The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Cellar Restaurant

Cellar Restaurant

  • 3.383.383.383.383.38
9 reviews (write your own)

189 Water Street, St. John’s
579-8900

Go back to the restaurant list
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.

9 Reader Reviews of Cellar Restaurant

(6 positive, 2 negative)
  1. avatar
    clark party (new years 2009) Says:

    we had great anticipation of going to this resturant as our first new years eve together. Our reservation was for 930pm, upon arrival being fashonably early, as to maybe secure a seat just to have a few drinks before our meal which was preordered from a menu specifically for new years eve, we were standing by the door which was becoming like a lineup to burger king . Left waiting with no one coming by to ask us our name for the reservation , we approached the maitre de who then went off to see if our table was ready, to return to tell us it would be about 15 minute wait but there was no seating to be had whilst we waited. Finally we were sat at a two seater inside the bar area which was very bright (not able to dim the lights ) and very cold to the door being open and closed ..i was unfortunate enough to be wearing new years eve outfit which wasnt fitting for the frigid temperatures inside the area.I then asked if we could be moved as i was bivering from being so cold. We were then escorted to a much more lively table inside the main dining room , only to be left there for maybe an hour before I actually had to ask would there be a server tending to us , and was told there was but alas my partner had to go to the bar to order us drinks!!!!! another half hour had passed before our tapas( finger samples) had arrived , which we tasty but not that great , another trip to the bar later , and as another hour had passed we had finally received our appetizers of clam chowder (which there was barely any of , and very spicy , breathtaking actually) and I with my french onion soup which was fair to middlin, we than asked how long it would be before our main course would arrive and was told it would arrive shortly (being now 1120) , as we waited another 5-10 mins we noticed the staff bring out champagne goblets and the champagne before the main meal had actually arrived …we were severely disppointed to say the least and decided if this evening was to go to spoil and decided to leave early enough as to view the fireworks at least we would end the evening on a good note …we were totally ignored , as my partner went to the bar one last and final time to pay for the farce , the maitre d bought the card back to the table with no receipt and when we inquired as to why we didnt recieve a receipt was told NO CHARGE , well that was about the only thing they did do right …wonder what happened …oh well enjoyed a lovely hot turkey sandwich at a resturant further up the street , after the fireworks ….will definelty not recommend this place to anyone ON A BUSY NIGHT OBVIUOSLY THEY LACK ORGANIZATION ESPECIALLY AFTER PREORDERING …VERY VERY BAD SERVICE

  2. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    an accidental foodie Says:

    Lovely atmosphere, friendly service, but very overpriced. My husband and I went for dinner one evening after working late (arrived around 8:00pm). I had called earlier that day to ensure this wouldn’t be too late for the kitchen, and the woman on the phone was very friendly. She said this would be fine.

    When we arrived, our coats were taken and we were seated at a lovely table in the main dining room. The ambience was great and had a very warm, comfortable feeling. A server came by, took our drink order and advised us of the specials, most of which inlcluded oysters this evening. For an appetizer, my husband had the mussels, which were one of the specials and I had the mushroom ravioli with herb butter sauce. The ravioli were very tasty, the portion size a little conservative, but flavourful. The texture of the mushrooms filling would have been nicer had it included some sauteed mushrooms instead of a puree, but still very nice. The butter sauce was a little oily, but other than that it was fine. The mussels were delicious with a very generous portion. I kept trying to sneak some from my husbands plate. They were very good, cooked and seasoned perfectly.

    I had ordered the shrimp and scallop risotto, which turned out not to really be a risotto at all. It didn’t appear to be arborio rice, just regular long grain rice. The rice was not creamy enough to be a risotto and was underseasoned. It was a little glutinous in texture and although I could see the telltale yellow of saffron, I could not taste it at all. I am aware that the term risotto only refers to the method of cooking, as opposed to the type of rice used, but if this rice was truly cooked risotto style, it should have had a much better texture. The shrimp and scallops were cooked well, but it would have been nice if the scallops were browned a little. They appeared to be steamed in the risotto itself. They were very tender and sweet, but again underseasoned. My husband ordered the roasted rack of lamb, which, again, was very good. The lamb was cooked very well and seasoned perfectly, the side vegetables and potatoes were very flavourful. Both portion sizes were generous, as well. We skipped dessert that night as it was getting a little late.

