The Scope closed in January 2014. This is a read-only archive of thescope.ca — commenting and submissions are turned off.
Scans of every print issue are at Memorial University’s Digital Archives · Search this site
Write a message for the Rant Farm
14
Like

Newfoundland is turning into Slumlord Land

Posted on Wednesday at 11 am - 76 Comments.

Illustration by Ricky King

Recently I was in a fire and my apartment is uninhabitable. Before that, I was evicted because my apartment had to have the entire kitchen redone due to it falling apart. Before that, I was in a basement apartment that had water pipes break underneath it, and I didn’t realize black mold was all over the place underneath my carpets, and hurting my health. The movers helping me move were hit with a wall of sickness when they entered the apartment. I called the city to make complaints and nothing was done. No one investigated. In the fire apartment, the city inspectors were in only 2 months before, and did not check any of the problems. I was unable to tell them things because I was afraid I would be evicted once again. Instead, I called 311 and added a complaint on the day the inspectors came telling them all of the issues that were happening to me anonomously. Nobody helped and then 2 months later — fire. Want to make a bet with me that the city will give this guy money to fix the place through a grant of some sort and he won’t do anything besides blow it all once he moves back from where he came from? And they won’t stop him or fine him.

In the apartment with the fire, the slumlord as I call him, never fixed my 20 year broken, old windows and the fire alarm had been working, but failed in the emergency because it was old. The cause of the fire – the stove in the basement apartment was faulty and not checked. The smoke billowed through the entire place, everyone running out from the 5 other apartments in the building. Both my partner and I got out safe. But there is quite obviously a problem here in this city.

Rent is now 800+ no pets if you are a pet lover like me, it is pretty difficult. Most of these places are not maintained well. I could leave here and go to halifax or anywhere else in Canada, and get a place for much cheaper with the bonus of there being more work in some areas. It is sad what Newfoundland is turning into — slumlord land.

Rather than anyone addressing the issue, they made it seem in the media like we were poor and useless. What a crock! People need to wake up here.

I try to go to housing, and that seems as if it will be impossible. The waitlist I have heard is in the 1000s for a 1 bedroom place because of the insane amount of rent wanted by the slumlords of Newfoundland.

Even the decent landlords are difficult to actually get a place with because they tell you, “I can’t give you an appointment time, there are far too many people looking right now for this place. you will have to come randomly, but not today.” Most of them are also being very discriminatory, asking for age, proof of employment, what you do on your weekends, etc. I called human rights and they won’t do anything about this unless you are “in the real situation”. How ridculous is that? It is a human rights issue.

The government needs to step in and find ways to regulate these things. It makes no sense to allow the rent to continue to rapidly increase. This will cause mass homelessness, especially in such a weak economy with constant lay offs and only part-time/seasonal work. It is also causing the so called “shortage of work” that we have. Everyone is moving away to better themselves. No one cares here about trades people or any other fresh-out-of-college person. There is hardly any beginning positions, and we should be ashamed that we are letting out future down with raising costs and no apprenticeships.

Oh and btw, the tenant board is unless and should be redone entirely. They only seem to protect the slumlords.

Apartments need to be regulated! Someone argued before that landlords would be worse on repairs if it was…but I don’t see the logic in that considering that people are currently neglecting their rental places.

Rant by Ranter

«

»

 

76 Responses

  1. avatar
    seaguy Says:

    They can be really bad sometimes. We just moved into a place and had issues on day one. We have gotten to the point where we just face facts and fix anything we can ourselves (as renters, in general). Our most recent issue was something we weren’t qualified to do (and it was way too expensive) and it took a good 3 weeks to get done. Meanwhile our landlords are on vacation and responding to my concerns with “lol”. We were so angry we debated moving but really the next one will probably be as bad as the current/last/every other one we have had. There is often just a major lack of empathy. Also, fuck post-dated checks.

  2. avatar
    JK Says:

    “I was unable to tell them things because I was afraid I would be evicted once again.”

    So your apartment was a piece of shit, and you didn’t do so much as call to make a complaint? How do you expect the problems to be addressed if you don’t identify them?

    “the stove in the basement apartment was faulty and not checked”

    How do you “check” a stove for being “faulty”? Either it turns on or it doesn’t. It probably caught fire because it was filled with mouse turds.

    “Most of them are also being very discriminatory, asking for age, proof of employment”

    Landlords want to make sure you’re old enough to enter into a contract? Landlords want to make sure you have a job so that you can pay rent? How terrible! How discriminatory!

    “It makes no sense to allow the rent to continue to rapidly increase”

    But house prices are rapidly increasing. I own a 3br house, and my mortgage payment is just under $1100. Insurance for a house in which the owner doesn’t live is anywhere from $50-200 a month. Are you suggesting that landlords should rent their properties at a loss?

    “No one cares here about trades people or any other fresh-out-of-college person.”

    Cry me a river. “Oh, you’re fresh out of college? Yes b’y, live here for free as long as ya wants”

    Maybe you need to realize that if you’re fresh out of college and don’t have a decent job, you can’t afford to live in the downtown core.

    Sure, there are slum lords in this city, and a lot of the big property management places in the *cough* downtown *cough* area are assholes, but it seems like you’re not doing anything to help your situation. The fact that you lived in a piece of shit house and DIDN’T FILE A COMPLAINT about anything is laughable.

  3. avatar
    JK Says:

    Out of curiosity, what were the issues you had on day 1? Did you not notice the issues when you were viewing the apartment?

    Also out of curiosity, what was the issue that took three weeks to fix? Depending on the severity of the issue, three weeks may not have been unreasonable.

    And hey, landlords are allowed to go on vacation too, right? Yes, they shouldn’t be responding to complaints with “lol”, but they’re private citizens with jobs, just like you, so I’m not sure why you have an issue with them going on vacation.

    If you’d threatened to contact the landlord tenancy board, like you should have, the issues probably would have been fixed a LOT quicker.

  4. avatar
    ranter Says:

    Please actually read before making comments JK. I did make a complaint, I made several to the city 2 months before the fire. Oh, the place was in bad condition and the person who had the fire in their place said that the bulb kept breaking constantly, which indicates there is an electrical issue of some sort. It didn’t suprise me considering the neglect. I was looking for another place but was having difficultly.

    You also have no right to judge me because you don’t know me, and you don’t even know which situation I am in. I didn’t say I didn’t have money to pay my bills and my rent. I say the human rights thing because there is no reason for anyone to be assuming someone does not have money just because they can’t show proof of employment. People have EI or savings when they are unnfortuate enough to lose work due to no fault of their own while they search for more work. Also, judging people based on their age is actually very discriminating. Someone who is 18-19 (I am not) can be just as mature as someone who is 30+. Many of these people are also hard workers and good people. There are bad people in various age groups.

    I love my pet also and that lessens my chances whereas in a place like Nova Scotia, I can find one much easier. So sue me that I love my pet, I had him for a long time and he isn’t loud or dirty and I take care of him like someone should.

    The government should step in and regulate the pricing a little and help renters out somehow so they can lower it slightly. I never asked for it to be super low or asked for a handout, but prices are going up by large amounts and slumlords are raising it up, not fixing things, and pocketing the money. There is an issue. If people don’t have shelter, it harms them when they are looking for work. Also, it is hard to get an apartment because people are not even taking appointments in most occasions and their is a lot of people looking. Believe me, I was up at 6am getting ready to look everywhere, everyday.

    I’ve been out of college a while, but it isn’t hard to notice all the jobs only wanting 3-5 years experience in many fields. While I understand people are getting busy, we should never leave our training out! That is where it starts, and then that is how you get experience. It isn’t a difficult concept.

    Instead of attacking people, I would rather talk about the obvious issues. Please refrain from judging each other and lets try to focus on the obvious problem. juding will just help nobody in the end. We are all people and we are better than that. I called some landlords decent, but they are getting hard to find.

  5. avatar
    ranter Says:

    actually, threatening a slumlord with the tenant board doesn’t work well at all. They evict you with the “no reason” clause. That is a loophole. And the tenant board have never helped me.

