The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
RPM Challenge Newfoundland and Labrador
RPM Challenge Newfoundland and Labrador
Info | Local Resources | Ask a Question | RPM Events | FAQ | Sign up! | RPM International | Listen

RPM Women

Feb 1, 2012

Last year’s RPM Challenge was the biggest yet for the province, yielding 103 full-length albums of original music made by 160 Newfoundland and Labradorians.

Strangely though, of those 160 participants, just 30 of them were women. That’s less than one fifth—roughly 19 per cent.

Are women here not as interested in recording their own music? For a place where music is such a big deal, that doesn’t seem to make sense. Is it something about the challenge itself?

Bryhanna Greenough brought together five women from different musical backgrounds to talk about it: Ariel Sharatt (AS), Andrea McGuire (AM), Erin Power (EP), Hilary Thompson (HT), and Sandy May (SM).

 
Why do you think so few women are making RPM albums here, compared to men?
 

AS I have started RPM projects before and not finished them. I think, for me, it comes down to a perfectionist streak and feeling a lot of pressure about putting something out there. I think that’s gender to a certain extent, but I don’t think it’s only gender. I’m know lots of men out there have a similar kind of experience with RPM.

EP For women friends of mine who participated last year—or wanted to—recording is a challenge. They could get the music together, but to sit down and record it and make it sound good was a whole other thing.

AS A lot of women I know have been raised with piano lessons and were more classically trained. They didn’t grow up around garages with drum kits and amps. They started playing music in an environment that can make people feel embarrassed about getting things wrong. It’s really perfectionist. I think the RPM is easier for people who are used to jamming than people who are used to playing in a youth orchestra.

AM I did classical piano for years, and I always wanted to write songs, but I kept thinking ‘oh my God it has to be amazing, it has to be as good as a classical song.’ Eventually I realized, no, it doesn’t. A song can be four chords and that’s fine.

HT Same for me. I played classical piano, and I tried to be in a band, but just couldn’t do it. I tried so hard on piano but would flip out. ‘I can’t improvise, I can’t do this.’ Then I would just walk away.

Then later, in my late 20s, a couple of girlfriends were like ‘let’s play in a band together!’ ‘Well I don’t…’ ‘We need someone to play bass.’ ‘But I don’t know how to play…’ ‘Whatever. Who cares? Just borrow my boyfriend’s bass.’

And so I get there and I ask, ‘Are you guys good?’ None of us knew how to play our instruments, so we were, like, ‘screw it!’ The rules were, ‘no rules and no judging.’ We got together once a week, had a beer, and played some music. Then, bit by bit, things started to come together.

We have a recording of us doing a Ramones tune… and at the end, you can hear all of us, a bunch of girls, going, ‘Yayyyy!!!’

SM The idea that women might have more classical training clarifies a few things for me… I often wondered, ‘don’t any women know how to play guitar?’ But that was my own baggage, thinking it was a negative thing because I was associating piano as being female, right?

AS There are women in this city who have become wicked keyboard-playing front women, but there are also the supporting roles for keyboards.

I play clarinet in a band. That’s pretty girly [laugh]… But I’ve also played guitar in a girl punk band. I loved that so much, I think, because it was a more active, powerful musical role.

In high school I wanted to play in a riot grrrl band. I didn’t want to play acoustic guitar like Jewel. [laugh] I attached really negative associations to female musicians, and that’s something I’m still getting over. There is this real divide between male music and female music, it seems.

SM If females play male music then it’s more legit, it seems.

EP Exactly, but why is it more legit?

AS If you went through Pitchfork’s top 50 for this year, I wonder how many of the women are playing ‘masculine music?’ But then there’s, say, Joanna Newsom. Then every article you read, it’s about how ethereal she is and how she sits in her little cabin playing her harp and thinking craazzy things. [laugh] ‘Listen to the feminine music coming down from the hills!’

AM I had classical piano and then moved on, but I don’t really think of instruments as masculine or feminine. I want to play so many different instruments, including guitar, I just haven’t made my way there yet.
 
Has anyone experienced assumptions about you as a musician that have been kind of strange?
 

AS I’ve walked into several bars with armloads of gear and set it down on the stage and then been told where the merch table is. Which is fine, because I probably am doing the merch too. [laugh] But I’m also in the band. The assumption is, though, they’ll talk to the guys about the input list and talk to me about where I can go put the CDs on sale.

SM I write about 85 per cent of our stuff, but a lot of people perceive that it’s Ian’s—my husband’s—stuff, even though I sing the lead on most of the songs, and play guitar. It’s frustrating.

“There’s something really overwhelming about sitting in a room by yourself and telling yourself, ‘I have to write a song and it has to be good.’”

SM I first got up the nerve to play in this city at Sherry Ryan’s. She had a bunch of women over to play and I was like ‘okay I can do this.’ It was so encouraging. I have a few friends who are really good, and they would love to play, but they’re terrified. But I was telling them about this women’s jam and they were like, ‘oh, I could do that!’ There’s something about it being all women.

EP I was at that same jam and that was probably one of the first times that I’ve ever played in front of people I didn’t know. Usually it would just be really close friends, but that was branching out.