    The bathroom was downstairs and while they had nice products/handsoap, it very much reminded me of a highschool bathroom. It was also a little confusing to find once I went downstairs, it was almost like a storage room down there at first. While no one really goes to a restaurant for the bathrooms, they certainly can make a difference should you need to use one (best ones so far are probably Portobello’s).

    All in all, I give this 3 out of 5 stars. It was pretty run of the mill, but it was very overpriced for the food we received. All in all, not bad. All of the problems I had with my meal could mostly be fixed with some salt and good rice. I wish I had ordered what my husband had as his food was great. The server was friendly and attentive and we didn’t feel rushed at all, despite our later dinner time. The host at the bar was also very friendly and congratulated us on hearing we were newlyweds. Again, the atmosphere of the dining room was great and comfortable. The central staircase is very beautiful, as was the artwork. I’d probably eat at The Cellar again, but for probably only for lunch. I wouldn’t want to risk having a similar meal for those prices again.

  3. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    4Real Foodie Says:

    The restaurant business is a fairly transient one. Restaurants come and go,but The Cellar has been around for about 20 years. The reason for their longevity is good food and good service,a couple of simple concepts that few can master.

    I would be remiss if I didn’t comment on the above 2 reviewers. You cannot go out on a night like New Years Eve and expect things to go smoothly,they never do. This would probably be THE only time you go out to a decent restaurant and have the unmitigated gall to complain.By the way,don’t complain about the cold if you aren’t dressed for it,this is St. John’s not The Bahamas. The staff likely realized quickly that you are “amateurs” and wouldn’t be back again if they gave you free food.

    For the second reviewer-I am not sure what you are accustomed to in terms of fine dining and pricing,but I can assure you,by the standards of anyone who knows the difference, The Cellar is reasonable,considering the high food and overhead costs associated with running a restaurant. Myself and a friend ate there a week ago,we had 5 appetizers (no entrees),a bottle of wine,2 highballs,2 coffees,all for $136. We were stuffed,the food was the amazing,the service equally as good.Also,one note on Risotto-this is one dish I would never order in a restaurant,Im not even sure why a restaurant would offer it.Good risotto has to be made fresh,served immediately (this is going to take 30+ minutes any way you slice it) and not reheated.In a restaurant the risotto would have to be prepped in advance and it just doesn’t translate well.FYI,the term “risotto” has nothing to do with the preparation,it literally means “little rice”.

  4. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Reviewer Says:

    Okay, 4Real Foodie, do you think that you’re a professional food critic or something? I highly doubt that you are if you’re posting you’re opinion on the internet. Real food critics would post their reviews/opinions in a magazine or newspaper. You cannot judge someone else’s opinion on a restaurant unless you were there at the time or you were the chef. I think what you have said is pretty ridiculous. I’ve been at The Cellar myself and the food and service is alright, but the prices are way out of line. $46 for a steak;a New York Strip, not even a Tenderloin. I’ve also been at Atlantica and I only paid $42 for their Rib-Eye. My experience at The Cellar was mediocre, so I would give it three stars, hopefully next time I go things will have improved.
    So, next time you should think about criticizing someone’s experience at a restaurant, because you may think you know, but really, YOU HAVE NO IDEA!

  5. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    4Real Foodie Says:

    Ok,Reviewer-I am not a professional food critic,apparently you need no credentials to be one though,ask Karl Wells. You slam me for my opinion about the two reviewers,yet you do exactly the same to me. I worked in the restaurant business up until 3 years ago,so I have been around the block, so to speak. As for Atlantica,yes it’s good and yes the prices may be somewhat in line with The Cellar,but you have to remember,for the average joe who likes to dine out,I can walk to The Cellar,or get there for an $8 cab,and I’m still downtown if I want to take in some nightlife. To go to Atlantica,if I cannont procure a ride (again,Im an average joe who doesn’t have limo service at my disposal) it means a $30 cab each way,then if I want to go downtown to catch a show another $8 to get home-that’s $68 in cabs (before tip). So,while Atlantica is great for a treat,it doesn’t have the accessibility of a downtown restaurant,so they can’t be too too aggressive in their pricing.

  6. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Lizzie Says:

    I have loved my Cellar experiences although my boyfriend refuses to go back, even with our $100. gift certificates. He felt the prices are too obnoxious to return. I think the food is great – there is no better steak in town and that Crab Chowder is to die for. I will go without him and enjoy the free meal!
    I have to agree with the comments made re: New Year’s Eve and other special occassions – it’s an unfair time to judge a restaurant. Too bad they didn’t pull it off but you should give them one more chance.

