PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, Rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.
I’ve eaten at Aqua on several occasions. They have an interesting and extensive menu. The food(which I and my dinner companions have had)has always been excellent quality and cooked to perfection. The service is excellent and all diners seem to be awarded the SAME high level of service, not just reserved for SPECIAL GUESTS. Every guest seems to be pretty special. Keep up the good work!!!!
My husband and I have enjoyed a meal at Aqua on several occasions. We found that the food was great and the service was excellent. We are a young couple who expected a little bit of the snobbery that you usually encounter at higher priced restaurants but I am delighted to say that we were treated with the same courtesy as everybody else. My husband had the caribou and it was quite probably the best meal he has ever had. The seafood is also delish! One of our favorite downtown restaurants for sure!
I’m so glad they finally re-opened! They were closed for too long for my liking! Definitely one of THE best places to take a beautiful woman out to dinner. While it is totally a “high end” restaurant in town, the prices are more like “medium end”. Service is great, and they just introduced a new cocktail menu. Two thumbs up!
It was the best restaurant in town, to me, for years. But now that it has reopened it has lost its class, its special thing that kept bringing my family and I back for years. It has defiantly down graded with its food, service, and atmosphere, the prices should follow. It’s actually quite disappointing. Why change a good thing if you’re not going to make it better. I won’t be back.
I can’t emphasize enough how spectacular my experience was at Aqua. Truly a delight for the senses. A beautiful young lady served me the most exquisite meal I have ever had the pleasure of eating. Can’t wait to try out the rest of the menu!!
After hearing a lot of great things about Aqua from friends, I was *slightly* dissapointed with my experience. The service was great, the wine great as well. My friend and I ordered the Chorizo Corn Dogs as an appetizer- what a mistake. I’m really open minded, but these things were gross. Totally bland, hard to eat, with a boring sauce on the side. Great idea, terrible execution. My main was Cod wrapped in prosciutto. While it was tasty, it was definately bland and nedded some spices. My friends Caribou however was, unreal! We shared a creme brulee which was really good as well. Overall, it was a weird experience- there were elements which were really good, and then elements which were really bad. I would definately go again, but order completely different things.
One of my favorite places to eat. Drew is the best server in the city, without a doubt. New Years Eve my Bf and I dined there and it was maybe the best meal I have ever had. Mark McCrowe is extremely talented and has turned Aqua around for the better!
To the people who said this resto is no good : do you have brain damage?
I would award no less than five stars for this local gem.
For ingredients so fresh and food so innovative (usually with an amuse-bouche, which is a bite-sized niblet meant to open up your palette served at the beginning of a meal) the restaurant is surprisingly affordable.
Every time I go to Aqua, I order the specials, because I know the excruciating deliberation they put into every one. Chef Mark McCrowe has a gift. I have felt like I was exploring food rather than just eating it.
What else?
The drinks! Try the Tokyo Tea! I have cravings!
The deserts are all made on sight.
If I could eat at Aqua every single day, I would. And doing so is one of my goals.
Consistently excellent in terms of both service and food. I find the place a bit noisy since the reno, but it is still the best in fine dining that you’ll find in St. John’s – and a better price then most of our higher end restaurants.
Did I LOVE Aqua? Mmm… no. It was good. The flavors seemed so great when described on the menu, but then when I ate the dishes I felt like something was missing. All the same, it’s obvious the chef loves to cook seafood and desserts, because seafood dominated on the menu, and was cooked to perfection. The dessert menu was creative and a few things were nostalgia-inducing (which is quite in vogue right now): warm chocolate chip cookies with Cap’n Crunch cereal milk. I’d go back again.
I’ve been here twice and both times were superb. Unpretentious but fine dining.
1st time, we were the only two in the place and the food and service was perfect. Duck and risotto were excellent, steak was delectable as was the calamari. Salmon Sashimi awesome.
2nd time, the place was packed! And the food and service was just as good. Cod was cooked just right, steak was again great. The Salmon Sashimi is absolutely delish. The service is very attentive whether busy or slow.
consistency. that’s it, that’s the most important quality to keep them coming back. Consistently great.