SM I find some women can be really competitive with one another, but it seems like when collaborating with music that doesn’t apply.

AS I noticed a lot of women finishing their RPMs were doing it with other people. Not necessarily other with women, but they were collaborating. There’s something really overwhelming about sitting in a room by yourself and telling yourself, ‘I have to write a song and it has to be good.’

EP I did the RPM the last two years on my own… It was more of a personal challenge. This year I have a couple of friends who would love to do it, but just don’t feel they could do it on their own. But together as a group they would love to be part of it.

AM I wasn’t thinking of doing it on my own at all. Last year I actually didn’t find it that hard really. A couple of the songs I had written before, then Becca also had songs and Shona did too. It’s less stressful when you do it with other people and it’s also more fun.

EP I think there’s strength in numbers. There’s not as much pressure on you, so it opens things up. That’s my favourite way of playing music. I have a group of girls that get together and we like to sing every week.

HT That’s what I want to do till I’m old and grey.
 
How would you recommend setting that kind of thing up, Erin?
 
EP Make it a regular weekly thing. You can always invite more people to come, but start with one or two you’re comfortable with… On Thursday nights we’ll sit down and have a little chat, catch up, and then we’ll play some music—all acoustic. The big challenge for us was to move away from playing other people’s music and into playing our own stuff. And it still is—even with people you know.

It can still be daunting to say ‘well, I wrote this song…’
 
Do you ever try to include people who aren’t very experienced?
 
EP Absolutely. I have a friend who loves to come over, and we taught her how to play four chords on the mandolin. Very easy.

But again it’s more about the time spent together, and the music made together than necessarily the quality.

“Write songs about oranges, dress up as Bruce Springsteen.”

AS Coming up with an idea a day for song-writing would be helpful. If it’s themed there’s a little less pressure to be saying something super meaningful. Like, you know, ‘I’m writing a song about an orange.’ When I’ve written songs with other people in the past they’ve been a lot funnier and a lot better.

Also, seriously, dressing up in costumes makes playing way more easy and way more funny. [laugh]

SM At the Springsteen tribute, I decided, ‘I’m gonna dress a little like Springsteen!’ The white T-shirt and stuff. Pretending you’re somebody else probably isn’t the most sound advice, but at the same time it’s way more fun and easy to play.

AS When I first started playing in public I had a uniform, a sweater dress that I thought was equal parts nerdy, ‘cos I was playing the clarinet, and also really cool and rock star. [laugh]

I still had to be me, but it was the me that could perform. I could get up in front of people and sing songs and play music and look like I didn’t want to shrivel up and go home and drink some tea… Again, it really helps you not feel so emotionally bare. So: Write songs about oranges, dress up as Bruce Springsteen. [laugh]
 
Any tips on how to make it comfortable with friends?
 
HT No judgment. Don’t be like ‘dude she’s really good’ or ‘I’m better than her or him.’ It doesn’t matter, you’re playing music together.

EP I think listening to each other is really important. Try to keep it as a collaborative effort more than a one-person show with a few back-up singers. It’s a beautiful experience when you open yourself up and you say ‘I’m just going to do it.’

AM It’s the best thing in the world if you can get over your own insecurities.
 
When the compulsion to take part is stronger than the fear of sounding bad…
 
SM I think the difference between people who do things and people who don’t is they just like say ‘whatever, I’m gonna do it. Let’s do it.’

Sign up at www.rpmchallenge.com

This was written by:

: e-mail

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Comments (which include restaurant reviews, rants, Wha? questions and I Saw You submissions) appearing on the site are not the opinion of The Scope, but only of the comment writer. We may remove questions, answers, and comments that are hateful, inflammatory, spam, or any other nonsense. Please play nice. More detailed terms here.
 

One Response

  1. avatar
    Rebecca Says:

    Good insights! I found myself nodding along like crazy as I was reading.

    Really interested by Ariel’s comment about trying to distance herself from “woman” musicians like Jewel…I’ve totally done the same thing- it’s so easy, when “feminine” artists don’t appeal to you, to veer into anti-female gender-bias. I suppose it’s pretty common when it comes to rejecting expected gender behaviours- you throw the baby out with the bath-water because you’re so pissed off that you’re always expected to be the one washing the squirmy little bugger.

    Another part of it is that there are comparatively fewer canonical female musicians out there (when I say canonical, i mean the ones that you hear when you’re 12 and that make you realize that playing music is awesome.)

    If a teenage dude doesn’t like, say, Led Zeppelin, then there are about million other very well known, very easy to access, dude bands he can look up to and someday hope to be like.

    On the other hand, if a musically-inclined female doesn’t like Joni Mitchell, then god help her (love you Joni!), the options are slimmer. It won’t mean that she won’t continue to love music, but it might make it just a little bit less likely that she’ll see herself as a potential musician.

    (Troll caveat: I’m in no way saying that males can’t ispire females or that females can’t inspire males, so give it up…By the same token though, when none of the people who are succesful doing something that you love are like you, it can have an impact, especially when you’re just starting out.)

    Anyhow, like I said- awesome, thought-provoking interview! Nice one :)