    My landlord was only available when the rent was due. All other times, the phone was off. Long vacation.

    It is ok for a landlord to be on vacation, but not to completely neglect their duties.

  6. avatar
    ranter Says:

    oh and btw, when I said unable to tell them things, that was the 2 months before the fire. They were physically there but the landlord had came in with them and was walking around with them. I tried to say something and was interupted, and they left quickly without looking at everything, even though the landlord said they had been there to see the windows. Then I called the city directly (property complaints) on the same day telling them the various issues and I asked someone to come out and re-inspect. I explained there was still a problem.

  7. avatar
    ranter Says:

    oh and I also made a complain about the mold apartment to the city. They called me a year later and I was long gone from the apartment. They were just only then sending someone over to investigate. I would say it was just my luck, but it is happening to many others here too.

  8. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    JK hit the nail on the head. I couldn’t have said it better myself.

    St. John’s does not have a significant problem with slums and low vacancy, this city is just full of entitled whiners. People making minimum wage (or even worse, welfare) expect to have executive class accommodations handed to them on a silver platter. They also expect to have pets, parties, and so forth. When they realize that they can’t afford exactly what they want they start crying about “slumlords” and low vacancy. Cry me a river. Learn to live within your means rather than just screaming for more socialist government regulations and handouts. We need less government involvement in housing, not more. Share an apartment with a few other people, just go on Kijiji if you don’t know anyone, people are desperate to get their extra rooms rented. That’s what you do when you’re broke. I’m a poor student and I have never had any trouble finding decent accommodations with good landlords, but I also know to live within my means and I know that I cant afford a palace all to myself.

  9. avatar
    ranter Says:

    I have a partner. I am not looking to live with roommates. That never turns out good. Not everyone can have a roommate, and to assume that isn’t fair. I don’t have a sense of entitlement, I am not looking for a palace. I just want a decent, affordable place where I can have my pet. I see no problem with that.

  10. avatar
    seaguy Says:

    I love people like JK, they act like it’s not possible for someone to have a valid complaint. I think it’s obvious why I didn’t go into detail about my issue. Not every renter is a partying college student or over entitled whiner (GEKKKKOOOOOOOO!). And I’m sure there are many bad tenants out there as well but I am a good tenant, I am an adult and I like to eat cooked food. If I had the money to go out and buy my own appliances I would probably just buy a house. Should I replace broken appliances myself? And yes, the tenancy board was contacted. You can threaten to withhold rent or move out, in writing, at a specific date if the issue is not resolved. Since I like to at least try and have a decent relationship with my landlord I would rather not threaten to move out less than a month after moving in. As for my vacation comment I do of course agree that landlords are real people with lives (except my second to last landlord) who sometimes even deserve a vacation but it is easy to feel soured when you can’t get something fixed, something that they have to fix knowing full well they are ON VACATION WITH MY MONEY! I probably should have checked the appliance before I moved in but this particular issue took at least 10 mins to occur.

  11. avatar
    ranter Says:

    My partner also has medical issues that makes living with others very difficult, we must live on our own. Again, I wasn’t asking for a handout, I am asking that someone regulate it better before the slumlords make it impossible to live. Repairs need to be worked on more, or we will have a bunch of old, falling down houses. Gekko, you must have been pretty lucky to find something decent. I have had 5 bad places, it doesn’t seem like coincidence.

  12. avatar
    Mark Says:

    i’m willing to bet that when someone simply says “stop feeling so entitled” or “get a real job”, they’re actually telling you to “get a job in oil/gas”, “Do something you don’t actually want to do”. “If you just did what I did and followed the money, then you could just get a brand new place in Airport Heights, just like me”. You say it like it’s as simple as hitting a light-switch, but everyone has a unique set of circumstances and it takes years to get up the ladder, career wise. Even the guy pipe-fitting for $32 an hour will eventually see that plateau and decrease once he’s struggling to keep his job from 100 other prospective, but unemployed pipe-fitters.

    Like any rental agreement, you abide by the tenancy act, you get repairs when the apartment needs them. No one is asking for marble countertops for -$600 a month. they just want fair and expected functionality from the place they pay to live in. If it’s in shambles, then maybe that agreement needs to change. Maybe that landlord shouldn’t be a landlord. I’d love to see tougher restrictions on landlords + subsidies to help landlords out. It’ll mean people finally get better quality rentals, Period.

    Sorry, but when I hear of folks getting same-size and feature apartments/houses in toronto or montreal for $100-$200 a month less than here, there’s a serious disillusion going on. Some places are worth the $800 a month, some most definitely are not.

    AND Not everyone can help it if a certain “economic boom” didn’t get their salaries up or help them make an exagerated amount of money from an inflated resource. They often have to find themselves struggling against a ton of inflated costs, much like renting, even if the unit itself hasn’t changed much.

  13. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    You said you went to NL Housing, so yeah you are looking for a handout.

    And yes, an “affordable” place that allows pets is too much to ask for. Landlords are under no obligation to allow your animal on their property. I have a real problem with people in your situation who insist on having pets, it just isn’t fair to the animal, and your attitude certainly does reek of entitlement. Personally I would love to have a dog, but I will not be getting one until I am more established and actually own a house. That’s called being responsible.

  14. avatar
    ranter Says:

    So what if I was trying to get housing. That doesn’t mean I am asking for a handout at all. Housing is there to help you when your in the very situation I am in. I don’t make enough to pay 800-900+ in rent atm, and i am trying hard to fix that. I lost my place because of a fire and I am not finding any places. I had my pet A LONG time as I said, and I will not get rid of him. Again, I am being judged. You don’t know me at all, so stop attempting to make me look like I am some poor slob sitting at home. Everything here changed really fast, too fast for people to keep up. You people always try to judge and then the real issue never gets addressed. It is pretty sad. I am not replying to your bull anymore. I for one, am leaving NL and it’s disappointing because I would like to stay. But this place is crawling with unfriendly, greedy people. Bye Bye.

  15. avatar
    Dj Says:

    Actually the vacancy rate is around 1% which the last time I checked is very low.

  16. avatar
    RT Says:

    So where are you going that doesn’t have unfriendly, greedy people?

  17. avatar
    andrew waterman Says:

    Taking advantage of the social programs our taxes pay for isn’t a handout. Just look to your wallet and your MCP. It’s about taking care of the people of this country whether rich or poor or healthy or unhealthy. If you got hit by a car today, hit and run say, and couldn’t work because of the injuries you would need affordable housing, access to healthcare, a bus pass, a wheelchair maybe. I would be honored to know that our taxes go to people like you. But of course you aren’t in that situation.

    We can argue til we’re black and blue about people taking advantage of welfare, ei, etc…. it happens all the time. But I would still have these programs in place and deal with the loss of money to these petty people just to have one person who needed assistance, get the help they need.

  18. avatar
    Gordon Gekko Says:

    Getting hit by a car and not being able to work isn’t the same as “I don’t want to live with roommates and I need to have a pet”.

  19. avatar
    Anon Says:

    Gekko, you don’t know what you’re talking about.

    My job takes me into the apartments of people who are living on low-income and minimum wage and yes, this city has a MAJOR problem with slums and slum landlords. In one case, a lady complained about her situation to the landlord and the result was all of her things being locked out of her room and left for others living in the house to pick through.

    Huge housing crisis in this city. Thanks to the OP for starting this thread.

  20. avatar
    ranter Says:

    I know I am getting away from here. This place sucks. I know I will still be dealing with unfriendly, greedy people, but at least I will have some work and an apartment and a few friends around and will be able to save a little. This place is dying. I’ve lived here my whole life and it gets worse all the time. All of my friends left to better themselves, and I am stuck in this hellhole because I was sticking around for my family and because I loved it here. I feel constantly like there are weights on my chest now.

