they r reviewing the minimum wage. it is now hit 10 bucks. still can’t get alot to work part time , it closed up some mom and pop stores or made them work even more hours. having come from retail , everytime wages go up so do expectations because they cut hours to put it inline with budget. so what is the magic number to get good service , keep people , and allow us to get our drive through order right or at least with a smile??
Rant by eveil Ed Cec






August 6th, 2012 at 10:32 am
There is no magic number when it comes to minimum wage. It will always be minimum wage. I get $2.50 above minimum wage… it doesn’t help. Customer service is customer service. Unless you get a trade/real job/follow your dreams etc. you will never be satisfied if the issue is with money.
August 6th, 2012 at 3:33 pm
Some economists have suggested that markets would flourish with some enlightened wage-scaling for the service sector, similar to the way in which manufacturing went from a low-paying job to a coveted (amongst the uneducted/underprivileged) position that could provide enough for a family to get by comfortably on. I think this concept has a lot of merit and as our economy shifts from a primarily manufacturing to a predominantly service based one it stands to reason that to encourage economic growth wages should raise for the majority of the population – I don’t believe the ‘minimum wage’ is an effective tool for implementing this revolution.
August 6th, 2012 at 3:59 pm
Agreeing with seaguy, there is no “magic number”, but 10 bucks an hour is certainly a reasonable benchmark. Despite what the entitled burger flippers and register jockeys may think, 10 bucks is a respectable living wage for unskilled work, but not so high that it would lead to employers cutting hours, laying off workers, or refusing to hire new ones.
August 7th, 2012 at 9:30 am
I was in management in a large retail sector. when we hit 10 bucks , the hammer fell. businesses have x number of labour dollars or call it wage percent. this is all they are willing to use , trust me. They look at the single easiest controllable expense as labour. that is a quote.
3 hours at 10 bucks 30 dollars , 2 hours at 15 – 30 bucks. math is easy as to what they will do to overspend. add in the extra training and/or food and health sasfety costs that have gone up to be legally solid – and that happens in every retail outlet know , having known sveral managers dealing with it. I agree 10 is a fair number – but trust me there is a lot less staff walking the aisles and handling the registers at many locations – even if you don’t readily see it.
August 8th, 2012 at 8:55 pm
I resent the existence of a government mandated ‘minimum wage’. If someone wants to do something for me for $2 then that is between them and I and none of gov’ts affair. This failed attempt at wealth distribution/equality is nothing but playing magic numbers, it benefits no one, with wage increase there is a correlating price increase as the same wealth chases the same products/services. I would rather the markets decide what each particular job is ‘worth’.
August 8th, 2012 at 9:25 pm
Welcome to Dickensian England: abject poverty for the toiling masses, and no government interference – the ultimate free market. Maybe try reading some history.
August 9th, 2012 at 5:15 am
Shadowwood, that’s the dumbest thing I’ve heard in a very long time!
August 9th, 2012 at 9:46 am
I’m well-versed in history and economic theory. Clearly your abrupt dismissal of my opinion without any attempt at a counterargument shows that you should read some history, some books in general would be useful, it might spur some ideas which will provide you the means of countering my ideas, since your kneejerk emotional response falls flat with me.
August 9th, 2012 at 9:49 am
An insult without bothering with a qualifier to shroud it with some rational basis – my feelings are hurt and I’m crying in a corner now.
August 9th, 2012 at 10:31 am
certainly seems this is politically cahrged whenevertheres an answer. ultimately there is however a growing gap in folks with less and folks with more. take seniors for instance , they can now get a free set of false teeth- ballpark figure 800 bucks. anyone getting old age pension now later in life has to wait till 67. thats 800 aprox per month lost for 24 months….
unless you are on the govt tit or well versed in certain social programs and willing to work unbeknownst to authorities , it will be a struggle how middle class partly because you need to compete to show abject wealth you really do not have.
it is not easily solved because those can make changes would have to make unpopular decisions and be removed from the very place where they can effect change!!
indeed though if the minimum wage goes to 15 than the prices rise as well , the level of service goes down , rental owners can now charge more again – its a cycle with a broken wheel heading down hill…bottom line.
