
Illustration by Ricky King
Dear St. John’s,
Seriously. Can we talk about ‘public space’ for a second here? Can there be a place we can go that is not a store to hang out in? What happened to culture and architecture and the quality of life? Do we really need another giant pet store? Can we stop and think about the way we want to live instead of the crap we want to buy for just a second? And can we stop ripping on each other for not being the hottest or best dressed or most eco conscious for just 6 seconds.
Posted by Anonymous
« Drove






May 17th, 2011 at 3:11 pm
Money talks. Pet stores make more money than places of culture. That’s Reality. Which is why developers/investors build stores, and cultural spaces are publicly/government funded for the most part. Not always of course, but mostly. If you had $20, you could invest it in a venture that could make you $100, or you could invest it in culture and make smiley faces. Smiley faces are nice, but sadly con’t pay the rent. I’m an artist myself, so I can appreciate the value of culture and quality of life. Just make sure that when cultural events take place, you take full advantage, and quality of life is what you make it :)
May 18th, 2011 at 6:44 am
There is no reason council couldn’t designate a public space….like a public square area. Could even have shops on the perimeter like they do in Europe. They’d rather squeeze in another hotel or a crappy subdivision though.
May 18th, 2011 at 7:40 am
No one in St. John’s is best dressed since i left.
Nobody.
May 18th, 2011 at 1:43 pm
dump gets it.
May 18th, 2011 at 2:56 pm
The reason is that this would have to be publicly funded. Council’s money = your money. It is a great idea, but if Council puts money into that, guess what? People are going to complain that the money could be best spent elsewhere. Always happens, sadly. Look at what people were saying when they announced they were revitalizing George Street. Bottom line, if you want a public square, you have to pay for it, or gather investors to pay for it. You never know, there might be a developer that would be interested in a public square type development! If they know there is significant demand for it, they will build it. Keep in mind too that most of those public squares in Europe have been there for hundreds of years, or longer. Of course we do have several beautiful parks in the City, but I think a public square would be an awesome space as well. Not counting Churchill Square, LOL.
May 18th, 2011 at 4:50 pm
The new pet store isn’t just another pet store, they do however sell the same products, but at a lower price then the other pet stores in St. John’s. But they have a grooming center, a training center, a kennel, and they’re doing wonders for the SPCA. Giving them space for the stray cats, dogs, kittens and puppies to give for adoption. And all the money they get for the strays is giving right to the SPCA.
May 18th, 2011 at 7:45 pm
The pet store was just an example. It’s great that they are helping stray pets. My issue is Stavanger drive and the multitude of stavanger drive look-a-likes. I pay taxes. I would pay more if they spent it responsibly. I see value in public spaces and, incidentally, art for it’s own sake. Money is not supposed to be the ends. It’s supposed to be the means to an end. I don’t mind if there are shops and stuff around, it just feels like there is no planning going on in the city based on giving people lifestyle choices. Sprawling suburbs of giant 2 story vinyl houses, big box stores, and pathetic public transport make me sad. I appreciate the parks, but, some kind of other pedestrian focused urban public space might be nice – people obviously want somewhere to go have you seen water street on a sunny day? I just find it frustrating that we have this vast amount of culture to draw from and we just keep making the same big box malls. I just think we can do better than that.
May 18th, 2011 at 11:44 pm
You’re tax dollars are not paying for shopping centres, but they would be paying for public space. The City doesn’t own all of this land, it is all privately owned, they would have to use your tax dollars to buy it.
May 19th, 2011 at 10:44 am
Relevant Letter to the Editor in today’s Telegram:
http://www.thetelegram.com/Opinion/Letters%20to%20the%20editor/2011-05-19/article-2518808/A-plea-for-public-fountains/1
May 19th, 2011 at 10:56 am
Ha! “It’s been my observation for a number of years now that water fountains and Conservative governments don’t seem to get along. Maybe it has to do with all that flowing water not being hooked into the electrical grid that gets them all riled up.”
May 19th, 2011 at 12:02 pm
The only place you will find any of this is 1 hour OUTSIDE of St. John’s.
May 19th, 2011 at 12:22 pm
I know that. I said I’d be willing to pay more if they’d do something constructive with it. I wouldn’t have to build a patio if there was a public place to hang our in.