    I’ve tried again and again here to make a living, but to no avail. Everyone here is overly stressed all the time creating lots of stress for me. Nobody wants to help you learn. Every job I was at there are people throwing stuff around out of anger, yelling and flipping out because “things suck at work”, constantly making it far less productive. Mismanagement is everywhere here. I never would act that way. It is despicable. It creates a terrible, unprofessional, environment and causes everyone to start complaining. On one hand though, I do understand their frustrations. No one cares here. There is a LARGE amount of apathy.

    They raised the minimum wage to help people out only for everything to skyrocket because they did so, and are not bothering to increase wages for people who are from college even though I couldn’t care less about the $, its still very disappointing when you go to college to improve and are only finding 3-5 years experience and nepotism left right and center. I have passion for what I do and it is more about that. I can’t get ahead here so I will leave.

    There are too many employers here who have the mentality of wanting everything for nothing and want to send their work to China. What they don’t see is this will collapse the place that they are in and they are only paying into the Chinese people’s slavery and mistreatment while not hiring Canadians leading to mass unemployment. China is falling anyway and Canada and the US are turning into them. Realistically the whole bloody world is because of everyone’s selfish attitudes.

    People deserve a place to live nonetheless and they deserve to eat. Just because someone didn’t chose to be a lawyer or doctor doesn’t mean they don’t deserve to have basic needs taken care of and good work to do if they are willing and raises so they can provide for their family if they are doing a good job. Anyone who disagrees with that should go and try to wear the shoes of homeless people, hard workers or those who are unfortunate enough to not find work. OH WAIT!!! You are too “entitled” to do that because you went to school and now your a lawyer, doctor, or some other person with a profession in demand currently. I forgot. Why don’t you wake up and see there are others who deserve and work hard?

    Oh and I know I wasn’t going to reply, but I had to say – How is having a pet an entitlement? There are people here on welfare who are in with the housing (which is pretty stable for most) and they’ve had their pet for many years. In fact, many of them have animals, so to say I can’t and shouldn’t have one just because I’ve had bad luck with my apartments is just ridiculous. So they are more entitled than me even though I am searching for work to be able to afford a stable home? I don’t judge these people, but there is something wrong when you say one is only allowed a pet if they have a stable place. Things change. When I first had my animal, I had a stable place to live. That changed. So are you saying if someone was rich or well off and somehow lost it all they should go put down poor old bootsy the dog or give them away to a stranger who they don’t know? Most people would probably do this, but that shows no respect either in my opinion. I consider my pet a part of my family and he is treated as such. I also pay a damage deposit for every apartment I go to, so if for some reason my pet does something, my deposit is gone, so really it is not an entitlement, it is something I am paying for if my pet does something, which he does not because I am responsible, and I take care of him, something I can’t say for everyone who has a house. (leaving feces in the middle of the sidewalks when they go take them for walks)

  21. avatar
    Reluctantly Blond Says:

    OP I’m so sorry for what you went through. I agree with you, apartments should be regulated better. The rent is atrocious and the conditions, especially downtown is horrid. If I wanted to pay a huge amount for a crap apartment, I would move to Toronto! The rent ads are very discriminatory and for those who are on work disability or below the poverty line, where are they suppose to go? Central Newfoundland was so much better for rent cost and quality. I hope the City of St. John’s or someone steps in to help with the housing shortage.

    Take Care

  22. avatar
    Reluctantly Blond Says:

    I also have a medical issue that makes it hard to live with roommates. (I’ve tried) Luckily my companion and I are saving up for a hopefully decent place. You have my empathy ranter.

  23. avatar
    Former St. Johns Resident Says:

    This is an unfortunate circumstance to say the least. And sadly, I certainly don’t think this is an isolated incident. I moved to St. John’s 10 years ago and stayed for just over 5. The entire time I payed less than 500 a month (2BR) in fairly decent areas of town close to the university. In truth I had no connections and was a poor student….lately St. John’s just does not seem to care about the ever increasing disadvantaged in its walls.

    St. John’s has become something far different than it used to be even a few years ago. To say slumlords are growing in number is an understatement. People mortgage outrageously priced homes at low interest rates because the banks will give it too them but then have to charge high rent just to cover their basic mortgage cost. Maybe its just me but that seems a little greedy and certainly foolish as eventually interest rates will rise and the greedy rich may find themselves on the other side of the coin.

    The bottom line is the gap between the rich and poor is widening and its time that the municipalities did something about. Here’s an idea “Rent Control”. Yes, I know there are a host of concerns with rent control as well but the bottom line is, at this point, St. John’s is simply not affordable. Unfortunately, its the politicians, decision makers and those with a vested interest in real estate that are making the decisions.

    Hence the reason I no longer live in St. John’s :)

  24. avatar
    Marshmellow Says:

    You mentioned in your initial rant that you could move somewhere else and get a better apartment for less money, and a better paying job. So why don’t you?
    Also, it’s not unreasonable for a landlord to ask if you have a job. They are trying to determine if you are going to be able to pay the rent, and the easiest way to do that is to ask you about your work situation. If you don’t have a job, but do have savings then you can let them know that. Maybe try to work out a deal with them where you pay a larger deposit (a couple months rent in advance for instance), undergo a credit check and/or show bank records.
    I also don’t think it’s incredibly unreasonable for a landlord to ask a perspective tenants age. Yes, older people are just as capable of having parties and/or being destructive in a rental property as an 18 or 19 year old, but it is a little less likely.
    As for the pet thing, I agree that it sucks trying to find an apartment when you have a pet. It’s hard if you have a cat; it becomes almost impossible if you have a dog. But again, you can mention this to the landlord and ask if there is a compromise that can be made, such as paying a pet deposit in case of any damage or paying a little extra rent each month, again in case of any damage.

  25. avatar
    Former St. Johns Resident Says:

    Well said. Especially on that last part. Costs of living are increasing dis-proportionally to overall economic income in St. Johns. Yes, a fair number have seen pay raises and gains from the oil industry but how about everyone else. A whole lot more people do not work in oil and gas than actually do.

  26. avatar
    Former St. Johns Resident Says:

    Marshmellow,

    You do raise some genuine and valid points regarding renters looking for employment history and the use of alternate agreements to accommodate pets etc… (Lets face it, to get a credit card you have to have credit history).

    However I think your missing the major issue of overuse and abuse of this approach. Take for example the phrase “give an inch, take a mile”. This appears to be what has occurred in St. Johns. Landlords are taking larger, bolder steps including things like gender, ethnicity and age. The bottom line is, that this process is discriminatory and needs to be addressed.

    I would like to comment on your initial statement as well about the ranter just moving….while I am unaware of the unique situation of this individual, it is important for us to remember that not everyone has that option. Personal, familial, financial and institutional barriers can prevent people from leaving to find employment elsewhere.

  27. avatar
    Marshmellow Says:

    Former St. Johns Resident,

    I agree that including things like gender and ethnicity are going too far in determining who you rent an apartment too, but I do not think that asking age is going too far. If you are renting an apartment and it were to come down between two people for you to choose who to rent to, and once person was in their 30’s and could provide references from prior landlords, and the other person was 19 years old. Who would you choose really? I know in that situation, if I was looking for a renter, I would go with the person in their 30’s. I do, however, agree that completely ruling out the possibility of renting to anyone based on age alone is discriminatory.

    I also get that there are situations that may prevent someone from leaving to find work elsewhere, which is why I asked why they don’t leave instead of just saying “don’t like it, get out”. With this said, there seems to be a lot of people in St. John’s that like to complain about their situation (no job, or not enough pay, paying too much for rent, etc…) that CAN do something about it but don’t because they don’t want to step out of their comfort zone.

  28. avatar
    Christopher Says:

    SO people are complaining here about being asked there age/proof of income and what type of person they are on weekends.

    I would love to see some of you “people” survive on the mainland. I ‘spose next thing you will be complaining about is when landlords ask for a background check as well.

  29. avatar
    andrew waterman Says:

    My apologies. It’s just when you said “… you went to NL Housing, so yeah you are looking for a handout.” it meant that in your opinion, everyone who goes to newfoundland housing is looking for a handout and that social programs such as these are nothing but a drain on our economy. I guess I looked too far into it, but when I hear the word handout in that context, it’s usually what I think the person is suggesting.

