The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Write a message for the Rant Farm
9
Like

Wherefore art thou Trollmeo?

Posted on Monday at 7 pm - 12 Comments.

Why must Rant Farm promote anonymity amongst its contributors? Anonymity breeds contempt. It encourages people to avoid taking responsibility for their views. In online public forums, this typically amounts to trolling.

So why encourage it? The call to action for ranters literally states “Click here to post an anonymous message for the Rant Farm.”

Is it foar teh hitz? Granted, polarized, poorly thought out rants will most likely garner a large (and equally polarized and poorly thought out) response. So the discussion generated might be inane and pointless for the most part, but a bunch of people clicked through. And I guess a few people got their jollies. Is that all Rant Farm is here for?

While I don’t think Rant Farm needs to go out of its way to disallow anonymity, I think encouraging people to post under their true identity would go a long way towards generating more meaningful discussion here.

If you’re into that sort of thing.

Rant by Darcy Fitzpatrick

«

»

 

12 Responses

  1. avatar
    Eon Says:

    I think the very title “Rant Farm” indicates not so much meaningful discussion as a place for people to come and vent all the little (or not so little if one is talking potholes ;) frustrations of life.

    If that generates meaningful discussion that is a bonus, but really, there are other forums for that. And anonymity lets people speak their minds freely – without having to worry about repercussions from co-workers, bosses, or friends and family.

    Yes, an anonymous forum is going to attract trolls. Can you show me any forum that doesn’t though?

    I like Rant Farm the way it is – a varied mix of sane and insane, meaningful, thought provoking posts and the fluffier “FML” types.

    Maybe The Scope could create another forum for people who want to talk more seriously and without the comfort of anonymity?

  2. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    I am all for venting frustrations and love that Rant Farm is here for that. I just don’t see why people can’t speak their minds freely without standing behind what they have to say. If you believe in what you’re saying, why would you need to hide from it?

    I can see why people might want to hide their identities if they’re being an asshole about what they have to say. But then why are we trying to protect asshole behaviour?

    Speaking out against oppression – the kind of situation where if you are caught naming your oppressors or their deeds would bring you and/or those close to you serious harm – is a case where anonymity is helpful.

    But sharing your frustrations about every day life? What sort of possible repercussion could someone face in talking about pot holes or cyclists or sleazy pick up lines that warrants them protecting their identity?

    Unless, like I said, they’re being an asshole about it.

  3. avatar
    so there Says:

    why are you so gung-ho about ‘outing’ commenters?
    I remember you had this discussion on your blog, which appears to be floundering these days… and there were several people who disagreed with you then too.
    and who are you to say who should be labeled “asshole”? is that the point, so you can find people you disagree with and call them ‘assholes’? that says tons about you.
    this forum is not for you to spout on about your issue with anonymity, you had your chance at that and it didn’t seem to hold water.
    this forum is for people to speak their minds without fear of reprisals from folks like you, and no matter what their reason for being anonymous, your opinion is not important.
    I recently ranted here about slow drivers (and older drivers, and etc., and yes I maybe got off track) and several folks came back with comments about how I didn’t respect my elders… well, the Boomers are the least respectful generation of all time, and are going to bankrupt your generation with hip replacements, and the cost of nurses, and extended life expectancies due to Big Pharma’s incessant uncontrolled output that is designed mainly to make money (“ask your doctor”) and not necessarily to improve life or families or anything. I appreciate that folks disagree, it’s harsh to say what I say, but the question still hangs: why do we approach aging and death this way? it’s philosophically and fiscally unsound.
    anyway, I’d bet you know who I am, or could find out, but I appreciate the Scope having this forum, as it allows me to speak about such an issue that really BUGS me, and I don’t have to have people like you saying I’m an “asshole” for saying it, while I float the idea and see what others think. I don’t even mind being wrong, I just think the content trumps the source. don’t shoot the messenger.

  4. avatar
    Eon Says:

    Well if someone is being an asshole – whether in the rant or in comments, you certainly have the choice to call them on it, or simply stop reading if it bothers you.