By far my favourite place to eat in St. John’s. The service is always friendly and non pretentious while keeping the air of fine dining, the wine is incredible, but the food is what keeps me going back. An incredible menu with creative and delicious options. Even the complimentary starters are to die for. The desserts are equally as impressive. Aqua is even very accomodating to my vegan boyfriend. The veggie specials are not on the menu, but they are just as delicious as every menu option. I have eaten here many times and will continue to do so until I can no longer chew. HIGHLY recommended.
Disappointing.
Went on a Friday expecting the chef/owner to be present, he wasn’t. It showed.
The food was good, but so what, most food is good. Nothing was excellent.
The service was kind, but inexperienced: waiter actually handled the replacement knife with her bare hands on the whole knife as she lay it down, no napkin. Take your dirty hands off my knife blade, thanks, I can see you. The basics of food service are STILL missing in this town?! How can you call it fine dining?
The food came out way too fast. Still on our cocktail, out comes the bread/tapenade, then a complementary amuse bouche (boring and not amusing at all) right behind it, and as we were just finishing that, there’s the appetizer. All in about 7-8 minutes. And the mains weren’t far behind… it was all WAY too fast, and I couldn’t finish my main as a result.
The food was more like a good diner, and not a fine dining room. Nothing stood out, nothing said ‘wow’.
Not bad, but certainly not a ‘fine dining’ experience.
I will never return, and am now soured at the Chef – apparently he was at his other restaurant this evening… thanks – you’re busy, and we’re eating a cook’s attempt at your menu. Full fare. That makes me a sucker.
*Disclaimer – this is not a layman’s review, I used to be a Maitre D’ Hotel who started as a dishwasher, so I know what I’m talking about when it comes to service and fine dining.
@ anon
Seriously? You would actually complain about food coming out “too fast”? That has to be one of the most ridiculous things I’ve ever heard. Talk about nit-picky! In most customers’ eyes, I would think that receiving your food promptly would be a good thing. It certainly is to me. And you’re upset because the chef wasn’t there? Who do you think you are?
I came on Valentine’s day and the food and service were great! Really interesting and delicious food combinations. Like, bacon wrapped scallops with bok choy? Who would have thought? But it was so good. And they’re tetley tea creme brulee with partridge berry jam! Yummm. Totally recommended. And it is resonably priced, which is a hell of a lot more than I can say for most fine dining restaurants in St. John’s that charge through the roof for food that is not nearly as good as Aqua’s.
Aqua is by far my favourite restaurants in the city….and I’m sure I’ve eaten at just about all of them….my boyfriend and I went again last night and we left post meal with the same belly -smiler feeling we always leave with. He had the Aqua Benny and I a freshly created delicious vegetarian option, root vegetable hash and mint pistachio couscous…the latter of which isn’t on the menu but if you ask the server the kitchen will whip up a delicious veggie meal and not make you feel like you have ten heads because you don’t eat meat! Service was excellent (thanks Richard!) oh and thanks for squeezing us in without a reservation!
January 2nd, 2008 at 9:55 am
I’ve eaten at Aqua on several occasions. They have an interesting and extensive menu. The food(which I and my dinner companions have had)has always been excellent quality and cooked to perfection. The service is excellent and all diners seem to be awarded the SAME high level of service, not just reserved for SPECIAL GUESTS. Every guest seems to be pretty special. Keep up the good work!!!!
February 3rd, 2009 at 7:42 am
My husband and I have enjoyed a meal at Aqua on several occasions. We found that the food was great and the service was excellent. We are a young couple who expected a little bit of the snobbery that you usually encounter at higher priced restaurants but I am delighted to say that we were treated with the same courtesy as everybody else. My husband had the caribou and it was quite probably the best meal he has ever had. The seafood is also delish! One of our favorite downtown restaurants for sure!
