The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Write a message for the Rant Farm
3
Like

Textbooks? Who needs them?

Posted on Wednesday at 11 am - 11 Comments.

Illustration by Ricky King

As most high school students may have noticed teachers and principles have a tendency to be irritated with the students who show up to class without their textbooks. I have spent numerous years in high school, three to be exact and I for one can count the number of times I have brought a book to any of my classes on one hand. Some will say it helps you learn, others will say you need it to learn, but I, and others have found a loophole in this twisted education system we have. This loophole being not bringing textbooks to class. There are countless reasons for this occurrence, I will talk about are as follows: the weight and size of the books, the uselessness of their content, and the simple fact teacher notes are better.

Throughout this paper you will have a first hand look through the eyes of a student with an 88% average who doesn’t bring his textbooks.

Surfing the web for other’s experiences I found an article on answers.yahoo.com, the question the writer posed was “Do they really expect me to lug these textbooks to class?” I was thinking to myself, hey it looks like I’m not the only one wondering these questions. He goes on to say “If I’m going to be walking half way across a 500 acres campus going up and down stairs to get to class in 15 minutes. I sure as hell am not lugging a book that weighs like 20 pounds.” Even though I sense a bit of sarcasm in the 500-acre campus, this kid also has a point. The grade twelve English book weighs a stunning 5lbs, the physic book an incredible 6lbs and the biology textbook coming in first at 7.5lbs. If I have read the student handbook correctly they, being the administrative board, expect us to lug these books for approximately a maximum time of 6 minutes through a clustered hall without going to our lockers in between classes. Therefore, if I have a locker on the first floor I walk myself 6 minutes to English on the top floor, 44 steps, then physics on the second floor. This is a stunning 66 steps with 11lbs on my back; no wonder youth today are having back problems. And that isn’t even including the extra paper, pencils, and exercises they expect us to have. These textbooks aren’t only an enormous size and weight but are also filled with complete exerts of useless information which leads me to my next topic.

This is a paragraph out of the physics textbook: “the term periodic: means reoccurring at regular intervals.” This seems like it would do good in the back of that 5lbs pound English book they have me pulling around not the physics textbook. This is only one of many examples of our textbooks containing useless content that is deemed to be “important”. I think 90% of the 7th grade population knows what the word periodic means. Even if they don’t, your taking a physics course you shouldn’t have to be handed definitions on a platter so it seems like your unintelligent and incapable of understanding it originally. These books may be the key to success but please tell me who unlocked my door for me? I have yet to bring a textbook to my physics, English, or biology. Not only have I still passed the course but also I have passed the courses with an almost perfect 4.00 GPA. Something somewhere seems to be getting lost maybe I’m an exception? Maybe the general population at my high school has the mental capability of an eraser? These questions and others are yet to be answered.

My next note may be the most important of all. If the teacher will just hand out notes which explain everything 1 trillion times better then the 7.5lbs biology textbook, why not save some rainforest for some more useful paper? During the courses of biology 3201 I was given 11 hands outs ranging in size between 12 and 18 pages long with 6 slides on each. Basically, the course handed to me in a matter of 9 months. These notes may have been the key to my biology success who knows? They weren’t as hard on my back as a 7.5lbs textbook and they seemed to be filled with knowledge in the form of jot notes and the important topics highlighted. I don’t need to be handed definitions on a platter but this I could get used too. Oh wait I had the same thing occur to me in physics, the teacher realized that this is an effective way of giving important information in a shorter time span. It happens that statistics show kids will bring sheets to class over a textbook. Maybe we don’t need these “keys” to the educational system but a much simpler and cheaper manner of just giving out notes or getting the students to read and write that.

Throughout this paper I believe you will come to realize that some courses in high school are more educational without the use of textbooks, that they aren’t the real key to a proper education. Also, for the betterment of the student’s future of walking upright, please don’t tell them to walk 66 steps with upwards to 15lbs on their backs.

Rant by M. Smith

«

»

 

11 Responses

  1. avatar
    Les Says:

    Life’s tough – I suggest you not move out for a few years.

  2. avatar
    M.Smith Says:

    I hope you at least had a chuckle.

  3. avatar
    J Says:

    It only goes downhill from here, kiddo. Throughout your lifetime there will be instances where you’ll be required to carry more than 15 lbs over varying distances. Get used to it.

  4. avatar
    JK Says:

    “This is a stunning 66 steps with 11lbs on my back; no wonder youth today are having back problems.”

    I lol’d at this, hard. 66 whole steps? ELEVEN WHOLE POUNDS? Stunning indeed. You poor thing!

    People hiking a leg of the East Coast Trail carry that much weight in WATER. The only thing stunning here is the fact that you felt you had something to complain about.

    Not even going to comment on the other points because they’re too inane to even discuss. Grow up.

  5. avatar
    M.Smith Says:

    I think you may have taken the rant a little to seriously.

  6. avatar
    Nathan Says:

    Awwwwwww :)

  7. avatar
    Emma Says:

    Stopped reading at “principles”. Maybe you should have read the part in your English textbook about homonyms. :-)

  8. avatar
    Cat Says:

    Perhaps cracking open that five pound English text book would be beneficial.

  9. avatar
    I see... Says:

    While I didn’t read the entire, long winded, rant, I do have to say that I get where the OP is coming from. The fact is that back problems in youth are on the rise, and it is due in large part to having to carry around extra large backpacks filled with heavy text books. While it may not seem that walking 66 steps with 11 pounds on your back is a lot, I challenge you to try it.

  10. avatar
    engstudent Says:

    I went through 7 years of university for engineering and bought all my books the first year spending damn close to $1000. From then on I bought maybe 1 or 2 books a year of the 6-7 required. With the arts it may be a different story but our profs rarely referred to the book and usually passed out all relevant materials. The university is selling books which the profs directly instruct you to not purchase! Came out in the top 3 of my graduating class. I know people in class who wasted $700+ a semester for 6 years to no benefit and are getting smacked with student loans now. The OP’s comments on the weight of books and walking is a little sad but the overall message is spot on.

  11. avatar
    AngryTeacher Says:

    I bought 2 books during my fast-track education degree. The reason for not needing textbooks is not related to weight or perceived irrelevant content. The reason is that you can collaborate with others and find content online.

    Many high schools in the US are being built without lockers. This is because the institutions/bureaucracy (yes, even them) know that books will be obsolete in a decade or so.


RANT FARM: Got an opinion? Then we want to hear from you. Submit your unsigned accusation or confession here. One submission will be printed in the paper each fortnight. Submissions may be edited for length, grammar, spelling, legal, or potty-mouth reasons. The Scope's Terms of Use are here.