
Here’s an album that manages to capture, in its entirety, the twenty-something Plateau Montreal experience. The smell of vegan mush stewing in second hand pots following you across the pizza plate-littered street from the balconies of tiny, crowded apartments, where some dreadlocked dude from your Aristotle class sits strumming a guitar… it’s all here. Even the Expos cheerleaders and the anglophone fear of St. Jean Baptiste day make an appearance. Sure, it all begins with grandiose promises of love, joy, and creativity, but it gets old — the songs bleed together, with occasional promising moments getting lost in the tough decision between doing too much or too little.
How Montreal.
— Sarah Smellie



April 10th, 2008 at 3:01 pm
Montreal may have issues it needs to deal with, but I don’t really hear those problems on this record (except, maybe, on the last track, and the last 2 minutes of track 5).
Plants and Animals have put together a pop record that’s friendly, fun to listen to, and a little bit adventurous. It may not win, but this is sure to be a finalist for the Polaris.