    Wow… it’s as if I’m learning…..

  30. avatar
    BB Says:

    Apartments are more affordable the further you go from the DT core; and the houses that the apartments are in are newer. An apartment in a 100 year old house is not going to be new, is not going to have new wiring and not going to have new plumbing. Try Mt. Pearl and you might find something decent. Good luck and I hope all works out for you.

  31. avatar
    JK Says:

    OK, so the facts are:

    1) There is an EXTREMELY low vacancy rate in the city. I think someone quoted a rate of 1%; this is probably true.

    2) Rents are EXTREMELY high in the city. The last house I lived in was $1200 a month, and it was literally a 4br piece of shit — black mould everywhere.

    So, the question is, what do we do about it?

    A few people have suggested that the government should regulate rent prices. This is ridiculous to the point of being offensive. House prices have skyrocketed because of rich people (either working here in the oil & gas industry, or making a fortune in Alberta and coming home) buying them, but you CAN’T MAKE LAWS SAYING THAT PEOPLE CAN’T BUY HOUSES. You can’t. So we have a bunch of rich people buying houses, which means that there’s a demand for houses. When there’s a demand, prices go up — this is because people are willing to pay more money to purchase a house.

    When prices go up, mortgages go up as well. If you paid $200k for a house, you’re looking at paying roughly $1000/mo on your mortgage. This cannot be changed; obviously your monthly mortgage payment must be able to actually pay off your mortgage.

    So now we’ve got a bunch of homeowners who have to pay $1000/mo on their mortgage. If they choose to rent out their house, they HAVE to charge more than $1000/mo in rent. They HAVE TO. Private citizens are not running charities; their mortgage has to be paid and repairs have to be done, stoves have to be replaced, basic house maintenance has to be done, etc.

    The question I’m going to pose to the crowd is this: How can the government regulate rent prices? Will the government force homeowners to rent their property at a loss? Will the government subsidize rent?

    If they force homeowners to rent at a loss, NOBODY WILL RENT OUT THEIR HOUSE. That 1% vacancy rate turns into a 0% vacancy rate.

    If they subsidize rent, that means everyone’s taxes go up, so the money you’re “saving” on rent just gets taken out of your paycheque every week.

    These two scenarios obviously won’t work, so I pose the question again:

    How can the government regulate rent prices?

  32. avatar
    Take off the rose coloured glasses Says:

    Why is it up to someone else to hire you? Start your own business. There are too many people in this province who feel entitled to a wage, as if it’s their right to demand one from government, big business, or “somebody else”.

    Why not be that “somebody else” and start something, anything. Save your money, reinvest profits and grow it to the point that you can hire on your pick of employees. Make sure that you don’t hire family that you trust to help manage, hire someone off the street, preferably inexperienced, instead. Be sure that you pay more than market wages.

    “But but” you say. You can’t do that, you don’t have the money. You’d never stay in business if your products are priced higher than the competition. Welcome to the real world. Sucks, doesn’t it?

    Now, go around your house and take a look for things that are not “made in China”. Then come back here and rant about how it’s the business owner’s fault that the wages they offer won’t allow you to live where you want and have pets.

  33. avatar
    ranter Says:

    I didn’t say that they shouldn’t make things in China. I said that employers should hire here as well and many do not because for some reason, they are judging people here and think China is the only profit maker. Everything is falling because of it. Look around you. Even profitable businesses will fail because of their attitudes since 75% of people getting rich from China owe most of their wealth to them. As soon as the people in China start demanding for more, which they already have started btw, what difference will here and there be then? So we are depending on their oppression. Where will business people run to when that ends? Probably back to us so that they don’t have to ship and so on.

    People should be able to live decently and not be in a slum, I didn’t say people should be given handouts constantly and be super rich, but they deserve enough to be able to keep up with where they live, which was the purpose of raising the min wage in the first place. But that also brought up everything else like apartments, food, bills, and made SLUMLORDS not care about repairs since it cost too much for them. No raises for hard workers though. It’s all profits nowadays.

    Actually, I could start a business, but not everyone can. And no, not everyone has the money to start one. In fact, I am starting a business very soon. It is low cost on my end. But guess what? Not everyone has the skill to start a business either (not refering to me because I do). You need to be careful with starting one, making business plans, marketing, etc. for it to succeed, and there are many other factors. Also, it definitely is better to have some EXPERIENCE before beginning your own business, and Newfoundland falls short on that. For example, an electrician just finishing school is typically not going to start their own business right away. They are going to spend some time learning so that when they do start a business, they will know what they are doing, and can teach others. Not only that, they can do it safely. But nobody wants to train people anymore. We’ve failed our youth who want businesses and need more than just “you can do it”.

  34. avatar
    ranter Says:

    Oh and many services with low running cost and high returns can be started without China, but yet people here and in the US are sending even those jobs overseas and Harper is trying to get them all into Canada, despite the fact that there are good people here without jobs who want them. Profits are not everything, and there are still ways to make profits here. You just have to be smart. Oh and also, people do still buy for quality, and there are many things that come from China that don’t have quality. If people worked on quality, they would have an edge on their competition anyways. So business people are crying because they have competition. Deal with it. Sounds like how bell and rogers are trying to make it so the smaller companies cannot compete. What a load of bull.

    I am a hard working person and I have money savings, but this place is still terrible and mismanaged. I can’t see how most people are surviving with the terrible mold growth in some places here, and with the cost of rent,food,etc. continuing to soar. And slumlords are here taking advantage with no repercussions. Of course it is only going to get worse, even for those who do have money.

    If it’s made in China and is cheaper, why is it products are going up by so very much for everyone? Obviously there is demand, but if businesses are making so much “profit” and saving money by going to China, why is the cost of living increasing? It’s called greed. Employers even came online on the telegram and said they don’t care about people and their families. Shame on them.

  35. avatar
    ranter Says:

    half my comment is in moderation now. It’s a bit long, sorry about that, but all this stuff needs to be said. I am tired of the excuses from business people in how they are letting things go off track and think they know exactly what it is they are doing all of the time. Everyone is human and should be treated as such. You need to stop treating others like they are all lazy bums just because they have something to say about issues that are concerning. I’m not a poor person, but I comment for those who are and even those who are not. We need to change things.

  36. avatar
    ranter Says:

    not really, on kijiji even many people who live in mount pearl want too much. It is still 800+ just about everywhere now. Even CBS and stuff is getting expensive. It is forcing many to have to deal with slumlords.

    I wasn’t in a 100 year old house. It was older though, and the issue was the stove in the basement apartment was not replaced for a long time and there was an obvious issue with it. how was I to know that? I didn’t speak with the person who lived there. I knew it was not good though and was trying to move. I had no choice but to move there at the time because I was evicted from my previous apartment and the kitchen was falling apart and needed to be redone, something else I couldn’t know about. I was unfortuately on EI at the time. I couldn’t find anything else in such short notice.

    I wish everyone would stop making the situation seem light when I almost died and it could happen to other people who are unfortuate enough to be stuck with a slumlord who completely avoids all issues and nothing is done to stop them. They are criminals in my book. Even in the tenant act is a unlawful to not repair and maintain safety.

  37. avatar
    Former St. Johns Resident Says:

    JK,

    Clearly you are uninformed about the intricate micro and macro economic factors that are associated with aspects of housing development and rent control. According to you “Government regulation of rent is ridiculous to the point of being offensive”. You also seem to believe that this is not possible due to the nature of free market economics. The bottom line is that the rent control DOES exist (ex. New York) and the jury is still out on its overall implication.

    While many economists will argue that rent control (i.e. price ceiling) will inevitably cause more harm than good, many social activists and public interest groups suggest that rent control is the only way to limit increasing rates of homelessness. Additionally, given the issues that can arise with rent control, there are other options such as rent stabilization.