  7. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Reviewer Says:

    I still have not had another chance to revisit The Cellar, but I have recently visited Bianca’s for lunch. It was reasonably priced; $95 for two including tax and tip. The food was as always very tasty and very well presented and the service was also good, but I won’t go into detail about that here and now. I was just wondering, 4Real Foodie, how you managed to contact Mr.Karl Wells and ask him that question, I would appreciate knowing that answer. About that though, maybe you don’t “need” credentials to be a food critic, but to really be recognized and respected as a food critic, yes some credentials and experience would greatly help. Another thing, I was not “slamming” you, I was merely saying that you should not criticize other people’s opinions of restaurants. I don’t know about you, but when I go out for a fine dinning experience I don’t look to just casually waltz in, grab a bite to eat and then go out for a night on the town. I walk in with very high expectations and spend a couple of hours enjoying the ambiance and cuisine. If I’m paying higher prices, I expect every aspect of the experience to be near perfection. It matters not to me how much I have to pay for the experience, but when I pay what I do, everything had better be excellent. So, 4Real Foodie no hard feelings and I thank-you.

  8. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    JD Says:

    Although we eat out at a decent restaurant weekly it had been years since we were at the Cellar. It’s not a place that we typically think of and now I remember why…it’s overpriced with terrible service! We were jammed in the bar which meant we were cold during the entire meal. We asked to be moved and told that there were no other tables. Interesting point considering that a table the same size sat idle prior to asking and after we left in the main dining area.

    The server while friendly enough was better suited to working Jungle Jim’s. LONG times between her visits to our table, bread arrived after appetizers, water glasses were often empty, she was not aware of how the food was prepared when asked (ie. is this soup cream based we asked…answer I’m not sure. It’s creamy but I don’t think they use cream. No offer to go to the kitchen to ask so we just moved on not sure she would even check if we asked). A series of such events continued and topped off by having the bills incorrectly prepared.

    There was a bright spot with some of the food though which is worthy of leaving 2 stars. The mussels were very good and the pork was excellent. However the steak was average and the salmon was a bit overcooked with too much maple sauce (think salmon pancakes!).

    When a restaurant charges higher prices, you are paying for the entire experience which is a combination of atmosphere, physical surroundings, service, and food. A cold location in a bar area combined with ill informed and inattentive service and food that was hit or miss only gives this place 2 stars.

    Do yourself a favour and skip this place. Try Bianca’s, Gypsy Tea Room, Chinched, etc etc etc. Or better yet keep rolling down the street to try Raymond’s. I haven’t been there yet but hearing great things. Hoping to go there soon though and will post a review.

  9. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    yowsers Says:

    We have been to the cellar 3 times so far and out of these times i would give it a rating of 5/10. It’s sometimes hit or miss there. The first time we went the appetizers were fabbbbb, but the entree we could have done without, there was so much goat cheese on the chicken it was unlike anything I have ever seen before. The second time we went it was much better, again, the appetizers were amazing. The service is so-so. It’s the little details that they fail on. We sat at a table (in the dark basement) without a candle, after being seated for 30 minutes and 2 waitresses coming back saying “oh, i’ll get a candle for you”, we finally got one half way through our meal. We got over it. – I hate it when people complain about little stuff like this, but really I understand your busy,but is it that hard to light a damn candle?
    We recently went for our third visit, and this time really did it for me. I had such high expectations because the last 2 visits there were really no major problems. This time the waitress went so fast explaining the entree specials that when she left the table we were still trying to realise what she had said. The first time we were told they had blackened cajun halibut, and then when we asked again, she said it was blackened cajun cod. Confused, I ordered the cod, as per her suggestion, only to be served with fish that was anything BUT cajun. It was just black and looked like it had been soaked in water for the past couple hours. It had ZERO taste and it was just as well they put a glass of water on my plate because that’s what it tasted like. The ceaser salad was ok, but again, no flavor. The appetizers we ordered were good, we had the scallops, which arrived cold(i could have dealt with this if i had just been served a nice, tasty entree!!), and cod tounges. I really, really didn’t want to be disappointed, but we were 100% not satisfied. It will be a while before we go back.
    DO NOT ORDER THE BLACKENED COD. A glass of water will suffice.

You can write a review right away below or you can log in here. (New user? Sign up here!)


    • Don't have an account? . Takes just a minute or two.

  • Leave a Review