
Illustration by Ricky King
i recall that http://www.straight.com/isawyou was mentioned here once as the model for the Scope’s I Saw You feature. It’s purely about what the personal classifieds often call “missed connections”.
Quoting myself on another thread, re a criticism of an I Saw You post:
“[The post was] just venting, though that probably wasn’t the designed purpose [of I Saw You]. Rant Farm with a catch-phrase to get started. Sometimes one can’t communicate what one needs to directly, and sometimes one just needs to yell into a bucket.”
Actually that wasn’t a particularly well written post, sorry.
Now, the Georgia Straight in Vancouver likely has a much larger readership than this site, so it probably gets more submissions, so there’s more leeway for editing out stuff that doesn’t fit the mandate. And The Scope probably has a good argument for being hands-off about what goes up under a category, drawing the line for legal concerns only.
Notwithstanding all that, what does it say about us, as a local culture, that our I Saw You is so much more negative than Vancouver’s? Especially when there’s a designated place for generalized ranting just a couple of table cells away?
This isn’t exactly a rant, just some observations that i’m curious to see some opinions on.
Rant by C.H. Monster






December 30th, 2011 at 10:34 pm
What does it say about our local culture? That people complain about other people complaining? Now there’s a typical Newfoundland complaint. All it says to me is: if you really think we bitch more in St. John’s than they do in Vancouver, you clearly haven’t spent enough time in Vancouver. Might I suggest the downtown eastside?
January 4th, 2012 at 10:30 am
Comparisons between St. John’s and Vancouver aside, the point about using I Saw You to rant rather than the more appropriately titled Rant Farm is still valid. Since the OP’s post, there’s been rants about a radio station and media coverage posted in I Saw You. If nothing else, it would be less painful not to have to read the awkward grammar often used when people need to start their rant with “I Saw You”.
January 4th, 2012 at 1:32 pm
I guess every town gets the “I Saw You” they create. This one is certainly more negative (“I saw you doing something I hate”) and less hopeful (“I sure hope I can find that person I met on a bus/in a grocery store again”) than any I’ve seen before.
January 5th, 2012 at 7:29 am
Too many places in Newfoundland have what I call the “lookabuddy” mentality – an instinctive, almost lunatic need to put someone else down for ANY reason given the slightest opportunity. In this context “I saw you” denotes not just a simple observation but carries an ominous threat. “I seen you doin’ sumtin you shouldna been doin’ dere buddy! AHAHA!”