May 19th, 2011 at 12:59 pm
God, I think a lot of young newfoundlanders nowadays would gladly pay taxes for a public space to be created. And if you ask the seniors another park or area where families can hang out is probably something they’d appreciate too. But apparently reality doesn’t like socializing outside his own home.
May 19th, 2011 at 1:13 pm
Her own home ;)
Also, I am extremely sociable, I am just playing devil’s advocate for the sake of debate. Just want to put out there that its not easy as all that. Just because I can’t afford it, doesnt mean I don’t want it. Nowhere did I say I did’t want any of these things, just trying to explain how things really are.
May 19th, 2011 at 6:17 pm
“people obviously want somewhere to go have you seen water street on a sunny day?”
“God, I think a lot of young newfoundlanders nowadays would gladly pay taxes for a public space to be created. And if you ask the seniors another park or area where families can hang out is probably something they’d appreciate too. But apparently reality doesn’t like socializing outside his own home.”
—
What makes you people think that everyone else in the city wants the same things that you want? Here’s a very simple lesson in business; If a huge chunk of the population didn’t actually want box stores and suburban two-stories, developers wouldn’t be building them, and investors wouldn’t be investing in them. And in response to Swedish Flowerpot, what’s it to you if people don’t socialize outside of their homes, or only socialize with a tight-knit group of friends and/or neighbours? To be frank, it’s none of your business, and it’s certainly none of council’s business to waste taxpayer money on setting up “public spaces” (and no one has been particularly clear on what or where those would be exactly) in areas where people don’t want them. We already have downtown and that’s enough, suburbanites are happy the ways things are, that’s why they buy homes in the suburbs.
May 21st, 2011 at 8:36 pm
Since when do we live in Europe?
May 21st, 2011 at 8:42 pm
You obviously do not have a clue when it comes to business do you? Are you that naive enough to think that everyone wants to hold hands and sing in a park. If a HUGE chunk of people did not want these vinyl 2 story homes or these big box developments do you HONESTLY think they would be so damn popular?
May 21st, 2011 at 10:44 pm
It’s also worth noting that not everywhere in Europe looks like what you see on the postcards and in movies. There’s more to Europe than the tourist stuff, the hip cafes, public squares, the ancient cathedrals, and so forth. They’ve got plenty of suburban sprawl over there too. They also have office towers, commercial and financial districts, and even dangerous neighbourhoods. I honestly don’t understand why the hippies here are always complaining, St. John’s really isn’t that bad.
May 22nd, 2011 at 3:14 pm
I’m with Anonymous- maybe people want something for themselves and for their families, as opposed to just something for themselves. Public space costs money, just as it costs to buy a coffee at a chain shop. There is nothing wrong with living in a place like Paradise or Mount Pearl; those towns at least can provide some services St. John’s can’t, like clear sidewalks in the winter. The last people we need in charge of a city movement are condescending, naive fools who think that any house besides an old fire-hazard of a row house isn’t worth anything. People moved to the suburbs to better their lives, not to participate in some sort of anti-urban centre conspiracy.
May 22nd, 2011 at 11:01 pm
Well, the suburbs will do for those with no desire for interesting esthetics… Row houses have character, and are part of what makes St. John’s worth living in at all, without the downtown St. John’s would be a bland, depressing place decorated with advertisements. I completely agree that St. John’s needs public space, a place that would be for people of all ages, and families too, of course. Perhaps you are content simply moving through a place in a car without interacting with your environment, but other people might be willing to put money towards a sense of community. You’re of course free to move to the suburbs, but can’t suburbia stay in the suburbs rather than slowly leeching into what is still (in my opinion) beautiful?
May 23rd, 2011 at 12:17 pm
Shooby, isn’t that what is currently happening? You guys living in what you call beautiful, and the rest of the city progressing towards a future.
May 23rd, 2011 at 5:52 pm
So the future necessarily has to be ugly? When my relatives came to visit they gasped at the gorgeous scenery from above, and then could not stop commenting on how dreary St John’s was compared to the nature surrounding it. Is that what we want people who are not from the island to think? St John’s is the “capital” of Newfoundland, but it’s pride and joy is still George street. And sure, they had good fun getting screeched in, but their favourite part of the trip was going hiking on a Signal hill trail, which is let me think, oh yes, out of the city. I’m not saying it should be taken out of the tax-money, I do realise many people could not care less about stepping outside their own house or going somewhere without their car. But where does all the tax-money go? Nothing is working properly or taken care of so where does the tax-money go?