    You also have to consider that St. John’s NL, has a tiny population with a vast geographic availability. The current state of housing is completely unnecessary. You are talking about homes being built and people taking out mortgages that they then have to rent at a certain rate because they need to pay their mortgage etc… Don’t you think that this might lead to an exponential growth in the rent curves (as has happened in the past number of years)? This is completely unsustainable from and economic standpoint. Tiny St. Johns does not have the economic input to maintain this type of approach for long. The bottom line is that having a stable renting class of workers is critical to the long term health of a community and government intervention on rent may be necessary.

    Secondly you made the comment “you cant’t make laws saying that people can’t buy houses”. While this may be true from a literal stand point, I would have argue that government certainly can and should control how people purchase houses. It’s all about regulation of things like interest rates and down payments. What happened to the days when you needed a substantial down payment to buy a home? Why do people borrow what they do? People buy these 3 and 4 hundred thousand dollar homes because it can be done with 5% down payment over 30 years. This is absurd. Do you think that regulation of the amount that people could borrow might limit the total rent that they would have to charge as you put it?

  38. avatar
    JK Says:

    Yep, I’m definitely uninformed about most aspects of housing development and rent control.

    After reading up on rent stabilization, don’t we have that in place here already? i.e., a landlord can set the rent on a vacant property to whatever they want, but once a tenant moves in, there’s a maximum % that the rent can increase when the lease is being renewed.

    You mention that there’s tons of land available for development, and that’s certainly true. What can be done to put some of it to good use? It seems like all of the new housing developments are geared towards large, suburban-style houses that are unaffordable for low-income families. Maybe the city could impose regulations on new subdivisions requiring that houses are built at a variety of price points?

    As far as regulating the amount that people can borrow — I’d like to think that after the meltdown a few years ago, banks have given up on lending to people they know can’t make the payments. Whether that’s the case is anyone’s guess, but I mean, as a society, we have no problem with enslaving people with debt; get close to the limit on your credit card, and you’ll soon find that your limit has increased.

    I’m not sure $400k houses are being put up for rent, but even with a 20% down payment that’s still a hefty mortgage payment.

  39. avatar
    Adrian Says:

    Quebec, Ontario, BC, P.E.I, and Manitoba all have rent controls, eg. in Manitoba the increase was 1% for 2012:
    http://www.checkfirstonline.com/rent_increases.htm

    Newfoundland needs rent control legislation, now! Join this group
    http://groups.google.com/group/stcah

  40. avatar
    Adrian Says:

    p.s. there are currently NO limits on the amount a landlord can increase the rent in Newfoundland. I.e., JK, there is no “maximum % that the rent can increase when the lease is being renewed”; all they have to do is give 3 months’ notice.

  41. avatar
    ranter Says:

    It looks to me like we are starting to turn into places like Fort Murray, which makes no sense considering we have much lower wages and less work. It is quite obviously from greed.

    JT, why should my rent pay people’s entire mortgages and bills(water taxes, electric, etc) on a monthly basis? If these people with mortgages are so responsible, then they shouldn’t have bought their house in the first place if they couldn’t keep up with raising mortgage prices, just because the down payments were low and they wanted it. Nobody can see the future of course, but it wasn’t hard to see that it would cause this nonsense. They should have known the banks would raise the mortgage.

    Besides, a tenant isn’t responsible for all of the owner/landlords bills but there are tons of people who are renting that end up having to do the repairs on their own just to make their apartment livable and are paying far too much. The landlords/owners had a choice, I don’t, because I seriously have looked and many of the places I went to are in bad repair, and I know they won’t be fixed before I move in due to many terrible experiences. And these are the only somewhat affordable places to live and are not even really affordable.

    Tenants take money from their OWN POCKETS to fix something they don’t even own and often don’t get compensated and eventually evicted under the no reason clause, which landlords/owners use to their heart’s content without repercussions.

    I love how people act like I am the “entitled” one, yet I have more responsibly by not buying what I can’t afford. I still need a place to live though, and it is becoming so costly to rent that it is almost just as well, even though I can’t afford it, to go out and get myself a house. I am leaving Newfoundland instead because I don’t want to be the landlord making people suffer because I can’t afford to repair or pay my mortgage/bills.

  42. avatar
    ranter Says:

    They shouldn’t be able to screw over all the tenants whom, whether low or medium income, are renting because they cannot afford a house, and in many cases these people work from paycheck to paycheck and still save what little they can. I understand that money house owners/landlords get from a tenant is theirs to do as they please with, but making us pay their full mortgages and bills by making the rent super high just because we are now a “have” province and because the banks like to shake things up is atrocious and greedy. Many are living off the backs of low/medium income people…Just because I can’t afford right now, and I am RESPONSIBLE enough to know it, I can’t put a downpayment on a house, even if it is only 15k say, because I know I can’t afford the mortgage. The banks wanted it to play out like this so they can make lots more cash. There is a problem with our system which needs to be fixed. I am tired of arguing black and blue with people for them to realize things.

    And then, the landlords have the nerve to not repair things that THEY ARE REQUIRED BY LAW to fix and they allow it to continue until someone gets hurt or almost killed like I was almost killed. I don’t feel safe anymore when I sleep at night for god sake. It didn’t need to come to that if only my landlord didn’t go on constant vacations and completely ignore repairs, even after he went to court with the city who were complaining about how badly it needed to all be fixed. And months after the city didn’t enforce, I almost die. In my previous apartment before that one, some people always fighting on the street drunk broke out my windows and it was never repaired. Scared the daylights out of me. The police came and I saw them laughing outside about it. WTF? And now, I am having lots of difficulty and I am restlessly trying to find a place to live in a place that has 1% vacancy rate. Very sad that nobody cares about people anymore, but instead, they only care about the money.

    first part of comment in moderation.

  43. avatar
    JK Says:

    I don’t think you read my post correctly. You seem to be under the impression that I said landlords were making your rent cover the cost of the mortgage on the landlord’s home. i.e., landlord buys a $500k home and rents out a 2br shitbox on Brazil Street at $1500/mo to cover the mortgage on his $500k home.

    That’s not what I said at all.

    What I said was that landlords must charge enough in rent to cover the mortgage on the RENTAL property. i.e., if the mortgage payment on the 2br shitbox is $900/mo, then the landlord has to charge $900 + insurance + a bit extra for upkeep.

    You do realize that not all landlords have fully paid off the houses they rent out, right?

  44. avatar
    JK Says:

    Sorry, replied to the wrong comment, see “I don’t think…” below.

  45. avatar
    ranter Says:

    LOL are you even reading? I said if they can’t afford the whole thing that isn’t my fault. IT IS NOT ME WHO NEEDS TO HELP WITH UPKEEP BECAUSE THAT IS THERE RESPONSIBLITY! MY GOD! They need to be responsible just as much as I do JT. That is there own expense, I am just renting and most places ARE NOT MAINTAINED SO YOUR ARGUEMENT IS INVALID. My rent doesn’t nesscessarily need to cover that in full. Get over yourself already. You are trying to keep proving me wrong for some messed up reason. I can’t see how you think there isn’t an issue. It isn’t right to be paying them to help them keep up with the mortgage and all their bills, espiecally if they don’t have there house paid off. Just say I was to leave and they couldn’t get another tenant right away, are they going to stop paying mortgage? So what if they don’t have it paid in full? That isn’t my fking fault! THAT IS THERE RESPONSIBLITY! OMG, I HAVE A HEADACHE! YOU NEVER READ WHAT I SAID AT ALL! WOW! SUCH ARROGANCE AND IGNORANCE!

  46. avatar
    ranter Says:

    Also, I pay a damage deposit in case I do something wrong! They are SUPPOSED to be EQUALLY responsible for fixing the apartment, putting in fresh paint every so often, etc. Stop acting like they should not have known this before hand and its ok for me to have to take on those expenses. Why don’t you go read the tenant act, and come back and respond again? If I am giving them $700 for an apartment or however much, I still expect them to cover things in THEIR house because THEY own it and when I am gone, someone else will follow. I am not a permanent tenant and making me pay their expenses for everything is wrong on so many levels especially when they are not maintaining things.

