The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site · Time machine
Write a message for the Rant Farm
6
Like

Whats happening to our culture?????

Posted on Sunday at 11 am - 19 Comments.

Illustration by Ricky King

I find it very saddening to slowly watch as the years go by that gradually we are losing our newfoundland culture. here are some examples of what is happening:

1. people’s accents arent as strong as they used to be, why is that?

2. Nobody listens newfoundland music anymore especially the kids

3. why do most of the younger generation try to dress like gang members from the ghetto

4. we dont have kitchen parties anymore

5. none of the kids eat our traditional food

6. none of the kids go fishing

7. everyone is tuned into the canadian media & technology so we forget more about newfoundland & think more like the rest of canada.

I know i might sound like an old grandpa but if you think about all of this, what is our culture now? Its a lot different than it used to be & eventually our culture will die out & we’ll be the same as the rest of the canadians. eventually st. john’s will be something like toronto or something. i know different parts of canada are different as well & i respect that, but newfoundland has the most irish heritage outside of ireland in the world & is said to be the most irish place away from ireland & even has its own name in the Gaelic language: Talamh an Éisc. Which means Land of The Fish. It is the only place outside of europe that has a Gaelic name for it. Newfoundland is very unique from the rest of canada & it breaks my heart to wonder about the future of our culture.

Rant by Erin

«

»

 

19 Responses

  1. avatar
    Maureen Says:

    I don’t know who you’re talking about but none of what you just wrote applies to my family (except matbe the accent thing, in which we certainly don’t have stereotypical accents). We have our cooked sunday dinners from time to time. We go fishing in the summer. My husband and myself constantly tune into Newfoundland news and make it a point to know whats going on around us, in Newfoundland, across Canada and around the world. I’m just going to have to disagree with you. I think us Newfoundlanders are doing just fine and have a great mixture of old and new.

  2. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    Wrong. St. John’s will never be as awesome as Toronto.

  3. avatar
    Lauren Says:

    You’re not a grandpa, I think you’re just witnessing the evolution of Newfoundland’s culture. Nothing ever stays the same – people, traditions, technology, dialects – even though most of us would probably like them to. (I still hate cellphones.)
    Personally, I love and actively enjoy Newfoundland food, music, fishing, and the “old” ways that you mentioned (I also regularly attend/throw kitchen parties!). Other people are more forward-thinking and leave the older traditions behind (unfortunate as I think that is). It might seem weird to embrace a place’s changing culture, but it’s what has happened since the beginning of time. Things aren’t what they used to be, and in 20 years things won’t be the same as they are now – there will be a new mixture of ‘old’ and ‘new’.
    We will always have a history and heritage, it’s just impossible for a culture to not grow and change with time.
    Sorry – I can’t help you with kids dressing like gangsters. That one’s got me stumped too. :)

  4. avatar
    DD Says:

    How’s that for relevancy?

  5. avatar
    Thurgood Says:

    Ever been outside of St. Johns, Newfoundland culture is everywhere you look if you travel outside of town.

  6. avatar
    T Says:

    Culture simply can’t be preserved. Not one act of cultural preservation has ever made things “Stay as they are” forever.
    Culture has to progress to become relevant. Don’t mistake progression with something being lost.

    1. people’s accents arent as strong as they used to be, why is that?
    It’s this kind of comment that makes me think you’re trolling. The St. John’s townie accent is still just as strong, and around the bay I find they’re stronger than ever. There are a lot of different accents in Newfoundland. In Grand Falls and Gander for instance, because of the influence of the American bases, you don’t find accents are quite as strong as, say, Long Harbour or St. Shotts.

    2. Nobody listens newfoundland music anymore especially the kids
    Go to a Dardanelles show, it’s traditional music and the place is full of 20 something artsy kids dancing to traditional music. Go to O’Reilly’s and look on the floor, the place is full of 20 and 30 somethings dancing to Irish (and often) Newfoundland music. Young folk at the hall is stronger than ever and if you go to the folk festival, the Neil Murray stage is blocked with young musicians singing traditional music.

    3. why do most of the younger generation try to dress like gang members from the ghetto
    Because we’re an island, but we have TVs and the internet. Other cultures are bound to make their way into ours – just like country music made its way in in the 1940′s and 50′s and made up the ‘traditional’ culture that you’re imagining. Dick Nolan and Harry Hibbs wouldn’t have existed if other cultures hadn’t made their way into ours. Traditional ‘Newfie’ culture is a myth.

    4. we dont have kitchen parties anymore
    Kitchen Parties are a myth…another reason I think this is a troll post. People in communities had parties in the kitchen because that’s where the heat was. They were just parties – and there are still a ton of them. Just go around town/the bay during Christmas. You’ll find them in sheds, in kitchens, in parlours and in backyards. Still lots of singing, guitar playing and accordions.

    5. none of the kids eat our traditional food
    Again – seriously? In St. John’s a lot of people have a cooked (Jiggs) dinner at least once a month, and Fish and Chip shops are booming.

    6. none of the kids go fishing
    How do you know? You know there’s a moratorium right? Besides that, lots of people go trouting. This is just wrong. Though I will say that the internet and TV and video games have replaced a lot of other activies…like fishing, baseball, soccer and everything. That’s just changing times.

