The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Write a message for the Rant Farm
21
Like

No Pets

Posted on Tuesday at 3 pm - 23 Comments.

Illustration by Ricky King

St. John’s oh beautiful city! Why doth thou have such expensive “no pets allowed” rentals! Having lived in Vancouver and Toronto in the past 5 years I am shocked to find that rental prices are so high here. A clean decent one bedroom apartment in a city with a population of a couple hundred thousand should not be over $1000 plus utilities. These apartments are not huge, not glamorous, they are standard basement apartments. How do you St. John’s expect your citizens to better themselves – to save money to buy a house and contribute financially more to the city if we are paying such absurd amounts for rent!

On top of that only a quarter of the apartments allow pets! What is this! A low to mid level income family cannot own pets? Do we not too deserve the joy of their company? Are we not equally as responsible and competent for the care of these animals as someone with a higher income! Pets are family and shame on you slum lords for trying to banish them from our lives. Shame on you citizens for not crying out to the community to change the Residential Tenancies Act! Perhaps the SPCA wouldn’t be so over run if people were allowed to keep their pets when they moved!

St. John’s landlords I beg of you lower that rent a hundred dollars and allow pets, your tenants will be happier – and probably respect you and stay longer because of it! You don’t need to gouge your neighbour for their last dollar, and take away their best friend. Be reasonable landlords – St. John’s is supposed to be a friendly city but I see greed in every rental advertisement I read.

Rant by Almost Homeless

«

»

 

23 Responses

  1. avatar
    HAH Says:

    Because I have no pity for the large number of greedy slumlords in this City, I agree that there should be some sort of control, however, It’s hard for government to control private rental rates. And, if you have to wait for the PC’s to try such a thing, you’ll be waiting a long time. They’re all about helping the wealthy get richer.

  2. avatar
    KJK Says:

    A one-bedroom apartment for over $1000, POU? Either you’re exaggerating, or you’re looking at “executive apartments” (which are, in fact, much more expensive in Vancouver and Toronto).

  3. avatar
    Moustachio home owner Says:

    Get a real job and stop having to move cities and afford a house.

  4. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    Another entitled whiner. Landlords don’t owe you anything, if you want to play by your own rules I suggest that you go to school, find a real job, and buy your own property. Then you can pretty much do whatever you want. Until then you had best suck it up. Landlords are not obligated to accommodate your pets.

    We don’t have a housing problem in St. John’s, we have an entitlement problem. If you’re working for minimum wage you don’t get to have nice things. Deal with it, or better yet you can take advantage of the relatively low cost of post-secondary education in this province. Get an education, a job, buy a house, and then you can have as many pets as you want.

  5. avatar
    BOB Says:

    Blah Blah Blah…

  6. avatar
    Pixie Blue Says:

    I’ve got a four year degree and can’t get anything that pays more than minimum wage in this city. So, I work full time, go to school full time (so that someday I’ll make more than minimum wage), and at the end of the month, after rent and utilities and tuition and buying gas to put in the car that I earned for myself to get me to my minimum wage job, I have very little left to feed and cloth myself. I don’t know how entitled a person can be when they’re drowning in student loan debt.

    My landlord wants to raise our rent so, quitting school and moving home might have to happen. So much for getting an education, a job, buying a house, and having as many pets as I want.

  7. avatar
    Adam Says:

    It’s a free market and yes, many landlords have to raise rent slightly because of the property tax increase, but I’m not convinced the market has had to shift as dramatically as it has.

    The rule of thumb for landlords should be that they should offer a place they would call a home for themselves and their family. Standards of living aside, this shouldn’t mean unfinished plywood countertops or broken showers. Its ridiculous what some landlords get away with in this city; they rightfully deserve the “slumlord” title.

  8. avatar
    Green is a nice colour Says:

    A four-year degree in some esoteric navel gazing BA is still not much of a skill. Critical thinking and paper writing is not unique to BA grads making it a pretty useless one-liner on a resume.

    Caveat emptor: Universities will sell you useless degrees that employers will still give you as little money as possible to work.

    The news is constantly bemoaning the watering-down of the value of a university degree, but if you look around the various faculties, the universities are producing an enormous abundance of graduates in fields that cannot come close to supporting that many jobs. The smart money is on the skilled trades and technical sciences, the wasted tuition goes into psychology, folklore and political science.

    Teachers tell you that you can do anything you like, but they never warn you that you might have to be practical somewhere in there also.

  9. avatar
    Max Zorin Says:

    “Entitlement” is at work on both sides there Gekko. Tenants aren’t the only ones who feel entitled to affordable rental rates. Majority of landlords in this city, and maybe this province in general, feel they are entitled to charge outrageous prices for dilapidated shacks.

