The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Write a message for the Rant Farm
7
Like

Un-smokin’

Posted on Friday at 4 pm - 12 Comments.

I have lived in an apartment owned by Northern Property for the past six years, and I recently have gotten new neighbours who chain smoke, and the stench is horrible. I’ve complained, and one of the higher up’s has just informed me that it’s a smoke friendly building, and always has been, even though my original rental agreement from 2005 says the building is non-smoking.

I’d like to move, but there’s hardly anything available, Northern Property owns a large amount of the buildings, and according to this woman they only manage one non-smoking building and it’s located in Pleasantville! Seriously, people that don’t smoke in St. John’s don’t even get their own building? There’s a sign outside saying you can’t smoke within 50 feet of the entrance, but inside damaging other people’s health is a-ok?! I don’t understand why they can’t better manage this, and have several designated smoking and non-smoking buildings! The rental agent told me there’s been a lot of friction between the smoking and non-smoking tenants, but her attitude was still “Oh well, what can you do? I guess you’ll just have to put up with it.” Their inept management is just staggering, because they show absolutely no regard for their non-smoking tenants health, and I’m being told there’s nothing that can be done because smoking is allowed! Smokers rights, really? This is 2011! I think health and rights of non-smokers (who make up more of the population), who would rather not have their damn allergies affected, is far more important than douches who like to pollute the place, and then turn on their fans so that I get blasted with even more carcinogenic fumes! How would I go about petitioning change with this?

Ranter: How in the Hell Can Smoking Be Allowed in the Majority of Apartment Buildings?

«

»

 

12 Responses

  1. avatar
    HBeez Says:

    Until smoking is illegal (and don’t hold your breath for that (no pun intended)), get used to the fact that other people DO smoke. I’m not a smoker, never have been, but I find all the laws and restrictions against smokers to be a little bit much. Have you even tried telling your neighbour how much their smoking bothers you? Maybe you cook food that they can smell, play video games late at night keeping them awake or practice guitar early in the morning when they’re trying to sleep. It works both ways.

  2. avatar
  3. avatar
    Anonymous Says:

    Since when is smoking allowed in a majority of apartments? That’s complete nonsense. Most landlords will refuse to rent to someone even if they smell cigarette smoke off the person. As a smoker, I’ve had to lie to landlords in order to get an apartment (I always smoke outside, and once I’ve signed a lease or rental agreement it’s really none of their business what I do outside the apartment). You may be in an unfortunate situation right now, but generally speaking the system favors non-smokers. If it bothers you so much you should probably think about finding another place to live, there are plenty of landlords who will be more than happy to rent to a committed non-smoker. Tell them why you’re leaving your current apartment and it will definitely look good on you.

    That said, if you really want to petition against this I’m sure you can find plenty of people who will support you. There’s a strong neo-prohibitionist movement in St. John’s right now, folks who know that smoking will never be illegal so instead have chosen to dedicate their lives to pressuring people to quit by petitioning for regulations that make it as inconvenient as possible for anyone to smoke a cigarette anywhere. I’m not going to tell you who they are. I disagree with what you’re trying to do and I’ve probably said too much already. However, there are organizations out there who will support you if you contact them.

  4. avatar
    Original Poster Says:

    Oh please, this is 2011, not 1960! Smoking is a disgusting vice, and everyone damn well knows that second hand smoke is incredibly harmful, so don’t boo-hoo to me about smokers rights. I’m well aware that other people can kill themselves if they want to, but they should avoid affecting anyone else’s health!

    I never said that smoking should be illegal, I stated that it’s ridiculous that Northern Property has told me that they allow smoking in all but one of their buildings (that’s not even located in St. John’s)! There should be several desigated smoking and non-smoking buildings so as to avoid issues like the one I’m having.

    Also, it’s ridiculous that you’re projecting nuisance issues onto me. If I recieved a call from management saying that I was being disruptive, I would be mortified (as would any reasonable person). However, trying to reason with the asshats next door (by me and management) has only seen the situation get worse. The least they could do is not chain smoke, that’s what I have issue with, because I can smell it all damn day. My lungs hurt when I wake up, I can’t keep towels in the washroom anymore because they reek, I’ve been having chronic headaches, and I can’t have certain family members over to visit anymore due to their asthma! For you to basically say “Oh, you’re probably a jerk too” is so dickish and counterproductive. For your information no, I am not. I respect my neighbours! I don’t play an instrument, I don’t play video games (and when my boyfriend does he wears headphones), and please, everyone cooks in their apartment and the occassioanl smells don’t hurt anyone’s health (I use the kitchen fan when I do, anyway)! This is a *health* issue, not a mere nuisance dispute!

