The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Write a message for the Rant Farm
30
Like

Waiter, there’s a fly in my soup

Posted on Friday at 12 pm - 26 Comments.

Illustration by Ricky King

This is my rant over morning coffee as i ponder my previous evenings work shift at a finer dining establishment here in St. John’s. You see, I am a waiter. I take great pride in what I do and have been doing it for a great number of years. I have worked in the greasiest of spoons to the Ritz Carlton. I have always enjoyed this career choice as it frees up my days to explore my love for photography and last minute travel to far away places. Since moving here last year i have been happily employed doing my thing and experiencing the best of what Newfoundland has to offer. I love eating out, i pick places on “the rock” to explore daily and truly have a love for the local populace. I genuinely feel at home here.

Professionally speaking there is indeed one thing about this corner of Canada that leaves me mystified over and over again. It happens when i return to check the gratuity on a table of guests that have recently vacated. Guests that had just swooned over food and service alike. Guests that makes another reservation on the way out the door, guests that shake your hand and say they will request your amazing service again. A table that just spent what for some people would be a weeks pay for an evening of sophisticated food and drink over a 3 hour period. A table that has just been serviced by a wine steward, a doting floor manager, a knowledgeable server with his backup team not to mention a friendly bartender and hostess greeting your evenings enter and exit. The tipping here in this province is unlike anything i have ever seen. From outright lousy to embarrassing. These are bankers, lawyers, politicians, big oil, mining, realtors, doctors and the list goes on that i am calling out. Yes, there are many great tippers (usually CFA’s) who come out within St. John’s for the evening and we acknowledge you. There are cities all across Canada that consistently value good service and tip accordingly. We should be amongst that group and we quite clearly are not.

This is not just another letter from a disappointed server in the world of poor tipping. This is a team of disappointed staff that share income and try over and over to take this provinces dining scene to a new level. A level that matches our long term growth prospects here. We see every evening that the face of Newfoundland is changing in a very positive direction and we want the local populace to be onboard and join the ranks of considerate and sophisticated diners worldwide. This is about the the art of appreciation….

Rant by Shredpet

«

»

 

26 Responses

  1. avatar
    Daniel Says:

    It’s a socialization problem. A lot of people just never learned what a proper tip for good service is. My dad (who is wealthy) thinks a standard tip is 10%.

  2. avatar
    Steve Says:

    Shredpet, I’m assuming %15 is appropriate?

  3. avatar
    Lena Says:

    There’s no excuse for poor tipping. Don’t blame socialization — there are plenty of tip-calculator apps for the smartphones these deadbeats are carrying. When you rave about the service, show that you mean it and treat 15% as the minimum that should be left as a tip. By the same token, if the service is poor you have every right to deduct from the 15% but base it on the service you receive and not on problems that are beyond the server’s control.

    I work in the service industry too, and I’m appalled at the tiny amounts some cheap bastards consider appropriate.

  4. avatar
    LocalGuy Says:

    I would like to know what restaurants are we talking about here?

    To me, there are three classes of restaurants in Newfoundland:

    1. Fast Food (Tims, McDonalds, BK, pizza by the slice, etc)

    2. For lack of a better term : intermediate level restaurants like Don Cherry’s, East Side Mario’s, Moxie’s, WokBox, etc who try to trick the customer into an atmosphere of fine/upscale dining while serving fast food (or close to it in some cases) charging ludicrous amounts for 2 oz of boiled chicken.

    3. Fine dining mish-mash : places that have some freshly prepared meals with good quality ingredients and some frozen or poor quality all thrown in the menu together. (Ever eat at The Keg outside of NF? I think their steaks are of noticeably higher quality.)

    I have an issue when it comes to tipping servers who have this attitude that they entitled to a tip just for doing their job. I don’t get a tip (nothing extra, on top of my paycheque) for doing my job. With that said, if the server makes an effort to give me a dining experience that gives ME an enjoyable experience, I have no problem tipping 15-20%.

    Had a horrible experience at an expensive place downtown recently. Waitress was very to the point, no welcome, how are you, nothing. We ordered soup that she told us was chicken and not spicy at all. It had beef and was too spicy for me to eat. I told her about it, when she took the full bowl off the table and she had no comment : no sorry, no we`ll take the off your bill, would you like another bowl of something else, NOTHING. I even went on to say I thought it was a chicken soup. She said “I guess I was wrong”, turned around and walked away. At this point, there was no saving the experience. When the time came to pay, I was not pleased so I said “I’m still paying for the soup?”, she said, “well you ordered it”. Obviously, I didn’t tip her anything. The look and the attitude I got when she saw I wrote 0 for the tip was enough for me to never go back again. I paid $60 (soup, main dish and softdrink) for attitude and bad service.