    Do you think before you write, or do you just blurt out the first thing that comes to your mind?

  10. avatar
    Question... Says:

    How do you know what kind of degree this person has?

  11. avatar
    Green is a nice colour. Says:

    It was an educated guess. This person is definitely not an engineer.

  12. avatar
    shadowwood Says:

    This place is lame. You know, just about no place includes heat or hot water, which tacks on at least an extra $120 per month, and that’s with heat turned off in most rooms and one shower per day. It’s pretty messed up when the combined hydro and rent cost of the city with the worst weather in canada (st. john’s) works out to the same as a place in Victoria (where hydro is cheaper, heat barely necessary and often included in rent). Factor in that this is also a city which doesn’t bother to snowplow sidewalks in winter, forcing its citizens to walk in the roads or drive everywhere and become obese and a job market which consists of employers who demand certificates of conduct just to wash dishes or any other min wage slave job and you have the most lame city in canada. Get out while you have the chance, this place has been ruined, oil has been our curse.

  13. avatar
    shadowwood Says:

    I find it funny that the argument is often given that ‘rent control will result in less rentals available and worse overall living conditions’. Just tell that to someone living in Montreal, a city a billion times the city St. John’s will ever be, with rent prices at half the cost of a St. John’s dump, wide selection of units across the city, no ‘key deposits’ or ‘damage deposits’ allowed by law, an average rent increase of 1 – 2% per year, amazing tenant protections. In this city you are a sitting duck, prey to your landlord who can impose anything upon you he wishes, knowing you won’t be able to win any fight with him even if you are within your legal rights.

  14. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    I agree with some rent control. Once you are in an apartment your landlord should have limits on how much they can raise the rent. These are people’s homes we’re talking about.

    I also think that damage deposits should be done away with. In Ontario they only have first and last, which costs a little bit more up front but is beneficial to the tenant in the long-term. If someone actually does damage the apartment or rip-off the landlord in some way there are other ways to handle it. When it comes to damage deposits landlords are very reluctant to give them back, and it can become a he-said-she-said fight which most tenants do not have time for. Put the onus back on the landlord to collect money for damages.

    And shadowwood, it’s very true that too much control over landlords will result in less/lower quality housing. People simply won’t invest if they can’t make money and have to deal with too much bureaucracy. You bring up Montreal, well that city is in Quebec, which seems to be some bizarre French socialist experiment. If you really think they have the right idea I suggest you go back there. I know that I would never, ever want to live in Quebec, I’m quite happy to pay market rates for rent if it means staying off that sinking ship.

  15. avatar
    KJK Says:

    So if your tenants beat a few holes in the walls and rip a door off its hinges, you’re gonna go to small claims court to get your repair money back? Great idea Gordon, it’d totally work.

    You’re supposed to fill out a rental condition form WITH YOUR LANDLORD when you get the keys, so there can be no argument over who caused any damage present when you move out. If tenants insisted on this, and wrote letters to landlords requesting their deposit back when they move out, they’d stop losing money.

    Unfortunately, most tenants don’t even bother asking for their deposits back, claiming “sure the landlord’s gonna keep it anyway b’y”. No sympathy for those who don’t fight for what’s theirs.

  16. avatar
    KJK Says:

    Five bucks says that the day rent control legislation is announced, O’Dea kicks out all his tenants and jacks up the rent by 30%

  17. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    You’re absolutely right about the rental condition form. That’s what I do, but frankly there are a lot of people out there who aren’t that bright. That doesn’t mean they should get stiffed when a landlord decides to withhold the damage deposit for arbitrary reasons. I believe that most people are good and just want a nice place to live and don’t want to cause damage.

    Landlords should be doing regular inspections of the property. Once a month if necessary. If there is a problem they can nip it in the bud.

  18. avatar
    shadowwood Says:

    Quebec’s socialist experiment is working (for now), thanks to their unique position of being a virtual occupied zone (that’s how many over there think). The federal government buys votes from Quebec and continued Quebec obedience with enormous transfer payments, completely unfair to the rest of Canada, but it allows Quebec to provide a standard of living the rest of Canada would die for. This situation may not last forever, but while it does last it is quite a nice place to live, especially for anyone who isnt a 1%.

    As for your not wanting to live there, well, it is French and if you don’t speak French there isnt a lot to do out there. Calling it a sinking ship while presumably living in Newfoundland is a little bit funny though, this province/ex nation is a ship that has never sailed and likely never shall Comparing Quebec to Newfoundland isn’t even fair, St. John’s is a little hicktown on the edge of nowhere, Montreal, or Quebec city are world-class cities with amazing offerings in culture, a highly educated cosmopolitan population, an active outdoor oriented lifestyle (despite the cold) and a political culture which favours money transfers downwards not upwards (okay here you may not enjoy it.. assuming you are a 1%.. which despite the boasting I find highly suspect).