    This place is going to be a ghost town with falling-apart houses and with constant employment. And now, the CONS want to force people into work. Here comes our salvery. Great, we are now mexico. lol I pay into that EI on every cheque! Federal studies suggest everyone should move who are on EI. Prepare to move NLers. Why don’t they do a study on how people are constantly displaced from their homes, the “shortage of work” is all a big scam (because it is since we have lots of people applying and not getting work, this is due to them getting all foreigners) and also about why it is that there are no entry level positions, and why the house of assembly cannot talk about issues because they act like 5 year olds! That sounds like a better study!

  47. avatar
    ranter Says:

    btw, I meant constant UNemployment of course. Typo.

  48. avatar
  49. avatar
    ranter Says:

    and tell your friends to sign and people you know! Lets put a stop to this!

  50. avatar
    Take off the rose coloured glasses Says:

    Wow. Yet you think that it’s the landlord’s fault that you can’t afford or refuse to pay market rates for housing.

    Someday I hope that you find that you are not the center of the universe. The world will be a better place.

    Happy travels, and mind the door…

  51. avatar
    ranter Says:

    There are tons of people in my situation,I’m not the center of the universe. People like you think you are the center of the universe. you don’t care about people at all. No worries, where one door closes another opens.

    Stop acting like you know everything like nobody goes through a crisis. Read everything else too! There is uprise here in crime, people have killed themselves because they couldn’t afford to live, the mha recently said we don’t have licensed home inspectors, constant articles about it, the list goes on. This is proof of issues. You think you know everything about each person’s life and you think nobody has troubles. You think, “there is no reason for this scum to not have a job and have money” get off your high horse. Anyone can be in similar situations.

    Umm, it is the slumlord’s fault! Read everything before you write. There is no reason for houses to be like they are and us having to pay most of our pay cheques for apartments that are falling down around our ears that we don’t get to keep! We need regulation for people to be able to thrive! We need more perm work so those with houses can survive so they can keep rent at good rates for those who are not fortunate enough to have high pay! You think everyone makes a mint and should? You are insane if you do.

    Also, people need help sometimes. Even you have had help at one point. Don’t lie and say you didn’t. That’s how people survive.

  52. avatar
    Take off the rose coloured glasses Says:

    You’re still here?

    You have no idea what I think, nor what I’ve had to do to ensure that there has always been a roof over my and my family’s head, no matter what personal sacrifice that took.

    There are no free houses. Landlords must buy, maintain, pay taxes, interest, and all the other costs associated with them.

    Either you’re not willing or you’re not able to pay what it costs to keep a roof over your head. If you’re not willing, that makes you a freeloader. We don’t need freeloaders. If you’re not able, go to the government and find the program that applies to you, they exist. If that doesn’t cover it, find a charity that’s willing to support your worthy cause.

    It’s not the landlord’s problem, it is your problem. Try helping yourself.

  53. avatar
    ranter Says:

    Never once did I say I want something for free… Anyway let me try and make it simpler for you. If I buy a house which has an apartment in it and rent it out should I expect to get my entire mortgage payments along with taxes from that apartment? no I should not by doing that it is then the owner of the house who is freeloading more so when they don’t fix any of the problems which is happening a lot here. There are some good landlords out there but the truth of the matter is there is probably a 1:20 ratio of good to bad landlords.

    It is a lazy attitude to not fix problems with apartments, expect to get the damage deposit when the place was left in the same condition it was in or expect to get a whole mortgage payment from a small section of your entire house.

    You’re exactly right I have no idea what you think I do however know that you are arrogant you have spent the whole time talking here making assumptions about myself or others and when someone does the same to you, you get overly defensive this also shows me that you know little to nothing of what you’re actually talking about because you lack any perspective.

  54. avatar
    Take off the rose coloured glasses Says:

    A landlord shoud be able to recover 100% of the costs of their rental units, plus a profit. You obviously have no idea what hosuing costs in this city. That’s not your landlord’s fault. Blame the economy that makes St. John’s a desireable place to live, and the resulting real estate prices and high taxes that any landlord must pass on to their tenant if they are to remain solvent.

    You state that there’s a 1:20 ratio of good landlords to bad. Do you have a cite for that, or are you just making statistics up to suit your argument? The majority of tenants that I know have zero issues with their landlords or apartments. By no coincidence, they’re renting at market rates, and not in low rent dumps downtown.

    You get what you pay for. You’re not able or willing to pay for a livable place, see my previous comment for your remedy for that.

  55. avatar
    Dj Says:

    ranter I’m sorry but you really have no clue as to what you are talking about. people cannot just get loans for hundreds of thousands for a house… they must qualify… and this qualification is for a specific amount based on what they can afford (what they make vs how much they owe)……..the total amount of rent cannot be applied to the mortgage, only 50% the other 50% counts as income which they have to claim on taxes…..there is no reason anyone should expect someone to take a loss when renting out a property there are in fact a lot of other costs included into the rent which one might never think of ….insurance, property tax, water tax, mortgage insurance…… if you want to blame someone for highrent blame the market or economy……all this aside i do believe that there are a high number of “slumlords” in the city or anywhere else for that matter, but this is not because they charge high rent its because they don’t give a shit about the condition of the property they take the rent (which should be high enough to cover cost of upkeep) but put nothing back into the house….so i do agree that living conditions should be regulated not price, price is dictated by another beast!

  56. avatar
    MW Says:

    Ranter, you are an clearly uninformed of the real costs of maintaining an apartment. Are you aware that water alone costs $800 a year?

  57. avatar
    ranter Says:

    Stop making excuses for slumlords. If everything is so expensive, government should regulate. That’s like 66 bucks a month…I pay more than that on my phone…If that’s the best you could come back with it’s laughable.

    Also if you ACTUALLY READ what I said I stated that MOST LANDLORDS DO NOT MAINTAIN PROPERTY HERE, also I’m sure they get the grants from Canada like most of the other freeloaders when they do fix it. I’m sure every home owner here is getting grants from the government to fix their place and then saying hey the government gave me X amount of dollars to fix the place so now I can rent it out for more.

  58. avatar
    JK Says:

    “I’m sure every home owner here is getting grants from the government to fix their place”

    What does that even mean? Any references to back that up, or…?

    Actually, you know what? I’ve got a better idea. Why don’t you pop over to MLS.ca and find a property listing for the downtown area. Find a two- or three-bedroom house for sale that isn’t a fucking dump, post the link to the listing, and the grown-ups here will explain to you how rental properties work.

    If you’re not interested in doing that (i.e., dealing with actual facts based on an actual property), why don’t you come back here when you get your GED and maybe we can have a sensible conversation. Otherwise, I’m no longer interested in responding. You’re so clueless that it’s like explaining physics to an infant.

  59. avatar
    Relunatntly Blonde Says:

    You have a good heart OP. I hope you find a place where things are easier for you and your partner. This place can be very dark behind the bar scene and Newfoundland music. If my partner wasn’t already here, I would have left for Calgary. I know your frustration, Ranter. Hopefully you and your partner can find a fulfilling, exciting life else ware.

    On another note, it’s hard to start a business if everyone is doing the same thing. If everyone is trying to find a distinguishable niche then no one is. Ah life..

  60. avatar
    Chris Says:

    You are delusional, or either you have drank to much ORANGE CRUSH, or probably a combination of both. My monthly payment on my house is 1885 a month, property and water tax cost 2850 a year. So ranter since you are ever so brilliant when it comes to housing how much should I charge to rent my 2 bedroom basement apartment? 300 or 400 or 500 a month? I bloody don’t think so.

  61. avatar
    ranter Says:

    You know the amount of anger and defensiveness you show JK and just directly attack me something typically associated with youth or idiocy. Chris I’m not exactly sure where you’re paying $2850 in water taxes but it isn’t here.