    Consider too that “being an asshole” means different things to different people. I am child-free and if I go on a rant (like the one posted here a few days ago) about how utterly fed up I am with seemingly EVERYTHING being “family” centered – and post it under my own name – chances are I am going to hear about it (endlessly) from my children-are-the-center-of-the-universe family members. As well, I own my own business and I would prefer to not alienate my many customers who think and feel as my in-laws do.

    “Asshole behavior” is in the eye of the beholder many times – which is why people choose to post anonymously.

  5. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    “I remember you had this discussion on your blog, which appears to be floundering these days…”
    – I don’t know if I’d call it floundering. I’ve ceased posting to it for the time being. I’m not sure what this has to do with the discussion here, so moving on…

    “and who are you to say who should be labeled “asshole”? is that the point, so you can find people you disagree with and call them ‘assholes’? that says tons about you.”
    – I suggested being an asshole as a reason why people would want to hide their identities. That’s not to say that everyone who chooses to remain anonymous falls into this category by default. It’s just the only valid reason I can think of for why someone would require anonymity in a forum like this. I’m open to other possibilites, though.

    “this forum is for people to speak their minds without fear of reprisals from folks like you, and no matter what their reason for being anonymous, your opinion is not important.”
    – You’ve contradicted yourself. Or am I to be excluded from the reprisal immunity this forum supposedly grants to everyone for some reason? Reprisal immunity, I might add, that very few people seem to adhere to here.

    “I don’t even mind being wrong, I just think the content trumps the source.”
    – Indeed, but must the source be divorced from the content in order for the content to succeed? I’m arguing that the content suffers as a result of this lack of responsibility taken by the author. It discourages the kind of effort that makes arguments into reasonable discussions rather than emotionally charged, accusatory fights.

    “don’t shoot the messenger.”
    – Words to live by.

  6. avatar
    RantPharm Says:

    Dear Mister Darcy,

    What’s in a name? That which we call a rose
    By any other name would smell as sweet.

    I don’t believe that you have to reveal your identity to have a meaningful discussion. You’d probably have better luck finding one in a forum that’s not called Rant Farm. But the name of the forum isn’t going to preclude the opportunity to having meaningful discourse. The name simply hints at the purpose of the forum and the culture that it will breed.

    Your post is pretty trolly in itself, by the way, even though your real name is being used. Rants are generally not methodical, and they tend to be selfish in nature. Most of the people here seem to be talking about things that bug them and trying to turn them into crusades on behalf of humanity, or the citizens of St John’s etc. (hyperbole anyone?) I think they’re just looking for affirmation that they’re not alone in being bugged by whatever it is that is bugging them.

    If you look at the posts you’ll see that they’re about a faceless subsection of the population or unknown individuals who are offending the poster. Showing one’s own name would be a disproportionate act.

    When someone complains about the lack of substance in a forum, my opinion is that the complainer should either start a topic that is engaging or stop complaining and look for substance elsewhere. Complaining about a forum which is itself about complaining! Well trolled Sir!

    With Love,
    Trollmeo

  7. avatar
    JB Says:

    There are a huge number of reasons outside of just being an asshole that people would want to post anonymously. St. John’s is a pretty small town, and often very judgmental. There’s a lot of disagreement here, and it wouldn’t take much to have people holding the attitude, “There’s Darcy Fitzpatrick, luh – you should hear the bullshit he writes on the scope” – justified or not. That’s just one example I can think of.

    Some people will use it as an opportunity to be an asshole, yes, but for others, it just allows you to better reveal exactly what you actually want to say about something. Some people have opinions that would be too controversial for their co-workers or families to deal with.

    Besides, the entirety of the Scope’s commenting and posting sections are anonymous. I don’t see why the rant farm would be any different.

    Now, all that being said, there’s one situation in which I see an even bigger downfall than just trolling, and that’s people anonymously posting details/complaints about someone around town, and purposely giving enough detail so that others can recognize who they’re talking about. That’s unfair.

  8. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    Thanks for the suggestion, RantPharm. And the love :)

    It’s not that I don’t take the point that a rant is a way for people to get things that bug them off their chest. And if someone chooses to remain anonymous while they do so, it’s certainly their choice. The premise of my rant, above, is that anonymity here is specifically encouraged and that I believe this promotes poorly thought out rants and dialogue. Where you get stuff like not bothering to get facts straight. Or making things personal. And the heart of the rant is lost as a result.