May 23rd, 2011 at 5:54 pm
And if parks are only going to get used for people holding hands in them and singing then I am against parks.
May 23rd, 2011 at 9:49 pm
Swedish, maybe just maybe, some people would not see suburbia as being ugly if they would take their rose colored glasses off and realize that we don`t live on a European Post Card. Correct me if I am wrong….but ain`t Signal Hill in St. John`s……..unless you are referring to the East Coast Trail. As for St. John`s looking dreary well you have Duff and O`Leary and the rest to blame for that, because according to THEM, the current state of DT is what tourists are flocking here for.
May 23rd, 2011 at 9:51 pm
Swedish, I was speaking metaphorically.
May 24th, 2011 at 9:53 am
I don’t see what one thing has to do with the other. Do you specifically want a public space where this new pet store is being built? Doesn’t seem like a very good place for something like that to me.
And what public spending would you like to see reallocated? A little research would help prove the point here, otherwise your rant is too easy to write off. “I don’t like big box stores, but I do like parks”. Looks more like fishing for agreeable comments than actually wanting to see this change.
It’s been pointed out here several times that the city doesn’t own this land, and aren’t paying to have these stores built. Why not do a little research, and decide exactly what money you think is being misspent that could be better spent on public spaces. Right now, this rant just comes off as yet another case of someone being wishy-washy, saying they want something to change, but putting no more effort in than it took me to write this comment.
May 24th, 2011 at 12:31 pm
It was a rant, I was bored and tired of wondering what to do in this city that’s not shopping somewhere shitty. I’m not a city planner. I like architecture. I thought something might get a discussion going. The public money and stores are unconnected I am not an idiot, i know now public money is used for stores. I was simply saying these boring places are our only option? I thought maybe a solid wharf regeneration project, or closing a small part of the downtown off to cars and making a pedestrian area, easy usable public transport links coming into the city to reinvigorate more rural areas or maybe just planning how the city expands. This wasn’t meant to be some sort of official document or petition. I assumed the ‘rant farm’ was simply an area for people to rant, not a scholarly journal. But thanks for the troll.
May 24th, 2011 at 12:33 pm
*before you assemble your lynch mob — i meant public money is NOT used for stores.
May 24th, 2011 at 1:13 pm
DT has turned into a shithole. That’s the current state.
May 24th, 2011 at 1:42 pm
Really? Downtown has turned into a shithole? And the rest of the city is A-okay?
May 24th, 2011 at 2:09 pm
So downtown has “turned into” a shithole? Wow. When did this happen? Was it last year, 30 years ago, what? I see houses being refurbished on every street where there were boarded up houses 10 to 15 years ago. Commercial and office buildings which were derilict or abandoned are being renovated. More major developments have been approved in this past year than ever before. Cruise ship visits and overall tourist numbers have been climbing every year for a decade or more, and they ain’t goin’ to Cowan Heights. If downtown is shithole, I guess a lot of people like shitholes.
May 24th, 2011 at 2:15 pm
Relax, I knew what you meant, and pointing out shit like that would be idiotic. I’m responding to the things you’ve said and points you’ve raised, not your typing/spelling abilities.
I just see this type of thing here too often. A “rant” is essentially a complaint, and it seems that a large number of the rants here have to do with issues about which something actually can be done, but all that’s happening is people complaining about something with no desire to act on it, and then getting overly defensive about any dissenters. It’s an interactive discussion by nature here – you *are* going to get differing points of view.
More than anything, I was questioning the link you made between the lack of public spaces and stores; “Can there be a place we can go that is not a store to hang out in?” and “Do we really need another giant pet store?”. Again, I just don’t see the connection. I don’t know a single person who hangs out in stores, and considering where this new pet store is, I honestly don’t see what it has to do with public spaces, since obviously, if anything is going to go in that particular location, it’s going to be a store of one kind or another.
