
I don’t really follow provincial politics, but it’s hard not to notice the large discontent with our current government (more particularly our premier). Obviously every government in power will receive negative feedback from the people, but has it ever been this bad? Is it as bad as it seems or is this just par for the course?
Rant by Curious






April 18th, 2013 at 7:54 pm
are you following the story about Gerry Rogers and the social media thing? have you watched the Premier try to talk her way out of it? she sounds like she’s in high school. it’s beyond pathetic, its sad.
they don’t just LOOK like fools, they are quite clearly in WAY over their head. the premier’s nickname is deserved. and she’s pissing away your taxes.
April 18th, 2013 at 10:30 pm
It’s the same old story really. Every government in Newfoundland’s history has had their share of public discontent at one point or another. When Dunderdale finally does get voted out, we’ll all be complaining about the person who takes her job.
As for the social media issue mentioned by gtronsistem, it’s too foolish to talk about, and our government should not be wasting time in the House of Assembly on such foolish issues. It really did speak for the small-mindedness of our leaders.
April 19th, 2013 at 9:24 am
two things,
first, there’s probably a legal case to be had if anyone was paying attention. and certainly not ‘foolish’ – I wouldn’t so easily dismiss the social media thing as petty. this is a big-brother phenomenon, just early days, so it appears to be trivial. think of PRECEDENT.
A seemingly untouchable ‘speaker’ of the house banishes a member for her internet contacts, and without any discussion.
It’s probably illegal what the speaker did. Don’t be so condescending, it might set legal precedence.
Second, back to the defense offered by the Premier. Please watch the 7 minutes of video on CBC where journalist Cowan asks her questions on April 18. She’s clearly not a very intelligent person, speaks like a self-righteous granny, and she’s spinning her own Bullshit from the night before. She called Rogers out, and said clearly “Oh we know FULL WELL how social media works” only 12 hours earlier, and now she’s resigned her account DUE TO NOT KNOWING HOW IT WORKS. She’s an OUTRIGHT liar.
Please don’t trivialize other person’s comments. You are showing standard Canadian attitude. “Its the same old shit, keep eating it”
it’s why things will continue as you say – because you have accepted the bullshit already. One vote isn’t enough, we need actual activism.
April 19th, 2013 at 10:27 am
Read the rant. The OP was asking if this kind of behavior has been the normal, and if it has happened in the past. The answer to those questions is yes. Every government in our history has been full of it, to different degrees.
April 19th, 2013 at 11:37 am
I agree. Social media should not be an issue in the house. It’s too stupid to talk about.They should be focusing on the issues of the province instead of their social media accounts.
April 19th, 2013 at 1:00 pm
It completely boggles my mind how Danny Williams can be treated like some sort of patron Newfoundland saint while Dunderdale is vilified when she deals with the inevitable consequences of Williams’ fiscal incompetence.
I’m going to give you guys a lesson here; A lot of people don’t understand what “have province” means. “Have” status is a euphemism meaning that we get less money from the federal government. It is not a blank cheque for social spending, but that is exactly what Williams did. He showered the public sector with money, it was unsustainable and now the current government has to clean up the mess with unpopular budget cuts.
As for the Gerry Rogers thing, I do not think that it should have been brought up in parliament to begin with, but it was and Rogers should have apologized. I don’t believe for one second that she supports violent threats against the premier, but as a politician she needs to make sure that she doesn’t end up on those sorts of sites. If she had apologized for her poor judgement this whole thing would have went away very fast, instead it is becoming a very unnecessary circus.
I went on a bit of a rant there and now I will address the OP. It isn’t just NL, almost all provincial governments in Canada are very unpopular, with the exception of Saskatchewan. Redford in Alberta was only elected because people were terrified of the Wildrose Party. Wynne in Ontario will likely be turfed out in the next election due to over 10 years or so worth of scandals and fiscal mismanagement caused by her predecessor. Clark in BC will be voted out next month. Marois in Quebec is not popular at all but she was voted in because the people in that province were sick of the corruption on lies from the Charest government.
I don’t like the current PC government in NL, but I don’t see any alternative. I will not vote NDP, and the Liberal party seems to be in disarray.
April 20th, 2013 at 11:06 am
“in Parliament”? you keep on giving us “lessons” gord-o – you are obviously qualified for it.
and if anyone asked me to apologize for that I would say the same – I have nothing to apologize for. it’s McCarthyism, folks, read your history.
and @ Max, like I said, you keep admitting its normal, some of the rest of us will attempt to change normal to right.
April 20th, 2013 at 11:49 am
Giant mistake #1: Introduce austerity to a historically economically depressed region which had just recently claimed to be a ‘have province’. Austerity is a completely self-defeating economic strategy. It doesn’t require going to higher education and studying economics to realize that when you throw thousands of high-salaried government employees out of work in a province of a few hundred thousand you are simply shifting the problem around, these people don’t suddenly invent new high paying jobs for themselves, they either leave the province, settle for one of the few min wage jobs available or go on benefits (welfare). The entire economic system grinds to a halt, something a province with virtually no agriculture or industry simply can’t afford. The entire economic basis for this province is for the government to take revenues from the oil industry and then disperse it amongst some lucky few thousand working in government. Let’s face it, there is very little else here, the few jobs in the actual oil industry itself are generally given to foreigners who have the experience and education (why invest in our own local workforce).
Giant mistake #2: The facebook fiasco. Really? Politics at it’s utter cheapest, pathetic, embarrassing and as CBC’s wonderful investigative journalism shows – completely hypocritical. Dunderdale has no political imagination or instinct, while she may be a good woman at heart she is not cut out for running this province, I get the sense her advisers and cabinet (are they called a cabinet here?) are the ones really leading her astray, filling her ears with nice-sounding things which her poor instinct continually falls for.
Well, she has chased me from town, I leave in a year from now. Newfoundland will continue to be chronically mismanaged as it has throughout it’s long history and I don’t intend to sacrifice my future to live here and watch more of the same, a living death. This is a great place for those who have given up on life. The capital city can’t even get its act together, a complete disgrace. I was embarrassed when my family visited in the winter and we had to walk on the road a day after a snowfall because snowplowing sidewalks isn’t a priority here like it is in any other city which would be ashamed to leave sidewalks in such a state.
April 20th, 2013 at 10:38 pm
You obviously have no idea what the “Dunderdale Must Go” group is even about. The intent of the group isn’t to spread threats to the premier. It’s there for people to exercise their democratic rights. It’s no different than street protest. Just because some redneck-psychopath made a death threat toward our premier doesn’t mean the group is intended for such a purpose. The threatening comment was quickly removed from this group. I know your stance on social networking, so your narrow mindedness on it doesn’t surprise me. If you want to take this a step further, it wouldn’t surprise me if Kennedy, King, Marshall, or Dunderdale had a fake Facebook account(s) created so that they could continue to view the groups posts anonymously. Bottom line is that Gerry Rogers didn’t make the comment. There is no need for her to apologize. Apologizing to the PC’s for no reason will just make their heads swell larger than they currently are.
April 20th, 2013 at 10:49 pm
I would like to see changes too, but if history is any dictation of what’s in store for the future, it’s not looking good. The likelihood that provincial politics, or politics anywhere for that matter, will ever get cleaned up, is poor.