  5. avatar
    Original Poster Says:

    Well hell, according to the rep. I’ve been speaking to from Nothern Pprperty, you can smoke in all but one of the buildings that they manage! I said the majority of *their* buildings, by the way, not every management company!

    For some reason they’ve gotten all militant that outside the buildings be non-smoking, with a sign that says you can’t smoke within 50 feet of the entrances.

    Why should I have to leave my home of six years? I have a lease until September anyway, I’m not moving when there’s still so much snow on the ground regardless, and, like I said, there are barely any places for rent in St. John’s. I would prefer to stay in a building, but not if it’s with Northern Property, because like the rep. told me *they* allow smoking in their buildings!

    You disagree with what I’m doing?! All I’m saying is that there should be several desigated smoking and non-smoking buildings under management by Northern Property. I never once said that smoking should be illegal, but you smokers should not be affecting the health of committed non-smokers. Thanks for nothing.

  6. avatar
    Original Poster Says:

    I’ve always found that they favour the landlords over the tenants, so I plan on contacting the local branches of Health Canada about this first.

  7. avatar
    JB Says:

    But you’re projecting your problems with others onto smokers in this case. Your main problem is with Northern Property right now. Unfortunately, if they’re a business, I’m sure they have the right to allow/disallow whatever they want in their properties as long as it’s not breaking any laws. If you don’t like their policies, you can choose to move elsewhere. (Also, if your original rental agreement says it’s a non-smoking building, bring that to the landlord/tenants board).

    The fact there are no vacancies in St. John’s is neither the fault of Northern Properties nor smokers. It’s just an unfortunate fact. The facts that you currently have a lease and there’s snow on the ground are neither here nor there.

    If people have the right to smoke inside, you can’t complain about how much they smoke, and ask them to cut back. It their decision if they want to stink out their own place, and it’s Northern Properties decision as to whether or not they can do this in the first place. Your original post seems to be suggesting that you have to either find living arrangements from Northern Properties or move out of St. John’s. As far as I know (maybe you can correct me), this is not publicly-provided living. You speak as if it is.

    I’m a smoker, and from the sounds of it, I’d still be disgusted with the people living next to you. There’s no need to transfer your hatred of them onto all smokers. If the attitude that you seem to be directing towards smokers in your first two posts is the line you’re taking, don’t expect support from reasonable people. You’ll either get the militant, dramatic anti-smokers, or you’ll get no one.

    This is probably a large part of the reason for the “friction” you speak of. It seems that rather than understanding that some people smoke and some don’t, and furthur simply expressing personal concerns to smokers that affect them, most non-smokers I’ve known are afraid to speak to the smokers, and would rather go to someone else, complaining that they’re disgusting and that rules should be changed to ban them.

    If I were you, I’d just start looking for other accommodations as soon as possible. And I wouldn’t worry, before long there won’t be any multi-tenant buildings left where smoking is allowed.

  8. avatar
    Original Poster Says:

    I found that little of your rambling made any sense. You agree that my neighbours sound disgusting, so I don’t understand your problem with what I’m saying.

    My beef is with my chain smoking neighbours, and the inept management company, I never said otherwise. This is a rant forum, I thought I was allowed to state an opinion, and *that* opinion is that I’m going to complain to whatever local organizations I can so that Northern Property will at least consider divying up their buildings into smoke friendly and strict non-smoking accomdations, because right now I’ve been told that they allow smoking in all but one building that’s not even located in St. John’s. I didn’t once say “Boo smokers, I hate ALL of you!” I’m not the one being unreasonable, I never said smoking should be illegal everywhere.

    It’s not that my neighbours are stinking out their apartment, they are stinking out *mine*, and others, as well, and I think it’s unacceptable. A few smokers shouldn’t get to make the lives of the tenants around them miserable just because they feel they have the right to. It’s not the same as making noise, but if I complained about *that* something would be done, and I think having to breathe in second hand smoke is a lot worse because it’s deeply unhealthy.

    I know plenty of smokers, and for the most part they are reasonable and they’ll smoke near an open window or take it outside, but my idiot neighbours chain smoke 24/7 and take no one else into consideration. There are plenty of children and people with health problems in the surrounding apartments, and I think it’s unforgivably thoughtless, and the management enables them. The building rep. I spoke with says that *she* doesn’t like the “tension” between the smokers and non-smokers, and like I said several times the obvious solution to this is to have more seperate buildings within St. John’s to accomdodate BOTH sides!