August 9th, 2012 at 3:16 pm
In the end there are more products and more food floating around thanks to technological innovation which has allowed more to be produced by less, for which even the poorest are living better than at any time in history. Minimum wage is just as financially sensible and effective as a government printing more currency to pay off debts – it’s magic economics, an illusion and a bluff.
August 10th, 2012 at 11:17 am
You regularly “enlighten” the rest of the readers with your negative, unkind, or ignorant (both rude and uneducated) statements. Please stop.
You’re either angry, bitter and a total cynic or a mean oaf.
Back off.
August 10th, 2012 at 11:42 am
True that poverty as such , seems hard to pinpoint when low income housing has trucks,vans,recreational vehicles at the door and their kids decked off in brand names. most of those are screwing the system as well though working on the side etc etc and god knows what else. but for an average person say in retail , and as a manager i know , the minute the rate goes up – the hours used go down and the workload goes up. it does impact business as they say it does but does indeed turn the screws on avaerage hourly rate employees. however even in tough times Ceos like mine still get multimillion dollar bonuses , so unless we get the full cycle fixed there will always be a problem…not an easy solution in a me first generation
August 10th, 2012 at 12:05 pm
I won’t speak to every business model, but a lot of these retail outlets have markups on their products of 400%+, shareholders/owners are making a lot of money even in lean times, the wise employer would like Henry Ford pay their workers more than the competition, which would in the long run save money through less employee-turnover, employee loyalty and eagerness to hold onto a job, as well as the benefit of having employees who can afford to buy a great deal of the products in the store.
I really don’t believe that the minimum wage is necessary or beneficial, either to the employees or the employers, there are several economically powerful nations, including Germany, Sweden, Italy, which don’t have any such thing as a minimum wage and instead use collective bargaining, a much more sound practice that isn’t based upon a cookie-cutter approach and instead works on a case by case basis. I should mention that I primarily work in ‘minimum wage’ employment (not having an uncle or cousin in this province to open a door kind of ensures that), do I feel any better that I’m being paid something that is by its very name ‘the _minimum possible_’, no in fact it tarnishes the value in my eyes of any employment that offers it or just above it, I’d rather take my chances with proving that I can create enough value for a company that justifies a certain wage, rather than being lumped with every other first-hires and given a min wage with annual .5% increment raises based upon nothing but the fact that you have a pulse.
August 10th, 2012 at 12:06 pm
I’ll start with some recent economic history. I’m guessing you’re under 30. Over the past 10 years, minimum wage jobs have been widely available in the St. John’s metro area and certain other parts of the province. Basically, if you want a minimum wage job here in St. John’s, you can probably have one pretty quickly, barring unusual personal circumstances. Anyone who lived here through the 90s knows that every available minimum wage job had dozens and sometimes hundreds of applications. Most retail outlets didn’t bother to advertize when they had a vacancy, because people were coming in off the street every day with resumes looking for jobs. If there were no minimum wage in St. John’s today, I’m not sure it would change things much, because it’s mostly a job-seekers market, and anyone who needs an employee knows you get what you pay for. In the 1990s, people were desperate. I remember hiring a guy for a minimum wage summer job that was normally for students. He had a wife and kids and was trying to survive. If there were no minimum wage. People like him were desperate, and lots of them would have taken a dollar or two less an hour, and then once that became the bottom standard, they would have taken less, and less and less, until you have malnutrition (leading to health care and education costs), desperate people (more crime), etc. It’s easy to say go live somewhere else, but there are divorced parents who need to live near their children, there are adult children of aging parents who need care. Methinks Shadowland has never had to survive on the margins of existence like many others, and has no real life understanding or empathy for those who walk where I would have to walk but for the grace of God.
