The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Blue on Water

Blue on Water

  • 2.452.452.452.452.45
21 reviews (write your own)

319 Water Street, St. John’s, NL
754-2583
www.blueonwater.com

Go back to the restaurant list
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.

21 Reader Reviews of Blue on Water

(9 positive, 11 negative)
  1. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    May Stafford Says:

    The best meal that I have EVER eaten was in this restaurant (Blue on Water). The people were pleasant and the service was great. We had a table of 5 for dinner and everyone at the table agreed that the meal was excellent. I went again for lunch. There was three of us and once again, the lunch was excellent.

  2. avatar
    pea Says:

    there is nothing better in this universe than the banana pancakes. nothing.

  3. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Jane Says:

    Ate Brunch there on my Birthday. Although service was great, food was extremely slow even with a fairly empty dining room, meal was mediocre at best, nothing special for the price we paid.

  4. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Not Impressed At ALL! Says:

    My wife and I went there to enjoy a “nice” meal in what I have heard was a great place…Well there were two other tables in the entire restaurant occupied the entire time we where there, yet we still couldn’t sit by the window….Okay get passed it…Took 23 minutes..yes I timed it…for me to get a beer….The meal was okay at best…my wife enjoyed her Salmon, and I received a slab of meat that just stopped beating b/c the blood was all over my plate when I asked for it to be cooked “medium rare” not just killed and put on the plate…since it took over 20 minutes for my beer and since the time between getting our appetizer and meal was over an hour…we were eager to get out of there and not complain…why do you ask since this wasn’t going to be a moderately priced meal?? B/C we were just so unimpressed we wanted out…But the real kicker….was when the girl (who lacks any form of professionalism) kept our card in her hand until the receipt printed and she could see her tip amount…Now granted I don’t know what she expected from us, but I certainly didn’t expect or appreciate her scarcastic oh thanks…from her $20 tip….Only b/c my wife made me do that, she got anything at all!!! We went to some coffee place on water after a stroll of cooling off from Blue and sat and enjoyed dessert with a better atmosphere and service! I would not return!!!!

  5. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    William Says:

    Went to Blue for dinner with my girlfriend. Firstly service was good. It was the end of slow night and the waitress was attentive to her three tables. We both ordered a glass of white wine, 20 dollars for wine that tasted like homebrew, hope they saved a bundle. Our appetizer was very good(escargot), and well presented. I ordered pork tenderloin wrapped in proscuito. The meat was delicious and well cooked. It was served on a bed of rice, which was drenched in a buttery soy based sauce, SALTY! She had the salmon special. Again the fish was well prepared, but drenched in a similar soy based sauce that took over the fish, and the bed of rice, so salty she didnt finish. We both drank about three glasses of water while there.
    One hundred dollars later and I wondered what i paid for? Why hadn’t I gone to the Afghan restaurant and saved the other 80$?
    Overall, overpriced mediocre food, and severely overpriced wine list, it starts at 50$ for an average bottle!

  6. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    KB Says:

    Had brunch there today for the second time. The first time was great, so I decided to go back with my sister. Terrible! The food was ok. Eggs were burned, toast was burned, bacon was undercooked and slimy. The man who served us was dismissive and a little rude. Never asked if we wanted more coffee or tea, and once our food was delivered by a different server (understandable, I know you can’t be everywhere at once) he totally ignored us for the rest of the time we were there. Walked past several times but avoided eye contact. My sister and I are both servers and this was unacceptable. We eventually went up to the front to get our bill, paid, and left.

  7. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    lanie doe Says:

    My Lord. The food is hit or miss, but the one thing that gets my goat here are the servers. Constantly texting, and if you happen to ask for something, they appear with a look of disdain upon their hipster faces…

    I have to say, Ive had a few great meals here, but its the constant train of bad service from snippy, unhappy females that really bothers me.

    And for that reason alone, I wont be returning.

  8. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Gary Says:

    Typical snobby Bistro, where everyone in here is too good to work here. I am just amazed why places like this always hire little tarts based on their looks, instead of their serving skills and customer relations abilities. They figure that if all the staff are model material, then the customers will be impressed. What they don’t understand is, this type of individual has had everything handed to them their entire life,and do not feel the need to work for anything.

    So my suggestion to the owners here —- find appropriate staff who need to pay their bills, and are in this industry for the right reasons, not young students who are only concerned about being “seen” and which club they will be hitting after work.

    Find those type and people and I would gladly return, untill then keep your snobby, bitchy little girls and their cell phones all to yourself.

  9. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    megn Says:

    Extremely rude bartender, poor service, and bad food (quail I could make better at home and a salad so salty I couldn’t eat it, and no, the waitress didn’t ask if there was anything wrong with it as she took away my barely touched plate). Won’t be back.

  10. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    KJ Says:

    Just back from a $170 meal. Had expected better. When I asked for medium-well lamb I was told that it may not be tender – my problem right? When it arrived “rare” I could not get the attention of our server to have it returned to the kitchen. What ever happened to “How is your meal, sir?” I fought my way through it and when the server collected the half eaten meal I finally had the opportunity to express my displeasure. Her reaction was to disappear and avoid our table for the remainder of our stay. Service?
    Blue on Water is obviously successful – the place was full. But next time you can have our table! We will not be back!