    I never said that I had to live with Northern Property or leave St. John’s. I pay my own rent in full. I’m merely stating that I feel trapped because there is a less than 1% vacancy rate in St. John’s, and Northern Property manages most of the buildings, and they live in the dark ages and allow smoking. I shouldn’t have to leave my home of six years anyway, and run away because the new neighbours I have are selfish jerks. I have health problems and can’t sustain a move at this time, and I don’t think asking the jerks next door to have some condiseration of their neighbours is too much to ask. Even though they allow smoking my building super does think they are being excessive, so it’s not like I’m being whiny over nothing! I have consideration for the people that live around me, so I don’t see why they should act any differently, and that *does* go to all smokers: If you want people to tolerate what you do then you should have to be considerate about it!

  9. avatar
    JB Says:

    I was mostly responding to a few comments like this:
    “Seriously, people that don’t smoke in St. John’s don’t even get their own building?”

    That’s a pretty general comment when you’re speaking on one particular management company. It’s also a bit of a strange way to view a business’s decision; that they should think things like “Well, non-smokers deserve their own building, let’s do that”. Obviously (and maybe unfortunately) they’re just going to make decisions that make the most sense for them as a business.

    “Smokers rights, really? This is 2011!”
    “Oh please, this is 2011, not 1960! Smoking is a disgusting vice…”
    The first comment quoted there is a response to the fact that the building allows smoking. That’s not a matter of smokers’ rights, it’s a matter of a particular management company’s decision to allow smoking. But my comment was largely a response to the attitude displayed: that the idea of smokers’ rights is a joke in itself.

    You’re asking how you would petition to change this. Obviously you’d have to petition the management company (maybe get a list of tenants willing to move out unless the smoking rules are changed), and barring that, you’re talking about banning smoking inside any apartment buildings (at the least). That second option might be hard.

    Your situation sucks. You moved into a place where smoking is allowed, I guess assuming that your neighbours would have the courtesy to consider you and other tenants. Unfortunately, that didn’t work out, as your chain-smoking neighbours have proven that you can’t count on everyone to be considerate. In the end, you’re in a place where, as long as smoking inside is allowed, there’s a chance that you’ll end up with yet another set of chain-smoking, fan-blowing skeets. It’s probably time to think about getting another place unless you can convince the company that enough tenants are willing to take action if they fail to act on this issue (again, a petition maybe?).

    My original comment was basically trying to say that although smoking is a health issue, and although many non-smokers simply consider it disgusting, at the end of the day you are essentially a customer saying that you’re not happy with the service you’re receiving. I personally don’t think that smokers’/non-smokers’ rights come into it as long as you have the choice to seek other accommodations. The market dictates what’s offered in most cases. If you were renting the upstairs or downstairs of a house, you’d have a near-impossible time finding a place that allows smoking, because the demand is so high that landlords don’t have to allow anything they don’t want to. Maybe the apartment building management companies are afraid that they wouldn’t fill the building if it was all non-smoking? I really don’t know, but I’m sure they have some reason.

    P.S. Of course you’re allowed to express your opinion. I’d never suggest otherwise. It’s just that when you do, others have just as much of a right to express theirs, whether they agree or disagree with you.

  10. avatar
    the Swedish Flowerpot Says:

    I’d like to say I agree whole-heartedly (well, 97% at least) with what “JB” has been saying. You seem to be upset over poor service, and instead of seeing it as that, you project your anger on singular individuals. Bunching together all smokers as out-dated stoneage people with no consideration for others is a rather oldfashioned point of view. Yes, it is 2011. That means that people who smoke (at least the ones that I know personally) are well informed of the harmful effects of smoking, both for themselves, others and the environment. I have personally only been smoking for a short period of time, and am so scared into submission by the strong anti-smoking policies in society today that I’ll walk outside the blue “no smoking beyond this point” lines even when there’s noone there, late at night, and my non-smoking friends may laugh but I won’t cross that line. For me, the line is a ban and a restriction enough. But many people couldn’t care less, and if it upsets you, it upsets me more, because it causes non-smokers to see all smokers as “asshats” with “dirty vices”. Just as all minority-groups get hunted and harassed by the majority, judged after the few who act abnormally, so are smokers today, and I dearly hope that you will realise most smokers are not inconsiderate chain-smokers like your neighbours, but just your regular person, with an extra bad habit tacked on top of the cheese-burgers and after-work beers.

  11. avatar
    Original Poster Says:

    I can’t comprehend way I have to repeat myself so often! I *did* say my beef was with the service of the management company, *and* with my inconsiderate chain smoking neighbours several times now, and not ALL smokers! You can read JB’s posts, but you can’t be bothered to read mine in full before you blather on, and make what I’m saying all about you?

