    I feel strongly that the pricing is reasonable. The pizza I like most is the Margherita Pizza. It’s very simple, basil, cheese and sauce! It’s 12 bucks and it’s tastey! The wine is cheap, the deserts taste great and the few apps I’ve had have been tastey too!

    It’s just pizza… and I like it!

  49. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    mark Says:

    What a rubbish review. It’s an Italian restaurant, not Vegan!

    I wish I could give you one star. Freakin’ hipster.

  50. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Chad Says:

    Pros:

    -Crust is phenomenal. Fairly thin but soft and “fluffy” as it should be.

    -Toppings are obviously fresh and authentic. Specifically the mozzarella cheese is unlike anything you’ll find elsewhere in town.
    Decent wine selection and fairly priced.

    -The atmosphere is welcoming with a modern style. The large pizza oven projects quite a bit of heat which keeps even the farthest seating areas toasty warm.

    -The staff are quite knowledgeable about the menu as well as wine selection and won’t hesitate to make an appropriate suggestion if asked.

    -We were seated immediately on a busy friday evening, the place was packed. We waited roughly 5 minutes to have our drink orders taken, 10 minutes for our appetizers to be brought out and another 5 for our pizza. Excellent!
    ______________________________________________________

    Cons:

    -The Price. As expected, the cost in comparison to the quantity of food is certainly above average, however it is made up for by the delicious toppings. An order of two appetizers, one pizza (shared), two drinks and a tip came to $50. Unfortunately we left still feeling a little hungry.

    Overall:
    -If you want to taste a real pizza, give this place a shot. It is a bit pricey but what do you expect, it’s a business, and it’s obviously managed very well. I do recommend that unless you weigh in at less than 110 pounds, you order a whole pizza for yourself as the thin crust makes it go down very quickly!

    A great experience and I will definitely be going there again in the future.

  51. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    H Says:

    Fantastic! Went last night for my birthday. I was afraid we might not get a table so we went early and didn’t have any trouble at all – got the booth at the back with a great view of the pizza oven!

    The food was delicious! Especially the thin, crispy crust, the awesome tomato sauce and amazing mozzarella! Our service was also fantastic – we were slow at deciding, but she checked back frequently and never rushed us. Once we got our food, we were checked on repeatedly to see if we needed anything.

    The only downside I think is the drink selection – I’m not a wine drinker and would have liked more selection in beers and maybe some mixed drinks to choose from.

    Great dining experience! I will definitely be back again… and soon!

  52. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    S Says:

    The atmosphere was fantastic!
    We had a bit of a tricky seating situation with people showing up later than the rest of the group but the staff were more than helpful once the later guests arrived.

    By far the best dough I’ve ever eaten.
    I’m not a fan of restaurants with huge portions that leave you bloated, but I would recommend ordering an appetizer with your meal as the pizza alone left most of our group wanting more.

    The price was what I expected for a restaurant of that nature.
    I believe I paid around 40$ (including a tip) for 2 glasses of wine and a calzoni.

    I’ll definitely be back!

  53. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    L Says:

    The Siciliani is hands down the best pizza I’ve ever eaten.

  54. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    J Says:

    There ipad reservation thing wasn’t working on Friday night and didn’t receive my text, so we were bumped to the wait line again, that time we gave them a different number and one of my friends replied to the text that it sent. AGAIN, they didn’t receive it. When we told them that it wasn’t working and that we ended up having to wait over an hour for a table when it was supposed to be 30 minutes, nothing, not the slightest bit of concern or care. Also, the woman working the door was quite rude and has no concept of customer service.

    I do love the pizza, but the service left a sour taste.

  55. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Left Hungry Right Says:

    I went there for lunch with my bf and came out paying $70 and left hungry.
    Not cool.
    1. App: Salad didnt have enough dressing on it and a light sprinkle of toppings for $8.
    2. Paid 18.50$ for a veggie pizza and wasnt impressed with their use of canned black olives, not very italian bys. And the pizza was really greasy and wet.
    3. I also found it weird that they use tumblers for their wine, instead of wine glasses, felt cheap.
    Overall I thought they were chincy with the food and overcharged me.
    For sure wont be returning again. Sorry Piatto first impressions.

  56. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Anomi Moose Says:

    Actually the tumblers are authentic, that’s what they drink wine from in Italy.

  57. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Lark Says:

    Finally went there for dinner – loved it. Our bill topped $90 for two, but we each had an app, a pizza, and admittedly went overboard with the drinks – I think there were 4 beer and a glass of wine, so that’s where the cost spiked.

    The apps were good – caesar and meatballs – and the pizzas were delicious. I had the Stephanie and I had to comment on how yummy it was each time I took a bite. It was way too big to finish and I took half of it home for another second dinner the next day.

    Would like to try the wine tasting meal for $30.

  58. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Shaun Says:

    After much hype I finally ate here before a hockey game last week. And I have to be honest, I was very disappointed. Every person I talk to seem to love this place, so maybe it takes more than my 37 years to acquire a taste for burnt pizza and piss warm beer.