March 16th, 2009 at 1:04 am
I’m so glad they finally re-opened! They were closed for too long for my liking! Definitely one of THE best places to take a beautiful woman out to dinner. While it is totally a “high end” restaurant in town, the prices are more like “medium end”. Service is great, and they just introduced a new cocktail menu. Two thumbs up!
April 1st, 2009 at 9:09 pm
It was the best restaurant in town, to me, for years. But now that it has reopened it has lost its class, its special thing that kept bringing my family and I back for years. It has defiantly down graded with its food, service, and atmosphere, the prices should follow. It’s actually quite disappointing. Why change a good thing if you’re not going to make it better. I won’t be back.
April 19th, 2009 at 12:42 am
It’s true; the new ownership ruined this gem.
May 17th, 2009 at 7:32 pm
Amazing food excellent service wonderful atmosphere
highly enjoyed, will be back
keep it up!
November 4th, 2009 at 11:09 pm
I have eaten at Aqua too many times to count. They have always had the most unique mixture of foods….love the prices and the relaxed clean atmosphere.
BEST RESTAURANT IN TOWN!!
November 4th, 2009 at 11:54 pm
I can’t emphasize enough how spectacular my experience was at Aqua. Truly a delight for the senses. A beautiful young lady served me the most exquisite meal I have ever had the pleasure of eating. Can’t wait to try out the rest of the menu!!
January 19th, 2010 at 4:53 pm
After hearing a lot of great things about Aqua from friends, I was *slightly* dissapointed with my experience. The service was great, the wine great as well. My friend and I ordered the Chorizo Corn Dogs as an appetizer- what a mistake. I’m really open minded, but these things were gross. Totally bland, hard to eat, with a boring sauce on the side. Great idea, terrible execution. My main was Cod wrapped in prosciutto. While it was tasty, it was definately bland and nedded some spices. My friends Caribou however was, unreal! We shared a creme brulee which was really good as well. Overall, it was a weird experience- there were elements which were really good, and then elements which were really bad. I would definately go again, but order completely different things.
February 10th, 2010 at 2:57 pm
One of my favorite places to eat. Drew is the best server in the city, without a doubt. New Years Eve my Bf and I dined there and it was maybe the best meal I have ever had. Mark McCrowe is extremely talented and has turned Aqua around for the better!
March 12th, 2010 at 11:36 am
To the people who said this resto is no good : do you have brain damage?
I would award no less than five stars for this local gem.
For ingredients so fresh and food so innovative (usually with an amuse-bouche, which is a bite-sized niblet meant to open up your palette served at the beginning of a meal) the restaurant is surprisingly affordable.
Every time I go to Aqua, I order the specials, because I know the excruciating deliberation they put into every one. Chef Mark McCrowe has a gift. I have felt like I was exploring food rather than just eating it.
What else?
The drinks! Try the Tokyo Tea! I have cravings!
The deserts are all made on sight.
If I could eat at Aqua every single day, I would. And doing so is one of my goals.
My name is Scott and I endorse this restaurant.
June 11th, 2010 at 5:58 pm
aqua = awesome
September 30th, 2010 at 6:42 pm
Consistently excellent in terms of both service and food. I find the place a bit noisy since the reno, but it is still the best in fine dining that you’ll find in St. John’s – and a better price then most of our higher end restaurants.
November 15th, 2010 at 2:57 pm
aqua may be my favourite spot in the city for lunch
perfect portions with the right amount of flavours in every dish and dessert
Mmmmm
March 5th, 2011 at 1:17 am
Did I LOVE Aqua? Mmm… no. It was good. The flavors seemed so great when described on the menu, but then when I ate the dishes I felt like something was missing. All the same, it’s obvious the chef loves to cook seafood and desserts, because seafood dominated on the menu, and was cooked to perfection. The dessert menu was creative and a few things were nostalgia-inducing (which is quite in vogue right now): warm chocolate chip cookies with Cap’n Crunch cereal milk. I’d go back again.
March 15th, 2011 at 6:56 pm
BEST RESTAURANT IN ST. JOHN”S, thus far.