I think you have a good idea; it’d be great to have more public spaces. But the reason more public spaces would be nice is because there aren’t that many here right now, not because of stores. The city will always be building and expanding in some form, and there’s no reason that can’t continue to happen at the same time as something like you’ve suggested.
May 24th, 2011 at 3:05 pm
Dump I have to disagree with you on this one. The DT is def not a dump, while the DT may not be perfect it is far from a dump.
May 24th, 2011 at 3:06 pm
Sorry DUMP but you’re wrong there.
May 24th, 2011 at 3:21 pm
Haha, just noticed your troll comment. You should really look that one up, because you obviously don’t know what it is. I’m not purposely trying to stir shit up for no reason, I’m giving my opinions. If you’re going to resort to name-calling instead of responding maturely to commetns, at least use the right names.
May 24th, 2011 at 4:13 pm
The rest of the city is far from OK. Sprawl is so out of control the city can’t deliver essential services.
May 24th, 2011 at 7:26 pm
Uhm, I really thought the rantfarm was here so people could vent steam about something that is upsetting them/makes them think? Because if it truly bothered anyone they would go out and do something about it, like protest, or raise money, or get out into the media, or even create a facebook group. But isn’t the rantfarm just here so people can complain without having to do anything? And the commenting is merely people who enjoy arguing about things?
May 24th, 2011 at 7:27 pm
A lot of times renovating an old house downtown is like putting lipstick on a pig. I’m surprised there are so many suckers out there willing to shell out for those firetraps. House flippers are making a ton of dough off them though.
I’m curious to know if there are less empty/derelict buildings down there this year than last. Doesn’t seem like it. A couple more burned down though.
Tourists and cruise ships….anyone remember when downtown was for the average resident?
May 24th, 2011 at 7:46 pm
To get back on topic here, and to reply to JB, it really doesn’t bother me when these people vent their frustrations about the direction that St. John’s is going in. That’s their opinion and you’re not going to change their minds. What pisses me off is when they take an activist role. We have a small but vocal minority of citizens in St. John’s who would be more than happy to force their personal tastes on a city where the majority of people want suburban two-stories, box stores, chain restaurants, better roads, tax dollars being spent on infrastructure before arts handouts, and all of those other terrible things. What makes it even worse is that some of them are on council, including our deputy mayor. It would be great if these people would stick to ranting online rather than taking an active role in standing in the way of development, business, and progress.
May 25th, 2011 at 8:52 am
Anonymous,
Your last comment was a tad bit condescending. I hope to God you are not implying that “handouts” to the arts communities are more important than upgrading our failing infrastructure in this city. This is 2011 and there are still people living in this city that DO NOT HAVE WATER AND SEWER.
May 25th, 2011 at 9:19 am
Fair enough. But, since there is a reply system set up, if anything in the rant doesn’t make sense, be prepared to hear about it. On top of that, if you’re expressing an opinion that other people will disagree with, be prepared to defend it (or at the very least to hear those differing points of view).
Once an actual discussion gets going about any rant here, the OP will often come back and give the equivalent of “Geez, guys, I was just bitching. I don’t really give enough of a shit about this to do something. Leave me alone.”
This is just a personal opinion, but there just certain topics about which I believe it’s inherently useless to rant and complain about if you’re not prepared to do even the first little thing about it.
I also don’t agree that the “commenting is merely people who enjoy arguing about things”. I think the commenting is people who feel compelled to share their point of view when there’s something they feel needs to be said, or when they feel their point of view can add to the discussion. This is also one of the few rants that specifically ask for a discussion.
May 25th, 2011 at 10:22 am
Hmmm, I’m not sure if you missed the point of my post or if my sarcasm detector is a bit off, it’s hard to tell on the internet sometimes. Just to clarify, I don’t think council has any business spending a single red cent of city tax dollars on arts funding while we have core infrastructure issues.
May 25th, 2011 at 2:54 pm
Uhu, but since we’re not spending the money on parks and other fancy unnecessary stuff like that, shouldn’t there be money to make sure those people do have water and sewers? But I’m sure that money is spent somewhere else equally important.