    I will go back because I had a white base pizza and I must admit my dining partner’s tomato base looked more appetizing.

  59. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Nicky Says:

    This place is great. The pizza actually reminded me of pizza I ate when I was in Rome so you can’t get any more Italian than that! And we actually brought our Italian Grandmother here to eat, and she thought it was fantastic so I don’t think I need to say more.

    The salads, apps, wine and pizza were all delicious and our server was excellent. Keep up the great work!!

  60. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Bethany Says:

    Ate here a few weeks ago for the second time. We were seated upstairs which we initially thought was great….except that it was FREEZING!! I felt like keeping my jacket on and was glad I decided to wear an extra sweater despite the fact it was October and not really that cold out!! The food was ok – the service was ok…..all in all, unfortunately nothing spectacular!!

  61. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Melissa Says:

    Last night was my second time at this restaurant and again the food was delicious. We went for my bf’s birthday and had two apps, a bottle of wine, a pizza and a dessert with the bill totalling $77.00 and we were both full :)The service was also excellent! My only complaint is that they don’t do reservations. We didn’t have to wait very long but it would be nice to be able to book ahead. Definately will be going there again.

  62. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    East End Boy Says:

    Having dined in Italy, dining at Piatto was very reminiscent of that! Great atmosphere, wonderful food (taste, selection, portions); the only constructive criticism that I have is that I noticed that, often the servers seemed more engaged in their own conversations rather than attending to the customers. Love this restaurant, can’t wait to go back soon!

  63. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Happy Hummer Says:

    Food is pretty good there, but the service is the reason we’ve never gone back for a second look. The one time we did eat there the server would disappear for long stretches of time, and we ended up waiting over an hour to get a pizza. Maybe when the “servers” start focusing on customers as opposed to each other, we might re-visit the idea of going again. But from the other reviews, I can tell that’s not yet the case.

  64. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Danielle Says:

    My boyfriend treated me to Piatto for our Valentine’s Day dinner on the 15th, and as expected it was beyond delightful. This was our second time dining here, and the restaurants non-reservation policy really worked in our favour.

    We were asked for a cellphone number which was typed into a fancy little app and we waited for a seat to be made available. After a short waiting period an automatic text was sent to my boyfriend’s phone telling us there was a vacant table. I have to say this is probably my favourite part about Piatto, it gave us the chance to walk around a little bit rather than wait inside the restaurant.

    Our server (the manager) was kind and chatty, and she often pooped by to see how we were doing. It was incredibly busy that night, so we would have understood had she not been able to come by often, but she did. Our pizzas were burned in the oven and she took the time to come by to apologize. We weren’t in any kind of rush since our appetizer came at a quick pace, and we could tell it must’ve been stressful for the workers. They remade the pizzas for us, but the fact that she took the time to come and apologize was very A+ for me.

    When our food did come it was nothing short of delicious. Well cooked, the dough was just how I like it, the meats and vegetables were well prepared and everything was well put together.

    We finished our meal with delicious coffees and were incredibly satisfied with the service.

    Needless to say we left big tips.

    Piatto has become my boyfriend and I’s go-to date restaurant. I’ve yet to have a bad experience and the decor and staff make me feel right at home.

    10/10 Would eat there again, and then recommend to friends and family.

  65. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    anon Says:

    Jeez by, she pooped on your table and you gave them 5 stars? table poops is 3 stars max.

  66. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    K Says:

    Food was great. Prices were a little high. Service was a little bad.

    There’s too many great places to eat in this city to come back to a place that doesn’t refil your water and hardly checks on you when it’s not very busy. I’d have to really be craving pizza made with fruit… but Old Town is a better bang for my buck so I’d rather gpick up a full pizza and a bottle of wine and eat that in the middle of bannerman than go back to this place.

    Like I said, pizza was good, but das it.

  67. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    op Says:

    The food is tasty and the ingredients are fresh. The restaurant is clean and offers a pleasant environment. The food is slightly expensive and the menu is limited. It is great that they will make the food to order. The staff is friendly and service is reasonably fast even when it is busy. Sometimes the pizzas have the toppings unevenly distributed and sometimes the dough is soft in the middle but it seems like it depends on who’s making it.

  68. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    g Says:

    I really do love Piatto, and it is quickly becoming a regular spot for my boyfriend and I on a friday night. The app they use to keep track of tables is brilliant! It’s great to be able to pop next door to the Republic for a drink while waiting, and not having to keep watching the clock. The service there has always been great. My boyfriend and I loved the strawberry bellini’s, but the glasses were quite small and we like to drink :) The server had no problem making a pitcher of them for us, and only charged us the price of the bottle of prosecco.
    The pizza is delicious. I will admit there have been times where it was better than others, but I have never had a bad experience. I have eaten in many pizzerias and Piatto keeps up with some of the top ones in Toronto. Desserts are great as well. I always leave well fed and watered, with leftovers in hand (they don’t last too long). And I always marvel at how reasonable our bill is. Highly highly recommend.

You can write a review right away below or you can log in here. (New user? Sign up here!)


    • Don't have an account? . Takes just a minute or two.

  • Leave a Review