    I had a great experience at a place on Kenmount Rd recently. Now this place is hardly fine dining. But, the waitress was very friendly, brought refills, someone close by commented the music was really loud, she went turned it down, we were not sure about having dessert – she offered suggestions but was not pushy… Very pleasant, no rushing, etc. To me, that was good service and I tipped.

    Bottom line for me: I find servers at too many places here expect a tip for doing nothing more than carrying food to your table with a sigh and no thank-you.

    That’s another rant for me: why do WE say thank you to the clerk/server/cashier – they should be thanking US for our business. They DO represent the business who is getting our money. Take notice the next time you buy something somewhere, who says “thank you”?

    Just my two cents.

  5. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    I agree with you completely. This idea of obligatory tipping is an American thing that has unfortunately spilled over into Canada. In the US many restaurant owners don’t have to pay their wait staff a minimum wage, the waiters and waitresses are literally working for their tips. Here they make a steady wage of at least 10 bucks an hour, yet they feel entitled to a tip regardless of how good they are at their job. I’ve worked plenty of jobs for minimum wage that were much harder than serving tables without expecting or receiving tips and I got by just fine. I feel no obligation to tip a waiter unless the service was extraordinary.

    In Europe it’s the exact opposite of the American system. Waiters there will accept a tip if it’s offered, but it isn’t seen as obligatory because those waiters are earning a steady wage. Waiters around here expect the best of both worlds, they get a reasonable living wage but also feel entitled to tips.

  6. avatar
    observer Says:

    Complete side note- I think you perhaps missed another level of Dining which definately largely exists here in the city. I shudder to think that anyone thinks The Keg is our top option… they may have better steaks at their mainland franchises, but even there, they’re just a steakhouse. There are many independant restaurants here that offer ONLY freshly prepared fine meals, that do not purchase their ingredients as a corporation, but as locally minded creators. The Keg has its place, but there’s so much more out there (here)!
    Either way, the Fine Dining service industry has their pay subsidized by tipping…without it they’d make LESS than entry level McDonalds workers- it’s not gold-lining their pockets I assure you. But I agree with tipping according to service…. I think in this case it was apparent service was NOT the issue. Merely the indication that a lot of people think 10% or even less is sufficient for doting service… it’s not. We’re all just trying to make a living, right?

  7. avatar
    money hungry Says:

    Who cares? A tip is a tip. Its your job to wait on these people, did you start that job for the tips alone? You are still getting your cheque every week or two. I tip, but just because its nice to do so, but if I dont like my waiter Im not going to be to concerned with spending more then I already have to. Do you always tip your hair dresser, tattoo artist, fast food server, cab driver, bar tender, your delivery boy, your paper boy? Thats alot of hard earned money just being passed out for somebody who you dont know and who is already getting paid for what they are doing.

  8. avatar
    observer Says:

    yes I do… every one of those people. And I am low income. It’s about thinking about other people. Period. People have to earn a living-how would you respond to a break-down of what exactly YOU get paid for vs. what other people think you deserve.

  9. avatar
    Steve Says:

    I also tip all those people. Not necessarily 15% each time, but I always tip cab drivers, delivery people, etc. Although I have a good income now, I used to work in the service industry. Cab drivers don’t get an hourly wage. A lot of delivery drivers don’t get an hourly wage either – they get a flat fee per delivery, which is not enough to justify the job without tips.

  10. avatar
    for reals Says:

    Not sure which lovely restaurant you work in, with doting courteous helpful and knowledgable staff, but I should save up all the tips I waste on crappy service to be there!

    Finding a good waiter or waitress is a treasured rarity here, service is usually awful. I know what its like to live off your tips, so I feel guilting into tipping even when service is pretty bad, but I tip better when it’s great!

  11. avatar
    rabbittown Says:

    it has npthing to do with “thinking” of other people. I work 40 hours a week in a low income job, trying to make my way up. Just becasue I make less cash, I don’t think I deserve preferential treatment. Ahhh I am so mad I could punch the screen with your post. You Tip becasue its social norm. Not becuase you feel bad for the person… ahh gawd my screen is broke

  12. avatar
    Nire Says:

    I think you put it perfectly and I agree with you.

  13. avatar
    LynPyn Says:

    Agreed! PS: Try Get Stuffed if you haven’t already, better food than the keg, cozier atmosphere, and very friendly staff! :) And no, I don’t work there, just love it!

  14. avatar
    dave Says:

    Insert ‘Reservoir Dogs’ diner scene.

  15. avatar
    ann Says:

    Personally, I think it’s rude that you are EXPECTING tips from everyone, when you’re just doing your job. I work just as hard as you do, and I don’t get tips..nor would I expect one if I were waitressing. Not everyone can afford to tip every waiter and bartender they encounter, so you should just be happy with what you get, even if it isn’t much!!