May 25th, 2011 at 6:32 pm
Yes i was a little irritated. Apologies. Honestly i didn’t really know how people felt about this issue. I get the whole no tax thing, but, I assume there’s already money in place for city planning and it just seems like city growth is chaotic and unplanned. It doesn’t feel like anyone is putting thought into the way we want to live. This city is going to get bigger, I feel that we should try to make it a liveable space that doesn’t just appeal to people with cars who want to shop at remote outlet stores to pass the time, yes it’s fine if that’s there, but, that kind of lifestyle shouldn’t be imposed on all of us. We “hippies” live in dt st. john’s for a reason, tourists come to nl for a reason; because we seem to have some sort of cultural distinction. I was frustrated that there seemed to be no forethought put towards city growth so I ranted. I have participated in advocacy and will in the future, but, I’m not qualified to plan, nor, do I pretend to know how the majority feels about this issue. I do feel that discussion is actually a good thing, but, I didn’t come here to present a case to the court of public opinion. I was just sending my uninformed thoughts out into the ether. But, if you have a problem with the rant section, why are you reading the rants?
May 25th, 2011 at 10:52 pm
Anon, the problem with our current growth, is due in fact to piss poor actions by previous council’s. Also about your comment about shopping at out of way places……where is the city and developers going to put these things if they can’t build here or can’t build there. I have always said……that you can’t stop sprawl if the inner city does not want any development.
May 25th, 2011 at 10:58 pm
By piss poor actions I mean having the attitude that we will never have a population boom. Our esteemed Dep. Mayor has even stated in a email response to me that she does not want to see this city increase in size and that this city is fine the way it is.
May 26th, 2011 at 11:08 am
I’d like to see her exact comment, if it’s in an e-mail.
May 26th, 2011 at 1:03 pm
Do you want entire email or snippets or would you prefer the email be forwarded to you?
May 26th, 2011 at 1:18 pm
everyone’s tax dollars pay for the pointless and inefficient urban sprawl that these places help create.
May 26th, 2011 at 1:21 pm
I for one reserve the right to be upset that my tax dollars are being used for things that don’t benefit me in any way. I pay my taxes and I obviously realize that it’s not up to me to decide how they’re spent. This does not mean I have to be happy with the bullshit status quo we have now.
May 26th, 2011 at 1:38 pm
“But, if you have a problem with the rant section, why are you reading the rants?”
I’m assuming this is directed at me based on what I said, but I’m not sure. If it is:
I don’t have a problem with the rant section at all. I just get disappointed when someone rants, starts a discussion, but gets extremely defensive and insulted with people who take a different view. I don’t understand why some people have such a problem with getting responses, or how they could expect everyone to agree with them. That’s all. I really enjoy the rant section.
May 26th, 2011 at 1:56 pm
I don’t describe myself as a hippy, but here goes…
my problem isn’t with the way things are, I love it here (don’t get me started on the litter though). My problem is with irresponsible, sprawling, development for the sake of development. It’s the cash rules everything mentality and the fact that those in charge seem to be intent on making all these problems worse, and anyone who suggests we slow down and think about what we’re doing from all sides (like me) is branded some type of anti-development hippy.
and why the hell should we settle for “really isn’t that bad” when awesome is still an option.
May 26th, 2011 at 1:59 pm
Then TRON, where do you expect people to go and shop. The Inner Sanctum of St. John’s is dead set against any form of development, therefore where are the stores going to go? Downtown……we all know that will never happen.
May 26th, 2011 at 2:05 pm
Shannie Duff actually wrote that? The arrogance of that foolish old woman is unreal, I don’t even want to dignify her comments with a response.
Also, Fort McMurray’s population is about 1/4 of the St. John’s metro area population, and there’s nothing even resembling sprawl. Maybe Shannie should go there. The city will be better off once she’s been voted off council, which isn’t as impossible as it seems. She didn’t exactly win a landslide last time, and most people I know only voted for her because the other guy was worse, not because Shannie herself has any redeeming qualities.
May 26th, 2011 at 4:16 pm
Let’s have the entire e-mail, with an explanation of where it came from Was it in response to one you wrote to her directly? If so, let’s have your entire originating e-mail as well so we can see the questions you asked her. Once we’ve all read both e-mails, if there’s any doubt as to it’s authenticity, perhaps Scope would put on its investigative reporting hat and check into it.