August 10th, 2012 at 12:17 pm
Why would I stop enlightening the rest of the readers? If what you claim is true and I have never made the claim myself, that what in fact I am accomplishing is to ‘enlighten’ readers, then it would be selfish of me to stop this behaviour as most would by its very definition benefit from some enlightenment. The interesting thing is that you also claim my comments are ‘negative, unkind (or ignorant) and (both rude and uneducated), it speaks to the state of the readers if comments like these can provide enlightenment. I do enjoy being singled out like this for some critique on my very behaviour of expressing an opinion, it means I’m having an impact upon you, I like that, what’s that saying ‘there’s no such thing as bad publicity’, well.. in any event, I caused a reaction in you, you were spurred on to notice me in my angry bitter and cynical mean oafish existence, that has to count as some sort of victory, right? *grin*
August 10th, 2012 at 12:33 pm
Cute anecdotal story and a cute attempt to extrapolate an entire justification for a failed mechanism by using the local example to prove what is a generalized and worldwide issue.
Do you think ‘min wage’ protected people in the 90′s? Confederation protected people, Ontarians and Albertans shoveling money in equalization payments to help their brothers in Newfoundland, a Newfoundland which now takes on airs and thumbs their nose ungratefully at the rest of Canada because they lucked into some oil offshore (ie, they still never figured out the rudimentaries of running a provincial economy – after 400+ years of attempts..). The min an employer would be willing to pay would never fall below the level at which welfare payments were set, or even close as it would remove all incentive for anyone to work, crime is also an option and likewise if employers began paying below a certain threshold ‘employees’ would react by finding alternative means to survive. If Ma Baker is running a little convenience store downtown and struggling to keep her head above water and can only afford to pay a buck less than min wage in order to weather the storm of a temporary economic downturn and there are people with few options for employment who would gladly accept that job which still provides more than welfare/EI, you are going to say “NO” it is “ILLEGAL” both for you to “OFFER” that amount and for that person to “ACCEPT” that amount. You asked me what my age was and it is definitely not below 30, but I wonder what sort of age (psychologically) you must be at if you still hold so dearly to the idea of a protective paternal/maternal government which will shroud you from the whims life might throw at you, perhaps its time to take off the diapers and stand on your own two feet.
August 10th, 2012 at 1:25 pm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troll_(Internet)
August 10th, 2012 at 1:50 pm
Elling: Being aggressively vocal about ones opinions in a forum hostile to those views isn’t being a ‘troll’ as you subtly suggest. I’m presenting my opinions in an aggressive fashion because I am not an anglo-saxon limp biscuit who is afraid of some emotion in a debate, in Mediterranean countries it is normal to argue and debate in aggressive ways, if anything it is I who am being trolled by those who rather than confronting my opinions head on with their own opinions instead continually make comment upon me, my character, my manner of presentation, etc, to which the only fault I am accountable is for responding in turn to these blank slates who are jealous of someone who thinks and speaks with some passion and belief in what he/she’s saying.
August 10th, 2012 at 5:31 pm
This article discusses a minimum income, which addresses similiar issues, even though it is different from a minimum wage.
http://www.dominionpaper.ca/articles/4100
August 12th, 2012 at 3:19 pm
I think welfare is fine how it is and that mincome idea is taking things a bit too far, on an emotional level I am uncomfortable with any government acting as arbiter of an entire nations ‘living income’; it’s no coincidence that the welfare state was invented in Imperial Japan as a means of creating the ultimate warfare state.
August 18th, 2012 at 4:35 pm
shadowwood, after reading your comments here my respect for you has increased substantially. You are 100% correct. I have nothing further to add.
August 22nd, 2012 at 4:51 pm
@shadowwood
You’ve made some good points here.
One question, completely unrelated to this rant. Big Justin Bieber fan or what?