    7. everyone is tuned into the canadian media & technology so we forget more about newfoundland & think more like the rest of canada.
    I mean there’s a small point to be made here, sure. There’s a fear that there’s a desire in young people now to be LESS Newfoundland, and look to the rest of Canada with some envy. But I think that’s overblown. I think there’s more of a sense of Newfoundland pride, and a celebration of our differences than ever before. You might just be looking in the wrong places.

    I’m not sure where you’re getting this. In fact, I think you’re just trying to get a rise out of this forum.

    Oh – and Cape Breton has its own DIALECT of Gaelic that’s still spoken there, and it’s taught in schools. So…wrong on that one too.

    Again – you can’t preserve anything. And this idyllic, romantic notion of ‘Newfoundland’-ness you have in your brain is just simply that. Newfoundland is doing and has done a great job at celebrating what makes us unique while entering a new generation. Just look at the variants on traditional cuisine going on at Raymond’s, the music of the Once and Great Big Sea, the writing of Craig Francis Power and Joel Hynes. Our culture is doing just fine. Chill out.

  7. avatar
    rzarro Says:

    Tradition is nice, but very overrated when it comes to food! Give me a good curry over fish and brewis any day.

  8. avatar
    John Says:

    Who cares if kids dress like gangsters, they’re kids, that’s the time in your life to dress how you want and that usually includes looking like a fool once in while, it’s part of the fun of being a teenager. I would be more concerned with the guys in their 30s that dress that way.

  9. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    Agreed. What exactly is Newfoundland food anyway? It’s not like Newfoundlanders are the only people in the world to eat pot roast dinner. Moose and caribou certainly aren’t exclusive to NL, in fact I don’t even think they are native species.

    The only thing that seems to set NL food apart is that it’s characterized by the need to be as economical as possible. Salt fish and boiled hardtack isn’t exactly gourmet. Most “traditional” NL foods have absolutely no flavor except from the massive amounts of salt used to preserve it. Today we have refrigerators, freezers, massive grocery stores, specialty food shops, and a ton of great restaurants. That’s not an erosion of culture, that’s called progress.

  10. avatar
    John Says:

    Meant to reply to the whole thing, not the food entry :) Although I agree there too.

  11. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    It’s also not exclusive to NL either. The UK has a longer history than NL obviously, and they have “skeets” too, although I believe they call them “chavs”.

  12. avatar
    Christopher Says:

    It appears that either as one person said…..this is a troll posting OR the OP has a severe fear of Change. Just because we as a society don’t go around talking like Buddie Wassissname, does not mean we are becoming more Canadian. Further more who really cares if people are becoming more and more Canadian and mainstream, after all it is the process of Evolution!

  13. avatar
    Dave Lane Says:

    Some great responses here, but I’m compelled to add my voice. I think the poster is out of touch…

    In fact, in thinking critically about whether I agree with each of his/her points, I have actually become more confident that Newfoundland culture is resilient and here to stay.

    And it’s sunny out! I’m in such a good mood now ^_^

  14. avatar
    Dave Lane Says:

    p.s. I go to kitchen parties all the time! The difference with olden days is that we sing four-part harmonies to Adele tunes. But we still get loaded and talk like a bunch of skeets

  15. avatar
    Ruth Says:

    Thanks T, I couldn’t have said it better! I spend about 2/3 of my year in town, the other 1/3 in an outport (90% populated by residents, not weekenders) and that’s what I see too.

    And the mullett wasn’t invented in NL but there’s still too many of them! I’ll take shaved heads and hoodies any day.

    time=change

  16. avatar
    totally_gay Says:

    Our culture is “dead coyotes looking for the best happy hour”.

  17. avatar
    Darrell Shelley Says:

    1. have you ever been to Ireland or spoken to an Irish person? most have not even heard of Newfoundland.

    It’s time to move on from the past and look forward to the future.

    Stop being a CRAB IN THE BUCKET…trying to stay and hold a culture to your own and expel those who wish to explore is counterproductive.

    Embrace change and better yet initiate it!

    After years of traveling the world I’ve come to the realization that some of the most intelligent and innovative people come from home.

    The only thing stopping them is people like you who criticize their ability to think beyond a one dimensional outlook.

    You almost sound like a Quebec separatist!

    It’s better to embrace change and realize that we are all citizens of the world! And Newfoundland can lead that charge if we look beyond simple one mindedness such as what you have demonstrated with this article.

  18. avatar
    lovesmesaltbeef Says:

    I’m from the west coast of the island and am of french decent… People from this island come from plenty of other cultural backgrounds as well. Why don’t we stop relating being a newfoundlander to to being of irish decent… The province keeps going after the overpass, regardless of what some people might think.

  19. avatar
    K13 Says:

    People can’t stay stuck in the past and global media will have an effect everywhere, but at the same time, I DO see a lot of young Newfoundlanders taking an interest in our cultural heritage. More young people are gardening, berry picking, knitting, hunting, than you think, and there is lots of interest in Newfoundland’s evolving local music and literature. It is now more of a case of learning Newfoundland’s place in a changing world. We can’t very well sing, write and live in the context of a past that isn’t our current reality.


RANT FARM: Got an opinion? Then we want to hear from you. Submit your unsigned accusation or confession here. One submission will be printed in the paper each fortnight. Submissions may be edited for length, grammar, spelling, legal, or potty-mouth reasons. The Scope's Terms of Use are here.