  16. avatar
    Paying my fair share as well as somebody else's Says:

    Of course, all of this substandard tipping income is recorded and declared to Revenue Canada – right? You are paying your share of taxes on all of your income, including all tips, like the rest of us schleps, aren’t you?

    Nobody is paid what they think they’re worth. The only difference between you and the rest of us is that not only are we underpaid, we also have no choice but to pay taxes on 100% of our income. Of all those that I know in the service industry, I’ve never heard anyone state that they declare 100% of their tips. Not one – and I’ve asked. The norm is much, much less.

    Count your blessings, there are many who are just as skilled and working just as hard that net a hell of a lot less. We don’t get to jet off on last minute vacations and spending our days enjoying the best that NL has to offer. When we do treat ourselves to a night out, it’s paid for with after tax dollars. consider that the next time that you’re bragging about how well you tip and ranting that others don’t measure up.

    I could afford to tip well too if I were only paying taxes on part of what I earned.

  17. avatar
    penny Says:

    i agree with the comment above that a good server is a “treasured rarity” in town. i am a good tipper for good service. I think its important to note that a poor server will see your poor tip simply as you being cheap not as an indication of their poor service. You are the customer; pipe up and say to the server or manager you were dissapointed. That being said i’ve been a good server, helping moms with their baby strollers, etc & gotten zero tip

  18. avatar
    Neil Says:

    Tips should be given in return for good service, and that’s across the board… whether in a taxi, getting a haircut… all service industries. We were recently dining with a party of 12 at Blue on Water and some of those in the group left no tip…zero!! Tho I thought it a bit harsh… it’s about what she deserved… it was the worst and I’ve done a lot of ‘dining’ in my day!!! That being said… Get Stuffed as mentioned here earilier is a great spot to dine…great prices… and great service! Cheers!!

  19. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    And perhaps if you are in the know… you should share your knowledge with him. As a wealthy man, he should be able to appreciate that a “tip” should be in direct relation to service experience as a whole. I’m sure he would be mortified to know that at 10% he is leaving a message he may not be meaning to leave.

  20. avatar
    Red76 Says:

    Wow,
    what a mixbag of responses to a rather touchy subject. I feel compelled to make my voice heard on this subject in this; my rant.

    First of all I have worked in many jobs, several of which were restaurants in my day… as the original writter, I have also worked in all atmospheres from greasy spoon to fine dining establishments. I have lived from coast to coast in this great country of ours. In my experience, tipping here is amongst the poorest in the country – and it occurs in both higher and lower end spots. It is very sad to me. Mostly because we have some of the most amazing restaurants and wait staff in the country right here at home!

    Wait staff (for the most part) who choose this line of work as a career, are dedicated, hard working , knowledgable and experienced. The work long hours, much like other professions, their job requires a unique set of skills; includes but is not limited to:
    - a knowledge of the city, it’s night life, it’s family activities, sights, experiences and venues
    - to have the balance of a circus performer and the reflexes of a cat
    - the stamina of a marathon runner (and my pedometer has told me I have travelled a similar distance in any summer friday night shift), sweat beading on the forehead and all, WHILE looking polished and clean and relaxed.
    - they are confident speakers, sometimes speaking to large groups, sometimes to an intimate couple’s first date, or last. They tell jokes like a comedian and are quick witted, and exceptional people readers – sometimes even knowing what you want before you do.
    - they smile quietly while scalding their own arms and hands holding heavy hot plates of food while waiting for a polite time to interject
    - they are often required to balance or change checks,
    - make and pour drinks like a seasoned bartender
    - they are too often ordered around like servants to bring you your every desire
    - they control restaurant inventory and stock shelves
    - set tables and wash dishes (and sometimes linens)
    - perform all cleaning duties (including toilets, bathrooms, floors and windows)
    - They field complaints, pass along compliments, organize schedules and take messages like a secretary
    - Take reservations and make sure to not over or under book a table, section or timeframe.

    In addition to these, they know menu items inside and out, ingredients lists for dozens of dishes (to protect you if you have any allergies etc)

    - They perform all of these things, often several at one time while thier families and often children are home at the supper table without them.

    For all these skills, almost all restaurants I have ever worked in have paid the MINIMUM wage. And while you may say that they are being paid $10/hr to essentially walk food back and forth from the kitchen and write a few things down – you should walk a weekend in thier tired, worn out, (sometime even) high heeled shoes.

    Have you ever choosen a career that you knew was only ever going to pay you minimum wage? So, yes, servers often work for tips, they rely on them to pay rents or mortgages, to pay for gas, schooling, etc. Not just to jetset around the world.