    I’ll copy and paste, I said:

    My beef is with my chain smoking neighbours, and the inept management company, I never said otherwise. I’m going to complain to whatever local organizations I can so that Northern Property will at least consider divying up their buildings into smoke friendly AND strict non-smoking accomodations, because right now I’ve been told that they allow smoking in ALL but one building that’s not even located in St. John’s. I didn’t once say “Boo smokers, I hate ALL of you!” I’m not the one being unreasonable, I never said smoking should be illegal everywhere.

    I also said:
    I know plenty of smokers, and for the most part they are reasonable and they’ll smoke near an open window or take it outside, but my idiot neighbours chain smoke 24/7 and take no one else into consideration. There are plenty of children and people with health problems in the surrounding apartments, and I think it’s unforgivably thoughtless, and the management enables them. I’ve said several times the obvious solution to this is to have more seperate buildings within St. John’s to accomdodate BOTH sides!

    And what the hell, once more (even though it’s stated above several damn times), I’ll c&p the same main point yet again:
    There should be several desigated smoking and non-smoking buildings under management by Northern Property. I never once said that smoking should be illegal.

    See? I’m *not* being an unreasonable harpy! I’m saying there should be strict polocies by at least Northern Property, the comapny that manages the building I live in as well as several others in the city, that suits both smokers and strict non-smokers. Like, when people apply to live in one of their buildings, they can say “I’d like a building that allows smoking” and then maybe management could have the building next door be for people who care about their health, and would rather live in a non-smoking building! The option should be there, is all I’m saying. I’m making pleas for reason!

    Can I be done with this now? I’m really tired of having to make the same points over, and over, and over because someone pipes up with nonsense about how I’m the one being a bad guy, and that I’m infringing on the rights of minorities (I won’t even fully get into the ridiculousness of that. You chose to smoke, but my family didn’t choose to have Asthma!)

  12. avatar
    Amki Says:

    “even though my original rental agreement from 2005 says the building is non-smoking.”

    As far as I understand, unless you have signed a new rental agreement since, the copy you have from 2005 is still legal and valid and you should be able to either sue them or simply point out to a party of authority that you are in the right and that no one should be able to smoke inside the building, in which case Northern Property would be forced to do something about it. But if you have signed a new agreement where smoking is allowed, I don’t see anything that could possibly be done about it, especially seeing as your neighbours don’t seem to be able to listen to reason.

    “Seriously, people that don’t smoke in St. John’s don’t even get their own building?”

    That is fairly unreasonable. I don’t think smoking indoors is ok, I don’t think anyone should do it, especially when it affects others around you, but it would be impossible for any company to try and create special “non-smoking” housing, especially on a larger scale.

    “Smokers rights, really? This is 2011! I think health and rights of non-smokers (who make up more of the population), who would rather not have their damn allergies affected, is far more important than douches who like to pollute the place, and then turn on their fans so that I get blasted with even more carcinogenic fumes!”

    Though the last piece of this sentence seems to be directed towards your neighbours, the first part is very insulting, and would have been to me even back when I didn’t smoke, because I didn’t judge my smoking friends and would often defend them before people who attacked their choice in life. Yes, smoking is a choice. But so is eating hamburgers, or consuming alcohol, or speeding. All these things put your own, and sometimes other people’s lives, at risk. But because a large number of people do it, I’m not really seeing an angry rant about it. When you’re saying specifically “I think health and rights of non-smokers (who make up more of the population)” you are going by the rule that majority has priority and that minority groups should not have their rights protected to the same extent.
    So yes, I understand your anger at your next-door neighbours and the inadequate management in the building where you live, because this is directly affecting you and in a very negative manner. But there are many points in your “rant” where you seem to be addressing smokers and smoking in general. And yes, I read through all of your posts, and all the replies, before I said anything. I live by the motto that people should get to do what they want as long as they’re not consciously hurting anyone else. Your neighbours (I trust you have informed them of your asthma/the unpleasant stench and all other ways their lifestyle is inconveniencing you?) are making a conscious choice to keep having a negative effect on your life and I do not agree with that. But when it comes to choices people make, may they be hurtful towards themselves or just appalling to you, let him without sin cast the first stone.


RANT FARM: Got an opinion? Then we want to hear from you. Submit your unsigned accusation or confession here. One submission will be printed in the paper each fortnight. Submissions may be edited for length, grammar, spelling, legal, or potty-mouth reasons. The Scope's Terms of Use are here.