    The more I read what other people have to say about this, though, the more I think that maybe I’m missing the point of Rant Farm. While I do find it disheartening to see a potentially meaningful discussion on a worthy topic be presented and subsequently hashed out as diatribes, if that’s what Rant Farm is here to be a platform for then my concern over the matter is misplaced.

    Still, ranting about Rant Farm – a tad meta, maybe, but I don’t see how it’s trollish.

  9. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    It was never my intention to say Rant Farm should do away with anonymity. I just felt that by outright encouraging it, rather than simply allowing for it (as is the case with comments), Rant Farm was encouraging more of the less savoury results that online anonymity can bring to a forum. Though it seems to me now like my point is moot, anyway, so I’ll lay off Rant Farm about it.

    On the subject of anonymity, though, I actually feel like a lot can be gained from standing behind what you have to say, regardless of how supposedly controversial what you have to say might be. For one, it encourages you to be more considerate, be it about what you’re saying or who you’re saying it to. It’s also liberating not to have to hide from what you think or feel. Then there’s the fact that it might encourage others who feel the same way as you to be open about it, too – anonymity doesn’t lend itself quite so well to building meaningful relationships and communities.

    If someone chooses to remain anonymous, it’s certainly their choice, but I really believe that the benefits to being open about who you are online far outweigh whatever drawbacks there may be.

  10. avatar
    JB Says:

    Fair enough. Well said.

  11. avatar
    so there Says:

    ok, I know you won’t listen to me, but read this:
    http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2011/08/04/real-names.html
    among other things, she says this:
    “The people who most heavily rely on pseudonyms in online spaces are those who are most marginalized by systems of power. “Real names” policies aren’t empowering; they’re an authoritarian assertion of power over vulnerable people. These ideas and issues aren’t new, but what is new is that marginalized people are banding together and speaking out loudly. And thank goodness.”

  12. avatar
    Darcy Fitzpatrick Says:

    A Microsoft employee going on the attack against Google and Facebook…

    Besides, notice how careful she is to use the term “pseudonymity” rather than “anonymity”? A pseudonym suggests some form of identity, history, even responsibility. Anonymity is nothingness, where any expression made from within it may as well have been evoked from the vapour.

    I’ve already acknowledged that there are going to be certain cases where anonymity is necessary, such as in the case of the oppressed seeking a means to speak out without fear of repercussion.

    I think the author of the article you’ve linked to (who seems perfectly comfortable using her real name, by the way) is taking her argument of “those who are most marginalized by systems of power” to the extreme. If those are the people who most heavily rely on pseudonyms, by all means allow them to continue (and keep in mind I never suggested disallowing anyone this right, but rather argued against encouraging anonymity wholesale). But given the fact that the majority of people online are using pseudonyms or anonymity in one form or another, does that mean the majority of people online are “most marginalized by power”?

    She also makes mention of the harassment argument, wherein it’s assumed if you use your real name online your personal life will somehow be invaded or compromised in some way. As someone who openly spoke his mind on a fairly widely known local blog for two years, I can assure you my personal life was in no way compromised by attaching my real name to every post I published there. In fact, I benefited immensely from doing so. And from the many people who contributed posts over those two years under their real names, I was never made aware of a single instance where one of those contributors felt that doing so negatively affected their lives.

    You have to wonder how it is that people can use their real name all day in the offline world and feel perfectly comfortable, but the moment they step online it’s no longer an option. Both worlds are made up of the same thing: people. Again, barring those with a very real need to protect themselves (not talking First World Problems here, but genuine need), I can’t help but feel like the real deal is that it’s just a convenient way for people to avoiding taking responsibility for their actions.


RANT FARM: Got an opinion? Then we want to hear from you. Submit your unsigned accusation or confession here. One submission will be printed in the paper each fortnight. Submissions may be edited for length, grammar, spelling, legal, or potty-mouth reasons. The Scope's Terms of Use are here.