  11. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    Fefe Noir Says:

    Went to Blue. Big lunch out.
    I arrived earlier than my partner. I had been shopping downtown as we live around the bay and was not dressed to the hilt but was willing to spend.
    I got seated in the back corner. I was practically in the kitchen. I looked around and there was a sweet young couple shoved in the corner next to me despite many empty tables. I asked to be moved.
    Food was excellent. New waiter great.
    I felt awful. Apparently young people, bay people, non suit people can’t be seen in the window.
    Great food. Shit attitude.
    When did St. John’s become so snobby?

  12. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Megan Says:

    I went to Blue On Water for the first time on my birthday a couple days ago. I haven’t been to many “upscale” restaurants in St. John’s so was interested to see how this one compared to the ones I’ve been in the States where I lived for years.

    First of all, the atmosphere was very comfortable. We were seated near the wall (where I prefer to sit) and our waitress was very nice. Within minutes our drinks were ordered and delivered, great timing and I was pleasantly surprised that she would come by periodically to pour my wine up for me.

    The appetizers consisted of calamari and mussels (good size portions), both were delicious and served in a timely manner. I had the chicken supreme, my bf had the pan fried cod…both were quite tasty and served in adequate time. I liked how they gave us space between our app and our main dish. So many restaurants serve those on top of each other, causes one to become full much quicker than I would like. For dessert we shared the crème brûlée, yum yum yum!

    The restaurant was decorated beautifully, our waitress was pleasant with a sense of humor, and I enjoyed it immensely! We were there for two hours, and it was the best two hours of my night :) Thank you Blue On Water for a great dinner!

  13. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Katie Says:

    Went to Blue for brunch. I had a bagel with smoked salmon and dill cream cheese, hashbrowns and a side of fruit. My boyfriend has the tenderloin burger. Definitely more fancy than any brunch I’ve ever had! The decor was really nice. There was a bit of a wait (prob 30 mins) on the food, but considering we had ordered a burger, I didn’t think anything of it. Our waitress was extremely nice and attentive. I prefer brunch at Bagel Cafe personally, but just because their hash browns are way better! Overall, the food was very good, just more gourmet than I’m used to!

  14. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    Brad Says:

    Went here for lunch. Our server was new and was trying really hard, actually she did a good job for someone only the floor for her second day. I hope the service starts to change for the better. I really enjoyed the atmosphere and decor here

    I had the steak, was really good except the went way overboard on the sauce/horseradish. My girlfriend had some kind of wrap and it was pretty bland.

  15. avatar
    Overall Rating55555
    Allison Says:

    LOVE this place.

    I’ve eaten here lots and never had a bad meal (halibut is in season for the next few weeks – they do a great job) Attentive, friendly servers and cool, modern decor. Eating on the bar side is just as enjoyable as the restaurant seating in my opinion. It’s also an awesome place to drink almost any night of the week, especially in the summer.

  16. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    R Says:

    I see a lot of negative comments about the wait staff but I wanted to say that I found the waitress that served our table last night was attentive, friendly and accommodating. She checked on us regularly, made sure our water & drinks were always topped up and was very pleasant. Maybe she’s new to the place, maybe they have been working on improving their service but either way it the service was good.

    As for the food, it was certainly tasty if a tad more expensive than I would have liked. Especially when you consider that one can get a equally good or better meal for cheaper in the same area. It was nice but I’d definitely consider Blue on Water to be somewhere you visit once in a blue moon than on a regular basis.

  17. avatar
    Overall Rating44444
    Jen Says:

    Have only eaten breakfast/brunch here. Very good and very decently priced. Highly recommend for a breakfast spot! Service was good and the food was delicious. However, do not salt your hashbrowns – they must salt them well before hand! (They tend to be busy, however, so I suggest making a reservation, even for breakfast).

  18. avatar
    Overall Rating22222
    MIMI Says:

    Full of arrogant yuppies including the servers. The wine and booze was great but that is because they didn’t make it. Wonder what will be in there in a couple of years from now?

  19. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Won't be fooled again. Says:

    Fool me once shame on you…fool me twice shame on me. Crap food every time. You would get better service from a bunch of teenagers and they would do a better job in the kitchen too!

    Seriously, don’t waste your time. The food sucks. Period.

  20. avatar
    Overall Rating33333
    freddychef Says:

    Sun slpashed and beer heavy friday….a great day sitting on a deck craving a feed of mussels, we struck out at a few places `Hey Kelley’s add them to the menu, we’ll probably stay longer and drink more!!!!!!`…we sauntered around a busy downtown and ended up at Blue on Water….suffice it to say quite busy but we were giving a table in the bar quickly, served quickly and the horseradish mussels were excellent as well as the calamari..service was attentive for such a busy spot and a great time BUT will reserve comment on a real meal as this was reward time on a very busy friday……

  21. avatar
    Overall Rating11111
    Not Good Enough For Blue Says:

    I’d like to be able to leave a real rating, but I have no idea what the food is like. My friend and I tried to go in for lunch and the ever-so-cool, Top Model wannabe hostess not only failed to greet us or do anything that a hostess generally does; she looked at me, looked at my friend, kind of smirked, and walked away to chat with a co-worker. My first thought was that perhaps I had misinterpreted her facial expression and she was checking with her co-worker to see if they had a table available, but no: the two of them just kept talking, glancing over at us, and snickering as we waited. Finally we felt so uncomfortable that we had to leave.

You can write a review right away below or you can log in here. (New user? Sign up here!)


    • Don't have an account? . Takes just a minute or two.

  • Leave a Review