    There is no paid vacation time or sick leave for wait staff. There is no knowledge week to week of what earnings will be had or sometimes if they will work at all. They have the same obligations for bills and the like as everyone else but have no idea what their income will be. They don’t qualify for loans or often mortgages on our own because of this…

    I do/did paid taxes on the portion of tips I recieved via credit cards – I will also admit that cash tips went mostly unreported – but I also suggest that most, if not all people, have at sometime in their lives, offered to pay, or take cash, for a job to save themselves that same tax.

    Servers work their butts off (if they are good at it) and they do it because they love it – ALL of it. It is no less a career then many other things I have done – and I have had many many jobs. It is also one of the most challenging and physically difficult jobs I have had. Because of my children and my family I no longer work in this industry – but I can tell you that I now work a salaried job with a very important and reputable organization. I love what I do now, and I’m good at it – but it’s nowhere near as difficult as waiting tables well.

    You may think tipping shouldn’t be expected… in that case I respectfully request you don’t eat at finer dining establishments. If you want minimum wage service – try the counter at a fast food joint.

    So please, the next time your server makes you laugh, fills your water without being asked, points you in the direction of what’s happening that night after you leave, fixes your bill, suggests a wine or a dessert or simply makes what they are doing look easy – please consider they are doing this to impress you enough for that very precious tip.

  21. avatar
    fthxc Says:

    The above is a great post, and exactly what any under-paid waiter should be saying to their employer. As diners in a restaurant, we are not hiring YOU — we are availing of your services as provided by the establishment we are patronizing. It is THEIR duty, not ours, to retain your skill set by providing sufficient financial incentive. Yes, tip. Yes, tip great service appropriately. But a tip is merely a bonus, and should essentially be used as a method to cultivate what will become an on-going server-consumer relationship, to ensure great service next time. Tips should never be a make-or-break for a worker, and should never be taken for granted.

  22. avatar
    Frank Says:

    I disagree. It’s not about being nice or thinking about these people in some special way, it’s about an obligation to tip in our society. That rubs me the wrong way. A tip should be earned. Great service will get a great tip from me every time, but it’s not a given.

    I don’t make a lot of money, but I tip generously when I tip. The difference is that I don’t tip without first considering how I was treated. This idea of automatic tips is for the birds.

  23. avatar
    Frank Says:

    Careful not to look too far down your nose at those of us working in fast food. Most of the language you use to describe waiting at a “fancy restaurant” applies to the fast food industry, except for the part about them deserving tips, I suppose: they do many of the same jobs, but this is the level of respect they are afforded by folks working in a very similar field.

    I feel for wait staff who make little money and work hard. I’ve been there while working in fast food. I always tip generously when I receive good service. But this attitude that anyone is ENTITLED to a tip by nature of their position in a fine dining establishment or any other business or industry is problematic to me, and reasoning that we should tip to subsidize an insultingly low salary doesn’t hold water for me. Like the poster below said, take your salary issues up with your employer. Tipping is about level of service, not about pre-tip salary or the financial situation of the server, not about wait staff working instead of being home with their kids (you’ll find many of us deal with this without expecting tips), not about how physically demanding the job is (we don’t tip ditch-diggers), or any other factor.

    You’re right about one thing, though, and that’s that becoming wait staff is a choice, and you’ve essentially chosen a career that you admit typically pays minimum wage if you make this choice. You have the choice to explore other career options if living this way is untenable. Just count yourself lucky that you can use your charm to earn yourself a few extra bucks in tips: your garbage collector, home care worker, or what have you don’t have access to this income stream, however large or small it may be in NL.

  24. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    Here’s a tip: buy low, sell high.

  25. avatar
    Kitchen Staff Says:

    I agree with most of the comments here. Also, unless some statistics are shown about tipping habits across Canada, I will have a hard time being persuaded that from a handful of servers’ experience, tipping is significantly worse in NL than the rest of the country.

    Even if this is the case, the sense of entitlement to obscene tips has to stop and servers have to recognize the financial constraints on those they are serving. How did the rant author know that she was serving “bankers, lawyers, politicians, big oil, mining, realtors, doctors?” Just because someone dresses nice, doesn’t mean he has a six figure salary.

    One more point: As is often the case, kitchen staff who are working equally as hard (if not harder) are not given a near fair share of tips. Some restaurants use tipping pools which are ridiculously skewed against the kitchen staff. The tip sharing works out to be 90% for servers and 10% for the entire kitchen staff. What’s worse is I’ve heard servers complain about sharing this measly amount with their hardworking coworkers.

  26. avatar
    i do Says:

    Apparently you don’t understand that tips are paid out in a paycheck in a lot of places, just like your regular wage- so yes I, for example, DO pay taxes on gratuity.


RANT FARM: Got an opinion? Then we want to hear from you. Submit your unsigned accusation or confession here. One submission will be printed in the paper each fortnight. Submissions may be edited for length, grammar, spelling, legal, or potty-mouth reasons. The Scope's Terms of Use are here.