    Rent control can work, Montreal is but one example, there are many cities in which it has proved a successful experiment. For myself it’s not even the biggest priority – what I would consider the single worst situation here is the form in which leases can be canceled by a landlord (with notice). In other provinces I have lived a lease automatically renews – ie, when you sign a lease, the apartment becomes your home, it’s YOURS until YOU decide to leave it. The ONLY conditions in which a landlord can cancel the lease is through a long and not easy process of proving that you have a relative who is going to move into that space. This situation means that you as a tenant can fight against a landlord using the legal mechanisms in place without fear of reprisals in the form of the landlord simply saying “okay, you’re out as soon as your lease is up in a year”. Example, landlord in Newfoundland doesn’t provide the legal 3 month notice of a rent increase. Instead landlord comes a day before the end of the lease to tell you he’s going to jack rent by $50. You legally could fight him over this – but in the end he has you screwed, forcing you into the inconvenience of having to move out at the end of the year, all the expenses and stresses which come with moving and the likelihood that he will withhold your damage deposit for a nice extra little profit. Renting an apartment is far too heavily slanted in the landlords favour.

    The rent prices are out of control here. Anyone with any sort of rational brain power would see that. Yes landlords CAN charge what they want – but I can also move out of the province and live somewhere else. Does it benefit the city to have a mass exodus of its population? I assumed this province was eager to people to move here and stay here. This is a large Canada, can St. John’s afford to continue chasing people away with an unreasonably high cost of life? Does St. John’s now fancy itself the Paris of the north? Let me tell you, this city has the worst weather of any city in Canada, it’s small and isolated, any job here you will be paid less than you would in just about any other city in Canada, there is a very large population of redneck/hicks whose cultural contributions leave much to be desired, its nearly impossible to walk outside for half the year due to no snowplowing.. etc .. etc .. for this we pay some of the highest rents in the country?? Something doesn’t add up there. I compare it with another island city, of approximate equal size – Victoria BC. Victoria BC has the BEST weather in all of Canada, the population is also far more cosmopolitan, the BC economy is doing good even without oil to artificially boost the figures, a person can walk or bike year round with only a week or two of snowfall, Seattle, California, Vancouver, all a short trip away, glorious scenic mountains and rainforest, vineyards, agriculture of all variety with fresh fruit locally grown.. etc etc. You would think the latter city would cost far more? Think again. When you factor in heating/hydro costs there’s VERY little difference. This place is for the fanatics, the “NEWFIE PRICE 4EVER” folk or those who just can’t hack it anywhere else and rely on family to boost them up. Calgary, Toronto, Vancouver, Victoria, even Halifax, are far better bets than this place.

  19. avatar
    KJK Says:

    Nope, nobody should get stiffed… but is eliminating damage deposits the answer? That only prevents tenants from getting stiffed. Landlords will bleed money.

    Would YOU let your landlord inspect your house once a month? Many people would find that invasive.

  20. avatar
    shadowwod Says:

    who this guy?
    He looks like his mom dressed him for his first day at school, what a good little boy, with his monkey suit and politician haircut. I’m sure he’s as interesting as he looks.

  21. avatar
    fartface Says:

    I pay rent (between 2 people) of $1200/month POU, and we paid extra on the damage deposit because I have a cat and a dog (the landlord required an extra $250 for deposit that he informed me I don’t get back because after we move out he will have to steam clean all the “carpet” which is only in one bedroom and have the house sprayed for fleas and ticks) which I paid because it was the only place I could find in 3 months of looking that would allow my elderly dog and cat. If my landlord wants to come in once every month at an arranged time to check for things like leaks and structural damage, as well as any damage me and my room mate may have caused, it’s fine with me because I don’t live like a pig and don’t fear my landlord walking into my house. He can go right ahead if it means I’m going to get that $600 deposit back.

  22. avatar
    shadowwood Says:

    I hope you have an executive apartment downtown for what you’re paying. For that much money you could be in a highrose condo in the heart of downtown Vancouver. They also seem to be quite pet-friendly out there (because they are so child-unfriendly). Why would you want to agree to having regular checks by your landlord? I don’t live like a pig either but I certainly don’t want someone entering the home I pay to live in to ‘check up’ on it.

  23. avatar
    agreed Says:

    here effing here. well said.


RANT FARM: Got an opinion? Then we want to hear from you. Submit your unsigned accusation or confession here. One submission will be printed in the paper each fortnight. Submissions may be edited for length, grammar, spelling, legal, or potty-mouth reasons. The Scope's Terms of Use are here.