May 26th, 2011 at 6:01 pm
Even if that email snippet isn’t authentic it’s still a clever take on Shannie Duff’s agenda. Based on the way she has conducted herself as a city councilor for the last 100 years or so I have no doubt that this is what she truly believes. Whether or not she would be so brazenly arrogant about it on public record is another matter, but you never know, I would also like to see the full email, as well as the originating message.
May 26th, 2011 at 11:28 pm
Hey guys no problem on both emails. I will post them when I get back to the originating PC on Saturday.
May 30th, 2011 at 7:40 pm
I recall a story out of Edmonton, Alberta where one suburban home caught fire and, due to rising temperatures and a fault in the quality of the vinyl siding of new homes there, houses surrounding also burst into flames.
older houses are older houses, sure. But any home, even new, can be a firetrap. besides, what’s a reno of an old home next to a $300,000 “bargain” out in CBS?
June 2nd, 2011 at 4:25 pm
Hmmm.
June 6th, 2011 at 1:42 pm
Chris,
So, did you misquote Deputy Mayor Duff? You placed quotation marks around her supposed comments and you indicated that she had said those statements to you in an e-mail. I am left with no other conclusion than that you did at the very least misquote her, based on your failure to produce her “actual” e-mail – if there ever was one.
I don’t care what side of a debate you are on when you do something like that, but when you are speaking in a public forum you should bear in mind that a)there are potential legal ramifications in representing that a statement from another person is a quotation, when in fact it is not (or so I understand – I’m not a lawyer) and b)it harms true public discourse when you vilify individuals instead of focusing on issues and c)it makes good people not want to bother with seeking public office because they have to deal with crap like you’re getting on with.
Most people seek public office because they want to do something good. There are always examples of people who are in there for the wrong reason, and maybe politics attracts more of them than other fields, but you’re not doing the public and the electorate any good when you drag the discourse down in the mud. You’ll never keep the bad apples out, but when we make it all about mudslinging, we definitely discourage the best and brightest who want to make a contribution without being vilified.
June 7th, 2011 at 1:29 am
I am also curious as to why Chris who has been speaking so passionately and aggressively on this matter all of a sudden refuses to hold true to his word. Personally to me it makes his opinion less valid. I’ll at least admit that my opinions are just opinions and not based on any good and solid facts. But I would never repost an email from a public (or private) figure. (Whether that is an actual email or not, though I’m finding it hard to believe after the empty promises). I just feel that it’s in no sense respectful to display what someone wrote to you in confidence.
June 7th, 2011 at 9:24 am
Good God almighty Guys, I am out in BC on an assignment.
June 8th, 2011 at 8:47 am
I contacted Deputy Mayor Duff, and according to her, Chris’s e-mail from her was completely fabricated.
“Hello Elling, Thank you for contacting me . This quote is a total make up and does not reflect my views on any of the issues. One of the downsides of social media is that anonimity allows people to make many statements that they never have to support, I would really appreciate it if you could remove this post.”
I removed Chris’s comment at Duff’s request.
June 8th, 2011 at 9:32 am
Good move Elling.
October 29th, 2012 at 3:14 pm
It’s not just the city that’s a SHlTHOLE its the whole province…. Labrador included.(wouldn’t want to leave out the Labs now would we?)
October 29th, 2012 at 4:48 pm
And now we know that the new suburban vinyl McMansions are even worse fire traps after that recent fire on Kenmount Terrace.
December 13th, 2012 at 8:55 am
In September I moved to St. John’s from Toronto into an apt I found online. When I arrived and realized I was planted in the middle of a suburb (Kenmount Terrace) I cried. Rows and rows of ugly cookie cutter houses, not a park in site but you can walk to WALMART (ugh). As exhausting as moving is, I could not live in that neighbourhood. I moved to Quidi vidi and I love it. When I get up in the morning I see little houses on rolling hills, and a beautiful lake. I have access to running trails and within a 10 min walk I can see the architecture of St. John’s or peer off the edge of a cliff at the ocean. KT is a like a pimple off Kenmount Road. It’s ugly and exploding. It’s sad that the culture and aesthetics of St. John’s should be eaten up by suburban wastelands like that. Even though my apartment here is older and dank, having nature at my doorstep energizes and inspires me. Bye bye ugly Kenmount Terrace.