    Also if you’re someone who is paying $1885 in a mortgage you have a MUCH larger house something you probably don’t need. I looked up the water taxes and in ST. JOHN’S it’s $615 per year http://www.stjohns.ca/cityservices/taxes/currenttax.jsp

    and as far as a mortgage goes for a $300000 house it’s somewhere between $1200-$1400 per month and land taxes are 1.06% of that so $3180 a year so around $1600 a month for a house with taxes paid give or take. and

    ###all this is assuming you bought your house within the last 3-4 years as even 5 or more years ago it was significantly less.###

    As far as maintenance goes there is little to none as most landlords do not take care of their places you know like how you were saying all downtown houses are dilapidated.

    And as far as the grants go the constant ads that used to come on any Canadian station to try and encourage people to get work done so there could be less unemployment is where I got that.

    This is an absolutely pointless conversation as I have already won any argument you may have because the best you can get back with is fake numbers or insults or facts that can’t be backed up by yourself. You can call many organizations that have to deal with housing issues and they will tell you there is a problem. I’m done anyway because arguing with an idiot will only bring you down to their levels and you have MUCH MORE experience than me.

  62. avatar
    Chris Says:

    Now listen up you sanctamonious POC. Who the hell are you to tell me what kind of house I “should live in”. As for the 2850 that includes property and water (learn how to read).

  63. avatar
    Elling Lien Says:

    Guys, guys, guys. Please tone it down a little with the personal insults and name calling or I’m gonna have to lock the discussion.

  64. avatar
    Take off the rose coloured glasses Says:

    Let’s do some basic math.

    House cost – $300,000 for an average 2 unit. Owner occupies one unit, rents the other for $850 a month.
    Downpayment – $30,000, so 270,000 mortgage. At a fixed rate of 4%, and a 25 year amortization, that’s $1420 monthly
    Property tax = $300,000 * .0106 = 3180
    Insurance = $1000.00
    Total monthly costs mortgage, property tax and insurance = $1420 + ((3180+1000)/12) = $1851

    Owner’s living portion – 60%, owners % of costs = $1111 (not including water tax)
    Water tax per unit = $615.00
    Cost for apartment portion = $740 + the water tax (615/12) = $792.00

    Contrary to your statement, owners that rent out space in their home do take care of their property. you can add in at least $600 a year for that, or another $20 a month attributed to the apartment Those that rent investment properties are subject to a higher downpayment (I believe that’s 30%), so there’s the opportunity cost of having that money tied up in a property, probably offset by a lower mortgage payment.

    Income tax = at least $2000 once all the write offs are taken into account. 2000/12 = $167 monthly.

    That apartment actually costs about $958.00. You’re already operating at a cash flow loss renting for $850.

    Add in the real costs of the months that the apartment is vacant, the unrecoverable costs of repairs above and beyond damage deposits, and amortizing the mortgage insurance over the term, and that loss increases.

    Add in the intangible costs of the inconvenience of interviewing tenants, dealing with contractors, additional noise, etc. and it becomes an “is this really worth it” proposition?

    You hopes of profit are linked to property value increases (taxable), paying out the mortgage and increasing the monthly contribution to your equity, which adds to the taxable as income as well.

    If you do the math, in a flat or marginally increasing real estate market it’s actually less expensive to rent than to own. It’s only the rapid increases in housing values that are making renting a marginally profitable proposition.

    And as for your argument about “only if you bought in the last 4 -5 years, that’s total BS. The number of tenants in St. John’s is increasing. There isn’t a magical inventory of 4-5 year homes out there waiting to service this need. New construction is necessary, and investment properties are flipped on a regular basis. To qualify for the grants that you rave about, you have to invest your own money in improvements, adding to your capital investment costs.

    Your rant would more accurately be titled “You get what you pay for”. You want to have your cake and eat it too. Either pair fair market rates and enjoy a well maintained property, or save on rent and live in sub standard conditions. Doing so makes it viable for slumlords to operate, which makes you part of the problem that you complain about.

    You have no right to complain that your below market rate apartment is not properly maintained. You’re getting exactly what you’re paying for. If you’re paying market rates, keep looking, there’s lots of decent, well maintained apartments that become vacant during the non-peak months. You’ll likely get a bargain from Nov – February.

    Welcome to the real world. We’re all suffering under the increased costs of housing. Government can’t do anything about that unless they pass the costs on to other taxpayer living in less expensive jurisdictions. That would be totally unfair to them.

    Living in St. John’s is a choice, not an entitlement. Get over yourself, you have no right to demand your living here be subsidized on the backs of others.

  65. avatar
    pattykay Says:

    bys would ya give it up already

  66. avatar
    shadowwood Says:

    So many people rave over the ‘accomplishments’ of Danny William’s government in bringing ‘prosperity’ to Newfoundland. The ones who are most vocal are often the ones who are least likely to benefit and more often than not the very ones who will suffer. This greater affluence benefits those who are in a position to benefit, namely those who are already affluent. For the majority of low to middle income people the dynamics of a boom economy can often leave one out in the cold. The infectious spread of pyramid-scheme type specul-vesting which has swept the rest of Canada has finally arrived in Newfoundland. Welcome to the bubble. Anyone with two dimes to rub together can become a homeowner, operating their investment properties at a loss, renting below the amount required to pay the associated costs with their home ownership, in the hopes of ‘flipping’ their property in a few years, on the *gamble* that some other sucker will come along and be willing to pay even more for a grossly hyperinflated property value. This is the bubble. Some will get very wealthy off this, the smart ones will have gotten in early and will get out just as early. In the end a lot of people will be left holding the bag, indebt to the amount of the excess valuation of the properties that they gambled on being able to flip. This is like any pyramid scheme, eventually you run out of people who are willing to buy in, the last man who bought in has effectively paid for the profits extracted by the preceding pyramidists. When this scheme crumbles (because it is by its very nature unsustainable), a few are left holding that debt, which thanks to lax bankruptcy laws is no big deal, foreclose, declare bankruptcy, move on with your lives, Gov’t (tax payers) can provide bailouts to the no bankrupt bank and mortgage companies. I can’t wait for the crash. We can return to the Prosperity of being a low income province, with all the benefits that come along with it, not in the form of shiny new SUVS and arrogant fashion tops, but in the comaraderie and fellowship that has made newfoundland such a culturally rich place to live for so many years and which seems to be the major benefit of widespread “poverty”

  67. avatar
    shadowwood Says:

    As an addition, I met an individual the other day, one of these specul-vestors, ie, a local Newfie with ‘two dimes to rub together’, who had turned gambler and was hoping for a fat payoff with minimal effort. This is afterall what a gambler is, one who wishes to invest a little bit of money and with little effort derive a huge profit, with the large possibility of being wiped out completely of the initial investment (they won’t admit this possibility). This guy was bloated, the shiny car, flaccid jowls of the overfed, nice sun tan. He showed me the apartment he was renting, the scent of urine/beer/cigarettes met me as I went in the door “don’t worry, we’re going to replace all these carpets”, as his squinty shifty eyes avoided mine, just as much as he avoided any mention of timeframes for repairs. The tenants residing in the unit appeared cowed in his presence, the submissive meekness of having been under the thumb of another, evident on their visage. “Do you have an application for this place, we might consider it?”, “Oh, just the standard..” as he hands me a pre-filled out lease, eager to stuff his hole with humanity, salivating while looking at me, like a walking ATM for his personal use. I found out later that he owned a few properties around the city, “specul-vestor!”. There are many of these middle-aged mediocrities who are eager for an early retirement and have decided that the pyramid scheme real estate boom market is the means of attaining it. The phenomenon of one man buying 5 properties is what is putting pressure on the market, pushing prices up. This man will not live in all five properties, meaning he must rent the remaining four. Since those others with the means and inclination to live in a house/condo must now compete for the -4 remaining properties in the city, the increased competition for limited properties pushes prices skyward. This results in higher rents. These higher rents don’t pay for all of the associated costs of the investment property, they just take some of the pressure off. The specul-vestor isn’t looking to become rich as a landlord, being a landlord is an afterthought. The speculvestor wants to become rich as a flipper of property. So the very same specul-vesting which is driving prices up, is the very same mechanism by which the speculvestor wishes to become wealthy. These properties have no suddenly gained in value through any intrinsic force of their own, their value increase is a direct result of specul-vestors paying ever increasing amounts for these properties. The money that a speculvestor makes or potentially can make, again will only come through another specul-vestor coming along and buying into the pyramid scheme. I know I’m repeating myself from my earlier post, but I want people to be very clear. These specul-vestors aren’t bad people, not really, most of them have worked hard over lean years, saved some bank, are fed up now and looking to take advantage of an opening to score big to enjoy a decent retirement. That’s fine. People are intrinsically selfish, it is our nature, the very selfish nature that can be useful to society, in the form of capitalistic competition, fueling economic growth. The problem lies with government lack of regulation, that is the government role, to manipulate, organize and channel that individual selfishness in such a way as to create a society that is enjoyable for the majority of its members. These specul-vestors are gamblers, creating devastating effects on the landscape of an entire city or province in some cases. The social dynamics that come about with this nouveau bourgeois mentality which chastises the poor while simultaneously contributing to the increasing gap between rich and poor, marginalizing the poor to ever further extremities, is the direct result of an unconstrained, misdirected selfishness. This will not turn out good. Every bubble bursts. These newfies you see, who are speculvesting and going on their 3 times a year vacation and driving their fancy car around town, the money that is paying them to do those things, is going to come out of the population at large’s pocket, in the long run. We arrogantly think we are different from the American experience of recent infamy, but the very same or worse is lurking for us around the corner. So next time you see a specul-vestor, patting himself on the back for being such a great ‘hard working guy’, (an irony, since by the very nature of his specul-vesting, he is intentionally doing his utmost to remove himself from the labour force and enter an early retirement), while chasting the ‘gross welfare bums’ (who by his selfish singlemindedness he has helped increases the rolls of), take another look at this middle aged phenomenon, look past his new sunglasses he bought at the store, scrutinizing himself in the mirror for long hours to reassure himself that he will be taken seriously, look past the shiny car that his ego led him to buy, this is a man petty in spirit, who has contributed nothing to the society around him. Even the welfare person contributes more, is paid far less as well, where would we be without welfare people, their excess of time and lack of funds has spurred many to creative heights.. even if those creative heights are no more than tagging the wall of the Sports Complex 20 times in a row or smashing a bottle on their own head.

  68. avatar
    shadowwood Says:

    There aren’t many jobs in this city, my cousin recently complained about his inability to find work, I was like “oh please, don’t be so picky”. I decided to check out some of these job sites to see if I could disprove his contention. Vindication, I was correct, there were plenty of jobs, only my cousin had some valid points regarding them. The majority were parttime/casual/on-call/temporary/shift work. I’m not kidding. Employers think mighty highly of themselves in this province to expect anyone to want to bother working under such constraints. Added to this is the requirement for a full criminal background check, credit check, multiple previous employer reference check.. for a min wage job. Are you joking? No, I’m not. Single employable adult on welfare makes somewhere in the neighbourhood of $800+, including full dental and prescriptions, full ‘job security’, access to multiple social programs and benefits and doesn’t need to get up in the morning. This individual will not be motivated to give up his ‘cushy’ lifestyle to work for an employer who asks for his soul and is only willing to pay min wage. It’s not just this tho, this is economics as well, in which an individual can find themselves making less working than they made on social assistance. For instance, find a job that offers 26 hours a week (most jobs in this city seem to be of this nature), make in the neighbourhood of $950/month, or, alternatively, stay on welfare, make $850 or so, get a job of 6 hours a week, get to keep up to $200 of the $200+ that you make, without any excess labour involved and while still having the ‘job security’ that welfare provides.

    In places like Vancouver, Toronto, Calgary, there is a plethora of fulltime jobs, paying well above minimum wage, which justify the increased housing prices. We don’t see that phenomenon here. This province on paper might be getting ‘wealthier’, but for the average person poverty is increasing. Danny Williams had a desire to remake this city in his own image, which is to say, in the image that his limited creativity could conceive of as being positive growth, namely in the mould of other so-called ‘successful cities’ the world-around, cities which are of primary benefit to the rich and stress life for the rest of us. Did Newfoundland have to turn into another Vancouver? We were doing just fine, thanks. I overheard an Irish man say “What’s all this fuss over the economic boom here [in Ireland at the time of the Celtic Tiger], people are working harder than ever, people are less happy, there’s more crime, more homelessness, things were simpler, people were friendlier when we had less money.” This sentiment seems just as true in our own backyard. The religion of quick-money has taken hold here and is firmly resolved to eradicate all traces of the humanity that has made Newfoundland famous the world-round. Tread lightly Newfoundland, boosting that insecure ego through material acquisition comes at a high price, resist the Devil, seek comfort in your roots, where you came from, a simple hard working people, full of love for one neighbour, a simple Faith in God, a life close to the earth. The U.S.A is not an example worthy of the greatness you once had and which was the envy of every American who came to visit to escape the hell of their creating.

  69. avatar
    John Says:

    I’m extremely fortunate in that my landlord didn’t ask me for a damage deposit and he let me move in with 2 dogs. I have a 2 bedroom basement apartment in Mount Pearl. The cost/quality of living from St. John’s to Mount Pearl is miles apart.

    I lived on Old Topsail, Prospect, Gower, Mullock, Lime and more in St. John’s, while some were in better condition then others, some were in rough shape. I had a city inspector into an apartment on Long’s hill once, they made a report and forwarded it to my landlord, my landlord called me and cut my rent in half, but never did fix the ceiling or roof, we lived one bedroom short for the entire year we lived there.
    The whole Lime Street/downtown property management event of ’08 is it’s own story and a half.

    When I moved out of St. John’s and moved to Ottawa then Halifax, the housing situations were a far contrast to here. I came back to Newfoundland not wanting to live in St. John’s, so I found a spot in Mount Pearl, now I have a 2 bedroom large basement apartment with my pets (we even got a cat after we moved in.) fenced in back yard, driveway, trails and parks everywhere, the snow clearing and garbage collection is far superior to that of St. John’s. And it’s only $600 a month.

    For the last 4-5 years St. John’s seem to be coming apart at the seams, stabbings and robberies on the rise, leaks in health care information, and in general people in St. John’s seem to be becoming less friendly, more egotistical and self important.

  70. avatar
    JJ Says:

    Ya think? I’ll tell you right now. There is a reason why the island is called NEWFIE-LAND. All the Newfoundlanders are gone on mainland while all that’s left are the dumb useless newfies. There is a reason why no one takes this place seriously. Minimum wage goes up so why not gouge everything else?. This place is and will always be a HAVE NOT PROVINCE. I wish you idiots would just separate from Canada. We don’t need you pogey jumping, welfare bumming ignorant excuses for human life. I hope a tsunami comes and drowns each and every one of you scum-bags. If they made a soap opera about NL it would be called “The Old and the Useless.

  71. avatar
    JJ Says:

    The whole city (and I use that term very loosely) of St. John’s IS A SLUM.

  72. avatar
    JJ Says:

    Taking care of each other? Seriously. What else more do you people want? Canada has been taking care of you all since confederation. It’s time we cut the apron strings on you low lifes.

  73. avatar
    John Says:

    Cool story bro.

  74. avatar
    MW Says:

    Writer, you are truly a disgusting entitled wretch!

  75. avatar
    ranter Says:

    oh I am a digusting entitled wretch am I? Guess what? I moved and I am doing much better btw. Nice, clean apartment now with no bullsh!t and a decent job. who is entitled now? Do you all have some sort of problem with people being unfortunate sometimes and having troubles? How can you mock and treat those horribly who have been in a fire or have had something bad happen to them? You are the entitled one MW and the others who think its ok to demean people because of issues they have had.

  76. avatar
    ranter Says:

    Oh and may I also add….whats that under the bridge? OH its a trollllll


RANT FARM: Got an opinion? Then we want to hear from you. Submit your unsigned accusation or confession here. One submission will be printed in the paper each fortnight. Submissions may be edited for length, grammar, spelling, legal, or potty-mouth reasons. The Scope's Terms of Use are here.