
Illustration by Ricky King
What do i hate more than splinters you ask? That st.johns heritage foundation. the buildings are old and garbage looking,get over it, the area needs to be developed. stop slowing the progress of this city and more importantly the province of nl.
Rant by trump






January 27th, 2012 at 1:09 pm
Exactly. The “heritage committee” should be abolished. We have people ending up homeless due to crumbling infrastructure (look into the recent water line breaks, some of those pipes are a hundred years old) yet we have elitist snobs like Shannie Duff and her heritage cohorts getting paid god knows how much taxpayer money to ensure that St. John’s looks like some kind of faux-Victorian era village. Council needs to be focused on nuts-and-bolts issues, primarily infrastructure. Not heritage, not culture, none of that nonsense. “Old” does not necessarily mean historic. St. John’s was originally designed as a backwater fishing outpost, but now it’s a major city. It’s time for the elitists and artsy types to grow up and acknowledge that we are now living in the 21st century.
January 27th, 2012 at 1:23 pm
Correct me if I’m wrong, but I was under the impression the heritage committee only exerted influence on areas of downtown designated as ‘historic’ – leaving the majority of the city open to broader redevelopment. This explains the more generic development seen outside very specific regions of downtown. If so, is the heritage committee even capable of applying significant housing pressure?
…and I’m seriously asking, here. Is this a real problem, or a perceived problem?
January 27th, 2012 at 2:06 pm
My understanding is that there are designated heritage areas in the downtown, and possibly some designated heritage buildings elsewhere that could be subject to a recommendation from Council’s heritage committee. As a committee, their recommendations are only that – they only mean something when a majority of council votes to ratify the recommendation. The Heritage Foundation, at least from my understanding, is a non-profit organization made up mostly of volunteers that simply promotes heritage preservation. They don’t have any actual power, and like Anonymous, we all live in a free country and they are simply expressing their opinions. Perhaps Anonymous should start an Anti-Heritage Foundation.
January 27th, 2012 at 3:50 pm
Maybe i should. Bottom like is i feel this city is lacking an inviting downtown area that does absolutely nothing to promote other business to set up shop here in the province of NL. i feel like have the development ideas that get requested are rejected because they are either a few stories to high or the council tend to lean with the heritage communit. quite simply Halifax has the same issues but nowhere near does it slow down the progress of downtown development like here.
January 29th, 2012 at 2:28 pm
In regards to the first comment that said “old does not neccesarily mean historic” couldn’t the same thinking be applied that tall buildings or hotels do not mean progress or entering the “21st century”? It’s pretty small minded thinking I believe to think that adding tall buildings to the downtown area would somehow magically thrust us into the 21st century. We have something amongst our downtown that makes St. John’s unique, it’s only one small area of the whole St. John’s area that has that left, and I’m not opposed to tall buildings but why can’t they be placed anywhere else in St. John’s? St. John’s is pretty small but the options of other places they csn build I’m sure are almost endless.
January 29th, 2012 at 7:03 pm
As has been said, it’s only a little section of downtown that’s protected. The City of St John’s takes up a huge chunk of land beyond that. Jeez b’ys. Build some high-rises on Elizabeth Avenue and no one will mind. It’s not “too far” from the downtown core for higher density development, either. The walk from Elizabeth to Duckworth is equivalent to, say, the walk from Bloor to Queen in Toronto.
“i feel this city is lacking an inviting downtown area” — I can’t tell if you’re being serious or if you’re trolling. Taste is taste and if you don’t like Downtown that’s fine (I suppose you can go hang out at the Starbucks on Kenmount or something), but clearly plenty of people find Downtown SJ appealing. You ever try to find parking down there at 6 on a Friday night? Also, what the heck do the tourists come here to see? Hint: it’s not some piddly 12 storey ‘high rises’ the likes of which you can see in any North American city of 100k or more.
January 29th, 2012 at 9:08 pm
I can agree with you there. I think a great area for high-rises and office towers would be out by the Village mall. My concerns have nothing to do with heritage or culture though, I just think that the area has better infrastructure (roads, parking) for that sort of thing. There’s lots of space, good roads, lots of land that isnt being put to good use. I cant understand why anyone would want to put an office tower on Water Street.
That said, when someone wants to build there I will support them on general principle. I see no heritage value, character, or cultural significance in those crumbling fire traps. I would have no problem with seeing the entire downtowm commercial area bulldozed so we could start over and get it right. I also really cant stand the heritage crowd and NIMBY types that hit the protest lines whenever someone tries to build something that doesn’t look like it came out of the Victorian era.
January 30th, 2012 at 9:22 am
“St. John’s is pretty small but the options of other places they csn build I’m sure are almost endless.”
Thus creating more urban sprawl!
“Also, what the heck do the tourists come here to see?”
Will the tourists offset my tax increases in the coming years…..somehow I don’t think so.
As for people NOT complaining about building on Elizabeth Avenue…..obviously you were under a rock when NIMBYism was alive and well when it came to the Piper’s building, and certainly you dont forget the fiasco over Howley Estates.
January 30th, 2012 at 9:52 am
There was minimal concern expressed in the area regarding Pipers. No matter where you go, there will always be some immediate neighbours who are not happy. The Mount Cashel (Howley Estates) Sobeys and adjacent subdivision are a different case, and not really typical. It wasn’t the redevelopment of a previously developed or “brownfield” site – it was a large green space with one building on it (the orphanage) which was demolished. Back when people purchased homes near that property, any land owned by the church had been under that ownership for a century or more, and that ownership was presumed to be as stable as a national park – ie, very unlikely to change or be used for any other purpose. Following the scandals associated with Mount Cashel, that all unravelled, however people understandably were disappointed that they had lost this large green space near their homes. So, don’t assume other developments in the area would be unpopular. There are several seniors’s condo towers in the process of development not far from there, and the opposition has been minimal.
January 30th, 2012 at 10:33 am
Stumper my point about Howley Estates was people complained about the development for the sake of complaining. I don’t know about you, but what came out of Howley Estates is what a “neighborhood” should be, it contains residents and it contains the services needed (supermarket, doctors offices, retail space). The residents who live there do not have to go very far for their groceries and what not.
January 30th, 2012 at 10:42 am
I agree.