I’ve been here twice and both times were superb. Unpretentious but fine dining.
1st time, we were the only two in the place and the food and service was perfect. Duck and risotto were excellent, steak was delectable as was the calamari. Salmon Sashimi awesome.
2nd time, the place was packed! And the food and service was just as good. Cod was cooked just right, steak was again great. The Salmon Sashimi is absolutely delish. The service is very attentive whether busy or slow.
consistency. that’s it, that’s the most important quality to keep them coming back. Consistently great.
January 4th, 2012 at 4:20 pm
http://katiejaynenorman.blogspot.com/2012/01/what-i-order-aqua.html
Delicious food! Can’t wait to go again.
November 20th, 2012 at 11:00 pm
By far my favourite place to eat in St. John’s. The service is always friendly and non pretentious while keeping the air of fine dining, the wine is incredible, but the food is what keeps me going back. An incredible menu with creative and delicious options. Even the complimentary starters are to die for. The desserts are equally as impressive. Aqua is even very accomodating to my vegan boyfriend. The veggie specials are not on the menu, but they are just as delicious as every menu option. I have eaten here many times and will continue to do so until I can no longer chew. HIGHLY recommended.
March 18th, 2013 at 12:08 pm
Disappointing.
Went on a Friday expecting the chef/owner to be present, he wasn’t. It showed.
The food was good, but so what, most food is good. Nothing was excellent.
The service was kind, but inexperienced: waiter actually handled the replacement knife with her bare hands on the whole knife as she lay it down, no napkin. Take your dirty hands off my knife blade, thanks, I can see you. The basics of food service are STILL missing in this town?! How can you call it fine dining?
The food came out way too fast. Still on our cocktail, out comes the bread/tapenade, then a complementary amuse bouche (boring and not amusing at all) right behind it, and as we were just finishing that, there’s the appetizer. All in about 7-8 minutes. And the mains weren’t far behind… it was all WAY too fast, and I couldn’t finish my main as a result.
The food was more like a good diner, and not a fine dining room. Nothing stood out, nothing said ‘wow’.
Not bad, but certainly not a ‘fine dining’ experience.
I will never return, and am now soured at the Chef – apparently he was at his other restaurant this evening… thanks – you’re busy, and we’re eating a cook’s attempt at your menu. Full fare. That makes me a sucker.
*Disclaimer – this is not a layman’s review, I used to be a Maitre D’ Hotel who started as a dishwasher, so I know what I’m talking about when it comes to service and fine dining.
April 1st, 2013 at 3:35 pm
@ anon
Seriously? You would actually complain about food coming out “too fast”? That has to be one of the most ridiculous things I’ve ever heard. Talk about nit-picky! In most customers’ eyes, I would think that receiving your food promptly would be a good thing. It certainly is to me. And you’re upset because the chef wasn’t there? Who do you think you are?
I came on Valentine’s day and the food and service were great! Really interesting and delicious food combinations. Like, bacon wrapped scallops with bok choy? Who would have thought? But it was so good. And they’re tetley tea creme brulee with partridge berry jam! Yummm. Totally recommended. And it is resonably priced, which is a hell of a lot more than I can say for most fine dining restaurants in St. John’s that charge through the roof for food that is not nearly as good as Aqua’s.
June 24th, 2013 at 2:40 pm
i love aqua…every time i go there i get something new and it’s always mind blowing. i think the singer of monsterbator works there too, super cool!
August 8th, 2013 at 7:10 pm
Aqua is by far my favourite restaurants in the city….and I’m sure I’ve eaten at just about all of them….my boyfriend and I went again last night and we left post meal with the same belly -smiler feeling we always leave with. He had the Aqua Benny and I a freshly created delicious vegetarian option, root vegetable hash and mint pistachio couscous…the latter of which isn’t on the menu but if you ask the server the kitchen will whip up a delicious veggie meal and not make you feel like you have ten heads because you don’t eat meat! Service was excellent (thanks Richard!) oh and thanks for squeezing us in without a reservation!